Show Posts

This section allows you to view all posts made by this member. Note that you can only see posts made in areas you currently have access to.


Messages - Mira

Pages: 1 ... 427 428 [429] 430 431 ... 459
6421
DF Spoilers / Re: Prediction: Bob wrote the Dresden Files
« on: December 21, 2017, 06:02:19 PM »
The journal idea is all but confirmed by Jim from a Q&A session, if I recall; something to the effect of "The books are Harry kind of looking back, years later..." So I think that this is solid.

Bob being the writer is interesting. I'd posit that Bonnie (if you're unfamiliar, that's the name we've been using for Harry's new spirit of intellect from the end of Skin Game) may be a better fit; she actually lived in Harry's head, and would have greater insight into Harry's state of mind during each of the early events, and has the perfect recall necessary to describe events years after the fact. So that's a good thought.

Also, welcome.

   I somehow doubt that Bob is the writer, unless in looking back he can make himself sound different from Harry.

6422
DF Spoilers / Re: Was Ascher telling the truth?
« on: December 21, 2017, 02:51:15 PM »
   Their responsibilities include protecting both the Senior Council and other White Council members from attacks, dealing with the Vampire Courts, the Faerie, and warlocks and serving as judge, jury and executioner when in the field against violators of the Seven Laws of magic. Many warlocks are killed resisting arrest, or apprehended after their crimes have earned them a death sentences. Hearings before the Senior Council are rare. Dresden Wiki

No, they are not judge and jury!  The accused are entitled to a trial, even if it has evolved to almost a kangaroo type event where the outcome is predestined because of 1] practicality, not enough wizards willing to risk to the Doom to rehab a young would be warlock, 2] because the Merlin in particular believes the results are mixed at best to disastrous if the rehab fails...   So it may have evolved to a point where young offenders are simply killed for a variety of reasons by the Wardens, but that isn't how it is supposed to be..  So these days the Council does a lot of looking the other way unless someone like Harry insists that a trial is held..   The whole point of the trial for the Korean kid in my opinion was an object lesson for Harry by the Merlin that trials are mostly a waste of time..

6423
DF Spoilers / Re: Was Ascher telling the truth?
« on: December 20, 2017, 07:42:50 PM »


  Okay, so the Wardens are the White Council's cops...  They arrest and enforce the Laws of Magic... However they are not supposed to sit in judgement of would be law breakers, that is the Senior Council's job.  With the wars and modern times both are spread pretty thin...  Also there are good and bad Wardens, if they are took quick on the draw and a young would be warlock loses his or  her head before trial, most in the Council look the other way, makes their job easier because they feel they don't have the time to waste on a kid that no one will put his or her own head on the line for and who is a lost cause anyway..    So from her perspective, Asher was telling the truth, if she has surrendered the odds of her keeping her head were not in her favor...  The chances were also good that she would have lost her head before a trial was arranged in the first place with no questions asked..

6424
DF Spoilers / Re: Was Ascher telling the truth?
« on: December 11, 2017, 09:22:14 PM »
When Harry tried to bring in Molly for trial the merlins reaction to was something like "why did you not kill her yet" and "you are wasting time". Even with a warden they do not really trust like Harry the overview is minimal.

I am sure a lot of wardens do their jobs as expected but there is a lot of room for abusing power, cutting corners, acting on tunnel vision, ....

And little chance of discovery. In such an organisation you need only a few bad apples to get a reputation among people who do not dare to complain because there is no independent complains department and wardens will cover each other. Because that is what members of closed organisations do if they get the chance.

And if a bad apple is in a position of influence others will copy his behaviour because they think it is normal.

Wardens have power. People behave differently around them which makes them less aware what is going on.

And most importantly pressure to get results can do the rest. The whole structure promotes abuse of power and no real brakes on it. The only brakes are the wardens own consciences. That is not enough.

So I do not think they will all the run out to kill the kids but if one does there is little to stop him and other abuse will even be more likely.

As I said, for various reasons some of them perhaps understandable, the White Council's justice for breakers of the Laws, has become a zero tolerance policy... 

6425
DF Spoilers / Re: The one character that you wish hadn't died
« on: December 11, 2017, 09:18:15 PM »


   Morgan.

6426
DF Spoilers / Re: Was Ascher telling the truth?
« on: December 10, 2017, 01:55:36 PM »
I think that the WC is trying to balance out their place between two worlds, the mortal and the supernatural.

I think it more about finding themselves less relevant in a modern world, the time of the village wise woman or man has past.   Kids who show signs of talent no longer have any place to go or any knowledge of what it all means.  All they know is they have these cool talents and like normal kids everywhere they experiment with them and get into trouble.  Meanwhile the WC has been decimated by wars over the last thousand years and have spent their time navel gazing unlike Harry who has attempted to fit into the modern world openly as a practicing wizard.   As a result, zero tolerance has evolved into not just being the safest course for both worlds but the easiest to implement.  But as we all know zero tolerance policies are seriously flawed because there isn't a one size fits all and justice usually isn't served by it... But those those who advocate it will argue, it keeps everyone safe so it doesn't matter that perhaps a few talented babies who might make great wizards someday are thrown out with the bath water.

6427
DF Spoilers / Re: Shagnasty and co. all nemfected?
« on: December 10, 2017, 01:40:17 PM »
Nemesis infection must be relatively rare otherwise that dagger wouldn't be such a big deal.

  I agree with this, but also about it being used strategically,  hence all the effort to infect the guardians of the Gates, the Winter Court and the guardians of the guardians, the Summer Court..   Having said that it is quite plausible that Skin Walkers were infiltrated eons ago, since if I remember correctly in Native American folklore they weren't evil to begin with.  Infesting them does make sense since with their shape shifting abilities they can go undetected just about anywhere. 

6428
DF Spoilers / Re: Re-read plans
« on: December 01, 2017, 02:32:04 AM »
That's really interesting. Any particular actions? Her particular malice toward Dresden, that's later pretty much gone entirely after Small Favor, does seem pretty out of place. It's handwaved when she says she was trying to protect him, or that she was showing him tough love, or that she's a changeable Fae and can do what she wants (pretty much variably at later points in the series), but it still sticks out pretty far to me.

Which makes me think that she was trying all along to resist the infection..  On one hand she was trying to undermine Mab, that is why she wanted the Knife to begin with, power..  At the same time she did her best to save Harry, perhaps her promise to Margaret in this case was stronger than the infection... But remember in Proven Guilty one minute she was warning Harry that she must not be let go, then the next wanting him to turn her lose. 

6429
DF Spoilers / Re: Re-read plans
« on: November 30, 2017, 06:00:56 PM »
What was the biggest puzzle piece that clicked into place, please.

One was that  Leah may have already been infected before the party, just some of her actions speak to that.  I also think she was fighting for her sanity just as she was in Proven Guilty when Harry saw her under treatment in ice.  Another is what a dupe Bianca was, and that Mavra and others played her like a harp.  Last but not least how Susan willingly blinded herself to what was really going on.  She covered the supernatural but I doubt that she fully accepted the reality of that world and thus chose to ignore Harry's warnings of the dangers and made that fateful step of stealing the invite to the party.

6430
DF Spoilers / Re: The Chicago Cubs
« on: November 30, 2017, 01:52:01 PM »

Yeah..... ;D

6431
DF Spoilers / Re: Re-read plans
« on: November 29, 2017, 12:48:53 PM »
How so? Catch a new clue?

Yes, or things rather some things seem to fall into place..  That was last year and I started and wrote three very long topics about it.

6432
DF Spoilers / Re: Re-read plans
« on: November 28, 2017, 09:34:42 PM »


I am rereading the series, but not all at once...  My last reread was Grave Peril which was fascinating considering what we know now...   

6433
DF Spoilers / Re: Harry after the BAT
« on: November 28, 2017, 07:23:40 PM »
Bwahahahahaha .... WAY too close to a happy ending.

And why shouldn't Harry have a happy ending?  If he is indeed the author of the files, I'd say he has his happy ending..  However "happy" is in the eye of the beholder...

6434
DF Spoilers / Re: Harry after the BAT
« on: November 28, 2017, 11:42:22 AM »
This feels like a comment that Jim would laugh at.....

Why?   If Harry's job is done, he either will  die or get his reward... 

6435
DF Spoilers / Re: Harry after the BAT
« on: November 27, 2017, 12:00:49 PM »



Harry is now the Merlin, he lives on Eb's old homestead and is surrounded by his daughter and many grand kids and nieces and nephews... He now has the family and peace he always wanted...

Pages: 1 ... 427 428 [429] 430 431 ... 459