Show Posts

This section allows you to view all posts made by this member. Note that you can only see posts made in areas you currently have access to.


Messages - Dagroth

Pages: [1]
1
DF Spoilers / Re: Lara Raith marriage consummation
« on: July 30, 2022, 12:57:03 PM »
It may be, but unless someone shows me something in text, I will keep my theory until !2 months. Mm, perhaps not even a text would convince me. Not after the trick Jim played us with the Christmas story.  :)

Which trick do you mean?

2
DF Spoilers / Re: "Dog Men" questions
« on: July 30, 2022, 12:53:42 PM »
I have to disagree with you there... To me, at least, Alfred comes across as an embodiment of Order/Law. He's the locus genii of the most secure prison in the mortal world after all.
In D&D terms, his alignment would be lawful neutral. That is to say, follows the letter of the law (although maybe not the spirit), regardless of what the law says.

I think they mean Puck, not Alfred, there. (though I only have a vague idea about the events of "Wild Card", having not read it yet)

3
DF Spoilers / Re: "Dog Men" questions
« on: July 27, 2022, 03:49:18 PM »
I have it as a separate comic book. No idea, if it was published as part of some larger collection.

4
DF Spoilers / "Dog Men" questions
« on: July 27, 2022, 01:53:10 PM »
I just finished reading it, and I'm wondering about two things:
1) When Harry nearly punched a guy wearing an animal mask, Listens-to-Wind all but threatened to report him to the White Council. What for? I mean, not to defend Harry's overreaction, but White Council deals with breaking the laws of magic etc., (nearly) punching someone in the face doesn't count.
2) After Harry shot the female ghoul's hand off, we see him tossing it out the car's window (after he decided not to use it to find her). Later on, he tosses what I think is the same hand to one of the Dog Men, saying they have a common enemy. Where did he get it? Is that a continuity error, or did I miss something?

5
DF Spoilers / Re: How powerful is Ivy getting?
« on: November 28, 2021, 01:10:25 PM »
She's the embodiment of knowledge but with as many people on the planet and the internet.

There's something I'm wondering about here: Ivy has access to everything written or printed on paper (Not just books, for example, in I think "Small Favor", Harry writes the message along the line of "Hold on, help is coming" on a random piece of paper, and Ivy later says she got it.) - but with computers, Internet, audio- and e- books, etc... well, does she have access to all that information, too? (Magic has problems with modern technology, as evidenced by Harry's)

If not, that'd seriously limit her knowledge. Or maybe even nullify her purpose. H.P. Lovecraft's works most likely also exist in audio- and e- book form, for example, and they made humanity aware of some of the Old Ones. Other ones can also easily be on the Internet, e-books, digital audio recordings... if Ivy's power can't access that kind of stuff, that'd make it largely obsolete in a modern age, at least until magic "catches up" (I don't remember where, but Harry once said, or narrated, that magic once caused warts and the like, which made its practicioners easy-ish to identify - presumably, it will eventually adjust to modern tech, and the side effects move on to something else).

6
Codex Alera Spoilers / What would the Vord eat, if they won?
« on: January 15, 2020, 12:26:31 AM »
I get the impression, that the Vord's goal is total eradication of all life that's not them.

So, if they achieved it, what would they eat?

Those in Wax Forest, back in "Furies of Calderon", seemed to be surviving on animals that fell or wandered in (like that crow whom Tavi tried to free from the Croach), and the occasional Marat, who failed to stay sneaky enough and was caught (Kitai said something about it, as far as I remember).

But if they killed everything there is to kill, and covered all the ground with Croach, it seems there'd be nothing left for them to eat.

Well, there were trees in Wax Forest (if they were still alive), but I got the impression Vord are carnivores, or at least getting whatever food they keep in and transport through the Croach from animals & people, not plants.

In fact, what did they eat in the areas they conquered and covered in Croach (like the majority of Alera at the time of Third Calderon) ?

7
I also believe this is why you go mad/have to be mad to mess with time, kill with magic etc. You have to believe in complete violations of the Laws of Reality.

How is killing someone with magic violating the Laws of Reality more than say, blowing up the building? To me, both seem equally "impossible", if you want to apply, let's call it "atheist" way of thinking (as in, "Magic does not exist!") and equally possible otherwise.

I think I've read somewhere, that it's the "slippery slope", that's a problem, evil (be it killing, or manipulating minds, or other stuff) gets easier, and eventually you find yourself a warlock (like with the guy who was executed early on in "Proven Guilty", or like how Harry explains why messing with people's minds using magic is said slippery slope, also in "Proven Guilty").

Plus (I think) it only seems to apply to humans for some reason - in "Changes", Harry flattened probably at least a few dozen of Blood Court vampires (by the end, when he did the gravity trick), without, as far as I can tell, any mental consequences.

Not to mention destroying the whole Red Court later on...

(well, unless there are consequences later on, and I just didn't get there yet)

Though I now wonder, if Winter Knight's Mantle had anything to do with it. Still in "Changes", I recall it showing Harry a mind-image of (I think) Rudolph frozen to the wall, or maybe impaled on some massive icicles. It didn't seem to have any actual control over him (so far?), but maybe it does some subtle influence, kind of like Lasciel's shadow did? (but don't tell me, I want to read about it for myself)

8
In various places in the books, Harry claimed that the magic has to follow the laws of physics (last time I saw it was in "Changes", that I'm currently reading) - we have seen examples too, like in "White Night", where he took the heat from the lake, created an enormous fire, and as a result, froze the lake's water (on the surface, anyway).

So, if that's the case, during the Listens-to-Wind's shapeshifting duel with Shagnasty, where did he either get the extra matter/mass from (when changing into a "bear the size of a minibus"), or where did it go to (when he changed into a raven, turtle, or a squirrel) ?

I suppose for the former, he could draw/create the matter from Never Never or something? But what about turning into all those small animals?

9
I'm reading "Grave Peril", currently at the party at Bianca's, where Lea claimed Harry broke the deal he made with her three times: one years ago, one a few days back, and one just a day ago or so when saving Charity Carpenter at the graveyard.

I remember two of those (years ago, when fighting Justin or his demon, and the one when saving Charity), but when did the third (technically second?) one happen? The only meeting they had in the meantime, that I remember, was when going after Agatha Hagglethorn's ghost in the Nevernever (from the hospital's maternity ward), but I don't remember Harry promising anything to her back then? (unless "I will go with you... when Hell freezes over!" somehow counts?)

10
If you are delving into the exciting world of Book Collecting

Not really, basically I just want to be able to read them all (plus short stories), and:
1) Can't easily get my hands on them for free (as in, from a library).
2) Have a rather low opinion on the quality of books published by the company, that does that over here.
3) Generally prefer to experience books (and movies, and video games) in their original language, where I'm able.

Anyway, I think I'll decide on Roc, I like their covers (as good a reason as any, I guess).

11
Hello,

So, I'm thinking to order all the DF books published so far (perhaps except for comics) as the English originals. The store I'm probably going to buy them from has the books from five different publishers:
1) Little Brown Book Group
2) Roc
3) Ace Books
4) Orbit
5) New American Library

Assuming they have all the books from each one of them (I haven't checked yet, looking up them all is going to take a while), which one you think has the best quality of published books? (things like durability, lack of typos, aesthetics, including the cover images, this sort of stuff)

Pages: [1]