Author Topic: Has Carlos sided with the merlin against Harry  (Read 12921 times)

Offline prince lotore

  • Conversationalist
  • **
  • Posts: 509
    • View Profile
Has Carlos sided with the merlin against Harry
« on: February 09, 2024, 06:33:33 PM »
I was rereading the series and it seems to me that Carlos is no longer Harry's friend. Carlos knows that harry is "working the problem" of the black council from the other side but is constantly suspicious of him. He puts a tracker on harry then gets Harry's only other friends that are wizards to accuse him of being disloyal. The whole time giving the Morgan line if you have nothing to hide let me interrogate you until I believe you. When Harry needs to talk to people to prevent from being thrown out of the council Carlos puts him on a security detail so he can't. And when Harry asks where this is coming from he is told Anastasia. But if he switched sides to team merlin after the beating that Molly gave him it could be part of a plan to isolate harry to either take him off the table for whatever the upcoming starborn event is or to force harry to tow the line for the white council. Either way I expect that it will be Carlos who comes after harry next and will probably be in charge of monitoring harry now that he isn't a wizard anymore. I also expect that Carlos now blames harry for what happened to the other wardens with dracul
Life should NOT be a journey to the grave with the intention of
arriving safely in an attractive and well preserved body, but rather to
skid in sideways, chocolate in one hand, martini in the other, body
thoroughly used up, totally worn out and screaming "WOO HOO what a
ride!

Offline g33k

  • Posty McPostington
  • ***
  • Posts: 2403
    • View Profile
Re: Has Carlos sided with the merlin against Harry
« Reply #1 on: February 09, 2024, 10:19:30 PM »
I find Carlos very "Schrödinger's Loyalty" right now.

He may have given up on Harry; or it may all be an act.  We don't know, for sure.

But please note:  when they spoke privately at the end of White Night, Carlos expressed very strong support for the idea that Harry would embed himself with the Black-Hat crew and work his way toward the White-Council traitor(s) from that side.  And everything he's done since then to "alienate" Harry could equally be seen as working to support Harry in that mission.

It occurs to me that maybe Jim himself hasn't decided which way to write it, and is holding off to see which way will work better.
« Last Edit: February 09, 2024, 10:24:01 PM by g33k »

Offline OutsideIn

  • Participant
  • *
  • Posts: 27
    • View Profile
Re: Has Carlos sided with the merlin against Harry
« Reply #2 on: February 11, 2024, 05:42:33 AM »
Yeah they went South on the Carlos character. Without any justification. At least not as yet. We might need a book with carlos's viewpoint

Offline magnuskn

  • Conversationalist
  • **
  • Posts: 230
    • View Profile
Re: Has Carlos sided with the merlin against Harry
« Reply #3 on: February 12, 2024, 10:14:02 AM »
I assume getting his spine bent into directions it shouldn't go by Molly in an act of treachery (which it has to be from his viewpoint, despite us knowing that Molly had no control over her actions) just may have colored Carlos's viewpoint.

Offline vincentric

  • Conversationalist
  • **
  • Posts: 582
    • View Profile
Re: Has Carlos sided with the merlin against Harry
« Reply #4 on: February 12, 2024, 03:52:18 PM »
The worst injuries of Carlos' life have come at the hands of the White Court and when he's been involved with Winter as an ally.

His injuries in the Wraith Deeps were his first as a mage. Molly messed him up badly and he was helping her. The PT/BG action led to his embarrassment during the meeting, a traumatic battle where he lost his two closest friends besides Harry and a climactic battle where he was merely a living shield instead of a major player. To him, being involved with the Winter and White Courts, is one of the worst places that a mage can be.

So now we have his relationship with Harry to consider. He still thinks of harry as a friend, but he can't completely trust him. He's wrong about Harry not telling him all his secrets, but Harry is beholden to Winter and is very friendly with the White Court. Blaming Harry for Kimiko and Wild Bill can be excused as trauma but even with his doubts he did argue against Harry's expulsion.

His warning talk with Harry at the end on BG wasn't handled well, but he had been thru nearly as much stress and trauma as Harry during that time. He wasn't thinking clearly and running nerves just as raw. I think he'll give Harry the benefit of the doubt when next they meet, but he'll be wary and Harry needs to be a tad more tactful himself.

Offline forumghost

  • Posty McPostington
  • ***
  • Posts: 2729
    • View Profile
Re: Has Carlos sided with the merlin against Harry
« Reply #5 on: February 14, 2024, 06:31:30 AM »
It's also worth noting that Carlos... actually kinda has a point?

Like, Harry is acting sus as fuck in PT/BG.

Carlos: "Yo Man, we're kinda worried that you've be enthralled by the Totally not White Queen™. Can you talk to us about what's going on"

Harry: *Grounds staff and begins Channeling Magic* "FUCK YOU, I'M NOT SUS, YOU'RE SUS. FUCK OFF OR FIGHT ME".

Like, actually what the fuck dude. You treat your frenemies/enemies with less venom then you do you supposed friends/allies, and then go all 'boo hoo woe is me, why don't they believe me' when they don't trust you.

Trust is a two way street Harry, you learned this in like, book 3 with Murphy, remember?

Offline prince lotore

  • Conversationalist
  • **
  • Posts: 509
    • View Profile
Re: Has Carlos sided with the merlin against Harry
« Reply #6 on: February 14, 2024, 04:15:14 PM »
I think after you are almost killed 15 times for random strangers who just asked you to save them you get a little credit in the could I have become evil bank. Now granted harry could say that he is protected from the white court because of Murphy but is there really any proof that the council will accept from harry that he is his own man
Life should NOT be a journey to the grave with the intention of
arriving safely in an attractive and well preserved body, but rather to
skid in sideways, chocolate in one hand, martini in the other, body
thoroughly used up, totally worn out and screaming "WOO HOO what a
ride!

Offline vincentric

  • Conversationalist
  • **
  • Posts: 582
    • View Profile
Re: Has Carlos sided with the merlin against Harry
« Reply #7 on: February 14, 2024, 06:44:45 PM »
If they don't give you credit for having the last 4 Knights of the Cross as close friends ...

Offline g33k

  • Posty McPostington
  • ***
  • Posts: 2403
    • View Profile
Re: Has Carlos sided with the merlin against Harry
« Reply #8 on: February 14, 2024, 07:21:40 PM »
If they don't give you credit for having the last 4 Knights of the Cross as close friends ...
THIS.
Being friends with the KotC's is about the closest thing you'll ever get in the Dresdenverse to overt, external, objective proof.

Offline Mira

  • Needs A Life
  • ***
  • Posts: 24391
    • View Profile
Re: Has Carlos sided with the merlin against Harry
« Reply #9 on: February 14, 2024, 08:49:10 PM »
THIS.
Being friends with the KotC's is about the closest thing you'll ever get in the Dresdenverse to overt, external, objective proof.

Indeed, I think the injury Carlos got when he tried to make love to the Winter Lady did more than physical damage to him.  Since Molly never warned him of possible severe physical injury if he made love to her, he not only blames her but now suspects the whole Winter Court.  That makes him very vulnerable to any negative suggestions about anyone connected with the Winter Court.  Thus the paranoia that the White Council feels about Harry is underscored in this case by the experience that Carlos had.

Offline LordDresden2

  • Conversationalist
  • **
  • Posts: 583
    • View Profile
Re: Has Carlos sided with the merlin against Harry
« Reply #10 on: June 30, 2024, 10:12:11 PM »
It's also worth noting that Carlos... actually kinda has a point?

Like, Harry is acting sus as fuck in PT/BG.

Carlos: "Yo Man, we're kinda worried that you've be enthralled by the Totally not White Queen™. Can you talk to us about what's going on"

Harry: *Grounds staff and begins Channeling Magic* "FUCK YOU, I'M NOT SUS, YOU'RE SUS. FUCK OFF OR FIGHT ME".

Like, actually what the fuck dude. You treat your frenemies/enemies with less venom then you do you supposed friends/allies, and then go all 'boo hoo woe is me, why don't they believe me' when they don't trust you.

Trust is a two way street Harry, you learned this in like, book 3 with Murphy, remember?

Actually, he learned the wrong lesson with Murphy, or maybe he learned both at once.  Harry was almost certainly right to keep Murphy in the dark as much as he did, at that time.  It was only after the loup garou rampage rubbed her nose in reality that it was probably safe to bring her fully into the loop.  Even after that, she occasionally starts to let her craving to use the Law as a comfort belief cause her to do something that would make a diasaster, and Harry has to remind her of the loup garou and Carmichael to sober her up.  Or remember the incident with the gruff at Mac's.

The Council has excellent reason to distrust Harry, based on his own past actions and inactions.  Harry, likewise, has good reason to distrust the Council.  The fault lies on both sides.  As Carlos pointed out, Harry would have been very wise to put in more regular appearances at Edinburgh, to maintain a good PR image and good relations with some of the other Wizards.  But Harry has reason to dislike associating with them, too.

The Council are afraid, in effect, that they're seeing Kemmler II emerging.  We don't know the history of Kemmler in detail, for all we know he might have started out as an apparently 'good guy' in the early stages.

But remember what Bob told Harry about Kemmler, back in Dead Beat:

"...he was a necromancer...he had truck with demons, he was buddies with most of the vampire courts...and some of the uglier fairies, too.  Plus he had his own little cadre of baby Kemmlers to help him..."

Sound familiar?  From the POV of the more skeptical Council members, the above sounds more than a little like Harry.  Not every detail, but Harry has apparently come back from the dead, he reanimated Sue, he's way too close for comfort with the White Court, he's known to have trafficked with demons, he's hooked up with a whole mess of entities who are, at best, not friendly to humanity, he's the Winter Knight, he's Margaret McCoy's son, he's managed to make himself the Warden of Demonreach (the ultimate unexploded bomb!), his former apprentice (a warlock herself!) is now Winter Lady, he's accumulating a number of powerful artifacts, he's gathering minions (the paranet would look an awful lot like a mechanism to do that from one POV) plus outfits like the Chicago protectors, he's allies (sort of) with Marcone, ...and he's copping an attitude.

What do we expect the Council to assume?  I suspect Carlos himself is probably torn.  I don't think, based on what he said in Battleground, that he thinks Harry is evil...but I do think he's afraid Harry might be headed that way in spite of himself, losing his footing on the slippery slope, so to speak.

The Council's attitude is completely reasonable, from their POV.


Offline vincentric

  • Conversationalist
  • **
  • Posts: 582
    • View Profile
Re: Has Carlos sided with the merlin against Harry
« Reply #11 on: July 01, 2024, 12:05:35 AM »
The problem is the White Council has selective memory where Harry is concerned.

No one can deny that many of Harry's exploits look shady from an outside view. But they don't give him credit for the bright ones or the times that he does the right thing when it might have been wiser to step aside.

Yes, he started the war with the Red Court (Though it was more that he gave them a pretext to put their plans in motion.), but he did it to save innocents from slavery and death. He resolved the war between Winter and Summer. He stood with the KotC as the Denarians tried to start anew Black Death. He stopped Kimmler's heirs. He again stood with the KotC to prevent the corruption of the Archive. He uncovered the traitor within the Council. He destroyed the Red Court. He dealt the deciding blow to Ethniu.  These are the things that they know about but give no credit for. Saving the world in Cold Days and being literally on the side of the angels (Multiple casual interactions with Archangel Uriel come to mind.) would be more to his good but they don't know about those beyond what Harry's reported.

Offline LordDresden2

  • Conversationalist
  • **
  • Posts: 583
    • View Profile
Re: Has Carlos sided with the merlin against Harry
« Reply #12 on: July 01, 2024, 12:43:42 AM »
The problem is the White Council has selective memory where Harry is concerned.

No one can deny that many of Harry's exploits look shady from an outside view. But they don't give him credit for the bright ones or the times that he does the right thing when it might have been wiser to step aside.

Yes, he started the war with the Red Court (Though it was more that he gave them a pretext to put their plans in motion.), but he did it to save innocents from slavery and death. He resolved the war between Winter and Summer. He stood with the KotC as the Denarians tried to start anew Black Death. He stopped Kimmler's heirs. He again stood with the KotC to prevent the corruption of the Archive. He uncovered the traitor within the Council. He destroyed the Red Court. He dealt the deciding blow to Ethniu.  These are the things that they know about but give no credit for. Saving the world in Cold Days and being literally on the side of the angels (Multiple casual interactions with Archangel Uriel come to mind.) would be more to his good but they don't know about those beyond what Harry's reported.

It depends on what you mean by credit.  From the Council's POV, the issue is not whether he did most of those things, but rather the question:  'Why did he do it?'

That is, what were his motives, and what are the effects on him, and where is he going?  Remember, a warlock can do good things and become a dangerous monster as a side effect.  It almost happened to Molly, and I'm sure other warlocks got trapped trying to do what they thought was right.  By many accounts, the start of Margaret's darkness was misguided idealism.

The Council is afraid they're seeing Kemmler II in embryo.  That could be true even if all of Harry's motives are good.  Yeah, he wiped out the Red Court.  But that has both good and bad effects.  He struck the decisive blow against Ethniu...but that could be in the service of good or bad intentions.  Even if his intentions are good, the results could end up being catastrophically bad, and the Council knows that.

They aren't asking where he's been or what he's done or why, they're asking "Where is this going?"  Which is a different question.


Offline Mira

  • Needs A Life
  • ***
  • Posts: 24391
    • View Profile
Re: Has Carlos sided with the merlin against Harry
« Reply #13 on: July 01, 2024, 12:44:58 PM »
Quote
The Council is afraid they're seeing Kemmler II in embryo.  That could be true even if all of Harry's motives are good.  Yeah, he wiped out the Red Court.  But that has both good and bad effects.  He struck the decisive blow against Ethniu...but that could be in the service of good or bad intentions.  Even if his intentions are good, the results could end up being catastrophically bad, and the Council knows that.

Or there are a lot of power politics going on, let's not forget that at least three on the Sr Council do not think that Harry is a baby Kemmler.. However there is at least one who feels threatened by Harry's growing power.  And yes, in many ways Harry has made his own bed and given that one or two of influence to twist and use all that he has done against him.. As I said, the hurt that Carlos received when he attempted to have sex with Molly went deeper than the mere physical and candidate number one for manipulation against Harry.

Offline vincentric

  • Conversationalist
  • **
  • Posts: 582
    • View Profile
Re: Has Carlos sided with the merlin against Harry
« Reply #14 on: July 01, 2024, 03:40:43 PM »
It depends on what you mean by credit.  From the Council's POV, the issue is not whether he did most of those things, but rather the question:  'Why did he do it?'

That is, what were his motives, and what are the effects on him, and where is he going?  Remember, a warlock can do good things and become a dangerous monster as a side effect.  It almost happened to Molly, and I'm sure other warlocks got trapped trying to do what they thought was right.  By many accounts, the start of Margaret's darkness was misguided idealism.

The Council is afraid they're seeing Kemmler II in embryo.  That could be true even if all of Harry's motives are good.  Yeah, he wiped out the Red Court.  But that has both good and bad effects.  He struck the decisive blow against Ethniu...but that could be in the service of good or bad intentions.  Even if his intentions are good, the results could end up being catastrophically bad, and the Council knows that.

They aren't asking where he's been or what he's done or why, they're asking "Where is this going?"  Which is a different question.

If you saw one of the most promising talents of the past century who is also a Starborn, walking close to the darkness, would you try a calm and reasoned intercession or would you bully, threaten and ostracize him even though he has not done any dark acts?

The Council became antagonistic to Harry when he used a political move to save Molly. Until he got on Langtry's bad side there, Harry was a rising star. He had emerged from the Doom, been promoted to the Wardens and then to the Warden in charge of North America. He wasn't even required to report to any of the three Senior Council members living there.

As Mira said, this is all about politics. Langtry feels threatened by Harry and doesn't like the direction that he thinks Harry would lead or influence the Council toward. He now has the best of both worlds as he sees it. Harry is a Council outcast, and he can still use Harry by exploiting his incapability to refuse to do the right thing.