151
DF Spoilers / Re: Brief Cases
« on: September 28, 2017, 07:08:40 PM »
Honestly, having so much Dresden goodness almost at once after the long wait would be very therapeutic.
This section allows you to view all posts made by this member. Note that you can only see posts made in areas you currently have access to.
Are you sure that he didn't mean that he had to have the manuscript turned in 8 to 12 weeks after that book?
The only thing that really bums me out about this is,that if history repeats, we won't get peace talks till Christmas or early 2019.
The swords are a great responsibility bestowed on Harry with trust. Being their custodian means that a higher power deems Harry worthy. Bob is a magical weapon that Harry stole or saved because he understood its value. Harry has a more personal feeling about Bob than swords.
D. How is Harry correct in his assessment that in his state of mind and situation he should give Bob back, but thirty seconds later, he's suddenly absolutely the right and only person who should have the Swords, which are just as important as Bob, and which are at greater risk? Personally, I think that his emotional reaction is because being the custodian of the swords means something to him. Bob, he acknowledges, is just a very powerful tool that’s dangerous in the wrong hands. Harry has a sort of respect for the swords and all it represents, and it hurts to be told he's not worthy anymore.
However, whether or not Harry thinks he is a good custodian of the sword is irrelevant – the only one who can really have an opinion on who should and should not be a custodian is TWG. The swords have been awarded to Harry despite his flaws and darker nature on many occasions, not because he’s some sort of paragon of virtue, but because higher beings on some other plane of existence see it fit that he should have it. Murphy and Dresden are second-guessing those beings, and Dresden's assertion that they were given to him is an assertion of that higher power.
Thank you. Sometimes I feel like I'm the only one who doesn't think Murphy is some kind of arrogant, power-playing manipulator just out to screw Dresden (or at least, the most vocal) and it's nice to get a little support now and again.
That is simply not true.
It's entirely Butters' distrust of Dresden that creates the incident.
Butters the one who secretly put a tracking and listening device on Dresden.
Butters is the one who thought Dresden was going to turn on them.
Butters is the one who fled to the Swords.
Meanwhile, Murphy is only involved at all because she shows complete trust in Dresden. He comes to her and asks her to walk into Hades with him, surrounded by literal demons and monsters, then tells her that he can't tell her crucial parts of the plan, and she instantly and completely accepts that.
That is complete, unflinching trust.
Has she really? No, there is distrust from Cold Days on...
Murphy wants that old Harry back, and he isn't ever going to come back. She should understand that, she has seen and taken part in enough of Harry's world, but somehow she doesn't. I think the contrast between Harry's conversations with her verses his conversations with Michael in Skin Game says it all. Michael accepts the changes both in Harry and in his life, and he also trusts who Harry is in his core being. Murphy doesn't, that is at the crux of it I think, she plays lip service to trusting him, but her actions/words say different.. I don't think she realizes it yet though, she means well, but all her concern for Harry not being the way he used to be only put an almost unbearable amount of self doubt in Harry. That is not good, not for Harry given his tasks ahead. For me that is what is annoying these days about their relationship, her observations and advice for Harry is all based on how his life used to be.. It is kind of like a parent of an adult kid who cannot accept that kid is grown and living a different life now, I believe the phrase is, "You never used to act this way...."
Just to be clear, if she goes Valkyrie, she's then a chooser of the dead and she's likely out of the story doing her job elsewhere in the world.
Which would be worse for her if she is a devote Catholic as you say because she'd be an instrument of a pagan religion.
It would, in the sense she would be working with her beloved father, and she'd be doing meaningful work. It also would be, if it was her choice to do so. Remember Harry had that choice at the end of Ghost Story, he chose to move on and face what was to come..
I meant to say that she could go to Valhalla because she is a warrior, Gard would say that. She could also go straight through the door to Judgement, as you say she has that kind of faith... But I think peace and happiness for her would be joining her father and working for Uriel.
And then parent-teacher nights became VERY awkward.
I'd be up for that idea though, just for that alone.