So as a bit of a what if - could you do a sort of vaguely Witcher/Mass Effect/God of War type game. Heavy on story and action of course, throw in some Arkham style detective work and puzzle solving and keep the comedy coming and I think it could be a lot of fun. The hardest thing to decide would be how much dialogue would be yours to choose I guess. I suppose you could do it like Mass Effect and have a sort of "canon" story and the rest are "what if" scenarios.
Anyway I am keen to here your thoughts, what could it look like, what would it need, what to avoid etc. Have at it!
thats a good idea but how you make the game is kinda problem as we have meet the team Sherlock deduction moments as well as balls to the walls saints row style action in same bucket. So we kinda need adamantium solid plot as the moment we gave player ability to craft his first spell they gonna build spells or mods to make sure their crazy theory is legit game material and create forum fires to prove its word of jim that susan is time traveled kuromori and she is actualy murpy's secret lover kinda whack job situations.
So the things to make sure game works perfectly
vampire masqurade style game plan were player is member of paranet papers who learns his powers from one of the faction leaders.
flexible but strict magic rules so no time travel powers or mind control unless you are specific faction or NPC( moly for mind control and big bad for time magic stuff as only users)
good character creation system to create any character except dresden and company( this one needed to be hard code blocked so no mods to change then make time walking adventures of dresden mod or expension pack)
lot of area to play but solid reason to keep retuning dresdens gang for either info or plot advancement.
lot of deadpool quality snark
harry vision were player sees important clues and selective npc with special mental comments like seeing lara raith in bikini triggers special snark on harrys mind.)