Author Topic: Is this enchanted item too powerful?  (Read 6173 times)

Offline dplanken

  • Participant
  • *
  • Posts: 28
    • View Profile
Is this enchanted item too powerful?
« on: August 24, 2013, 02:07:16 PM »
Is this enchanted item too powerful or balanced? This is the first time a player took magic in my game, and with that comes enchanted items.

Handmirror that imitates Abby's power to see 1-2 seconds into the future.
Created with A Lore of 4 with a focus item of lore +1 so Lore 5 total.

What we decided it does, is grant a bonus to defense (+5, usuable once a session, not usuable for other players) when someone makes a physical attack. Right now it doesn't cost any action to use, it's a free action.

If he lowers the bonus/power of the enchanted mirror by 1 he can use it twice with a bonus of +4. That seems really powerful to me, if he lowers it to +3 he can he use it 3 times. A bonus to any physical defense of +3, 3 times a session seems imba.

What do you guys think? Is it balanced?

Offline Mr. Death

  • Posty McPostington
  • ***
  • Posts: 7965
  • Not all those who wander are lost
    • View Profile
    • The C-Team Podcast
Re: Is this enchanted item too powerful?
« Reply #1 on: August 24, 2013, 03:18:36 PM »
I think you misunderstand enchanted items. They do not provide a bonus to defense. An item like this would replace the defense roll, like a block. So this item would never be a +5 to the defense roll, it would make the character's defense 5.
Compels solve everything!

http://blur.by/1KgqJg6 My first book: "Brothers of the Curled Isles"

Quote from: Cozarkian
Not every word JB rights is a conspiracy. Sometimes, he's just telling a story.

https://www.youtube.com/channel/UC_T_mld7Acnm-0FVUiaKDPA The C-Team Podcast

Offline Todjaeger

  • Conversationalist
  • **
  • Posts: 332
  • Dresden Files Alpha Burn Playtester
    • View Profile
    • Butchered New Haven campaign site
Re: Is this enchanted item too powerful?
« Reply #2 on: August 24, 2013, 06:50:46 PM »
I concur with Mr. Death.  An enchanted item can be thought of as an item which stores a spell, with the effect of the spell being dictated by the desires of the player and what they can accomplish with their Lore.  Now using an enchanted hand mirror to duplicate the effects of Abby's supernatural power A Few Minutes Ahead could be done but that doesn't provide her a bonus to Defense, nor does it take the place of a Defense action.

From OW99

Quote
A Few Seconds Ahead (Minor Ability) [–1]: Abby can use her Lore skill to get a reasonably accurate picture of events 1-2 seconds ahead of now (limited to what she will personally experience in those moments). She may roll her Lore skill to defend against physical or social attacks or maneuvers.

Reading from the description, the power allows her to use her Lore skill to defend against physical & social attacks, instead of the normal Athletics, Empathy, Fists, Rapport and Weapons skills. 

It could work to have someone with an item which allows them to have a new Trapping for a skill, but that is more the sort of thing achieved with an Item of Power, since Stunts which cost Refresh are what provide for new Trappings, and the player is effectively trying to replicate a Supernatural Power (which again, costs Refresh).

Now if the player is just looking for something to aid or replace their character's defenses look at the examples given by Mr. Death for how it would work, or look in the novels for info on Harry's enchanted leather duster.

-Cheers
Kill the Child, Doom the World...  Or is it, Kill the Child, Save the World?

Dresden Files Purity test: http://knnn.x10.mx/purity2/purity.html

My results: http://knnn.x10.mx/purity2/purity-result.html?55:70:18:23:6:6:17:26:11:27:11:37:14:41:20:28:3:5:

Offline dplanken

  • Participant
  • *
  • Posts: 28
    • View Profile
Re: Is this enchanted item too powerful?
« Reply #3 on: August 24, 2013, 07:55:47 PM »
Ah, yes I definitely misunderstood enchanted items. This makes far more sense and I won't be afraid it's overpowered at all. Thanks!

Offline InFerrumVeritas

  • Conversationalist
  • **
  • Posts: 813
    • View Profile
Re: Is this enchanted item too powerful?
« Reply #4 on: August 25, 2013, 01:45:33 PM »
If they want a bonus, have it create an aspect that they can tag for a +2.

The rules require at least a +3 to make an aspect, so reducing 5 shifts to 3 would give you two additional uses per session.  Not bad.

Offline Mr. Death

  • Posty McPostington
  • ***
  • Posts: 7965
  • Not all those who wander are lost
    • View Profile
    • The C-Team Podcast
Re: Is this enchanted item too powerful?
« Reply #5 on: August 25, 2013, 01:50:52 PM »
If they want a bonus, have it create an aspect that they can tag for a +2.

The rules require at least a +3 to make an aspect, so reducing 5 shifts to 3 would give you two additional uses per session.  Not bad.
Though that brings up the question about whether defensive maneuver items can be used as a free action--I've always allowed it, but I'm not sure if that's supported by the RAW.
Compels solve everything!

http://blur.by/1KgqJg6 My first book: "Brothers of the Curled Isles"

Quote from: Cozarkian
Not every word JB rights is a conspiracy. Sometimes, he's just telling a story.

https://www.youtube.com/channel/UC_T_mld7Acnm-0FVUiaKDPA The C-Team Podcast

Offline dplanken

  • Participant
  • *
  • Posts: 28
    • View Profile
Re: Is this enchanted item too powerful?
« Reply #6 on: August 25, 2013, 08:35:16 PM »
If they want a bonus, have it create an aspect that they can tag for a +2.

The rules require at least a +3 to make an aspect, so reducing 5 shifts to 3 would give you two additional uses per session.  Not bad.

Could you point me in the direction where I could find this information?

Offline PirateJack

  • Posty McPostington
  • ***
  • Posts: 1843
    • View Profile
Re: Is this enchanted item too powerful?
« Reply #7 on: August 25, 2013, 10:25:50 PM »
If they want a bonus, have it create an aspect that they can tag for a +2.

The rules require at least a +3 to make an aspect, so reducing 5 shifts to 3 would give you two additional uses per session.  Not bad.

From personal experience, this is overpowered as hell. Since Enchanted Items can exchange strength for uses and they recharge between sessions, it effectively means a Wizard can consistently work with at least +2 (I'm dealing with constant +4's with 8 uses per session, thanks to crafting specialisations) to every action he takes. Then there's the way Practitioners can get extra uses out of their items through spending a point of mental stress.

At this stage I think Enchanted Items need some serious rebalancing.
Quote from: JoeC
"Why are you banging your head against the wall?
'cause it feels sooooo good when I stop..."

Offline Sanctaphrax

  • White Council
  • Seriously?
  • ****
  • Posts: 12405
    • View Profile
Re: Is this enchanted item too powerful?
« Reply #8 on: August 26, 2013, 12:02:51 AM »
Though that brings up the question about whether defensive maneuver items can be used as a free action--I've always allowed it, but I'm not sure if that's supported by the RAW.

Pretty sure it's not.

Heck, even letting people use defensive armour items as a free action requires a bit of interpretation IIRC.

Could you point me in the direction where I could find this information?

Which information?

From personal experience, this is overpowered as hell. Since Enchanted Items can exchange strength for uses and they recharge between sessions, it effectively means a Wizard can consistently work with at least +2 (I'm dealing with constant +4's with 8 uses per session, thanks to crafting specialisations) to every action he takes. Then there's the way Practitioners can get extra uses out of their items through spending a point of mental stress.

At this stage I think Enchanted Items need some serious rebalancing.

Couldn't they accomplish the exact same thing using mundane maneuvers or regular spells, if you're allowing that kind of thing?

I've seen some balance issues with high-end crafters, but I don't think I've ever seen this one before.

Offline UmbraLux

  • Posty McPostington
  • ***
  • Posts: 1685
    • View Profile
Re: Is this enchanted item too powerful?
« Reply #9 on: August 26, 2013, 02:30:15 AM »
Though that brings up the question about whether defensive maneuver items can be used as a free action--I've always allowed it, but I'm not sure if that's supported by the RAW.
It probably comes down to how it's worded/used.  Declarations are free until fiat says otherwise so any maneuver you can declare is free game.  Fate Core does a good job of reigning aspect creation in, DFRPG can be (kind of) OP unless you house rule a few things. 
--
“As our circle of knowledge expands, so does the circumference of darkness surrounding it.”  - Albert Einstein

"Rudeness is a weak imitation of strength."  - Eric Hoffer

Offline Sanctaphrax

  • White Council
  • Seriously?
  • ****
  • Posts: 12405
    • View Profile
Re: Is this enchanted item too powerful?
« Reply #10 on: August 26, 2013, 03:14:55 AM »
It probably comes down to how it's worded/used.  Declarations are free until fiat says otherwise so any maneuver you can declare is free game.

Nope. Enchanted items contain spells, spells can't do Declarations.

Offline UmbraLux

  • Posty McPostington
  • ***
  • Posts: 1685
    • View Profile
Re: Is this enchanted item too powerful?
« Reply #11 on: August 26, 2013, 12:15:30 PM »
Nope. Enchanted items contain spells, spells can't do Declarations.
That's one possibility.  Another is simply that the character make a declaration related to items.  This is why wording matters.   ;)

DFRPG rewards creative players. 
--
“As our circle of knowledge expands, so does the circumference of darkness surrounding it.”  - Albert Einstein

"Rudeness is a weak imitation of strength."  - Eric Hoffer

Offline Haru

  • Posty McPostington
  • ***
  • Posts: 5520
  • Mentally unstable like a fox.
    • View Profile
Re: Is this enchanted item too powerful?
« Reply #12 on: August 26, 2013, 02:03:59 PM »
From personal experience, this is overpowered as hell. Since Enchanted Items can exchange strength for uses and they recharge between sessions, it effectively means a Wizard can consistently work with at least +2 (I'm dealing with constant +4's with 8 uses per session, thanks to crafting specialisations) to every action he takes. Then there's the way Practitioners can get extra uses out of their items through spending a point of mental stress.

At this stage I think Enchanted Items need some serious rebalancing.
So that's 8 times a +4 to the roll? I'd seriously question that. If the enchanted items create aspects, and those aspects are applicable to pretty much everything, I'd veto it entirely. Make different items that have situational applications and all is good. If you can shove the game into a direction so you can use all of them, kudos to you.

Then there is another issue. Maneuver spells usually require an action to be used. I could see an item every now and again that allows you to simply use the aspect it would create, if it makes sense, but I would not let players create enchanted items that only do this. They should be the exception, not the rule.
And if you have to spend an action to create aspects, other people can use their action to remove the aspect or at least remove your tag on it. Especially if you create 2 aspects simultaneously, which means each aspect can be removed with significantly less effort than if it was only one. After that, it's not going to be nearly as powerful.
“Do you not know that a man is not dead while his name is still spoken?”
― Terry Pratchett, Going Postal

Offline Todjaeger

  • Conversationalist
  • **
  • Posts: 332
  • Dresden Files Alpha Burn Playtester
    • View Profile
    • Butchered New Haven campaign site
Re: Is this enchanted item too powerful?
« Reply #13 on: August 26, 2013, 06:36:21 PM »
So that's 8 times a +4 to the roll? I'd seriously question that. If the enchanted items create aspects, and those aspects are applicable to pretty much everything, I'd veto it entirely. Make different items that have situational applications and all is good. If you can shove the game into a direction so you can use all of them, kudos to you.

Then there is another issue. Maneuver spells usually require an action to be used. I could see an item every now and again that allows you to simply use the aspect it would create, if it makes sense, but I would not let players create enchanted items that only do this. They should be the exception, not the rule.
And if you have to spend an action to create aspects, other people can use their action to remove the aspect or at least remove your tag on it. Especially if you create 2 aspects simultaneously, which means each aspect can be removed with significantly less effort than if it was only one. After that, it's not going to be nearly as powerful.

Two things keep coming to mind with the discussion about using Enchanted Items to provide bonuses.

The first, (which people seem to be overlooking) is that the RAW allows an Enchanted Item to store/cast one single spell. *Yes, a Warden Sword is an Enchanted Item with two different functions but that is a special case.  Depending on the GM and table choose to interpret or allow, this means the Enchanted Item can only cast one spell which either could only do the same Maneuver, or it might be allowed to perform different, similar Maneuvers.  In other words the Enchanted Item couldn't be used to perform a Maneuver to knock over a case of ball bearings to create a Temporary Aspect: Unsteady Footing and then at some other point do a completely different Maneuver to create a fog cloud for a Temporary Aspect: Obscuring Mists.

The second is that Maneuvers to create Aspects are either opposed rolls (much like an attack roll) or against the environment.  In a number of cases, a difficulty of Good (+3) will allow the creation of a Fragile Temporary Aspect against the environment however that isn't true in all cases.  Using the example above of creating a fog cloud, in an area with plenty of water/moisture and cool air that could quite easily be only a Good (+3) environmental difficulty.  However, trying to create the same sort of fog cloud at high noon in Camp Kaboom, New Mexico...  That would likely a Fantastic (+6) or greater difficulty.

The variations in difficulty depending on circumstances are important because what the Enchanted Item can accomplish (shifts of difficulty) and number of uses is set at the item of item creation or the appropriate milestones.

In the example given by InFerrumVeritas, the +3 item 3x per session would allow Temporary Aspect creation via Maneuvers three times per session without causing Mental Stress, assuming the environmental or opposed difficulty was only Good (+3) or less.  However, if the difficulty for any of the attempts was Great (+4) or better, the Maneuver would fail, the attempt used up, no Temporary Aspect created, and using the Enchanted Item to maneuver would require the character to use an Action.

If the players are creative, then they might come up with spells for a maneuver which is fairly broad, allowing more frequent application when creating Temporary Aspects, but in general I would consider using an Enchanted Item like this inefficient or wasteful.

-Cheers
« Last Edit: August 28, 2013, 02:15:29 AM by Todjaeger »
Kill the Child, Doom the World...  Or is it, Kill the Child, Save the World?

Dresden Files Purity test: http://knnn.x10.mx/purity2/purity.html

My results: http://knnn.x10.mx/purity2/purity-result.html?55:70:18:23:6:6:17:26:11:27:11:37:14:41:20:28:3:5:

Offline Sanctaphrax

  • White Council
  • Seriously?
  • ****
  • Posts: 12405
    • View Profile
Re: Is this enchanted item too powerful?
« Reply #14 on: August 27, 2013, 07:49:17 AM »
That's one possibility.  Another is simply that the character make a declaration related to items.

Okay, but that would have nothing to do with the enchanted item rules and so it wouldn't reflect on whether or not those rules are balanced.

And FWIW, I haven't found DFRPG to reward creativity any more than average. Creativity is a huge asset in pretty much every RPG.