Show Posts

This section allows you to view all posts made by this member. Note that you can only see posts made in areas you currently have access to.


Messages - Tinfoil hat

Pages: [1] 2 3 ... 10
1
DF Spoilers / Re: Marcone and the Castle
« on: Today at 07:40:59 AM »
My point is though, is apparently Marcone when he owned the castle either wasn't aware, or was unable to make use of Merlin's wards.  Odd in that he was hosting a fallen angel with top wizard skills.  I'd like to know how this particular castle was selected to be purchased and brought over here.
I think that marcone knew about the wards but was not yet ready to do what Harry could. Remember that Marcone most likely doesn't have the skills to pull this off. Not the knowledge Nam has the knowledge. Not sure of  their relationship and how much control Nam has over Marcone. The closest analogue I can think of is a person having an accident and having to relearn to walk. Marcone has to build up his skills and focus step by step in spite having the knowledge all ready.
Plus Marcone probably has to prioritize combat magic over the more subtle type of magic.

2
DF Spoilers / Re: Thresholds
« on: February 03, 2026, 08:03:42 PM »

  Maybe because Basil was in the sky and landing on a roof and not entering a door or window it isn't technically a threshold?  ??? ??? ???
Remember if you have no ill intent towards the household the threshold isn't a problem. Case in point the brownies ( Harry's cleaning service), Mab or lea or whoever fixed little Chicago. Basil had no ill intent towards Harry

3
DF Spoilers / Re: Thresholds
« on: February 03, 2026, 06:07:09 AM »
The castle does have a strong threshold cause of the number of people calling it home. Harry invited the blampires in the final fight. He worded it carefully in a way that the blampires may think it was a mistake ( I may be wrong on this one). But he definitely invited them in on purpose. He had home court advantage and he used it. He can shift parts of the castle so fighting them inside the castle was easier

4
DF Spoilers / Re: What about Etri? 12 Months
« on: February 02, 2026, 03:49:25 PM »
There is a problem with that though, and it's an inconsistency in the series.  Remember back in Blood Rites when Eb said he tried to kill Lord Raith and couldn't?  This was Blackstaff talking right?  Margaret was able to block Raith's feeding with her death curse, but she couldn't kill him with it.  Harry sensed the cold emptiness inside Lord Raith, he wanted very badly to kill him, but didn't try it because of what Eb had told him.. Fast forward to 12 Months and Eb tells Harry in effect that he chose not to kill Lord Raith? The point I am making is if the general knowlege was that Lord Raith couldn't be killed, that wouldn't satisfy Etri.  Plus, even at this point, though most know better, Lara is still the power behind the throne not the head of the White Court, and if Lord Raith was handed over, that would blow the court up politically and destabilize things more.

He did try, but his options were limited, his political power is limited, or was.   He did come up with a solution, getting that boon from Mab.

I doubt that, she had negotiated it with Etri ahead of time.  Because if it was last minute as you say, there was no gararantee that Etri would have accepted those terms.  She didn't set the price, Etri did.

I am not sure of what you are trying to say here.  1] Would the child even have been born? Did the Outsider want it to be born?  Remember the mid-wife in this case was actually Mother Summer, was that necessary?  If it was a normal birth, there were several people on sight that could have assisted.  The fact that Justine was still possessed by the Outsider meant that it took someone like Mother Summer to assist and keep the child safe during the birthing process.2] Yes, if there was no negotiated  settlement, Thomas surely would have been killed. 3] Why would Harry and Lara fight over the baby?  They are still on track to marry if Mab gets her way, and she usually does, they would just be foster parents.. 
Personally I don't think the baby could have been born any other way. You don't ask Mother Summer to be a mid wife if it's possible any other way. Either the Nemesis would have possessed the baby to use as an escape route or as a vector for possessing others.
2) the solution to Etri's demands
Finally hours of obsessing over a song of ice and fire, and history finally pay of.

Mab properly didn't discuss it with Etri beforehand but Etri conditions were clear a life for a life. Either Thomas or someone of his blood. The baby is of his blood. Giving your child as hostage or a price to your foes to ensure peace or as a weregild was not uncommon in past across multiple cultures.  Hell marrying Margie to Etri's son was not out of the question. Mab implies it although Harry sees it as a threat against Margie's life but I think this was what she was trying to get across. In the most Mab way possible.
Also Etri didn't have a choice in this situation. Someone had to be punished for the attempt on his life. Doing nothing makes him appear weak to both his allies and enemies. Even knowing about nemesis does not excuse Thomas. Thomas was not possessed he was forced to do it sure but he still did it of his own will even if under duress. He had to be punished and publicly at that. Etri taking his son is that. Then to show what a kind, noble , honourable and wise ruler he is to his people and other the baby has to be treated well to show that he is not driven by revenge and he can be a good Ally. Think Theon in asoiaf

5
Here be spoilers

Turn back Now


I'm serious
In the aftermath of PT and BG, a lot of Carlos hate was thrown around on this site and others, Carlos is blind, dump, should trust Harry etc, etc. In the post 12 Months discussion there is little being said about Carlos and Harry interactions ,and Eb and Harry's interactions.
Carlos turns out to be on good terms with Harry while hiding it from the WC. He shows up several times even helps in a fight or two. But here's the thing. Carlos claims WC intelligence is  2nd to none in the presence of Molly and Lara when discussing how to gather info on their enemies implying its comparable or better than winter court spy network,  the white court and mortal intelligence gathering. He isn't laughed out of the room.
Long tangent but hold on I'm getting to my point.
Eb says damn the Merlin for  kicking Harry while doing so in a way that Harry thinks Is leaving a lot of information out.
To my point Carlos is young and he already knows Harry is on the level. The SC has networks of info, spys and spirits they can use to gather information on just about anyone yet they still don't trust Harry. The rank and file I get but seriously the older members of the council should know better. Harry is practically attached to the knights of the swords and the swords themselves. He owns a temple dog if nothing else ancient Mai should be on his side.
 Is the SC council blind, dump or do they have something else planned because at this point their level of distrust for harry is
about to reach mission impossible levels of stupid. In the mission impossible movies series every movie the higher ups think Ethan has gone rogue hunt him then oops he was on our side repeat 8 times



6
DF Spoilers / Re: Continuity drift - Lara and soul gazes
« on: February 02, 2026, 02:28:21 PM »
The continuity here definitely bothered me, but I can see how it can be argued that she was playing Harry.

The main problem I had was that the soul gaze itself was a bit anticlimactic. The description of it was cool, but it seemed like in this Soul Gaze they both shared the same vision? Or maybe I misread it. And then it seemed like she didn't really have that much of a reaction (unless I totally missed it).

I was expecting a payoff from him saying bad A his previous reactions had been.
Lara seeming not to know what a soul gaze is leads to so many questions.
1) how open are wizards to telling people what it is? Is it public knowledge
2) and how much information is out there about it?
3) how accurate is the information? Do the wizards tell people they can't control what one sees and how it is triggered.
Lara should know what a soul gaze is. She experienced one. From a dolist reason Jim wanted to reintroduce the concept. From a watsonian reason Lara wanted more info about them

7
DF Spoilers / Re: List your top 5 Dresden files books
« on: December 21, 2025, 12:11:25 PM »
Can’t really pick favourites but these are some of what I feel are the best:

Changes
Skin Game
Turn Coat
Proven Guilty
Twelve Months 
12 months  already. Kkkkk
I see the law against time travel is more of a suggestion than a rule. Ps does the queen know you are here.

8
DF Spoilers / Re: List your top 5 Dresden files books
« on: November 03, 2025, 03:19:12 PM »
  I don't think of a favorite either;
Grave Peril
Dead Beat
Small Favor
Summer Knight
Turn Coat

Interesting, while RobReece did list Battle Ground, so far everyone have listed books pre-Changes, though some did include Changes.  Small sample to be sure, but I wonder if that says anything about either the writing, the setting for, or the stories post-Changes?
Lets wait for the sample size to be a bit larger before we draw any conclusions .
There is a book or 2 im waiting to see if they are on anyone's list

9
DF Spoilers / List your top 5 Dresden files books
« on: November 02, 2025, 07:51:39 PM »
I have seen several arguments about which is the Dresden file book/ personal favorite so
Just curious what you guys fav / top 5 Dresden files books. I will start
1)Turncoat
2) Changes
3)deadbeat
4) skin game
5) small favours
Bonus
6) white nights
Curious to see your lists



10
DF Spoilers / Books books everywhere
« on: October 14, 2025, 10:32:01 AM »
Just realised that physical books are important.  Over the last few years most of my books are online and while trying to recall something from the series noted that the books tend to bled into each other in my mind. Especially when i binge read. Like i started the files in 2020 and read them in a few days. Even my reread i tend to just binge read from one to the next. Am i the only this happens to.
Now to the point what plot point did you miss in the books during your first several read though that you cant believe you missed

11
DF Spoilers / Re: Out Law, novella (?)
« on: September 24, 2025, 07:59:35 AM »
I totally agree, those are my thoughts as well.  In that light if Marcone does decide to give up the coin, it will be a huge sacrifice for him.  Given that, it could lead to him becomming a Knight, but that all remains to be seen.
I agree with Nammy Marcone is at best extremely low level talent. But Jim has said that power increases with age. I think snake boy was a small power but thanks to the fallen and long live after centuries when he lost the coin he could still do some magic

12
DF Spoilers / Re: is Nicodemus Archleone *the* Nicodemus (from the Bible)?
« on: September 09, 2025, 07:13:24 AM »
My knowledge of the New Testament is limited, but I also remember that Nicodemus was the man who helped to take down Jesus from the Cross, I also think it was his tomb that they placed the body of Jesus in, but I could be wrong about that part. 

As for the  Pharisee who I believe was also rich who asked Jesus how to enter the Kingdom of Heaven?  Was answered I think with the famous "eye of a needle" quote.  Now it is possible that that was Nic, who got very upset about that and somewhere along the line became buds with Judas.  Nic's noose has never been explained, we all know about the most famous noose in history, the one that hung Judas.  So we keep on coming back to this point in history, also Judas was paid with thirty pieces of silver, there are thirty Denarians each trapped in presumedly one of those coins.
.
Biblical Nic was a pharise, ( teacher of the law) the intellectual class of the day. Jesus was uneducated but seemed to know more that the pharisees themselves. Biblical Nic became a believer. Nic on the other hand may have been from the time period but i doubt he was a big deal at the time

13
DF Spoilers / Re: Out Law, novella (?)
« on: September 06, 2025, 05:31:11 PM »
  I have a hunch that Marcone will need Harry.  I think Marcone will eventually regret his choice. 
My guess is that Marcone will have a case that breaks his rules but he cant act openly against the people responsible. So similar to the monster short he hires it out. Only this time harry is the only one available. Harry starts a war with Canada has Marcone feared he would in that story.  And Marcone ends up hating harry even more

14
DF Spoilers / Re: Murphy
« on: September 06, 2025, 05:26:00 PM »
Since she is dead, why would she need a health plan? 
Of course she does. Do you want to have any idea how much visiting the dentist when you're died would cost. Kkk
Uriel is no saint people....
He is an angel and a spy seems shady to me....
Having said that. Murphy was raised catholic, but is clearly not devout. Especially with what she has seen. The deal Mr sunshine probably offered was carefully worded to imply she would rest , wait for judgment, while stuff happened or she could go on fighting the good fight and wait for judgment. But Mr Sunshine was involved in this . One eye did not act alone on this

15
DF Spoilers / Re: Murphy
« on: August 30, 2025, 08:46:43 AM »
Or maybe Santa Claus is running a big con on Harry and she was faking it under his orders. I am, in retrospect, actually kinda surprised how things went down, with Murphy being a devout catholic. One would think Uriel would have something to say to Odin about taking someone who wielded one of the three swords as an Einherjar. Unless they both want Murphy to power up in preparation for what is coming down the line. Just saying.
Considering how big a deal free will Murphy had to be given a choice. Go in to the light, or join be Odin crew.
Does anyone one still have the quote about Odin having Soul fire. Im not sure but it seems to be used in the creation of einherjar and valkyries.

Pages: [1] 2 3 ... 10