Author Topic: Elders of the Black Court  (Read 5563 times)

Offline Yuillegan

  • White Council
  • Posty McPostington
  • *****
  • Posts: 1383
  • Forum Moderator
    • View Profile
Elders of the Black Court
« on: December 14, 2020, 07:28:15 AM »
Did the Elders seem a bit...nerfed to everyone?

They did to me. Let's look back on what we know.

1. Mavra was there, and she is considered a Wizard level talent as per Blood Rites - not a mere Sorcerer (who are only skilled in destructive magic). And was implied to be the least powerful and important of the Elders as she had to be the drummer. Considering what we have seen of her this says a lot.

2. The other Elders seemed pretty strong (although none used Mavra's typical "dark energy" magic). Perhaps Jim decided to do more thematically, or perhaps he decided there is more than one style of magic that the Black Court Elders use.

3. However, Dresden referred to them all as Sorcerer's rather than Wizards. Now while this is possible, it seems unlikely that Mavra's Elders would be less knowledgeable and proficient than Mavra herself. No more likely than Luccio being more proficient and knowledgeable than any member of the Senior Council - even if she is a better battle mage than some of them. SO for Dresden to refer to them as Sorcerer's is incongruous and seems both arrogant and unreasonably dismissive, if not outright foolish and uninformed.

4. On the other hand, they didn't seem to be that skillful or smart. Sort of brutish and crude. Not even as scary as Grevane, even though physically they surely are still more scary than most. Certainly not the almost godlike terrors of the Red Court (the Lords of the Outer Night) - which I will grant are quite different to them considering how they might have gained their power. But there is a snag.

5. The snag is that in an old WOJ when asked "Who could beat Mab?" Jim answered that most couldn't even if they wanted to, but only a few beings/groups we had met had the horsepower, and even then this assumed Mab didn't have her army and was outside of her domain. Granted, the rankings and list might have changed a bit but the answer was this:
Quote
Quote from: Warden John Marcone on March 04, 2009, 05:48:02 PM
I’m still curious about who could hurt Mab.  Other than Titania, nobody comes to mind.

Hmmm.  In terms of pure, raw power, several who have appeared or been mentioned in the books could pull it off, though neither side would really “win” as much as “continue to exist.”  Plus, the sudden absence of Mab would do freaking HIDEOUS things to the earth.  But here’s who has the necessary horsepower do it:

o   Titania–though it would be a coin toss.  Almost literally.
o   The Mothers (who wouldn’t)
o   The White Council.  As in, ALL the White Council.  Every wizard on the planet.  And they’d need her Name.
o   Drakul.
o   Ferrovax.
o   The Red Court–again, ALL the Red Court, though their odds wouldn’t be good.
o   The entire White Court–very, very long odds on that, but if they actually pulled it off, whoever took Mab would effectively control her power.
o   Cowl (if the Darkhallow had succeeded).
o   A union of the old Elders of the Black Court.  They were freaking scary until the Whites arranged to have them hounded down by mortals.

All of that, of course, assumes that Mab is standing there alone, outside of Faerie, and not commanding an entire nation, literally millions and millions and millions of nightmarish creatures of every description.  Which she does.

There’s a REASON that when Mab said, “Sign these Accords and abide by them,” people listened. :)

I don't know what book Jim read, but I doubt all of them even with Drakul could have taken Mab. Now let's say Drakul was holding back in his fight against the Wardens, sure. Maybe he could do it. Let's say that perhaps those 6 Black Court were not all the "old Elders of the Black Court". Maybe some have died since then - the quote does say the White Court had them hunted down. Maybe some didn't even join Drakul and were waiting back at base (although Jim said in an interview the Drakul normally likes to surround himself with a small A-Team of vampires and it was Dracula that tried to spread the thing and turn it into a Court).

Also, was Jim really saying that the entire Red Court of Vampires (let's say 1000 vamps) plus the 13 Lords of the Outer Night (each of whom is almost a demigod) AND the Red King (Kukulcan) would be required to beat JUST the Queen of Winter herself? I'd have accepted all the normal Red Court Vamps, or the Lords of the Outer Night + Red King. But both seems like far more than necessary.

Just seems all a bit inconsistent - which is somewhat expected over so many years of writing a series. But still, it would be nice to get some clarification on whether those Elders in Battle Ground were the ones he referred to, and if so, why did they seem so weak? It seemed like without Drakul that Harry and the Wardens (not even including River Shoulders and Listens-to-Wind) could have taken them out.

And I have a whole other thread on how underpowered and underwhelming Drakul was. Sigh.
Hi, I'm a moderator. We're here to help. Please remain calm. Don't go outdoors.

Offline TheCuriousFan

  • Special Collections Division
  • Seriously?
  • ****
  • Posts: 16609
    • View Profile
Re: Elders of the Black Court
« Reply #1 on: December 14, 2020, 09:27:14 AM »
Yeah they seem like a pretty clear case of the group getting nerfed from their early sketch version since that early version is too powerful to use in the story without a TPK.
Currently dealing with a backlog of games.

If you want me to type up a book quote or find a WoJ quote, send me a PM.

Rest in peace mdodd.

Offline Kindler

  • Posty McPostington
  • ***
  • Posts: 1139
    • View Profile
Re: Elders of the Black Court
« Reply #2 on: December 14, 2020, 03:35:46 PM »
Could be the Law of Conservation of Ninjutsu. One ninja takes the protagonist twenty minutes to beat, but the protagonist can take down one per second when there are a hundred of them.
For a non-meta answer, yes, I do think that they were mildly disappointing. But I've also only read PT and BG once thus far (I'm listening to them now, but since the Plague started I haven't been driving much, so only listen to audiobooks for 15-30 minutes per day when I'm out with the dogs).
They did manage to kill Wardens in a straight up fight, when they were together, and "ready" (though I question whether you can ever really be ready to fight Drakul). Damn shame about Wild Bill, too. I liked him. Though I'm sure we'll see Chandler again (in fact, I'm surprised he didn't pop back up in BG).
From what I remember, Drakul didn't even seem to be really trying. I wonder what would've happened if someone like Morgan or Luccio were around for that fight—older battlemages with plenty of power to throw around and the technique to match.

Offline The_Sibelis

  • Posty McPostington
  • ***
  • Posts: 1036
    • View Profile
Re: Elders of the Black Court
« Reply #3 on: December 15, 2020, 12:16:05 AM »
I took the remark to mean they had less scope with their power even though they had more power than Mavra. Like harry, they're big british thugs by comparison. I think, it's because Mavra actually knew magic as a mortal where as the elders shown did not. When they can, in my mind/headcanon, simply eat someone and gain more power I don't think they've had a strong urge to study deeper into it than necessary.
Another thing.. on the VS Mab power levels. Blamps seem to have some absolutely extreme mind/willpower. The way they basically locked the wardens down and broke their mind. I think Mab might have more elemental power at her disposal but on the level of one on one, Drakul or the combined elders could match her. I do notice he said a reunion of the old elders. Maybe he meant when they were at full strength. For some reason I thought there were 30 elders it was said somewhere? Woj?
And Drakul was sooo holding back. Lord Raith gave it more of a go than he did really. He wasn't eager for the kill, he was just batting fly's around.

Offline Yuillegan

  • White Council
  • Posty McPostington
  • *****
  • Posts: 1383
  • Forum Moderator
    • View Profile
Re: Elders of the Black Court
« Reply #4 on: December 15, 2020, 03:10:10 AM »
Yeah they seem like a pretty clear case of the group getting nerfed from their early sketch version since that early version is too powerful to use in the story without a TPK.
Yeah it seems so. I mean, Jim could have written something like that in...but he chose not to.

Could be the Law of Conservation of Ninjutsu. One ninja takes the protagonist twenty minutes to beat, but the protagonist can take down one per second when there are a hundred of them.
For a non-meta answer, yes, I do think that they were mildly disappointing. But I've also only read PT and BG once thus far (I'm listening to them now, but since the Plague started I haven't been driving much, so only listen to audiobooks for 15-30 minutes per day when I'm out with the dogs).
They did manage to kill Wardens in a straight up fight, when they were together, and "ready" (though I question whether you can ever really be ready to fight Drakul). Damn shame about Wild Bill, too. I liked him. Though I'm sure we'll see Chandler again (in fact, I'm surprised he didn't pop back up in BG).
From what I remember, Drakul didn't even seem to be really trying. I wonder what would've happened if someone like Morgan or Luccio were around for that fight—older battlemages with plenty of power to throw around and the technique to match.
Indeed, I think that's a reasonable meta analysis. Just a very disappointing idea really. They only really beat the Warden's because Drakul entered the fray, and he took out Chandler and immobilisedg Ramirez and Harry in a matter of moments. Yoshimo and Wild Bill ran for cover (and Bill probably would have died had Chandler not stepped in), but while Dresden was distracted and Ramirez was down, Yoshimo and Bill were taken out - but the fight was both of them versus roughly 4 BCVs (5 if Mavra helped, as one was taken out by Ramirez and/or Bill - the writing seems to be inconsistent). Which actually is a very hard fight. I wonder if it had been a straight 2 on 2 whether Yoshimo and Bill would have won. And none of it explains why Drakul didn't just flatten them all with his Will attack. Or why Drakul was surprised by River Shoulders, as presumably he has super senses (Mavra has superhuman hearing) and he may even be able to Listen like Dresden as that could be a Starborn trick. Even if River was somehow masked from sight, sound, smell and touch...I can't really see Drakul not hearing a 12 foot obelisk being torn out of the ground. Maybe he was too distracted by Dresden...whatever. It does seem like Drakul wasn't trying to kill them all however, as you say. And I am not sure Bill and Yoshimo are "dead" exactly...I suspect they have been turned. I agree, it would have been interesting if Morgan or Luccio were around (especially at full strength - pre Dead Beat Luccio especially, plus the Warden blades). However I doubt either of them would have been a match for Drakul. If LtW (who matched a Skinwalker and caused it to flee - even if was it because it couldn't easily win) was getting smacked around by Drakul, even with River and Harry aiding him, I doubt they would have lasted long. LtW didn't seem to think they would have survived if Drakul hadn't left. Ebeneezer was afraid of Drakul (and we've seen what he can do). I doubt any single member of the Senior Council could have taken him; perhaps not even all of them. According to the quote above Drakul could take out Mab on his own, and as above it seems that the ENTIRE White Council would be needed to beat her (plus her Name). But then again...it does seem like that list is a bit out of date.

I took the remark to mean they had less scope with their power even though they had more power than Mavra. Like harry, they're big british thugs by comparison. I think, it's because Mavra actually knew magic as a mortal where as the elders shown did not. When they can, in my mind/headcanon, simply eat someone and gain more power I don't think they've had a strong urge to study deeper into it than necessary.
Another thing.. on the VS Mab power levels. Blamps seem to have some absolutely extreme mind/willpower. The way they basically locked the wardens down and broke their mind. I think Mab might have more elemental power at her disposal but on the level of one on one, Drakul or the combined elders could match her. I do notice he said a reunion of the old elders. Maybe he meant when they were at full strength. For some reason I thought there were 30 elders it was said somewhere? Woj?
And Drakul was sooo holding back. Lord Raith gave it more of a go than he did really. He wasn't eager for the kill, he was just batting fly's around.
Great pick up Sibelis! You reminded me of that WOJ and I found it, along with some other interesting ones. I think we can reasonably guess that most of those present in BG while being older and more senior (and more powerful) than Mavra, they were not the original Elders of the Black Court. Which begs the question, just how badass were those guys? Somewhere between what we saw and Drakul. Because while Harry called them "Elders" as you and I both have guessed, I suspect they were not the "original" 30 Elders. And even if they were, 30 of those guys would have been scary enough. We only saw 5.
Not sure I am with you that Mavra is more likely a better user of magic than the others (although that is possible), at any rate Drakul seems to pick Wizards as his recruits so there isn't much reason to suspect that those others were not Wizards either (as mortals, let alone as Vampires). But your head canon is as good a reason as any I think.

I think you're onto something with the extreme mind/will magic. Especially when you consider all Vampires we have seen have some version of it. Not to mention at the strongest level, beings like Drakul and the Lords of the Outer Night and the Red King seem to have that godlike Will attack power. Not to mention that the Corpsetaker's mind magic seems to be related to it's Necromantic knowledge, and the Black Court are out there using that same dark power. Maybe it's a matter of the right tool for the job. Perhaps those kind of attacks would be uniquely effective at taking out a being like Mab. I wonder if the other "original Elders" were more like the Lords of the Outer Night and could use their Wills as weapons?

And you are quite right, Drakul was holding back. But I still have no idea why, which is incredibly frustrating.

Anyway here are the relevant WOJs, plus some interesting other ones.

Quote
2009 WoJ forum post
4. if the elders of the black court could have taken mab, then HOW ON EARTH did any mere force of humans manage to go up and stake them? i mean, they should’ve wiped out anything that was coming after them if they can take on MAB herself…just a thought
Power in the spirit world isn’t the same thing as power in the material world.  And a one-on-thirtyish fight (Mab vs the elders of the BC) is WAY different than a one-on-20,000 fight (a BC vampire against a modest mortal city).  Especially when the 20,000 know what your weaknesses are, and how to kill you with them. Smiley  And that’s assuming that you don’t have a saint, or an independent wizard, or a shaman, a Knight of the Cross or some other champion, or other spiritual allies on your side which was not uncommon.  Hell, for that matter, you might well be aided by vampires from the other Courts.  *Everyone* resented how powerful the Blacks had become.
(and shouldn’t the black court be the most numerous? in blood rites, ebenezer mentioned after a few weeks, there would be dozens or even hundreds of vamps, so y don’t the black court vamps just settle down in africa or india and start biting away?)
Nukes.  :)
You get all /that/ assertive, and you risk stirring mortals into awareness.  And we monkeys are /dangerous/ in large groups, especially with all our ferromancy (technology).
There’s also a psychological issue on behalf of the vampires.  Bear in mind that evolution made a pretty brutal selection among the Black Court.  The ones who survived and prospered were those who avoided notice, respected the potential danger mortals represented, and who were generally quick to leave town rather than charge into a confrontation.
In any personal-scale conflict, a mature BC vamp is gonna tear holes through any mortal or White Court vampire.  But the mortals started cheating, and doing all their fighting in angry mobs, and creating weapons that were ridiculously overpowered for the job of killing one another which could actually inconvenience, wound, or even kill a BC vamp.  Murphy did all right in that BC nest, because she had allies, appropriate weapons and (most importantly) knowledge and a plan.
Quote
And also what is Drakul a scion of?
Drakul wasn’t a scion of anything! He was something entirely unhuman that got trapped in human form. Dracula was his half-human child, who naturally had enormous paternal issues, and wound up creating himself as the first Black Court Vampire in an effort to win his father’s approval.
It didn’t work out so well.
2015 AMA
How are Black Court Master Vampires made/elevated? Elders?
Mainly by growing more powerful by feeding on more lives. The more you kill, the stronger you are, as a Black Court vamp. Also by demonstrating that you can beat the stuffing out of your rivals. They’re very much a Darwinian society of might-makes-right.
But most of the old ones worked out that you can’t just go on killing sprees to farm XP. You’re helpless a large portion of every day, and the food will come find you and end you. So they wait for good opportunities for that kind of thing. Wars, famines, and plagues are awesome for leveling up.
2016 Reddit Podcast Q&A
When are we going to see Mavra again?
Um… 19?  *pondering*  Wait, I’m sorry we’ll definitely see her in Mirror Mirror.  She’s a fast ally of Dresden’s in Mirror Mirror.
2016 Reddit Podcast Q&A
When your a black court vampire who essentially just gets to stay alive for as long as you want, time is much different to an immortal or virtual immortal than it is to one of us.
How old is she?
I think she’s about 600.

WoJ on Vampires
Blampires, and the Stokerlipse
Quote from: jimbutcher on June 21, 2011, 08:59:27 PM
Quote from: Drulinda
if it came to it would he [Harry] actually be able to use necromancy on mavra?

Harry wasn’t bluffing.  ::)
[...]
The BC didn’t /know/ about the WC’s involvement until well after the fact, at which point it was entirely academic.  The BC who are left survive because they are extremely pragmatic.  They don’t have enough trouble surviving /without/ picking a fight with the entire White Court, who will only send the peasants and pitchforks anyway?  If one needs to vent one’s spleen, one does it on hapless mortals, preferably those no one will miss.

The BC who wanted to get all ballsy about Just Vengeance died in the fifties and sixties, culminating in the heyday of the Hammer films. :)

Also this interesting bit about Lord Raith:
Quote
2016 Reddit Podcast Q&A
How old is Lord Raith?
He’s a couple thousand years old.  He’s got 2 thousand years of paranoia kinda built up.  Plus he’s been absolutely bonkers the past 30 years or so.  He’s hardly functional as a vampire, he’s getting to where he’s not evne functional as a figure head for much longer.  That’s going to be a problem for lara to deal with.
Will we find out about Lord Raith’s library?
There’s kind of a long game going on in the Dresden Files, and Lord Raith has been involved in it in the last couple of cycle’s it’s gone on.  He’s been trying to educate himself about it, and he meant to be a player in it this time it came around, but getting involved with Margret kind of screwed him over.
Lara’s got his library now and knows everything he knows, which explains a lot of her actions.
later in the video

Now we have an idea of the game, and some of the players (both current and former). Drakul does seem to look a bit like Lord Raith too...and even a bit like the Red King. Just saying. Make of that what you will. What I found most interesting was that Lord Raith has been involved in the Cycle a few times, but only recently tried to become a 'player'. I wonder what role he played previously? And what the difference is between the 'players' and those who are merely involved?
Hi, I'm a moderator. We're here to help. Please remain calm. Don't go outdoors.

Offline Mira

  • Needs A Life
  • ***
  • Posts: 24329
    • View Profile
Re: Elders of the Black Court
« Reply #5 on: December 15, 2020, 02:38:42 PM »
Quote
And also what is Drakul a scion of?
Drakul wasn’t a scion of anything! He was something entirely unhuman that got trapped in human form. Dracula was his half-human child, who naturally had enormous paternal issues, and wound up creating himself as the first Black Court Vampire in an effort to win his father’s approval.
It didn’t work out so well.
2015 AMA

So now as of Battle Ground, Drakul supposedly is a star born.  So how did that happened?  So did whoever parented him mess up with the star born process and end up with something not human but star born?  Was that an answer that Jim just gave off the top of his head and forgot about when he wrote Battle Ground?

Offline Yuillegan

  • White Council
  • Posty McPostington
  • *****
  • Posts: 1383
  • Forum Moderator
    • View Profile
Re: Elders of the Black Court
« Reply #6 on: December 15, 2020, 10:36:23 PM »
So now as of Battle Ground, Drakul supposedly is a star born.  So how did that happened?  So did whoever parented him mess up with the star born process and end up with something not human but star born?  Was that an answer that Jim just gave off the top of his head and forgot about when he wrote Battle Ground?
I think that's confirmed, we don't need to assume it as it came straight from Drakul.

Could be that Harry isn't totally human...perhaps the starborn thing is like a butterfly life cycle and Harry is just in caterpillar stage and Drakul is full butterfly. Who knows how the process goes?

I think that description of Harry from the Cornerhounds perspective (a towering being of light with a storm front around his shoulders) is quite telling. Reminded me a bit of Vadderung (who I would not at all be surprised to find out was a starborn).

And it's all tied up with Lucifer somehow.
Hi, I'm a moderator. We're here to help. Please remain calm. Don't go outdoors.

Offline KurtinStGeorge

  • Posty McPostington
  • ***
  • Posts: 4246
  • Oh no, there goes Tokyo
    • View Profile
Re: Elders of the Black Court
« Reply #7 on: December 15, 2020, 11:51:11 PM »
I agree with the OP.  If you go back and read the battle that took place with Harry, Lara and a badly wounded Thomas on one side versus three newbie Black Court vamps in Blood Rites, Mavra's recruits seemed far scarier than veteran Black Court members, which logic tells us should have been tougher and scarier than Mavra herself.  (Or itself)

As far as Drakul goes, for some inexplicable reason he was holding back.  If that's not on the list of evil overlord mistakes to be avoided, it should be.  "I will not hold back and spare any enemies because I want to take their measure, and I won't waste time with banter.  I'm just going to get the messy business of killing them done as quickly as possible.  That way I can go home and have more time to binge watch "Emily in Paris."  Because after a hard day of spilling my enemies entrails and devouring their souls, I need something light and romantic to even things out." 
« Last Edit: December 16, 2020, 06:21:34 AM by KurtinStGeorge »
Those are my principles, and if you don't like them... well, I have others.

Groucho Marx

Offline TheCuriousFan

  • Special Collections Division
  • Seriously?
  • ****
  • Posts: 16609
    • View Profile
Re: Elders of the Black Court
« Reply #8 on: December 16, 2020, 06:51:27 AM »
Yeah it seems so. I mean, Jim could have written something like that in...but he chose not to.
It probably would have worked better if he went with Mavra being the head of the group instead of the annoyed junior of the bunch.
Currently dealing with a backlog of games.

If you want me to type up a book quote or find a WoJ quote, send me a PM.

Rest in peace mdodd.

Offline Yuillegan

  • White Council
  • Posty McPostington
  • *****
  • Posts: 1383
  • Forum Moderator
    • View Profile
Re: Elders of the Black Court
« Reply #9 on: December 16, 2020, 10:00:48 AM »
It probably would have worked better if he went with Mavra being the head of the group instead of the annoyed junior of the bunch.
Agreed. I honestly would have preferred Drakul was saved up a bit more and had more time to be worked on.

I agree with the OP.  If you go back and read the battle that took place with Harry, Lara and a badly wounded Thomas on one side versus three newbie Black Court vamps in Blood Rites, Mavra's recruits seemed far scarier than veteran Black Court members, which logic tells us should have been tougher and scarier than Mavra herself.  (Or itself)
Appreciate it! Good point, they were hardly scarier than Mavra herself and barely her brood. Even if you take into account Harry and Co. have grown in power and skill, it still doesn't make sense. Then again, this is exactly what happened to the Denarians. Also, no use of Faith magic by Harry or any of the others?? I get they didn't have garlic or daylight etc. And why didn't Harry use that special "how to control Black Court Vampires with Necromancy spell" from the Word of Kemmler?

Also surely Drakul has the Word of Kemmler...so why hasn't he used it yet? Is he waiting for a convenient trip to Chicago because all the other major population centres are booked out for ascension rituals?

Quote
As far as Drakul goes, for some inexplicable reason he was holding back.  If that's not on the list of evil overlord mistakes to be avoided, it should be.  "I will not hold back and spare any enemies because I want to take their measure, and I won't waste time with banter.  I'm just going to get the messy business of killing them done as quickly as possible.  That way I can go home and have more time to binge watch "Emily in Paris."  Because after a hard day of spilling my enemies entrails and devouring their souls, I need something light and romantic to even things out."

This has to be the most likely explanation lol. Love the "Emily in Paris" bit especially. But yeah, glad I am not the only one confused by Drakul's apparently light touch.

Hi, I'm a moderator. We're here to help. Please remain calm. Don't go outdoors.

Offline TheCuriousFan

  • Special Collections Division
  • Seriously?
  • ****
  • Posts: 16609
    • View Profile
Re: Elders of the Black Court
« Reply #10 on: December 16, 2020, 10:04:33 AM »
Agreed. I honestly would have preferred Drakul was saved up a bit more and had more time to be worked on.
Appreciate it! Good point, they were hardly scarier than Mavra herself and barely her brood. Even if you take into account Harry and Co. have grown in power and skill, it still doesn't make sense. Then again, this is exactly what happened to the Denarians. Also, no use of Faith magic by Harry or any of the others?? I get they didn't have garlic or daylight etc. And why didn't Harry use that special "how to control Black Court Vampires with Necromancy spell" from the Word of Kemmler?

Also surely Drakul has the Word of Kemmler...so why hasn't he used it yet? Is he waiting for a convenient trip to Chicago because all the other major population centres are booked out for ascension rituals?
 
This has to be the most likely explanation lol. Love the "Emily in Paris" bit especially. But yeah, glad I am not the only one confused by Drakul's apparently light touch.
Because roll for sanity loss with each use.

Quote
When Dresden threatened to use necromancy against the Black Court, was that something he learned directly from the Word of Kemmler that was part of the book or was it just that he learned more about how they worked with necromancy?

Oh no Kemmler had a recipe, "how to make a Black Court vampire your bitch", he had that. That was practically the name of the spell. Dresden's like "oh yeah I see how that works now yeah I can screw you up ". It'd do horrible things to him, roll 3D6 that's how many sanity points you lose. Like that.
Currently dealing with a backlog of games.

If you want me to type up a book quote or find a WoJ quote, send me a PM.

Rest in peace mdodd.

Offline Mira

  • Needs A Life
  • ***
  • Posts: 24329
    • View Profile
Re: Elders of the Black Court
« Reply #11 on: December 16, 2020, 05:20:24 PM »
Quote
I think that's confirmed, we don't need to assume it as it came straight from Drakul.

I get that but it totally clashes with what Jim said about him in 2015!

Quote
And also what is Drakul a scion of?
Drakul wasn’t a scion of anything! He was something entirely unhuman that got trapped in human form. Dracula was his half-human child, who naturally had enormous paternal issues, and wound up creating himself as the first Black Court Vampire in an effort to win his father’s approval.
It didn’t work out so well.
2015 AMA
So apparently one doesn't have to be human to be star born, or someone tried for it and screwed up.

Offline The_Sibelis

  • Posty McPostington
  • ***
  • Posts: 1036
    • View Profile
Re: Elders of the Black Court
« Reply #12 on: December 16, 2020, 07:37:34 PM »
I get that but it totally clashes with what Jim said about him in 2015!
So apparently one doesn't have to be human to be star born, or someone tried for it and screwed up.
you don't, you don't have to be Mortal. It's in a new Woj I just read in the transcription section thanks to TCFs work.
Jim implies you just have to be very unlucky.. I'm wondering if it's simply being Starborn is unlucky or he specifically meant being an immortal Starborn is unlucky. Drakul did end up stuck in a mortal(ish) she'll after all.

Offline KurtinStGeorge

  • Posty McPostington
  • ***
  • Posts: 4246
  • Oh no, there goes Tokyo
    • View Profile
Re: Elders of the Black Court
« Reply #13 on: December 17, 2020, 01:07:40 AM »
And why didn't Harry use that special "how to control Black Court Vampires with Necromancy spell" from the Word of Kemmler?

Yes, all Harry needed to reanimate Sue was Butters acting as his drummer.  I could see Harry having a future conversation about that night with Bob which ends with Bob saying something like, "Harry you idiot.  You went toe to toe with Mavra and three Black Court vamps older than her and you didn't try to sock puppet them with necromancy."  You also have to wonder if Drakul is alive or undead.  If not alive, necromancy should work against him as well.

The only reasonable defense Harry might have for not using necromancy was there was a mortal who was about to be sacrificed.  Perhaps pulling off the spell would have taken longer than Harry believed he could wait.


Also surely Drakul has the Word of Kemmler...so why hasn't he used it yet? Is he waiting for a convenient trip to Chicago because all the other major population centres are booked out for ascension rituals?

Mavra was acting as the drummer, so I think that means she wasn't doing the spell; however, Mavra was the one who got the word of Kemmler from Harry.  So, did she teach the spell to one of the older Black Court vampires or to Drakul him itself?  The whole thing was just a charade so Drakul to gather up some new recruits.  It seems odd that he picked out Wardens Wild Bill and Yoshino.  What was special about them?  At some point, I'd like an explanation for that.

For whatever reason, Jim didn't want to give us anything substantial to ponder over other than wondering what "Stars and Stones" actually means.  Personally, I found that somewhat disappointing.  We've been waiting for Drakul to appear since he was first mentioned in Blood Rites, which was published in August, 2004.  I started reading the Dresden Files novels in late 2006, so I got to Blood Rites sometime in 2007.  That's a long time to wait; and when Drakul finally makes an appearance all we learn is that he resembles an ivory statue, he eats Starborns like they were his Wheaties and something called the "Stars and Stones" is going to happen soon. 
« Last Edit: December 17, 2020, 01:12:31 AM by KurtinStGeorge »
Those are my principles, and if you don't like them... well, I have others.

Groucho Marx

Offline Yuillegan

  • White Council
  • Posty McPostington
  • *****
  • Posts: 1383
  • Forum Moderator
    • View Profile
Re: Elders of the Black Court
« Reply #14 on: December 17, 2020, 07:13:42 AM »
Because roll for sanity loss with each use.
Always thought that was a rather weak explanation especially considering it didn't make Dresden's threat all that credible. He might have been bluffing but it's hardly a workable spell if he can't use it. It more sounded like Jim forgot he wrote it and came up with an explanation to dig himself out of the hole he wrote himself into. But fair enough then. Still doesn't explain the lack of Faith magic though.

I get that but it totally clashes with what Jim said about him in 2015!
So apparently one doesn't have to be human to be star born, or someone tried for it and screwed up.
Mmm. I am not so sure it does clash necessarily...but I can't be certain either. It could be that (as a possible explanation) that Drakul was born a starborn and became a monster (and so is a "what can go wrong" type of thing). Sibelis is right - the WOJ seems to confirm you don't have to be mortal to be starborn. There is certainly a missing link. I think a better question is why is Drakul a starborn? What does being a starborn get him? What does it do the story to have him as one?

It wouldn't even surprise me to learn of other Immortals and semi-immortals who are also "starborn" whatever that means. But Jim also says it's really unlucky, so it probably isn't that many.

Yes, all Harry needed to reanimate Sue was Butters acting as his drummer.  I could see Harry having a future conversation about that night with Bob which ends with Bob saying something like, "Harry you idiot.  You went toe to toe with Mavra and three Black Court vamps older than her and you didn't try to sock puppet them with necromancy."  You also have to wonder if Drakul is alive or undead.  If not alive, necromancy should work against him as well.

The only reasonable defense Harry might have for not using necromancy was there was a mortal who was about to be sacrificed.  Perhaps pulling off the spell would have taken longer than Harry believed he could wait.

Mavra was acting as the drummer, so I think that means she wasn't doing the spell; however, Mavra was the one who got the word of Kemmler from Harry.  So, did she teach the spell to one of the older Black Court vampires or to Drakul him itself?  The whole thing was just a charade so Drakul to gather up some new recruits.  It seems odd that he picked out Wardens Wild Bill and Yoshino.  What was special about them?  At some point, I'd like an explanation for that.

For whatever reason, Jim didn't want to give us anything substantial to ponder over other than wondering what "Stars and Stones" actually means.  Personally, I found that somewhat disappointing.  We've been waiting for Drakul to appear since he was first mentioned in Blood Rites, which was published in August, 2004.  I started reading the Dresden Files novels in late 2006, so I got to Blood Rites sometime in 2007.  That's a long time to wait; and when Drakul finally makes an appearance all we learn is that he resembles an ivory statue, he eats Starborns like they were his Wheaties and something called the "Stars and Stones" is going to happen soon. 
Could well be that alive or dead is a bit of a grey area with Drakul. I suspect a good in-universe explanation for Harry not using Necromancy is that he was already under enough scrutiny from the Council and at that point wasn't attempting to oppose them. But I am sure Bob would have thought Harry was being a moron - he normally thinks that anyway! And yes, perhaps it isn't the easiest bit of evocation to perform under pressure.

It was...but why go to Chicago? Are there not enough vulnerable Wizards out in the world? I get that Jim wanted to show him off...but it just felt a bit implausible. And why not pick LtW and River or Harry? Why pick the three least powerful? Not to mention...would any of those seem impressive to a being who has been alive for millennia? I agree we definitely need better explanation about this.

Yeah, exactly! After 16 years this is what Jim has to reveal? Quite the let down really. I don't know what's going on with Jim's writing, and I did despite my grumbling actually enjoy the latest few books on the whole. Unfortunately it just feels like because things have been going on so long Jim is making a lot of errors, and mostly because it seems he doesn't remember what the original idea was all that well or what he has previously said or written. Which is a bit understandable considering the length of time. Perhaps he should have written his own compendium of background info and world building, or instead of going to the wiki when he needs to remember come instead to this site and look through the WOJ section and the various threads.

Hopefully Jim will sort it out in a future book.
Hi, I'm a moderator. We're here to help. Please remain calm. Don't go outdoors.