16
DF Spoilers / Re: Malcolm gives Harry more to bargain for
« on: March 27, 2024, 09:53:30 PM »Quote
Harry the unreliable narrator with a very confusing backstory even without the constant shifts?
Is he? Everyone says that yet outside of a few short stories he is the only narrator we've got. So is he a liar? Just stupid? Maybe senile when he wrote his story? Unless you got an alternative story out there..
Quote
Let's jump back to Star wars for the metaphor of chosen Orphan. Did luke know... Anything that was true? Leia what about Rey?What has that to do with anything? Harry is a starborn, he would be so whether he was an orphan or not. As far as his names go as Harry explains back in Fool Moon, it isn't the names themselves that would give Chauncy power over him, it is giving him, his names.. Harry was careful even to change the inflection of how to say the names he did give him to try and prevent Chauncy from having power over him.. Didn't matter if his name was John Jinglehimer Smith, or Harry David Copperfield Dresden, it was giving his name or part of his name that gave Chauncy power over him and what he bargained for.
Quote
I find it far more likely they named him together, as they were indeed together before her death 👀So what if they did? Harry's name in of itself has no power, at least up to this point it hasn't shown itself to have power of any kind or protection.
Quote
I find it fair less likely Malcolm named him unilaterally and just by happenstance gave him the extra protection of names in a verse where such things actually matter.(Something Harry mentioned in storm front, FM, GP, ECT)Whether Malcolm did or didn't give him those names unilaterally doesn't matter. The name, Harry, in of itself has no power or protection, nor David, nor Copperfield, nor Dresden, what gives power is that they are his names.
Quote
Again: do we know this? Was he on-board with the "starborn" scheme? I don't really count the scene in the dream (around the campfire), because it's evident that Malcolm was VERY clued-in at that point.Oh I think he was more clued in than you think, at least the importance of the conception, even if he didn't fully understand. This is hinted at both by Margaret herself during Harry's soul gaze with Thomas in Blood Rites and when Lash begins to tell him about his power over Outsiders in White Night. It takes two to make a baby, and that's even more important in the case of a star born.