Show Posts

This section allows you to view all posts made by this member. Note that you can only see posts made in areas you currently have access to.


Messages - SerScot

Pages: [1] 2 3 ... 25
1
Errmmm... where does Harry suggest this?

This honestly holds together with a startlingly-coherent throughline.
Peabody, in this line, isn't "Black Council" but an independent power-seeking wizard (possibly an Outsider pawn); but not part of the Black(Grey) Council.

Harry doesn’t.  I do,

2
DF Spoilers / Re: [12 Months Spoilers] Minor Detail Mid-Conversation
« on: February 25, 2026, 03:38:27 AM »
I don't have a copy of the text in front of me, so this is paraphrased.  If someone could find the exact text, it might be helpful.

Partway through Twelve Months, Harry has a conversation with Mab in his apartment in the castle.  In the midst of this conversation, Harry notes that Mab wanders over to one of his bookshelves and re-orders the books of the Chronicles of Narnia.  Neither he nor Mab note this verbally, and to my recollection, Harry doesn't return to this point later in the book at all.  What is going on here?

A few points to start:

1) I assume that Mab is adding information that was not previously present; that is, her actions are meaningful in that she is intending to communicate something.  She is not randomly tidying Harry's bookshelf--that would be both out of character* and too trivial to mention as part of the narration, unless you want to postulate that this is intended as a meta-hint that something is wrong with Mab.  I mention this last bit for completeness, not because I think it's plausible.

2) Narnia has two standard orderings: original publication order and internal chronological order.  I would assume that the books started in one of these orderings (interestingly, both orderings are "official" in different contexts--you can find different editions with the spines of the books numbered in either ordering).  If the new sequence contains extra information, the resulting order would have to be neither of these; I think going from one order to the other is too trivial to mean anything.

3) The clue could be a seven-digit number containing the digits 1-7 once each, as read from the spine of each book in the new order.  Perhaps a phone number?
http://
* In terms of Mab's character, I believe that her every action contains both intentional aid and the intentional infliction of pain.  In this case, both aid and pain would be quite minor (an obscure hint vs. the irritation of a disordered bookshelf), but both would exist.

The correct ordering of The Chronicles of Narnia is publication order.

3
DF Spoilers / Re: Where have the Black Council and the Grey Council gone?
« on: February 24, 2026, 05:17:09 PM »
This makes me wonder, again, if Harry was right on point.  That the “Grey Council” is really the “Black Council” coming to the fore.  That Eb is part of that and was looking for a way to bring Harry in.  Because the White is fundamentally and irreparably broken?

Maggie Sr. was raised and trained by Eb.  She had “Black Council” tendancies per Luccio.  What if she learned those tendencies from her father/master.  What if the “Black Council” isn’t “Black/Evil” at all?  We know Eb is willing to do the “wrong thing” if he believes the reasons behind it are just.  What if everything our unreliable narrator has told us… is wrong?

4
DF Spoilers / Will and Georgia’s child
« on: February 16, 2026, 07:49:34 PM »
Anyone think this child might have been conceived on Demonreach during the events of Turn Coat?  If so… will that impact the child?  How will it impact the child?

5
DF Spoilers / Where have the Black Council and the Grey Council gone?
« on: February 09, 2026, 04:21:44 PM »
Seriously?  Why no mention of either in this book?

6
Harry does say, I think in Changes, that dust on his summoning circle in his lab degrades its efficiency. In Changes he also creates a circle purely in his mind.

From this, I take it that intent and human will are close to 100% of the deal. Not quite, but very, very, close.

Doesn’t this mean it is impossible to “accidentally” break a circle?  Doesn’t this mean that “intention” is all a circle is?  That if you believe in a moving magical circle… and genuinely believe it exists and protects you, in the DV, it should do so?

7
DF Spoilers / Matter crossing a circle boundary… disrupts the circle
« on: January 14, 2026, 06:58:49 PM »
How does this operate?  Does it apply to any physical matter of any size crossing a circle boundary? 

If someone is talking to someone in a circle and spittle from their mouth crosses the circle boundary is the circle disrupted?  What about blowing air across a circle boundary does that disrupt a circle?  Circles obviously aren’t hermetically sealed as they are magically not physically boundaries. 

I’m sure intention and belief come into it.  But this is really confusing.  Why would accidental spit not disrupt but intentional spit would?  Is it the intention of the people inside or outside that controls entirely?

8
DF Spoilers / Re: List your top 5 Dresden files books
« on: January 08, 2026, 06:16:56 PM »
1 Changes
2 Dead Beat
3 Skin Game
4 Small Favor
5 Proven Guilty


9
DF Spoilers / Re: Does anyone think Harry isn’t the original Merlin?
« on: October 22, 2025, 12:43:24 AM »
So the island is the source of the leylines and provided the energy for the denarians to create the greater circle to contain Ivy. I would hazard a guess then that it provided the power for Merlin to set down spells/enchantments to create Demonreach. We know from another quote in Cold Days that the energy that keeps people away is the body heat put off by the prisoners. I wonder if it also has tainted the leylines/well. Rashid warned Harry not to touch the leylines. Was it because it was too much power for him to handle or potentially corrupting due to the prisoners?


In Cold Days Harry says to himself that “the well” for the leylines is the “bodyheat” of the prisoners contained in Demonreach.  That means the Leylines didn’t exist before the Prison did. 

Now, what is interesting is the idea of using the prisoners own power to keep them contained.

10
All that being said, as I am typing this, I realize that this prison was established by Merlin in the beginning days of the White Council. The White Council mapped the ley lines. It is possible that the prisoners are the original source of the ley line. Merlin could have created the prison and the ley line developed as the prisoners were added or he could have created the prison on top of an existing ley line and the prisoners supercharged it with their body heat.

It is called “the Well” because that is the “wellspring” of the leylines radiating from the Island.  I believe that is made explicit by Rashid when he confronts Harry in Turn Coat

11
Just you wait, it's only a matter of time until Harry defeats communism by making a giant statue of himself and butchers the evil pacifists.

What about the chickens who personify “evil”?

12
DF Spoilers / Re: Does anyone think Harry isn’t the original Merlin?
« on: April 17, 2025, 03:01:36 AM »
What if Merlin is a Mantle? And no not like the title in the White Council.... though in thinking that, maybe Merlin is a Mantle that was forgotten (on purpose or by accident) but though lore/history the White Councile adopted it a title.

Lord… I hope not.

13
DF Spoilers / Re: Do you think we'll see Elaine again?
« on: April 11, 2025, 07:17:05 PM »
Yes, we will see Elaine again.  It wouldn’t surprise me to see her in the next book.

14
DF Spoilers / Re: Does anyone think Harry isn’t the original Merlin?
« on: April 11, 2025, 07:16:02 PM »
I really think Harry… is… Merlin… we will see.

15
DF Spoilers / Does anyone think Harry isn’t the original Merlin?
« on: April 10, 2025, 12:35:32 AM »
Seriously.

Merlin is said to remember the future the way other man remember the past.  We know, given how Demonreach was created, that Merlin played with time… hard.  We also know Harry will at some point break the law against time travel.  We know Harry felt a kinship to Demonreach even before he claimed it… why is that?

It makes sense for Harry to… be… Merlin.

Pages: [1] 2 3 ... 25