ParanetOnline

The Dresden Files => DF Spoilers => Topic started by: SerScot on November 07, 2021, 03:55:35 PM

Title: Thomas hoped Marcone would Kill Lara?
Post by: SerScot on November 07, 2021, 03:55:35 PM
In the discussion on the WB on their way to Demonreach Harry mentions that he hoped Lara would kill Marcone.  Thomas mentioned that he hoped for the opposite.  That was a bit surprising. 

I thought there was genuine love between Lara and Thomas… or… is that simply not possible for White Court Vampires.
Title: Re: Thomas hoped Marcone would Kill Lara?
Post by: Mira on November 07, 2021, 06:30:24 PM
In the discussion on the WB on their way to Demonreach Harry mentions that he hoped Lara would kill Marcone.  Thomas mentioned that he hoped for the opposite.  That was a bit surprising. 

I thought there was genuine love between Lara and Thomas… or… is that simply not possible for White Court Vampires.

Page number, chapter, book, please, I don't remember that and need context.
Title: Re: Thomas hoped Marcone would Kill Lara?
Post by: SerScot on November 07, 2021, 08:08:44 PM
Page number, chapter, book, please, I don't remember that and need context.

I was listening to the audio book.  Please give me a moment.
Title: Re: Thomas hoped Marcone would Kill Lara?
Post by: SerScot on November 07, 2021, 08:41:02 PM
Page number, chapter, book, please, I don't remember that and need context.

Cold Days Chapter 19, pg. 185 hard cover edition, bottom middle of the page:

Quote
”I was sort of hoping she’d kill him,” I said. (Harry) “I was sort of hoping for the other way around,” Thomas said.
Title: Re: Thomas hoped Marcone would Kill Lara?
Post by: b4utoo on November 07, 2021, 10:25:57 PM
I think it was just shit talking
Title: Re: Thomas hoped Marcone would Kill Lara?
Post by: Mira on November 08, 2021, 05:15:35 AM

Thanks I will look it up.  However when you think about it, it makes some sense that he'd say that.   Lara was happy in a weird way after Shaggy got done with Thomas, because he became more coldly vampire like she was.  Remember how he was at the end of Turn Coat, but then Jim never did anything more with that.
Title: Re: Thomas hoped Marcone would Kill Lara?
Post by: b4utoo on November 08, 2021, 10:38:12 AM
Because of the vampire White Court they need to eat. And Thomas wasn't eating. He was the equivalent of starving. Nobody wants to see their sibling starve themselves.
Title: Re: Thomas hoped Marcone would Kill Lara?
Post by: Mira on November 08, 2021, 11:27:02 AM
Because of the vampire White Court they need to eat. And Thomas wasn't eating. He was the equivalent of starving. Nobody wants to see their sibling starve themselves.

No, he wasn't, his hair business had taken care of that.. Also it wasn't that so much as how he began to look at humans, they became "kine" not people to him.  That latter was Lara's big lesson.
Title: Re: Thomas hoped Marcone would Kill Lara?
Post by: Snark Knight on November 10, 2021, 03:16:29 AM
Thanks I will look it up.  However when you think about it, it makes some sense that he'd say that.   Lara was happy in a weird way after Shaggy got done with Thomas, because he became more coldly vampire like she was.  Remember how he was at the end of Turn Coat, but then Jim never did anything more with that.

Plus Thomas wasn't ever particularly happy about Justine being Lara's secretary. The job was putting her in danger fairly regularly, and there was more than an undertone of Lara keeping her as a hostage against Thomas' good behaviour, no matter that she seems to have been materially well treated.

I'm not sure he was all the way sincere about wishing his sister dead either, but he has ample reasons for a ... nuanced ... attitude towards her.
Title: Re: Thomas hoped Marcone would Kill Lara?
Post by: vincentric on November 10, 2021, 05:07:57 AM
It's also quite possible that Lara feels more for Thomas than Thomas for Lara.
Title: Re: Thomas hoped Marcone would Kill Lara?
Post by: forumghost on November 10, 2021, 09:56:04 AM
I think it's to do with the fact that Thomas thought Lara has gotten "real scary" in the last couple of years.

So even if she's big sis, she's becoming that big of a problem/threat.
Title: Re: Thomas hoped Marcone would Kill Lara?
Post by: morriswalters on November 10, 2021, 12:39:44 PM
Lara was using Justine to make sure that Thomas toed the line. With Harry it's Marcone becoming more of a threat. They were, in part, responsible for increasing the power of their respective irritants. This seems like a wistful look at the choices they made that got them there.
Title: Re: Thomas hoped Marcone would Kill Lara?
Post by: groinkick on November 11, 2021, 07:58:27 PM
I think Thomas does probably love Lara.  If he truly wanted her dead, he'd have tried.  I think it's more that he knows how dangerous she is, and her motivations.  So on some level he loves her, but also knows that Justine, and Harry are in danger from her, and if he got in the way, she'd get rid of him too.
Title: Re: Thomas hoped Marcone would Kill Lara?
Post by: Mira on November 12, 2021, 05:39:48 AM
I think Thomas does probably love Lara.  If he truly wanted her dead, he'd have tried.  I think it's more that he knows how dangerous she is, and her motivations.  So on some level he loves her, but also knows that Justine, and Harry are in danger from her, and if he got in the way, she'd get rid of him too.

My take away still is that I am disappointed that Jim didn't do more with the Thomas we saw at the end of Turn Coat.  There were real questions after the meeting in the zoo between him and Harry, whether or not Thomas could regain his humanity and or how Harry was going to deal with that. That could have been really interesting, but the next time we see Thomas it was like his sessions with Shaggy never happened.
Title: Re: Thomas hoped Marcone would Kill Lara?
Post by: SerScot on November 12, 2021, 11:07:40 PM
My take away still is that I am disappointed that Jim didn't do more with the Thomas we saw at the end of Turn Coat.  There were real questions after the meeting in the zoo between him and Harry, whether or not Thomas could regain his humanity and or how Harry was going to deal with that. That could have been really interesting, but the next time we see Thomas it was like his sessions with Shaggy never happened.

This.  If the author introduces a moral quandary for a character don’t forget you did so three books later.
Title: Re: Thomas hoped Marcone would Kill Lara?
Post by: Mira on November 13, 2021, 11:54:00 AM
This.  If the author introduces a moral quandary for a character don’t forget you did so three books later.

Indeed, that is what happens when there are years between books, one is busy beginning and finishing other series, and have five other projects on the burner.. Oh yeah, try to have a life outside of that as well.. ::)  Details tend to get lost..
Title: Re: Thomas hoped Marcone would Kill Lara?
Post by: vincentric on November 13, 2021, 02:45:57 PM
Thomas's mental struggles are a feature of Thomas. If Jim gives us more short fiction from Thomas's POV then I suspect we'll learn a great deal more about them.

But the books are about Harry. There was no time to go in-depth about Thomas since TC. Changes takes  place over four days time and Thomas has a short discussion before they go to Rudy's and then is pretty much gone until they leave for Chichen Itza. He's not in GS until the end and then we get their conversation on the boat in CD which covers a lot of this in a book that covers one and a half days once the plot begins. No Thomas in Skin Game because it's about Murphy, Butters and Michael and then he's a plot device in PT/BG. Used to provoke the Eb/Harry fights and manipulate Harry into taking Justine to Demonreach. 
Title: Re: Thomas hoped Marcone would Kill Lara?
Post by: Mira on November 13, 2021, 03:45:31 PM
Quote
Thomas's mental struggles are a feature of Thomas. If Jim gives us more short fiction from Thomas's POV then I suspect we'll learn a great deal more about them.

But that's my point, at the end of Turn Coat, Thomas had murdered several young women to survive after Shaggy tortured him to the point of death, the whole rinse and repeat brought out the full vampire.  This pleased Lara, but Harry was totally taken aback by the change.  Then the next time was see Thomas, he is the same guy he always was, still a vampire, but also very human.  I guess that plays into Harry not understanding Eb's attitude towards Thomas in Peace Talks.  But I still wish it had been explored more.
Title: Re: Thomas hoped Marcone would Kill Lara?
Post by: vincentric on November 13, 2021, 10:41:21 PM
But that's my point, at the end of Turn Coat, Thomas had murdered several young women to survive after Shaggy tortured him to the point of death, the whole rinse and repeat brought out the full vampire.  This pleased Lara, but Harry was totally taken aback by the change.  Then the next time was see Thomas, he is the same guy he always was, still a vampire, but also very human.  I guess that plays into Harry not understanding Eb's attitude towards Thomas in Peace Talks.  But I still wish it had been explored more.

The end of Turn Coat was about 2 weeks after the torture occurred. Thomas was just beginning to heal. After that he has four extended non-action scenes.

The short conversation in Changes which was partly about Thomas but mostly about strategy. The short glimpse at the end of Ghost Story.(The solution to his feeding problem may account for his partial recovery.) His conversation with Harry on the Water Beetle.( A reunion with his presumed dead brother, which also let them clear some emotional baggage.) Finally his talks with Harry at the beginning of Peace Talks where he informs him of Justine's pregnancy and then later in the apartment where they discuss fatherhood before Eb shows up.

Between Justine giving him a way to feed and be with her and Harry returning from the dead, Thomas had a lot going well from him to help him in healing.
Title: Re: Thomas hoped Marcone would Kill Lara?
Post by: Basil on November 16, 2021, 02:09:12 AM
This.  If the author introduces a moral quandary for a character don’t forget you did so three books later.

Good point.  What Thomas has gone through before being put in Stasis is likely many times worse than what Shaggy did to him.  Plus, he doesn't have the real Justine anymore (or perhaps his illusion of her is gone). 

Question:  Is a hypothetically well-fed Thomas actually a match for Lara?  I actually don't think so.  I suspect that Lara, Thomas and Lord Raith are the three strongest of the Whites, but that doesn't mean that he can take down Lara.  She has too much experience, is older (and therefore stronger) and probably knows how to use the Hunger to achieve a wider range of tactical objectives. 
Title: Re: Thomas hoped Marcone would Kill Lara?
Post by: KurtinStGeorge on November 16, 2021, 04:54:57 AM
Good point.  What Thomas has gone through before being put in Stasis is likely many times worse than what Shaggy did to him.  Plus, he doesn't have the real Justine anymore (or perhaps his illusion of her is gone). 

Question:  Is a hypothetically well-fed Thomas actually a match for Lara?  I actually don't think so.  I suspect that Lara, Thomas and Lord Raith are the three strongest of the Whites, but that doesn't mean that he can take down Lara.  She has too much experience, is older (and therefore stronger) and probably knows how to use the Hunger to achieve a wider range of tactical objectives.

Add to that, Lara has had the time to peruse her father's library; which I believe was supposed to contain a great deal of magical knowledge.  My guess is that probably meant White Court vampire abilities.  Way back in Blood Rites, we were given a description of Lord Raith's 'kiss of death' technique, which he would use; presumably against other White Court vampires, to start business meetings of the Court to get everyone's attention.  Harry even teased Lord Raith about his inability to use the kiss of death any longer because of Margaret's death curse.

I'm think this is an example of Chekov's gun.  We've been given a graphic description of a rare and powerful White Court vampire attack method but we haven't seen it used; at least not yet.  My hypothesis is that at some point we will get to see it used.  I think it could occur in the next book.
Most likely, that means a resurgent Lord Raith uses the kiss of death to show everyone he is back, or; and I think this next scenario is far more likely, Lara Raith uses the same ability to show those in the White Court she no longer needs her father as a figurehead to maintain her leadership of the Court.

I suppose a third possibility is that Thomas will get the opportunity to learn this nasty trick and his father's other secrets, which will allow him to challenge Lara and become the leader of the White Court, but at present that seems highly unlikely to occur.

   
Title: Re: Thomas hoped Marcone would Kill Lara?
Post by: Mira on November 16, 2021, 03:35:20 PM
Quote
Chekov's gun

Shaggy's treatment of Thomas and how this affected him at the end of Turn Coat is a very good example of it.  Jim had Thomas repeatedly beaten up to the point of death, presented with young women he had to feed upon until they died and it changed him.  This changed him, he seemed more at peace with being a vampire at the end of the story, this pleased Lara, but upset Harry greatly.  He even asked him what he thought Justine thought about all of this.  So the promise of conflict between Harry and Thomas, but it never really happened. 
Title: Re: Thomas hoped Marcone would Kill Lara?
Post by: vincentric on November 16, 2021, 07:10:02 PM
It would have been an issue if Thomas was feeding and killing like a typical White Court vampire but he wasn't. He did have to come face to face with the fact that he is really a predator when pushed to his utmost. That he could not overcome his nature and not feed on those victims was the cause of his despair.

Whatever else Justine/Nemesis was doing when she showed him how to feed again, by feeding him she mitigated this emotional crisis. He didn't have to feed on unsuspecting or unwilling victims or survive by constant nibbling on his clients.
Title: Re: Thomas hoped Marcone would Kill Lara?
Post by: Cornbred on November 23, 2021, 03:03:20 PM
I can't help but wonder if something else is going on here.  Thomas had been remade by Shagnasty into a killing machine in TC, and then suddenly in Changes he is the same old Thomas.  We know that Justine is Nfected, is it too much of a stretch to think Thomas was also Nfected by Justine?  Maybe the whole thing is a retcon by Jim but the fact that nobody in-universe notices or comments on Thomas' sudden personality changes is disquieting. 
Title: Re: Thomas hoped Marcone would Kill Lara?
Post by: vincentric on November 23, 2021, 05:33:25 PM
I'm beginning to wonder if I got a different copy of Turn Coat than other people.

Thomas was taken by Shagnasty and tortured to near death. Then while he was only semi-coherent he was given a victim to feed off. Which he did killing them in the process. This cycle was repeated several times in rapid succession driving him to near insanity. Harry knocks the unconscious Thomas into the cabin with Molly and Morgan and he wakes up and Molly activates the crystal to protect herself.  The battle is won and Lara and family take Thomas away to treat him, probably killing several more young women in the process.

When next we see Thomas in the epilogues, he is just able to go out in public after several weeks of healing. By his own admission he realizes that he is a vampire when driven to his utmost and that he is seeing people as food first. But he never states that he is going back to killing like a regular WC vampire. He's just weeks removed from a mental and physical trauma that left him with severe PTSD and just starting the healing process.

A year or so later in Changes, he better but still struggling against his nature as he, Harry and Molly talk on the way to Rudolph's house. Then Harry dies and he's thrown into his deep funk which isn't lifted until the end of Ghost Story. But he wasn't killing. Justine chides him for starving himself.

And eight months later, in Cold Days, he's close to the Thomas we're used to. But he's more conscious of his nature and more honest about it as he advises Harry on dealing with his mantle.

So while I understand that the end of Turn Coat may have hinted at a change in Thomas. After almost two years, he's healed quite a bit and should realistically be close to his old self, san a trigger.
Title: Re: Thomas hoped Marcone would Kill Lara?
Post by: Mira on November 23, 2021, 07:37:01 PM
Quote

So while I understand that the end of Turn Coat may have hinted at a change in Thomas. After almost two years, he's healed quite a bit and should realistically be close to his old self, san a trigger.

Yeah, but at the end of Turn Coat Thomas was more the "classic White Court Vamp," that isn't Thomas.  Then that gets swept under the rug pretty quickly, what I'm wondering is if at the point he was more vulnerable and HWWB/Justine is able to take advantage of him.. As in at the end of Ghost Story she brings in a lesbian to have sex with so she and Thomas can touch each other and have sex.  Ask yourself, if it was that easy, why didn't they do that years before? Remember  at the end of Battle Ground Justine/HWWB was boasting to Harry how he/she set things up so Thomas could get her pregnant..  Hmmmm... Was Shaggy cahoots with Outsiders back in Turn Coat?
Title: Re: Thomas hoped Marcone would Kill Lara?
Post by: vincentric on November 24, 2021, 05:25:17 PM
Yeah, but at the end of Turn Coat Thomas was more the "classic White Court Vamp," that isn't Thomas.  Then that gets swept under the rug pretty quickly, what I'm wondering is if at the point he was more vulnerable and HWWB/Justine is able to take advantage of him.. As in at the end of Ghost Story she brings in a lesbian to have sex with so she and Thomas can touch each other and have sex.  Ask yourself, if it was that easy, why didn't they do that years before? Remember  at the end of Battle Ground Justine/HWWB was boasting to Harry how he/she set things up so Thomas could get her pregnant..  Hmmmm... Was Shaggy cahoots with Outsiders back in Turn Coat?

While I think it happened earlier, it's possible that Nemesis had not infected Justine until Turn Coat and was not in full control of her until after Changes or Cold Days. We know that there is some part of Justine still there because her love for Thomas renews their protection after each liaison.
Title: Re: Thomas hoped Marcone would Kill Lara?
Post by: Mira on November 24, 2021, 06:31:44 PM
While I think it happened earlier, it's possible that Nemesis had not infected Justine until Turn Coat and was not in full control of her until after Changes or Cold Days. We know that there is some part of Justine still there because her love for Thomas renews their protection after each liaison.
Do we?  As far as Nemesis goes, I don't think that would affect the "true love" protection.  My point is if it merely took a sex act with someone else to cancel it out, why didn't it happen before Ghost Story?
Also there were some questions regarding Justine in Turn Coat..  I just skimmed across them looking for something else, but after Shaggy takes Thomas it becomes a question of whether or not Justine can still sense Thomas for I think were tracking purposes.  As I said it was a quick glance, but what if Shaggy was softening up Thomas for Nemesis?  Could Justine been lying about not sensing Thomas so Shaggy would have time to remove as much humanity from Thomas as possible?
Title: Re: Thomas hoped Marcone would Kill Lara?
Post by: vincentric on November 25, 2021, 06:23:23 PM
Do we?  As far as Nemesis goes, I don't think that would affect the "true love" protection.  My point is if it merely took a sex act with someone else to cancel it out, why didn't it happen before Ghost Story?
Also there were some questions regarding Justine in Turn Coat..  I just skimmed across them looking for something else, but after Shaggy takes Thomas it becomes a question of whether or not Justine can still sense Thomas for I think were tracking purposes.  As I said it was a quick glance, but what if Shaggy was softening up Thomas for Nemesis?  Could Justine been lying about not sensing Thomas so Shaggy would have time to remove as much humanity from Thomas as possible?

Thomas would still love Justine but I doubt that a Nemesis dominated Justine loves Thomas.

Just like completely controlling Cat Sith in Cold Days overrode his Sidhe compulsions, dominating Justine to betray Thomas and kill Harry breaks something in Justine. Barring a healing on the Mab/Leah scale, I don't think she(or Cat Sith) can come back to themselves and I doubt Justine has the strength to survive the procedure.
Title: Re: Thomas hoped Marcone would Kill Lara?
Post by: Mira on November 25, 2021, 09:35:41 PM
Quote
Thomas would still love Justine but I doubt that a Nemesis dominated Justine loves Thomas.

Of course not, but a Nemesis dominated Justine could fake it and the sex act with another is all that she needed to fake it.  Once the protection is gone, it stays gone..
Title: Re: Thomas hoped Marcone would Kill Lara?
Post by: vincentric on November 30, 2021, 12:45:38 AM
Of course not, but a Nemesis dominated Justine could fake it and the sex act with another is all that she needed to fake it.  Once the protection is gone, it stays gone..

The usefulness of this strategy is dependent on how quickly the protection is reestablished after the act. Mere seconds and they may get burns no matter how careful they are, A few minutes or more and this would be workable. Jim knows surely(or at least he should) but that may be going into too much detail.
Title: Re: Thomas hoped Marcone would Kill Lara?
Post by: Mira on November 30, 2021, 04:12:36 AM
The usefulness of this strategy is dependent on how quickly the protection is reestablished after the act. Mere seconds and they may get burns no matter how careful they are, A few minutes or more and this would be workable. Jim knows surely(or at least he should) but that may be going into too much detail.

I don't think it works that way, unless Justine's girlfriend came to live with them and they had sex just before she had sex with Thomas.  Remember HWWB/Justine confesses to Harry on the boat how she set things up so she'd get pregnant and be able to blackmail Thomas into becoming an assassn.
Title: Re: Thomas hoped Marcone would Kill Lara?
Post by: vincentric on November 30, 2021, 05:03:51 AM
I don't think it works that way, unless Justine's girlfriend came to live with them and they had sex just before she had sex with Thomas.  Remember HWWB/Justine confesses to Harry on the boat how she set things up so she'd get pregnant and be able to blackmail Thomas into becoming an assassn.

I was keeping it strictly mechanical. Justine and 3rd party have sex to disable protection and then she gets with Thomas which resets it. If it resets instantly, then no cuddles would be possible and they have to spring away from each other to avoid burns. If it takes some time, then there would be cover for your theory about how HWWB pulled this off.
Title: Re: Thomas hoped Marcone would Kill Lara?
Post by: Mira on November 30, 2021, 11:42:01 AM
I was keeping it strictly mechanical. Justine and 3rd party have sex to disable protection and then she gets with Thomas which resets it. If it resets instantly, then no cuddles would be possible and they have to spring away from each other to avoid burns. If it takes some time, then there would be cover for your theory about how HWWB pulled this off.

I doubt that it is that simple, especially if by Ghost Story she was taken over by Nemesis.. That is the point of what HWWB/Justine said, it was all planned out, so it is very doubtful that there was a true love reset there, because there was none.  It was all an act, that isn't to say that the real Justine isn't buried in there somewhere, but she lost the battle long ago.
Title: Re: Thomas hoped Marcone would Kill Lara?
Post by: vincentric on November 30, 2021, 08:28:39 PM
The only reason that I have some doubts about her being completely possessed until after Cold Days is because HWWB could have gotten what he wanted if he had struck while they were confronting Maeve. From the time Harry's backup team covers themselves in mud, until they were at the finale where Harry summons Mab, Justine was inside Demonreach's defenses and was not watched suspiciously as everyone was concerned with rushing to Harry's aid. No one, with the possible exception of Mouse would have seen it coming.
Title: Re: Thomas hoped Marcone would Kill Lara?
Post by: Cozarkian on December 01, 2021, 12:59:19 AM
The only reason that I have some doubts about her being completely possessed until after Cold Days is because HWWB could have gotten what he wanted if he had struck while they were confronting Maeve. From the time Harry's backup team covers themselves in mud, until they were at the finale where Harry summons Mab, Justine was inside Demonreach's defenses and was not watched suspiciously as everyone was concerned with rushing to Harry's aid. No one, with the possible exception of Mouse would have seen it coming.

Yeah, I think there has to be some rationalization between "time of possession" and "ability to assert complete control." Cat Sith was taken over pretty quickly, but perhaps human free will makes the process take longer.
Title: Re: Thomas hoped Marcone would Kill Lara?
Post by: Mira on December 01, 2021, 05:33:19 AM
The only reason that I have some doubts about her being completely possessed until after Cold Days is because HWWB could have gotten what he wanted if he had struck while they were confronting Maeve. From the time Harry's backup team covers themselves in mud, until they were at the finale where Harry summons Mab, Justine was inside Demonreach's defenses and was not watched suspiciously as everyone was concerned with rushing to Harry's aid. No one, with the possible exception of Mouse would have seen it coming.

Timing is everything, Outsiders may have their own timeline.
Title: Re: Thomas hoped Marcone would Kill Lara?
Post by: Ed0517 on December 01, 2021, 09:15:25 AM
Add to that, Lara has had the time to peruse her father's library; which I believe was supposed to contain a great deal of magical knowledge.  My guess is that probably meant White Court vampire abilities.  Way back in Blood Rites, we were given a description of Lord Raith's 'kiss of death' technique, which he would use; presumably against other White Court vampires, to start business meetings of the Court to get everyone's attention.  Harry even teased Lord Raith about his inability to use the kiss of death any longer because of Margaret's death curse.

I'm think this is an example of Chekov's gun.  We've been given a graphic description of a rare and powerful White Court vampire attack method but we haven't seen it used; at least not yet.  My hypothesis is that at some point we will get to see it used.  I think it could occur in the next book.
Most likely, that means a resurgent Lord Raith uses the kiss of death to show everyone he is back, or; and I think this next scenario is far more likely, Lara Raith uses the same ability to show those in the White Court she no longer needs her father as a figurehead to maintain her leadership of the Court.

I suppose a third possibility is that Thomas will get the opportunity to learn this nasty trick and his father's other secrets, which will allow him to challenge Lara and become the leader of the White Court, but at present that seems highly unlikely to occur.

   

How about a fourth, just to twist it a little more?

The Kiss of Death is like Dim Mak - the Death Touch - but what if it can be delayed? I do not recall all the mechanics of it.  But if Lara wants Daddy Dearest to look strong, could SHE administer it to an enemy, as a member of her father's entourage to a rival family member who has betrayed them? A smooch set for 5 minutes, long enough for Daddy to reveal treachery, plant his (now impotent) Kiss of Death, then Lara's takes effect. Just as  <Kill Bill spoiler>
(click to show/hide)
   

If the other vamps do not know exactly how it is done... why would they not assume Papa did it?