Show Posts

This section allows you to view all posts made by this member. Note that you can only see posts made in areas you currently have access to.


Messages - Snark Knight

Pages: 1 ... 43 44 [45] 46 47 ... 78
661
DF Spoilers / Re: Christmas Eve from JB's Twitter (no news, just fun)
« on: December 28, 2018, 01:16:46 AM »
  • What's with Mother Winter not giving Harry a gift?
    If it's an obligation, is she not obligated?  Or is her gift to not show up and ruin his night?

Given her limitations on travel in general and visiting earth in particular, perhaps Kringle was representing her?

662
DF Spoilers / Re: Christmas Eve from JB's Twitter (no news, just fun)
« on: December 26, 2018, 07:20:20 PM »
(click to show/hide)
even without knowing what happened, does anyone think there's any way the mortal world will be able to explain something this major away?  Will this be the straw that draws the Librarians out into the open?  Brings the government out against the magical community? or are they
(click to show/hide)

it appears that the Carpenters survived fairly well, who do we think didn't?


(click to show/hide)

663
DF Spoilers / Re: Where are the jötunn?
« on: December 24, 2018, 02:51:19 AM »
Got a link?  What I'm trying to do is tie down who guarded the gate previously.

The Aesir pantheon might have been previous defenders, but I doubt the Jotun would have been helping with that. If they're friendly with the Fomor, they're probably the kind of snakes who would aid the Outsiders for a promise of a place in the new order if they ever break in.

664
DF Spoilers / Re: Some thoughts on the vampire courts
« on: December 21, 2018, 02:27:03 AM »
    The vampire courts are therefore attempts by various nefarious powers to maintain their influence on Earth/ through humans. I think of the vampire courts as 3 successive iterations - each moving further away from humanity & mortality, getting cruder but vastly gaining in strength. Whamps were the first version, Reds were the second & Blamps were the third.
    ...
    • Drakul, progenitor of the Black Court's name means son of a dragon.


    FWIW, someone asked in a Q&A a while ago what Drakul Sr. was a scion of, and the WOJ was that he's something completely inhuman that got trapped in human form. His scion, Dracula, was attempting to do something that sounded a heck of a lot like an ascension ritual in an effort to impress his father when something went wrong and he turned himself into the first blampire.

    As for Goodman Grey, I suspect his origins owe more to a naagloshii divining that the best way to hurt some poor woman was to make her carry a monster's child than out of an attempt to create a free-willed servitor. The naagloshii are beings that shirked their duty and purpose - they're scary powerful in comparison to a wizard, but miles down the power scale from beings like the Mothers that need a knight or scions to get things done on earth. The skinwalkers don't even seem to have much in the way of objectives beyond feeding on pain. Shaggy only even left his home territory at all because he was acting as mercenary muscle for the Circle.

    665
    DF Spoilers / Re: Any news on Peace Talks
    « on: December 21, 2018, 02:13:07 AM »
    I think after twenty years of writing about the same character he may be a bit tired of it. That is only natural, yet I can see him unwilling to wrap it up because Harry is to a great extent his bread and butter.

    Perhaps there's also a bit of a barrier that PT is the one to slog through, before getting to MM which is going to be the fun one.

    It seems like most of the fans are more hyped for the concept of MM anyway. Hard to blame the author if he's feeling a bit of the same way.

    666
    DF Spoilers / Re: Question about the Black Court
    « on: December 16, 2018, 06:49:16 PM »
    They probably don't "cultivate" because unlike the Ramps, they don't have fangs, but regular human teeth -- so instead of a couple little holes to suck from that can heal up with relatively little non-feeding blood loss, they bite out a chunk of your throat. Plus, no venom, so their victim isn't sedated and they either have to kill them to keep them still or just do it incidentally in the struggle.

    Well, a Renfield would willingly cut their arm to feed their master and bandage it up after a sub-lethal feeding if a Blamp really wanted to order it. Don't need addictive venom when you can just obliterate the thralls' free will.

    So I figure the actual death matters in some way to the Blamps' feeding.

    667
    DF Spoilers / Re: Question about the Black Court
    « on: December 15, 2018, 12:43:33 PM »
    Blood, but it might be as a medium for life itself. I don't think there have been any in-book instances of blamps cultivating a food human to feed on repeatedly like the Reds do. Plus the WOJ was that they grow in power basically through running up their kill count.

    668
    DF Spoilers / Re: Any news on Peace Talks
    « on: December 09, 2018, 01:43:55 AM »
    I just found a little gem on the Upcoming Works page of Jim's website. http://www.jim-butcher.com/faq/upcoming-works As of December 6, 2018 Peace Talks is up to chapter 36 in draft form!

    The last 3 books had 51-53 chapters. So if Peace Talks is around the same length, the draft is now 68-70% done!

    I'm not into complaining about it not being ready yet ... but why the hell was he giving public statements that it was almost done months ago, if he just hit the two-thirds mark last week? He doesn't owe anybody a book on any schedule but his own, but at least do the fans the courtesy of not being misleading about it.

    669
    DF Spoilers / Re: Battle of Hastings was a Stone Table fight
    « on: December 08, 2018, 02:26:19 AM »
    Call it semi-intentional. Sanderson has explained more of the details of cosmic-level mantles being subdivided in his work, but what we know of the Dresdenverse Fae being divided from a common origin seems similar enough to use the same vocabulary.

    And, yeah, I'd rate the Lea theory unsupported but also not contradicted by anything. The Mother Summer one falls victim to inconvenient WOJ though.

    670
    DF Spoilers / Re: Battle of Hastings was a Stone Table fight
    « on: December 06, 2018, 02:06:29 AM »
    The backstory about Mother Winter being the original and Mother Summer being the second to fill the role wasn't from the books, it was a WOJ in response to someone asking about succession among the Mothers and Queens. His answer was that the first Mother Summer wasn't killed at all, she just got tired of the role and retired, passing on her mantle.

    Some people have speculated that MW being the original might mean that the Winter mother mantle is the shard of the original unitary mantle that Hecate chose to keep for herself. I like the theory, but it's unsupported so far.

    And as for Lea, the WOJ is that she built her personal power from the ground up, mostly by bargaining with humans to her advantage over the centuries. Judging from Sarissa there's no particular reason an unmantled sister would start with great personal power, but there's no solid reason yet to guess at Lea having a particularly more significant bloodline than any other Sidhe.

    The Stone Table may very well have been in play around the events of Hastings, though.

    671
    DF Spoilers / Re: Who is Sandra Marling?
    « on: December 02, 2018, 01:25:35 AM »
    Anyway, Michael slew the Dragon, saving Charity. I wouldn’t be surprised if this put the both of them on the revenge list of the Black Council. So when Molly is of age, they send in Sandra Marling to begin pushing her towards the dark side.

    I don't think the Circle has much of an institutionalized "revenge list". Harry has screwed up a lot more of their projects than one pawn sorceror making deals with a Dragon, and even as of White Night Cowl was angry that Madrigal threw out a challenge to Harry because the chance to kill him wasn't worth the possible disruption of their work. Ariana held a grudge, but that was personal over Ortega's death, not about some half-insane anyway cutout.

    If the Black Council targeted Molly, I think it more likely they had some idea of what she could become and wanted to subvert her early. Some of them probably have some form of foresight to counter Mab, Odin and Rashid - they'd practically have to, to have contended against the good(ish) powers for as long as they have with any degree of success.

    672
    DF Spoilers / Re: Ghost Story and Susan's Fate
    « on: December 01, 2018, 03:49:52 PM »
    Dresden may persecute himself for "murdering Susan Rodriquez" - but he didn't actually do that. If he had, the Bloodline Curse wouldn't have wiped out the Red Court. "Susan" was gone already when he killed the vampire she'd become.

    If "Susan was already gone" were true, would a vampire really have laid down on the alter to willingly die as a weapon against all the other vampires? That was pretty clearly still Susan making the choice.

    I doubt Uriel could or would have told Harry what happened to her afterward, though. Not being allowed to know for sure seems like another one of the Rules.

    673
    DF Spoilers / Re: Was Anduriel in Storm Front?
    « on: November 28, 2018, 01:19:35 AM »
    If it was more than just normal shadow's I doubt it would be a wizard doing anything since Harry seems to be pretty good at picking up magic.  If it was a wizard it would be someone of higher skill than say Sells who was the villain of that book.  Still I can't help but wonder if it was Anduriel.  What do you think?

    Given the plot has absolutely nothing to do with Nicodemus and I doubt Jim was laying things out that far in advance -- particularly when it's clear that it's not for another two books that he's laid out most of the major cosmology -- and the fact that Victor Sells is called the Shadow Man, I find it extremely unlikely.
    That bit is when Murphy is bringing Harry to look at the first victim, so if it's anything at all, it's probably Victor keeping an eye on the crime scene, just like he does (with a shadow) when he sends his demon after Harry.


    Frankly, I got the sense Victor was too ignorant and arrogant to be bothered keeping an eye on the police investigation. He was just the cutout for a much more sophisticated practitioner; possibly Cowl and / or the distributor of the hexenwulf belts. I don't get the sense he was clued enough about the wider scene to realize he should be worried about Council wardens, let alone that he should keep an eye on SI.

    That text does sound like Harry was twigging to something, and certainly there's nothing to rule out Sells being smarter than I interpreted him as, or Anduriel doing some early research. He and Nic do seem to be antagonistic towards The Circle, and acquainted with Margaret, so there is tangential grounds for him to take an interest.

    But if it's a matter of playing the odds, I'd bet on it being Sells' master.

    674
    DF Spoilers / Re: Who is Sandra Marling?
    « on: November 24, 2018, 03:16:28 AM »
    It makes one wonder if Goodman Grey could pull if off?

    I'm not still not sure how evil he is when he's not taking 'paying the Rent' jobs. The Monster LLC spinoff will be interesting if it ever happens.

    675
    DF Spoilers / Re: Who is Sandra Marling?
    « on: November 24, 2018, 12:40:28 AM »
    I may be mistaken, but I believe we have seen Mouse growl at black magic users and monsters with the exceptions of everyone already knew the threat was present, and Harry said the black magic user/monster was okay.

    I mean, by definition if a villain was being super stealthy and Harry and the audience didn't recognize them yet, we wouldn't know if Mouse missed alerting on somebody.

    Pages: 1 ... 43 44 [45] 46 47 ... 78