Author Topic: Proven Guilty: An update to my previous thoughts on the topic  (Read 14542 times)

Offline wardenferry419

  • Posty McPostington
  • ***
  • Posts: 5265
  • Can I get a Hells Bells !!!!
    • View Profile
Re: Proven Guilty: An update to my previous thoughts on the topic
« Reply #45 on: October 30, 2017, 02:25:32 PM »
My bad. I forgot foreshadowing.
Make Mine Butcher!
Who do I have to turn to ice to get a whiskey on the rocks?

Offline Firestarter

  • Conversationalist
  • **
  • Posts: 140
    • View Profile
Re: Proven Guilty: An update to my previous thoughts on the topic
« Reply #46 on: November 08, 2017, 04:08:43 PM »
Future Harry rammed current Harry.
Future Harry fixed Little Chicago.

I may be mistaken, but given the impact on those events, it's probably that.
... hear me roar ;)

Offline Rasins

  • Seriously?
  • ***
  • Posts: 12188
  • Aid the younger and weaker.
    • View Profile
Re: Proven Guilty: An update to my previous thoughts on the topic
« Reply #47 on: November 08, 2017, 05:56:12 PM »
OR .... Mab fixed Little Chicago.  She was responsible for Harry's well being since she had Leah on ice.
At times I wish I had a clone, but then I realize, I could never live with that a-hole.

DV Rasins 2006 BK+++ RP++ JB++++ TH++++ WG+(+?) CL SW++ BC- MC---

Offline Foxed

  • Posty McPostington
  • ***
  • Posts: 1438
    • View Profile
Re: Proven Guilty: An update to my previous thoughts on the topic
« Reply #48 on: November 08, 2017, 09:40:50 PM »
The answer lies in the future roles planned for Molly Carpenter. Mab's desire to have her and Harry positioned for future work is the driving force of the story.

I don't buy it. Mab is simply not interested in who Harry is training. Unless I see more, I don't think so.

My theory is that Charity is a descendant of Titania, an Molly was being groomed by Titania for the Summer Lady position.

First of all, the weather is mentioned as it usually is with Fairy Queens around. It is a hot summer. One could conclude that Titania is in Chicago.

Second, Titania hates Lily. Lily is the Summer Lady because Titania didn't plan for Aurora's death. Mab, on the other hand, is basically keeping Sarissa around offpage for this reason (as well as a connection to humanity). So, grooming Molly for Winter Lady at this point doesn't make sense. Mab HAS a spare. Plus whatever covert grooming Molly received emphasized emotion over reason (such as using fear to change minds).

Quote
Remember this is all kicked off by a letter from the Gatekeeper.  We now know that he hangs with a lot of folks from Winter and is working with Mab to defend the Outer Gates. His message was about Black Magic in Chicago.  Harry gets this message right after the execution of a Warlock.

If so, that's an awful roundabout way to get Harry to look for black magic. I think we must take Bob's theory as fact for now: Rashid could not tell Harry more. Also, they spend an awful lot of time discussing time travel for it to have no effect on the plot. Jim's a lazy writer. He wouldn't their in time travel rules for no reason.

Quote
Molly, at this point, is a Warlock and clearly on a downward slope.  Charity admits that she had problems and future events (particularly TC, Changes, and GS) show that Molly is touched by darkness.  Imagine that Harry does not act.  I would consider it likely that Molly would be full Warlock and be executed.  The primary outcome of PG is that Molly is saved from immediate Warlockdom and is Harry's apprentice.

Molly is tricked into creating fear anchors, which a fairy queen uses to send the fetches to kidnap her. I suspect this is Maeve, who is trying to subvert the gullible Lily. Realizing that Titania is creating a spare, Maeve seeks to destroy it before it's useful. Mab, however, suspects that Maeve is subverted by the enemy, and summons the Fetches to her with the girl that Maeve is so interested in. This brings along Harry and only THEN does Mab know Molly's importance. Her choice for Winter Knight. Titania's choice for Summer Lady.

Quote
The entire scenario would be set up for Glau to monitor Molly's progress to evil.  I agree with Harry that Glau was a cutout and that leads to the answer to the next two questions.

Glau doesn't know Molly exists. And even if he did, how is he both monitoring her and a decoy? I suspect that Glau was a secondary fear anchor in Maeve's plan.

Quote
Mab sent the fetches to kidnap Molly to keep her away from the Black Council.  They were upset enough about this that they attacked Arctus Tor.

Except the battle of Arctis Tor is finished when the rescue party arrives, and Molly is still there.

Quote
That means it is Mab that fixes Little Chicago.  She does so because she wants Harry to succeed in his rescue.  This is similar to the help she gave him by calling Thomas in CD.  I want to point out that this plot is similar to (in some ways) the Archive in SmF.  Mab tried to kidnap the Archive so that the Denarians could not (and failed).  In the PG case put Molly in instead of the Archive.  She does not make these things easy for Harry (remember the line about preparing Harry to become Winter Knight). 

Mab doesn't seem the type. If her damned fool wizard is going to blow himself up, he's a weak fool and she doesn't want him.

Quote
The other thing that gets accomplished in PG is that Mab shows Nemesis to Harry.  He does not recognize it but it is called a sickness and several nFected sidhe are part of the story.  If Mab is listening in to the conversation at Mac's with Maeve, then she would know that Maeve in nFected right then.

Mab almost certainly figures it out in this book. Next we see her, she is still too mad to speak without killing mortals. My guess is that Maeve subverting the Eldest Fetch is what proved it, if not how Harry managed to smuggle Summer fire into her domain.

Quote
Finally, Ace likely is the one that hits Harry's car.  He is likely the bomber of Murphy's car in WN.

That is much too simple and too pat for me. Elsewhere I said I think Lash made the whole car accident up. Harry details Lash's illusory powers directly before it happens and there are no witnesses. Why?

Future Harry is living in Harry's brain for the duration of Proven Guilty, and the accident is to fake a concussion to explain away Harry's limited mental real estate. He's who Lash speaks to when Harry's asleep, and he's who fixes Little Chicago. He's why the author hits us with a giant clue bat that says "TIME TRAVEL." I don't know to what end, but expect a future book will clear this up.
My Theory Emporium

Eldest Gruff: Based on what
raidem: TEXT, go find it yourself.

Offline Foxed

  • Posty McPostington
  • ***
  • Posts: 1438
    • View Profile
Re: Proven Guilty: An update to my previous thoughts on the topic
« Reply #49 on: November 08, 2017, 09:58:52 PM »
If you can not see the problem with going back in time, then remember this - if you can...do the "Kill the bad guy" thing before it becomes a problem for Harry.  Why would TT Harry just not wait at Molly's, Kill the Fetches, and move along.  He knows they are showing up.

Yeah, but kill the Fetches and Molly never becomes Harry's apprentice. Never becomes Lea's responsibility.

Never becomes Winter Lady.

Interfere with Proven Guilty, and who the Winter Lady is post-Cold Days is a total wild card.
My Theory Emporium

Eldest Gruff: Based on what
raidem: TEXT, go find it yourself.

Offline wardenferry419

  • Posty McPostington
  • ***
  • Posts: 5265
  • Can I get a Hells Bells !!!!
    • View Profile
Re: Proven Guilty: An update to my previous thoughts on the topic
« Reply #50 on: November 08, 2017, 11:21:06 PM »
Good points, Foxed. Nice to hear from you again.
Make Mine Butcher!
Who do I have to turn to ice to get a whiskey on the rocks?

Offline Kindler

  • Posty McPostington
  • ***
  • Posts: 1139
    • View Profile
Re: Proven Guilty: An update to my previous thoughts on the topic
« Reply #51 on: November 09, 2017, 02:56:25 PM »
That is much too simple and too pat for me. Elsewhere I said I think Lash made the whole car accident up. Harry details Lash's illusory powers directly before it happens and there are no witnesses. Why?

I'm not really sold on the time travel stuff yet, but this is a really interesting idea that I've never considered or seen before. Not sure I agree with the reason for doing it, but I like the concept a whole lot.

Does Harry bring the Beetle to Mike? Dang it, I just reread most of the series and I can't remember.

Offline raidem

  • Posty McPostington
  • ***
  • Posts: 5634
  • Duck's Apprentice
    • View Profile
Re: Proven Guilty: An update to my previous thoughts on the topic
« Reply #52 on: November 09, 2017, 03:05:35 PM »
Murphy comes and sees the actual damage.
Theory doesn't fit.
"That's it???  It's really that simple? 
LIES!  Damn lies!  It's a cover up!
WOJ: http://www.paranetonline.com/index.php/topic,21772.0.html

Offline Talby16

  • Conversationalist
  • **
  • Posts: 402
    • View Profile
Re: Proven Guilty: An update to my previous thoughts on the topic
« Reply #53 on: November 09, 2017, 03:46:04 PM »
Quote
Grayson came ambling over to us. "Wrecker's on the way," he said. "What do we got here?"
"Hit and run," Murphy said.
Grayson lifted his eyebrows and eyed me. "Yeah? Looked to me like you got hit a couple of times. On purpose-like."

Furthermore the other cop comments on the damage.

Offline Talby16

  • Conversationalist
  • **
  • Posts: 402
    • View Profile
Re: Proven Guilty: An update to my previous thoughts on the topic
« Reply #54 on: November 09, 2017, 03:52:32 PM »
Quote
"You sure it was deliberate?"

"Yeah. But whoever it was, he wasn't a pro."

"Why do you say that?"

"If he had been, he'd have spun me easy. No idea he was there until he'd hit me. Could have bumped me into a spin before I could have straightened out. Flipped my car a few times. Killed me pretty good." I rubbed at the back of my neck. A nice, all-body ache was already spreading out into my muscles. "Isn't exactly the best place for it, either."

We know that the attack was not very successful. Which means that it truly was an attack of opportunity as Murphy speculates or it has another purpose altogether. When you remove the chance of injury/death to Dresden, the attack only accomplished a few things. Chief among them is that it involved Murphy from the beginning. We do not know how long Harry would have waited to bring her in if she had not come to the scene of the wreck. My opinion is that a third party (Mab or future Harry possibly) wanted to make sure Murphy was helping Dresden from the get go. Either to ensure the operation's success, ensure Harry's survival, or to move Murphy into a new position on the board.

Offline jonas

  • Posty McPostington
  • ***
  • Posts: 1258
  • Surpassed Ms. Duck
    • View Profile
Re: Proven Guilty: An update to my previous thoughts on the topic
« Reply #55 on: November 09, 2017, 04:11:24 PM »
Applying a very simple formulaic approach most of these can be answered by what they change in hindsight to what would have happened without them happening, like LC making Harrys head pop. Iirc right after the crash is when Murph gets involved... Going backwards to an early reference to shenanigins, Id Harry(a widespread though of intrusion) directly tells Harry to trust Murphy more, thus getting her involved more directly and changing their early antagonistic dynamic.
Which if i'm correct about MM being original unaltered timeline, would make sense she's more enemy than friend to Yrrah, him never having trusted her there...
Quote from: A. Lanning
I'm sorry, My responses are limited. You must ask the right questions.
Quote from: C Chaplin
...And so as long as men die, Liberty will never perish.

Offline raidem

  • Posty McPostington
  • ***
  • Posts: 5634
  • Duck's Apprentice
    • View Profile
Re: Proven Guilty: An update to my previous thoughts on the topic
« Reply #56 on: November 09, 2017, 05:02:41 PM »
Yeah, Most of my thoughts have touched on IdHarry telling Harry "tell Murphy everything."  And, I've mentioned before I think in this thread about how the car crash brought in Murphy, which also led to Murphy inserting herself and then helping Harry to think of using Charity's blood to find where Molly had been, so as to locate where she had crossed over into deep Faerie.
"That's it???  It's really that simple? 
LIES!  Damn lies!  It's a cover up!
WOJ: http://www.paranetonline.com/index.php/topic,21772.0.html

Offline Rasins

  • Seriously?
  • ***
  • Posts: 12188
  • Aid the younger and weaker.
    • View Profile
Re: Proven Guilty: An update to my previous thoughts on the topic
« Reply #57 on: November 09, 2017, 07:28:47 PM »
Murphy comes and sees the actual damage.
Theory doesn't fit.

"Murphy" comes and sees the actual damage.

Does she ever mention it later?
At times I wish I had a clone, but then I realize, I could never live with that a-hole.

DV Rasins 2006 BK+++ RP++ JB++++ TH++++ WG+(+?) CL SW++ BC- MC---

Offline Talby16

  • Conversationalist
  • **
  • Posts: 402
    • View Profile
Re: Proven Guilty: An update to my previous thoughts on the topic
« Reply #58 on: November 09, 2017, 07:30:12 PM »
"Murphy" comes and sees the actual damage.

Does she ever mention it later?

At some point during the book doesn't she mention Harry's unknown hit and run driver being an unresolved plot thread?

Offline Kindler

  • Posty McPostington
  • ***
  • Posts: 1139
    • View Profile
Re: Proven Guilty: An update to my previous thoughts on the topic
« Reply #59 on: November 09, 2017, 07:32:34 PM »
Shhhhhhhhh. You guys are ruining perfectly good speculation fodder by bringing up the actual events of the book and applying critical thinking.