The appropriate cost of the True Emotion Catches is something of a hotly debated topic on these boards.



A few points that might support it's +0 value:

True Emotion is difficult to maintain for significant durations (the largest contributor to the duration of Harry's protection by way of True Love was his horrible facility with women preventing him from having an opportunity to 'get back on the horse'), so even if a substantial portion of humanity experiences it at some point in their lives, only a small portion would have experienced it recently enough to be protected by it

True Emotion (and particularly non-violent emotion) is incredibly difficult to weaponize (making this Catch more useful as a source of Compels than as a way of bypassing any Toughness powers, and Compels are cost-neutral)

True Emotion is even more incredibly difficult to verify (without the involvement of an entity for whom it serves as a Catch) than it is to weaponize, so not only do you have to discover that your target is vulnerable to True Love, but you also have to discover which of those decades-old bands of gold alloy (or whatever) actually serves as a symbol of True Love

It completely and totally makes sense that True Love is one of those things that only a few people have access too. Thomas and Justine, and that one wedding ring that Laura burned herself on are the only examples, so three of them, just as rare as Swords of the Cross. But that doesn't cover the notability portion of it. I would be floored if Harry hadn't informed Paranet, and even more surprised if it wasn't learnable through dedicated and careful research. So it should qualify for a +1 or +2.

In the context of the universe, only Bob and the White Court seemed to know the catch or really how the Whampires worked.  That is, it requires personally knowing a WCV.  Remember, in the novels, Harry is very close with the WCVs and his intimate level of knowledge is rather rare amongst other wizards.  I don't think it's something you can just go look up.  I know this book is technically cannon, but I don't treat it as such in my game.  Too meta.

I think one of the Red Court new about it. (Short story.) And Harry has played a big role in Paranet so he should have distributed it to Paranet.

(click to show/hide)

"holy crap this guy is full of bat monster"

.

No matter what the personality is you need to make sure there is an actual conflict. Suppose the co-pilot a friendly spirit of goodness, and it wins. After it helps your friends it goes directly to charging the local red court base. Maybe you get captured. Maybe you start a war. Maybe it succeeds and the red court hates you now. Oh, and you gave all your stuff to charity. Regardless being taken out is bad.

If it was a sudden reveal I suspect you'd be correct - though that time of chaos could be an interesting setting.  Is a "big reveal" the only option?  For that matter, you make a case for those in power being aware of it since the Inquisition...wouldn't that lessen the impact of a public reveal?

I've always thought the way to do it, would be too many of the big boiling over actions have happened. Zombies running through Chicago, the Nevernever wall increasing ghost activity, the general boiling over of magical conflict and slowly everyone knows. Of course, everyone shuts their mouth so they don't go to the funny farm. Then, someone goes on T.V. and yells: "the king monsters have no clothes secrecy." And then everyone pulls out their supersoakers filled with holy water/iron-salts, bloody hula-hoops (instant circle)  and blessed Molotov cocktails, and its open season on baddies. The big reveal isn't telling people about the supernatural world, the big reveal is telling people everyone knows already.

I'm not sure magic is repeatable enough for an 'industrial' revolution.  The WC uses widespread publication to make spells powerless.  That alone might drive a need to keep your spells secret.

Those are specific rituals. Those can't be industrialized, nor improved. They aren't human magic anyway. But there are other ways to revolutionize magic. Start mass harnessing the emotional power of humans. Make sure all slaughtered animals have their life extracted. Train anyone who can learn magic (like random college kids). Also of import using magic affects if your kids have magic. If the idea that being able to sense magic is what lets people be wizards, give them a weaker three eye, and you have artificial wizards. Also I'm pretty sure that drawing on external power sources heavily helps you build magical muscle: I think Victor Sells did that to be stronger than Harry for example.

I'm going to guess magical arms race. Especially since there are all most certainly ways to build up the mortal magical power base if one tried. Also while insane necromancers won't preform their ascension rituals on a desert island, a lot of the nicer governments would certainly try. The industrial revolution would happen to magic. I don't see anything good coming of this.

An alternate point of view: any wizard who did the sorts of things described above (mind-controlling cops, replacing them with duplicates, committing mass-murder via wards, deliberately hexing helicopters in flight. etc) would become White Council Enemy #1 so fast that he wouldn't be able to say "Oops" before his entire body was diced into bite-sized chunks, let alone his head lopped off.

Mind Controlling and the Hexing in flight copters would get his head chopped off. Reflecting attacks is a standard White Council trick. Remember Harry was planning on doing this with a lethal spell. And killing people is a-okay with the White Council as long as you don't break the first law. Recall how Binder was going to call up his boys and kill his way out of jail? I suppose the Council might get pissed, but they haven't stopped Binder.

Somehow I missed the part where the wizard escaped from jail.

He's a wizard, he can turn into a cloud of gas and slip through the wall, or portal out in the Nevernever. Or pull a Binder and kill his way out.

And where he transformed himself so he wouldn't traced under the 'armed and extremely dangerous" bulletin - the sort of want that can someone shot because he kind of looks like the guy they're looking for.

If he had to escape from jail and leave a doppelganger behind they don't know he's gone.

If you want wizards to be supermen in your game, that's fine.  That's not how they are in the DV, where the White Council ensures they don't mettle too much with mortal governments.  Where the supernaturals fear that the next inquisition could happen - one where everyone accepts whatever the government says they have to do in order to keep the nation safe from the monsters.

Dresden, a wizard, has spent time in lock up.  He hasn't been able to do any of the things you suggest - possibly he isn't capable of doing it or possibly his moral code won't let him.  Which is why Rudolf's still walking around.

Binder was just going to kill his way out of jail if he wasn't set free. Not only that he expected Dresden to know exactly what would happen. And I don't recall Dresden ever being in jail for more than a day.