The Dresden Files > DF Spoilers
Murphy
g33k:
--- Quote from: Mira on October 02, 2025, 08:37:23 PM --- ... However I don't think you can say that Murphy was misled, she was well acquainted with the Einherjar a long time before she died.
--- End quote ---
You seem to have misunderstood me.
I'm not saying Murphy was misled.
I am suggesting -- as a WAG -- that in the future we will see Murphy get back onscreen via a "convenient" combination of loopholes in the "rules," and conflicts over which "rules" apply in her specific case, and some degree of being "misled" (which gives Uriel just a touch more leeway to act) and her own rebelliousness over "following the rules" vs. "doing the right thing."
All of it, largely, orchestrated by Uriel (who exceeds even Mab for subtlety).
Mira:
--- Quote ---I am suggesting -- as a WAG -- that in the future we will see Murphy get back onscreen via a "convenient" combination of loopholes in the "rules," and conflicts over which "rules" apply in her specific case, and some degree of being "misled" (which gives Uriel just a touch more leeway to act) and her own rebelliousness over "following the rules" vs. "doing the right thing."
All of it, largely, orchestrated by Uriel (who exceeds even Mab for subtlety).
--- End quote ---
Maybe, but Murphy chose to break the rules, no one pushed her to do so. She chose to proclaim that she believed she had the right to judge Nic over the Almighty and got a Holy Sword broken in the process. She demonstrated an arrogance akin to one of the Fallen. None of that was orchestrated by Uriel, wouldn't be. This is stuff she took upon herself. I think the best that could be done for her was to let her go to Valhalla and become an Einherjar, one of Odin's warriors. She may be back in Mirrormirror, and possibly Harry will figure out a way to being her back to his dimension, but she will not be the same. That's the wisdom of the rule, it's a kindness not a punishment. Actually I have a WAG of my own, there will be a moment when Harry will have to chose. He can only bring one back to his dimension, the choice will be Murphy or Chandler. At the end of the day, Harry knows that his Murphy is dead, this isn't the same Murphy, she belongs in that dimension, and Chandler was snatched from his dimension and trapped in one where he doesn't belong. Harry knows what is right and he will do the right thing, he will leave Murphy, painful as that is, and restore Chandler to the dimension he belongs in.
Dina:
Do you think Chandler is in the Mirror dimension?
Mira:
--- Quote ---Do you think Chandler is in the Mirror dimension?
--- End quote ---
I do, remember he was disappeared into another dimension, he wasn't killed, wounded, or turned in Battle Ground. I think Jim did that for a reason, now we see Harry on his own as Wizard of Chicago, powerful yes, but he is going to need help. I think if Chandler is in the other dimension and Harry rescues him, the White Council isn't going to welcome him back with open arms. Chandler will be forced out like Harry was and he is going to join Harry as his right hand man so to speak. Backing up another step during the confrontation between the Wardens and Harry on the road in Peace Talks it was Chandler who was sending signals to Harry that the Wardens weren't on his side and to beware. Now all of that may blow up in the end, but this is what I think is being set up.
Dina:
It is a good theory and I would like it.
Navigation
[0] Message Index
[#] Next page
[*] Previous page
Go to full version