Show Posts

This section allows you to view all posts made by this member. Note that you can only see posts made in areas you currently have access to.


Messages - Snark Knight

Pages: 1 [2] 3 4 ... 78
16
DF Spoilers / Re: Whose the backup plan for...? - Battle Ground Spoiler
« on: October 26, 2024, 01:00:54 AM »
The stain left by HWWB might be very disturbing for a wizard to look upon and if Morgan had ever used his Sight on Harry before, this would explain why he wouldn’t want to do so again.

The residue of the walker certainly seemed to make an impression when the ThreeEye addict looked at him all the way back in SF.

I've also wondered for quite a while about a connection between wizards looking at each other with the sight and a soulgaze shared between wizards and mortals.  Seeing the walker's residue would contribute to the running away screaming or psychotic breaks from some of the mortals who have looked Harry in the eye.  Sure, he's powerful and somewhat prone to a temper, but agent Denton thought he saw actual Hell in Harry all the way back in the second book, when he hadn't really done anything all that disturbing other than (probably) kill Justin in a fair fight.  But if Denton got a conduit to looking at the Outside?  That would do it.

17
DF Spoilers / Re: Whose the backup plan for...? - Battle Ground Spoiler
« on: October 24, 2024, 06:13:16 PM »
If Listen is still alive, which seems doubtful after Harry buried him under a wall of dirt, he might be a candidate, but I'm just not feeling it.

Listen is a cockroach. Unless the body is seen on page, assume he's going to continue causing trouble.

I doubt he'd be amenable to switching to team Mab, though.

18
Yet Elaine seems to know about about the White Council, where is she getting her information?

That much is explicable by her making low-powered contacts pretty quickly after leaving Aurora's protecting ... she probably heard about the Council being a bunch of trigger-happy Inspector Javerts from the forerunners of the paranet.

The wizard the Council should *really* be afraid of is Simon Pietrovich having faked his death to become Cowl, though.  Elaine is just the apprentice.

19
DF Spoilers / Re: Has Carlos sided with the merlin against Harry
« on: October 18, 2024, 05:12:41 PM »
Jim stated that Drakul thought that Kemmler's behavior was amusing, something that was funny.  While that gives us a clue just how twisted Drakul is, I think it also tells us that he didn't rate Kemmler that highly.  Kemmler was a very dangerous person, but even though things like setting up World War One was supposedly one of his projects, I suspect the mad necromancer was somewhat random in his depravity.  Beings like Nemesis and Drakul rank higher on the bad news scale because they have a plan.       

I'm still a bit confused what to make of that bit, given we know from DB that Kemmler's research interests included "how to use necromancy against the black court".  Looking for weaknesses in his elite personal guard seems like the kind of thing Drakul would find pretty far from amusing.

Unless the WOJ meant Drakul found Kemmler's earlier career with the world wars and stuff funny, until he crossed a line in his final publication?  The timing seems awfully coincidental that the Council had been after him for the best part of a century and only got him for good shortly after he published the one thing that might have genuinely pissed Drakul off.  I wonder if Drakul took a page from the Stokerlypse and exploited the council into being his mob to burn down Kemmler and purge (almost) all the copies of his last book.

20
  LOL!  I agree, the worst thing he finds out about Lara is she is a strict vegetarian! :o

Eh ... somebody probably needs to point out to Harry that if you're planning for a lifespan in the centuries, you probably don't want your arteries clogged for the back 80% of that life expectancy.

21
Also, I keep forgetting to answer the titular question, every time I come into this thread.
I keep getting side-tracked by all y'all's interesting ideas!

Alright, we're all thinking it, I'll say it.

Harry takes Lara to dinner ... at Burger King.  Diplomatic incident ensues.

22
Agree about Mab's characterization. She was also much more cruel in Summer Knight. I think Jim decided to change his alignment from legal evil to legal neutral.

Nearly freezing Harry's eyeballs in SmF was pretty cruel too.

I'm not sure if her characterization change was organically done on the fly, or a planned shift based on how the narrator is also changing.

23
I think the most likely partner for Summer is the Svartalfs.  Wizards and the Fae don’t really trust one another so I don’t think the White Council would make a good candidate, though I’ve been wrong before.  The Swartalfs probably suspect that Lara Raith had something to do with Thomas Raith’s escape from the dungeon in what was formerly Marcone’s castle and of course they are right about that.  The Svartalfs still have a score to settle with Thomas and they may suspect that Harry has found a magical way to shield Thomas.  The Swaretalfs are normally a very insular people but circumstances might make them rethink their normal policy of remaining aloof.

The svartalfs didn't seem like they held any grudge against Harry for Thomas' extrication at the conference at the end of BG.  Their high lady word-gamed some support for Harry's play to claim the castle from Marcone when she didn't particularly have to.  They're smart, they must have figured out in retrospect that Harry and Lara being out of the conference room when Thomas was taken was a Clue - I'd guess they figured that any help Harry gave was probably owed under an obligation.

Titania and Langtry do have hating Harry's guts in common, though, and Langtry isn't so rigidly honorable as the svartalfs.  That teamup therefore seems like a good way for Jim to torment his protagonist.

24
   There still is the issue of "true love" to get around.  Was what Harry and Murphy had true love?  And if is was, is Harry still protected?

He accidentally burned Lara when they brushed into skin contact while busting Thomas out of the cell.  It definitely was true love.  (Also, despite a distractingly painful burn, Lara figures out right away it must have been Karrin and seems genuinely approving for them to have found a healthy relationship.  First time through, it reads like irony that the monster understands and reacts much more positively than Harry's supposed friends. Second reading ... yeah, I feel a bit dumb for not seeing that for the foreshadowing it was).

Uncertain if that protection survived Karrin's death, but I tend to think it would for as long as he's heavily occupied by mourning.

25
DF Spoilers / Re: Harry being a detective again
« on: August 23, 2024, 02:07:17 PM »
Actually, the last time Harry was a detective was in The Law. It's not a super tough mystery, but it is more in line with real life PI work.

Jury Duty was also pretty recent, if we're counting short stories.  Sure, Marcone didn't explicitly hire him to take it as a case ... but he maneuvered Harry onto the jury and counted on Harry being Harry to figure out the case wasn't what it looked like and start his own investigation.

26
DF Spoilers / Re: Warden Survival Rate and Current Strength?
« on: August 05, 2024, 06:30:30 PM »
I don't think we know, neither by canon mention nor by WoJ from events.

The WC was certainly recruiting/training them up thru the final Chichen Itza battle, & I preume the training didn't stop instantly; as the Fomor and other "new" threats emerged, the WC might even have decided to keep their wartime training levels going.

But... we just don't know.

I'd be surprised if the narrator actually knows either.

Even after Rashid vouched for him being back alive and himself to the Council, Mab had him almost totally incommunicado on the island for CD-SG.  For the few months he was back on land for SG-PT, Langtry was probably leaning on the wardens to limit Harry's access to new classified information while the expulsion vote was brewing. If you're kicking Harry out for being in a conflict of interest for swearing to Winter, you probably don't want him leaving with a head full of fresh Council secrets like Warden force levels, personnel files, etc.

27
DF Spoilers / Re: Have there been any . . .
« on: June 06, 2024, 05:49:57 PM »
Does it, though?
I think "balance" is one of the critical elements upheld by both Courts.

It's strict for the mantles.  Less so elsewhere.  Like I said in the earlier point, how do you exactly balance Eldest Malk or Eldest Fetch compared to the Eldest of some of the Summer-affiliated Fae subspecies?  They have inherently different powers and roles in their nations.

I think the reason a little more flexibility is allowed other than in the mantled roles is that Winter just allocates its overall surplus to the Gates.  Even if there isn't a 1:1 counterpart for every single role, they can maintain an aggregate balance with Summer by shuffling forces between Gate duty and the home guard.  Letting Lea be strong enough to cover for her in shifts at the Gates is a big part of why Mab allows her to be as strong as she is.

28
DF Spoilers / Re: Have there been any . . .
« on: June 06, 2024, 02:18:13 PM »
Lea is interesting.  Lea is the most powerful member of the Winter Court after Mab.  So more powerful than the Winter Lady, but not in the line of succession.  Also, for every other high member of the Winter Court, there appears to be a counterpart in Summer.  Except Lea, as far as revealed.  Why no Summer counterpart?  Is Lea truly something different/special hiding in plain sight?

There isn't an exact 1:1 in every role. For one thing, there's the position of Eldest of all the Fae species other than Sidhe for which the particular species follows one court or the other rather than being split.  Eldest Gruff is probably the closest parallel to Lea that we've seen on page in Summer, being a powerful magic user and confidante of the Queen, but that's far from an exact parallel. 

But a lot of Lea's personal power isn't from handmaiden of the queen being a mantle of Winter. It's power she's accumulated over the centuries by making deals with mortals like Maggie Sr that were skewed in her favour, slowly making her stronger and stronger. That significantly takes away from the obligation for Summer to have an exact balancing parallel.

29
DF Spoilers / Re: Twelve Months - What our you expecting from it?
« on: May 24, 2024, 03:10:18 PM »
  • As you said KSG, The Librum Bellum aka Men in Black aka the Librarians presence will be there, probably subtly. I suspect we may even meet one of their agents. A new, highly dangerous threat. Even Vadderung was wary of them. A lot of what Harry does in the book (hopefully helping people) will be noticed, but also some of the more destructive stuff. ... Was it one of their agents in Dog men?

That's a question that's bothered me for a while.  Because the Librarians are supposed to be highly secretive, and particularly cautious of Harry in part because he publicly advertises, and also because of his propensity for destruction.  I recall a WoJ that the main reason the Librarians never reached out to Karrin was that she was considered suspicious for being a known associate of the wizard.

The feds in the Dog Men comic weren't exactly enthusiastic to cooperate with Harry, but they weren't super shy of letting him know they were aware of the supernatural in general and specifically of him, either.  It's been a while since I read that one, but I don't think they came across as being as impressively prepared / capable as I'd have expected from the Librarians, either.

So are there two branches of clued feds?  The Librarians in the background being super cautious, and the more goonish branch doing more open field work?  Either independently, or directed from the shadows by the Librarians, as pawns that known just enough to do their missions, but not enough to compromise the Librarians if something happens to them?

I wouldn't be surprised if they try to get Tilly working for them, but probably not trusted at too high a level, as making their Chicago presence someone who more or less already trusted Harry would make it a bit too easy for him.

30
Cinder Spires Spoilers / Re: Olympian Affair (Spoilers All)
« on: December 01, 2023, 12:53:36 AM »
I'm pretty sure the fantheory(theories) linking Alera and/or Dresden and/or CS has been explicitly denied by Jim. 

Ish. He said something like a denial but it could have been read as a sarcastic "oh, I'd neeever have a common thread running between my series". 

Pages: 1 [2] 3 4 ... 78