The Dresden Files > DF Reference Collection
WOJ: Hexenwufl solved
Ms Duck:
--- Quote from: Mr. Death on May 01, 2012, 08:36:26 PM ---It could be a veil, just not one limited to sight. Just like Harry reformats his shield spell to cover different types of energy beyond kinetic, I don't see why a wizard of Cowl's caliber couldn't put up a veil to mask his scent and sound as well as sight.
--- End quote ---
its mentioned in changes that Molly improved her veils enough to hide from werwolves; in fact, she does so in GS at the scene with mort.
now, how she does this without breakign the third law is a much debated topic ;D ;D ;D
the neurovore of Zur-En-Aargh:
Oh, OK, I'd not remembered that bit. Suppose it could have been a veil after all.
Thork:
--- Quote from: the neurovore of Zur-En-Aargh on May 01, 2012, 08:05:00 PM ---I think that's a clue as to where he hangs out, not what/who he is. or at least, the mildew reference i remember around Cowl is when he and Kumori disappear when faced by the Alphas in DB (and we can be pretty sure that's not a veil because of Bob's explanation of how invisibility is useless against wolves in FM, so it kind of must be an escape to the NN), and I think what that's meant to connect up with is the description of the place Peabody runs to at the end of TC.
I'm not recalling that off the top of my head, other than his voice sounding not particularly human, which I tend to read as part of his disguise. I don't think Harry has that reaction to his magic anywhere, anyway. Am I forgetting something ?
--- End quote ---
The main reason I suspect Cowl is Fomor is actually that he says "Thrice I ask and Done" to Harry, and that's a Fae formulation. We know the Fomor have Fae traditions, so that coupled with the nonhuman voice, human magic, and mildew, all together make me think human with Fomor modifications. His extreme magical oomph is also an argument here -- he's stronger than Ebenezer, much less Harry, so he's likely done something dark to get that power.
I see what you're saying about how the mildew reference is possibly a clue as to where rather than what, but all the "mildew"-referenced portals are opening from and (and therefore into) dramatically different places -- either they're using a different kind of portal into the nevernever such that they can zap themselves over into a different nevernever, and that different nevernever smells musty and mildewed no matter where you go in it, OR they can open an Odin-style teleportation portal whenever they want to, OR there's something in Cowl's (and perhaps Peabody's) magic that's tainted, and that taint of mildew is expressed in the way they open portals.
Either way, I read the mildew/water/damp connection as a likely connection to the Fomor, mainly because if the Fomor haven't shown up at all prior to Aftermath, that's bad plotting on Butcher's part, and I don't see him doing that; villains that major must have been foreshadowed somewhere. Plus, having Cowl conceal his identity because he's Fomor (or fomor-modified human) is a nice twist on the "expected" reveal that if we see a disguised villain, he "must" be someone we've already seen.
the neurovore of Zur-En-Aargh:
--- Quote from: Thork on May 01, 2012, 10:06:43 PM ---The main reason I suspect Cowl is Fomor is actually that he says "Thrice I ask and Done" to Harry, and that's a Fae formulation.
--- End quote ---
I'm not sure it's significantly more a Fae formulation than wizards use in general, though, cf Harry setting three conditions on his agreement to become Winter Knight in Changes, or the questions he gets from Lea in GS. (I kind of tend not to notice that as a Fae-specific thing because it's not exceedingly rare to find that sort of pattern in spoken English in Celtic countries, it was the sort of thing people around me when I was growing up might plausibly say.)
--- Quote ---I see what you're saying about how the mildew reference is possibly a clue as to where rather than what, but all the "mildew"-referenced portals are opening from and (and therefore into) dramatically different places -- either they're using a different kind of portal into the nevernever such that they can zap themselves over into a different nevernever, and that different nevernever smells musty and mildewed no matter where you go in it, OR they can open an Odin-style teleportation portal whenever they want to, OR there's something in Cowl's (and perhaps Peabody's) magic that's tainted, and that taint of mildew is expressed in the way they open portals.
--- End quote ---
That argument seems to me to contain the assumption that Earthly geography maps consistently into the NN, and I think the evidence in the books argues otherwise; in GP Harry gets into Bianca's house from fairly close to where Michael and Thomas leave the NN, but they end up in a strip club because Thomas has an affinity for such places; in WN the two portals opened into the Deeps in the final battle lead to wildly different parts of the NN.
I think Cowl in DB and Peabody in WN are more likely aiming for the same general region of the NN, possibly very close together, but that they can get there from pretty much anywhere in Earth.
--- Quote ---Either way, I read the mildew/water/damp connection as a likely connection to the Fomor, mainly because if the Fomor haven't shown up at all prior to Aftermath, that's bad plotting on Butcher's part, and I don't see him doing that; villains that major must have been foreshadowed somewhere.
--- End quote ---
I'm inclined to disagree here too, both because halfway through the series does not seem too late to be introducing major players to me, and because having Sidhe-type Faerie seems to me to automatically imply something Fomorian-like as part of the same mythos so they've been implicitly set up since GP; it's no more bad plotting to my mind than not introducing angels loyal to Heaven until halfway through the series if there were explicitly Christian-mythos fallen angels several books earlier.
Thork:
--- Quote from: the neurovore of Zur-En-Aargh on May 01, 2012, 10:37:19 PM ---I'm not sure it's significantly more a Fae formulation than wizards use in general, though, cf Harry setting three conditions on his agreement to become Winter Knight in Changes, or the questions he gets from Lea in GS. (I kind of tend not to notice that as a Fae-specific thing because it's not exceedingly rare to find that sort of pattern in spoken English in Celtic countries, it was the sort of thing people around me when I was growing up might plausibly say.)
--- End quote ---
Yeah, but in both those circumstances Harry is speaking with the Fae and so consciously adopting their lingo -- it's not something Harry just does when he's talking to, say, Kincaid, or Ebenezer, or Mavra. So I think it's a tipoff. Is there anywhere else in the series where we get that formulation and there isn't a Fae in the conversation?
--- Quote ---That argument seems to me to contain the assumption that Earthly geography maps consistently into the NN, and I think the evidence in the books argues otherwise; in GP Harry gets into Bianca's house from fairly close to where Michael and Thomas leave the NN, but they end up in a strip club because Thomas has an affinity for such places; in WN the two portals opened into the Deeps in the final battle lead to wildly different parts of the NN.
--- End quote ---
Yeah, that's the assumption, or at least one possible assumption. The way I've read the books so far, there is a 1:1 map between Dresden's Prime Material Plane and the NeverNever -- it's just that there's a wild variation over distance, i.e, even moving an inch in 'reality" might take you to a wildly different place in the NN. The main evidence for such a 1:1 map would seem to be the possibilty of guarding things from the NN side -- i.e., Lea's Garden, the Nazi Ghost Beach, etc. The other evidence would be the relative stability of Ways through the NeverNever -- You can't just wish up a spot near you that will take you to X place, you have to find a spot near you that opens up into a spot that's near the spot you want to get to in the NN, etc. Without some degree of stable correspondence and mapping, Harry's mother's amulet is an unnecessary waste -- you could just hop straight to wherever you wanted to go.
The way I read the passage with Thomas and Michael, they'd had to travel to a spot where there was a corresponding spot that Thomas had an affinity (the strip club). But I admit it's open to interpretation.
--- Quote ---I'm inclined to disagree here too, both because halfway through the series does not seem too late to be introducing major players to me, and because having Sidhe-type Faerie seems to me to automatically imply something Fomorian-like as part of the same mythos so they've been implicitly set up since GP; it's no more bad plotting to my mind than not introducing angels loyal to Heaven until halfway through the series if there were explicitly Christian-mythos fallen angels several books earlier.
--- End quote ---
Fair point, but one that might seem stronger to someone raised in Celtic lore. For us ignorant Americans the Fomor are pretty darn esoteric -- most modern fantasy that talks about the Fae doesn't talk about the Fomor (Tolkien, Gaiman, Susannah Clarke, etc.).
Navigation
[0] Message Index
[#] Next page
[*] Previous page
Go to full version