31
DF Reference Collection / Re: Law Breaking Vs Black Magic [Spoilers for everything]
« on: December 01, 2013, 03:34:17 AM »Where are we getting the whole "it's rewriting reality" thing from for magic? Seems to me that magic is about 90% just moving and affecting assorted forces. Not any different from using a shovel to move some dirt with your hands, other than the mechanism of doing so. But when you move the dirt, you're moving the dirt, not just causing an alteration in the fabric of reality in which that dirt was always in the other place.
IIRC, there was also at one point a WoJ that the level of belief in magic for a wizard is such that they'd be flabbergasted if they attempted a familiar spell and it didn't work (in the same way that vanilla mortals would be shocked if they dropped an object and it didn't fall). That the reason magic works for them is that this is how they believe the world should work on a fundamental level.
Which might help explain why killing with magic is bad: the wizard believes on a very deep level that that whatever/whoever they're killing isn't supposed to be alive.