Show Posts

This section allows you to view all posts made by this member. Note that you can only see posts made in areas you currently have access to.


Messages - KurtinStGeorge

Pages: 1 ... 37 38 [39] 40 41 ... 59
571
DF Spoilers / Re: Proven Guilty speculation, because, why not?
« on: June 26, 2019, 08:29:18 AM »
It appears to me that it, in fact, it almost did let Nemesis find it's happy space.

Do you mean by almost releasing nemfected Lea?  I don't think Mab would have allowed that to happen.

Dunno, man.

This quote seems to imply that the Ladies have out-smarted Mab on the "cunning manipulations" front.  Freaking MAB.

I'm not buying that.


Of course... given that Mab was apparently right there all along, hidden beside Lea, it's equally possible that the plan went off mostly as the Maeve&Lily wanted it to... which was, in most regards, ALSO mostly as Mab wanted it to.

You are both right and wrong at the same time.  The Ladies did not out-smart Mab.  In fact, you could say THEY didn't do anything, the Adversary did.  Poor Lily thought she was a becoming a real power player, when in fact she was just an easily manipulated puppet.  Maeve was pulling her strings and Maeve in turn was run by the Adversary.  Maeve's entire motivation was to screw over her Mom for past grievances, so she went along with the Adversary's plan.  If it had just been Maeve and Lily working together on their own I doubt they would have been much of a challenge for Mab to outmaneuver.   

I think it's only in Cold Days when Maeve put her own spin on the Adversary's orders by killing Lily in order to both remove her possible replacement and take Sarissa away from Mab.


572
DF Spoilers / Re: Proven Guilty speculation, because, why not?
« on: June 24, 2019, 08:45:01 AM »
I do not think it's reasonable to claim that faeries are the only beings capable of using illusion magic without detection.
Ok,who?

If the party doing the magic is someone who we didn't see in Proven Guilty, but we will learn about in a time travel story, a good candidate would be Mavra.  She's very good at veils.  We learned this from the way she took pictures of Murphy killing the Reinfield in Blood Rites.  She would have been within 10-15 feet from Harry and the Hellhound, and neither one of them had a clue.

Now Bob doesn't think Mavra is capable of creating a fine thrall; assuming that's what Sandra Marling was, someone who wouldn't even know they are a thrall, but what if Bob is wrong?  It wouldn't be the first time.

Another possibility; but one which too little is known to put together a detailed description of, is there is more than one party at work in Proven Guilty, maybe several.  Each could be acting for their own reasons.  For example, Mavra was trying to corrupt Molly, but Maeve was the one summoning the Fetches.  We already know there was a Denarian assault on Arctis Tor which probably took place sometime before events in the novel started, but it's why Mab was inside when Harry got there.  I'm not saying it was a Denarian a Splattercon, I'm just saying things are complicated to the point where a simple explanation, meaning a single actor was responsible, might not be the best one. 

573
DF Spoilers / Re: I think Murphy is going to get killed here is why
« on: June 19, 2019, 06:34:45 PM »
I've only commented in the early pages of this thread.  Has anyone thought of a counter argument to both the OP and the idea Karin Murphy will be completely sidelined because she will probably have a major role; perhaps the major role, to play in getting Harry out of his gig as the Winter Knight?  Before they went into the old meatpacking factory to meet Nicodemus, Murphy told Harry that she didn't believe there wasn't anyway other than death to get out of being the Winter Knight.  So that raises the question of how Harry could do that.

After Harry flash froze then blasted apart the Sidhe noble who gave him some lip at his birthday party at Arctis Tor, Mab commented, "No one has lifted a hand to them that way since the days of Tam Lin."  So who is this Tam Lin guy?  The wiki page about Tam Lin is somewhat sparse, but he has dealings with Mab; who sometimes is called Maeve and other odd spellings.  Eventually Tam is going to be sacrificed by the sidhe, but he is rescued by a mortal women who hides him; and there's some shapeshifting involved.  The main thing is that Tam is free from Mab and can go about seducing mortal maidens, which seemed to be his regular pastime.

My guess is there is probably more than one story about Tam Lin and Jim will adapt whatever he needs in order to tell his story, but I'd bet dollars to donuts Karin Murphy won't get completely put on the sidelines.

574
DF Spoilers / Re: Proven Guilty speculation, because, why not?
« on: June 18, 2019, 07:04:31 PM »
The only way we will see Maeve again is if Harry is involved in some time travel shenanigans.  However, Proven Guilty is exactly the book where that would seem a reasonable possibility, so your hypothesis may have some merit; but my guess is you've missed the mark by a wide margin.  Meaning, while I think that it's possible Maeve was involved in the events of PG, I don't think she was pretending to be Sandra Marling. 

Remember the amount of time and effort that was needed by Sandra Marling to set up Splattercon and to draw Molly into her sphere of influence.  Maeve was far too lazy to do either of those two things, but more than that she despised mortals and wouldn't lower herself to pretend to be one for any extended length of time, plus I seriously doubt she would have had the skill set needed to organize a human endeavour such as a Con; and finally, she had no reason to want to corrupt Molly.  Mavra or even the Denarians are better suspects for attempting to corrupt Molly.

To reiterate, it wouldn't shock me if we discover Maeve was working in the background during PG.  In a time travel story we might even be shown how Mab learned her daughter was nemfected.  Jim might do this to explain exactly what and why Mab did what she did, before and during PG.

575
DF Spoilers / Re: What is Harry Watching?
« on: June 18, 2019, 05:17:46 AM »

576
DF Spoilers / Re: Any news on Peace Talks
« on: June 17, 2019, 08:03:35 PM »
The denouement chapter will probably only take a couple to three days for Jim to knock out.

In two and a half weeks Jim will be in Utah for Spikecon or Westercon72.  (I think Westercon is part of Spikecon, but that's a minor detail.)  I will try to record any panels I go to where Jim is the sole speaker and try to make it to any other panels he is a part of.  I'll let everyone know when I can post to YouTube.  If Jim says something really interesting about Peace Talks or other upcoming DF books; beyond answering questions like "Why did you set the Dresden Files in Chicago", I'll create a thread here so we can discuss first.  For fans of the Cinder Spires, if Jim says anything interesting about that series I'll post it in that part of the forum.

I'm really glad Jim won't have to face any, "How much longer?" questions.  Now that I think about it, if Penguin doesn't announce a release by the July 4th weekend I'm sure someone will want to know when it will be released, even if Jim doesn't know.     

577
DF Spoilers / Re: Mirror-Mirror Cosmology Question
« on: June 16, 2019, 05:08:02 PM »
Quote
AKA - will MM world's lasciel also carry a huge grudge against Harry.

How do you know MM Harry won't be carrying her coin?  The way I see it, MM Harry has to be more dangerous than regular Harry.  This doesn't mean MM Harry can cast harder hitting spells, but he has has deadly arcane knowledge that regular Harry lacks.  In fact, knowing how to summon Harry's from alternate universes might be something MM Harry learned from Lasciel.   

578
DF Spoilers / Re: What is Harry Watching?
« on: June 16, 2019, 04:52:25 PM »
It's obvious Harry would watch the movies Snowpiercer, The Grey, Happy Feet, March of the Penguins and Smilla's Sense of Snow. (To name a few Winter-ish movies.)

579
DF Spoilers / Re: Any news on Peace Talks
« on: June 16, 2019, 04:28:09 PM »
It will soon be announced that just as Quentin Tarantino divided Kill Bill into parts 1 & 2, Peace Talks will be released in two parts.  Whether we will have to wait until after the second Cinder Spires book is released for Peace Talks part 2, is an open question.  ;D

580
I would love to hear a theory of the crime not using magic. Assuming that the police weren't too busy dealing with a Dark God wreaking havoc around the University.  Why Harry, Butters, Cassius and a 200 pound killing machine broke and entered the Field Museum.  How Cassius tortured Harry trying to steal a coin containing a fallen angel.  Why Cassius doesn't exist record wise.   

A prosecutor would ignore the magical elements and concentrate on the physical violence and corresponding evidence.  Also, neither Harry nor Butters could reasonably talk about magical side of the story unless Harry's public defender was going for an insanity defense.  Cassius not having a traceable record isn't a big deal either.  People can and have been prosecuted for killing a John or Jane Doe.

I suppose Harry's attorney could go for a diminished capacity defence (or maybe not), but that would be very iffy even if it was possible.  Essentially, the defense would be that Harry had been knocked unconscious and then physically tortured and both the concussion and other physical trauma rendered Harry incapable of having the intent to commit murder.  In other words Harry was acting irrationally not intentionally.  Obviously, Harry did intend to kill Cassius, I'm talking about what could be proven, not the actual events. 

The reason this is a very iffy defense is because the defendant is openly admitting they did the deed and it's not the same thing or as potentially solid as an insanity defense.  Plus, in many jurisdictions it's been abolished as a defense so if that is the case in Illinois Harry's lawyer couldn't even try to use it.  I know of a case maybe ten to fifteen years ago where an individual was assaulted in their own home; beaten and knocked unconscious by robbers, but came to while his home was still being ransacked.  He retrieved a gun and confronted both men and shot one man dead when the robber came right at him.  He was not prosecuted for that killing.  It was decided that killing was (probably) in self defence.  He was tried and convicted for shooting and killing the second man.  That man ran the other way and out the front door into the street.  The home owner chased him down the sidewalk and shot him multiple times in the back.  Saying the homeowner suffered a concussion wasn't good enough to demonstrate he didn't have the intent to commit murder.  If I recall the jury had several options for conviction, so the defendant wasn't convicted of first degree murder.  I think they settled on first degree manslaughter, which still carries a very stiff penalty.       

581
DF Spoilers / Re: Any news on Peace Talks
« on: June 16, 2019, 06:24:41 AM »
Chapter 65!

582
DF Spoilers / Re: What does the White Council Do?
« on: June 13, 2019, 07:06:14 PM »
I'm not certain we can say the White Council is very strong in North America.  They have four wardens and Harry hasn't been doing his job as such for a couple of years.  They almost certainly don't have much of a presence in Mexico as the more southern parts of Mexico were Red Court territory.

As far as training goes, it wasn't clear when Harry was at Luccio's bootcamp if any of the apprentices had a specific teacher.  Could the White Council have taken on the role of teacher to a large number of students rather than relying on the old system of individual teacher and student pairs?

583
DF Spoilers / Re: Cowl Unmasked!
« on: June 12, 2019, 11:57:10 PM »
Cowl may be, or once might have been, a member of the White Council.  For example, one hypothesis is that Cowl is the presumed deceased Senior Council member Simon Petrovich which would explain why I said Cowl might have been a member of the White Council.  If that is the case, or if Cowl is any other presumed dead member of the Council then Harry won't have the opportunity to meet Cowl at a meeting of current White Council members.

We know very little about Kumori other than she was on a quest to defeat death, the time when she had a one on one conversation with Harry, as part of their truce she took off some kind of bracelet or glove (I forget what the item was, I sure someone can find a description in Dead Beat.) and she was working for, and studying necromancy under Cowl.  I believe Kumori studied with Cowl for some time, that she wasn't a recent recruit, because she was quite certain that Cowl had survived many death curses before.  I don't think you don't can gain that kind of certainty unless you've seen it demonstrated repeatedly.  One more thing, the EMT Lamarr said Kumori is white.  He would have seen her hands and probably part of her forearms when she did her holding off death trick with one of Marcone's goons who was shot.
 
Of course one early and persistent hypothesis is that Kumori is in actuality Elaine.  While not unproven I think Elaine is something of a red herring as far as Kumori goes, but even if I am correct, Kumori could be in a similar position vis a vis the White Council as Elaine is.  She might not be a member of the White Council.  Like Elaine, Kumori may have kept her abilities a secret.  In fact I think that's likely or Kumori probably would have been recruited to fight the Red Court.

Harry may presume that Kumori is dead, seeing as Cowl was apparently injured by the Dark Hallow blowing up in his face and Cowl was probably much stronger than Kumori.   I think Kumori bailed out and opened a way to escape before the backlash occurred, but currently Harry has no reason to suspect that's the case.  Harry was too busy at the time to notice and even Bob presumed Kumori was blasted into atoms. 

So what does that leave us with?  Well, we have an idea of how tall Cowl is.  We know he was badly injured, but the last time Harry saw Cowl was how long ago?  How far back are the events in White Night?  That wizard healing thing means Cowl might not look quite as beat up as he did in the Raith's Deep.  Finally, we know the command word that Cowl used when he threw power at Harry, "Garoosh!"  Harry also got  a feeling for Cowl's magic.  Like Harry's it was touched with darkness, but not blatantly corrupt.  I think those last two items are the most important ones.  If he meets someone he doesn't know is Cowl, Harry should recognize the use of an identical command word and the feeling of Cowl's magic.

With Kumori, I think she made a big mistake allowing Harry to see the item she removed from her hand or wrist .  If Harry sees that item again it should be a huge clue for him.  Of course knowing Harry it will take him half a dozen or more chapters to put two and two together.         

584
DF Spoilers / Re: Malcolm's murder
« on: June 09, 2019, 07:58:36 AM »
@KurtinStGeorge & morriswalters
My only issue with this scenario is why Lea would view Justin as the right person to teach Harry? He was never known as a teacher - no other former apprentices are mentioned (aside from Elaine). Additionally there is strong evidence that he was walking on the left-hand path - witnessed by his keeping Bob & likely summoning HWWB to track Harry after his thralling attempt fails. Sure, Lea could’ve been wrong, but I believe Harry says in GS that Lea had always kept an eye over him even when he was younger, so wouldn’t she be keeping a very close eye on what all Justin is upto?

I think it much more likely that Justin & Simon (so Cowl) got some knowledge (perhaps because he & Maggie were ‘friendly’ or through a demon like Chauncey) that there were 2 Starborns in mundane orphanages around the country ripe for the plucking. His goal seems to have been to round them up, train them, emotionally manipulate them & then enthrall them into his personal service.

I’m also a little unsure of why Lea thinks Harry can go back & defeat Justin as a 16 year old.

It doesn't matter if Justin had or hadn't had an apprentice before.  He was a wizard who both had the knowledge and the motivation to teach Harry to use his magic.  Also, it's probably not a situation where Lea had several candidates to choose from. 

If Lea was a passive observer and not the murderer, at some point in time she became aware of Justin's plans and made a decision not to intervene.  If Lea is the killer then she met with Justin to make a deal with him.  In either scenario Lea already knew Justin or knew something about him from before this time because Justin had been a one time associate of Maggie Sr.  Also, remember the conversation Lea had with Harry about Justin in Ghost Story?  Lea didn't know the specifics of how Harry first met and defeated HWWB, but she knew Justin DuMorne and had very specific opinions about him.  This indicates Lea had enough knowledge about Justin to make a reasoned decision about his fitness to teach Harry, and probably enough knowledge to guess doing so would give Lea an opportunity to take complete control of Harry in the future.   

Your last statement is a very astute.  It is odd that Lea was confident that an inexperienced 16 year old Harry could defeat his teacher.  Then again, we really don't know how it all went down.  Could Lea have done something to hamstring Justin or even just distract him at the right moment?  I'm going to have to stick a pin in that idea for now.  I need to think about it some more, but I do have one thought to add.  Lea wanted to know about Harry's fight with HWWB, but she didn't ask about Harry's fight with Justin.  I'll bet she saw the battle from start to finish.

585
I'm late to this discussion, so if someone has already mentioned this incident, I apologize, but it seems to me there is one time when Harry withholding information has led to someone getting hurt and it's in Storm Front and it's not Linda Randall.

Quote
"Don't make me choose, Harry." Her voice softened, if not her eyes or her face. "Please."

I thought about it. I could bring everything to her. That's what she was asking - not half the story, not part of the information. She wanted it all. She wanted all the pieces in front of her so she could puzzle them together and bring the bad guys in. She didn't want to work the puzzle knowing that I was keeping some of the pieces in my pocket.

What could it hurt? Linda Randall had called me earlier that evening. She had planned on coming to me, to talk to me. She was going to give me some information and someone had shut her up before she could.

I saw two problems with telling Murphy that. One, she would start thinking like a cop. It would not be hard to find out that Linda wasn't exactly a high-fidelity piece of equipment. That she had numerous lovers on both sides of the fence. What if she and I were closer than I was admitting? What if I'd used magic to kill her lovers in a fit of jealous rage and then waited for another storm to kill her, too? It sounded plausible, workable, a crime of passion - Murphy had to know that the DA would have a hell of a time proving magic as a murder weapon, but if it had been a gun instead, it would have flown.

The second problem, and the one that worried me a lot more, was that there were already three people dead. And if I hadn't gotten lucky and creative, there would have been two more dead people, back at my apartment. I still didn't know who the bad guy was. Telling Murphy what little more I knew wouldn't give her any helpful information. It would only make her ask more questions, and she wanted answers.

If the voice in the shadows knew that Murphy was heading the investigation to find him, and was on the right track, he would have no qualms about killing her, too. And there was nothing she could do to protect herself against it. She might have been formidable to your average criminal, but all the aikido in the world wouldn't do her any good against a demon.

Then, too, there was the White Council. Men like Morgan and his superiors, secure in their own power, arrogant and considering themselves above the authority of any laws but their own, wouldn't hesitate to remove one police lieutenant who had discovered the secret world of the White Council.

I looked at the bloodstained sheets and thought of Linda's corpse. I thought of Murphy's office, and what it would look like with her sprawled on the floor, her heart torn from her chest, or her throat torn out by some creeping thing from beyond.

"Sorry, Murph," I said. My voice came out in a rasping whisper. "I wish I could help you. I don't know anything useful." I didn't try to look up at her, and I didn't try to hide that I was lying.

So Harry trying to protect Murphy led to her treating him as a suspect.  It led to Murphy searching Harry's office because she didn't have the information she needed and I'm certain you will all remember, it led to Murphy getting stung by Victor Sells ever growing scorpion construct or demon.  (Whatever it was.)

Now it could be argued that Murphy sometimes makes questionable to bad decisions, but I see that more in Fool Moon than in Storm Front.  Murphy's view of supernatural world in Storm Front is like someone looking through a keyhole rather than a nice large window and Harry tries to keep it that way; and though Harry does it mostly to protect Murphy, it backfires instead.

Pages: 1 ... 37 38 [39] 40 41 ... 59