Or Oberon is Santa Claus, the King of Winter who got press-ganged into Christian mythology.  After all, Santa's workshop is supposed to be filled with elves, right? 

McAurther Park.

I'm totally serious. Big open place in the middle of the city, lots of police and homeless presence. Why? The homeless figured out less of them get "disappeared" if they stay in the park overnight. (no hunting for red court and ghouls) And the cops add a "don't show off in front of the mortals" factor.

 That's pretty much the same reason that Centennial Olympic Park is ANG in Atlanta.

I think we're getting somewhere now... I think I'm going to make it a local band, as suggested.  This makes it mire plausible that they'd be doing multiple shows, so a pattern can more easily start to emerge.  I think I'm going to have the whole band have Cassandra's Tears, and they all trigger at random, which is why it's never the same song it works on twice.  I think they won't even know they have it, but all the effects they cause are amassing power for the big nasty of my campaign (whatever I decide that to be... It's early, I can be vague).  Their songs will be almost entirely covers, which also lends to the random effects.  As for the songs themselves and their effects, I'm working on a list.  So far I've got...

Filter- Hey Man Nice Shot - increased suicides, gun murders
Offspring - Come Out and Play - increased youth crime
Nickelback - Never Again - increased domestic violence
Green Day - Having a Blast - suicide bombers
Metallica - One - soldiers returning from Iraq have lost their arms, legs, sight, hearing... This one is REALLY dark...

I need some more.  Anyone got any for me?

You may be able to draw on this old medieval myth about the tritone, too.  Maybe all those monks weren't wrong?  Perhaps when the interval is played by someone with the "right" supernatural heritage, it really IS evil?  Bwahahaha!

http://www.religionnewsblog.com/14485/the-devils-music

Just Google "the devil's interval" or the "devil's chord" and you'll find more info on it.

I'll be there!

Envy would work too. All of the people who don't make it...

 One of the local White Court families in our Atlanta game, House Cadiz, feeds on Envy.  They are huge in the fashion industry and compete with Raith for the club scene.  They really do bask in the glow of others' admiration.  Cadiz' Catch remains True Love, though it would be more accurate to say that their Catch (and the Catch of most White Court Vamps) is "Selfless Devotion", a pure and true emotion whose most potent expression is True Love.

 The other White Court family is House Lazio, which feeds on Gluttony.  They have their fingers deep in many high-end fine cuisine restaurants and are in direct control of several "Dinner in the Dark" restaurants where the darkness is not a hinderance to them.  The Lazio can feed freely on guests who would only be aware of having the best meal of their life.  On the criminal side, the Lazio are involved in the designer drug trade, since drug and alcohol addiction is also a form of gluttony.

Consider that if the power of Holy Touch to satisfy catches is not unique, and does not cost fate points or refresh to replicate, then the power effectively only gives weapon: 1 to fists against things repulsive to the faith of the user, which is weaker than a stunt.

 Nah, being the Catch for things like vamps, demons, ghouls and so on is worth a +1.  It cannot be taken away, and that's a feature this game values.

Also, look at the way the catch is calculated for things weak to holy stuff.  These catches tend to be low values, suggesting that holy stuff is something only a vary rare class of people have access to.  Someone who has a faith, even one he strongly believes in, may not be able to produce holy stuff except under extraordinary circumstances (this being an aspect invocation).

And yes, Harry does use his faith to ward off vampires from time to time.  He always does so with his mother silver pentacle, which is why that is one of his aspects, I believe.  I would see him using it that way as an invocation of that aspect.

 This is a serviceable solution, but what I don't like about it is that there's no allowance for a character's Conviction.  Conviction is the skill that measures the strength of one's beliefs and, by the novels, that's supposed to mean something.  Having an Aspect related to your beliefs is always good, but it shouldn't be required to satisfy any Catch.

 So, how's this... in order to channel one's faith against a creature through a holy object, one must first place a maneuver upon the object using their Conviction as a supplemental action.  If successful, then the object may satisfy a creature's "holy stuff" Catch.  If not... then it's just another trinket and you better have a good Plan B.  A character with Superb Conviction (like Harry and most True Faith characters), will succeed almost every time.  On the other hand, a character with only Fair Conviction (checks book real quick... like Fix or Susan) would need a little bit of luck to succeed.  If you have merely Mediocre Conviction, then you'll need a really lucky roll to pull it off.  Does that sound reasonable?

Sure, its a passive ability, meaning they don't have to pay fate points (beyond the 1 fate point lost from refresh) to use it.  Thats why I'd say that not having a True Faith template would require you to invoke an aspect to get blessed weapons.  It would be easier to hand wave it for someone with a True Believer template but not Holy Touch, because thats what they've devoted their character to.  Having other characters just be able to do it without cost just makes it a cheap trick, and I'd really resent it if I played a True Believer in a campaign where everyone could do it without paying anything for it.  Maybe you don't have True Believer's in your group, so maybe you can convince your GM to house rule blessed weapons for people who have faith aspects.

 Eh, I just see the True Faith powers as a variant form of Sponsored Magic (or, in this case, Sponsored Powers), where the Will of the Almighty is expressed through them.  That's how things like Bless This House, Guide My Hand, and Righteousness work; you're borrowing some of the Almighty's mojo, which is why they cost Refresh (aka the sacrifice of your own free will) to acquire.  A strong, personal faith in something requires no higher power or even regular church attendance (in fact, Harry mentions this several times [most recently in Changes, p202]).  Or are you suggesting that Harry has a True Faith power?

My character already has the Aspect and I have few qualms about invoking it for effect, I just don't think it's necessary.  I mean, you don't need an Aspect/FP to bypass a Cold Iron catch or a Fire catch, right?  Why is Holy Stuff more special than those Catches?

Also, the sword would not be considered "holy stuff" for anyone but that swordsman (or, I suppose, his retired grandfather), due to the nature of the weapon and what it represents to him.  So, if another PC picked it up and used it, it would be just another Weapon:2 sword.  For an item to be inherently Holy, irregardless of the wielder's own faith, it would require some supernatural mojo (a la the Sword of the Cross).

This... still sounds like a supernatural power.

 It comes close, but no more so than Listening, Devout Words, or Finely Attuned Third Eye do.  IMO, at least.