ParanetOnline

The Dresden Files => DF Spoilers => Topic started by: Con on March 24, 2020, 02:58:11 PM

Title: Peace Talks Trailer.
Post by: Con on March 24, 2020, 02:58:11 PM
Damn that was better than I was expecting.

First Question

(click to show/hide)

Second question

(click to show/hide)

Third Question

(click to show/hide)
Title: Re: Peace Talks Trailer.
Post by: Frielove on March 24, 2020, 03:41:06 PM
My guesses:

1:
(click to show/hide)

2:
(click to show/hide)

3: I have no guesses about this.
Title: Re: Peace Talks Trailer.
Post by: Mira on March 24, 2020, 04:12:08 PM
(click to show/hide)
Title: Re: Peace Talks Trailer.
Post by: didymos on March 24, 2020, 04:22:54 PM
(click to show/hide)

(click to show/hide)
Title: Re: Peace Talks Trailer.
Post by: Mr. Death on March 24, 2020, 04:34:18 PM
(click to show/hide)
Title: Re: Peace Talks Trailer.
Post by: Avernite on March 24, 2020, 05:25:37 PM
Ok then, seems we're doing it this way :)

(click to show/hide)
Title: Re: Peace Talks Trailer.
Post by: Arjan on March 24, 2020, 05:39:30 PM
(click to show/hide)
Title: Re: Peace Talks Trailer.
Post by: KurtinStGeorge on March 24, 2020, 05:57:39 PM
My guess about:
(click to show/hide)

(click to show/hide)
 
Title: Re: Peace Talks Trailer.
Post by: Mira on March 24, 2020, 06:28:53 PM
My guess about:
(click to show/hide)

(click to show/hide)


(click to show/hide)
Title: Re: Peace Talks Trailer.
Post by: magnuskn on March 24, 2020, 09:04:32 PM
(click to show/hide)
Title: Re: Peace Talks Trailer.
Post by: Bad Alias on March 24, 2020, 09:32:55 PM
(click to show/hide)
Title: Re: Peace Talks Trailer.
Post by: Wolfeyes on March 24, 2020, 09:42:12 PM
(click to show/hide)
Title: Re: Peace Talks Trailer.
Post by: Mira on March 24, 2020, 09:49:07 PM
(click to show/hide)

(click to show/hide)
Title: Re: Peace Talks Trailer.
Post by: KurtinStGeorge on March 24, 2020, 09:50:34 PM
(click to show/hide)

(click to show/hide)

I'm not going to spoilerize (That's a new word I just made up.) this next part.  Some scenes in the trailer are from Battle Ground.

From the Q&A with Jim and Priscilla, if you look at the 35 second mark of the trailer; which shows many of the characters at the Peace Talks, Mr. Ferro is standing on the left with an unlit cigarette but smoke coming out of his nose, Warden Ramirez, Eb and Warden Chandler are standing on the right, Mab is standing center stage, Molly is sitting on the left, next to her in Ivana; a svartalf who was in a short story with Molly and Thomas, on the right sitting down is Marcone and next to him is Lara Raith.   
Title: Re: Peace Talks Trailer.
Post by: Dina on March 24, 2020, 11:46:58 PM
Well, I just saw the trailer. I will confess that I am not very impressed
(click to show/hide)

Specific comment:
(click to show/hide)
Title: Re: Peace Talks Trailer.
Post by: Bad Alias on March 25, 2020, 01:00:46 AM
I've been on the good ship S.S. Elaine for a long time. I freely admit that ship seems to be sinking fast. Can we knock off the spoilerizing? If someone's gotten this far down the thread, they've likely read everything or stopped.
Title: Re: Peace Talks Trailer.
Post by: Yuillegan on March 25, 2020, 01:02:06 AM
Okay, so a few things.

(click to show/hide)

Arjan - Why must the assassin be Kincaid? There are several assassins in the books so far, why him?

I am not sure True Love is a protection against WCVs. More like being in love with someone...I know it is semantics but I think the point is that it doesn't have to be your one and only soulmate.

KurtinStGeorge -
(click to show/hide)

Dina -
It's fair not to like it, but to be unimpressed is just odd. It wasn't meant to be Hollywood-level. Either your expectations are unrealistically high, or you are unreasonably critical. It's meant to simply generate interest and give some fan service. Like a youtube fan film etc. I think production wise it was actually pretty good - and I have been involved in Film on and off for many years now. There were lots of nice touches with editing to conceal some Easter Eggs, and while the casting might not be to everyone's taste, they worked with what they had. Not bad really. I think after putting in so much time and effort and passion, it's more than a little disheartening for the creators and a bit ridiculous and churlish of you to be negative - especially in these difficult times.

Title: Re: Peace Talks Trailer.
Post by: Snark Knight on March 25, 2020, 01:09:12 AM
(click to show/hide)

(click to show/hide)

As for the trailer itself, it was fine. I wish the Q&A had fielded more of the general questions than being mostly about the trailer though.
Title: Re: Peace Talks Trailer.
Post by: Dina on March 25, 2020, 01:19:03 AM
Dina -
It's fair not to like it, but to be unimpressed is just odd. It wasn't meant to be Hollywood-level. Either your expectations are unrealistically high, or you are unreasonably critical. It's meant to simply generate interest and give some fan service. Like a youtube fan film etc. I think production wise it was actually pretty good - and I have been involved in Film on and off for many years now. There were lots of nice touches with editing to conceal some Easter Eggs, and while the casting might not be to everyone's taste, they worked with what they had. Not bad really. I think after putting in so much time and effort and passion, it's more than a little disheartening for the creators and a bit ridiculous and churlish of you to be negative - especially in these difficult times.

Wow! Ridiculous and churlish (a word I don't know, actually)? And a low hit on top of that? Sorry, you can make me feel bad all what you want, I may go to a corner to hide and cry, but even if I wanted, I cannot change what I've felt when I watched it. I tried not to be aggressive or offensive, seriously. I thought this is a place where we were allowed to say our feelings, without offending anyone. That is what I tried to do. And your answer really surprised me.

But if you think the people involved may have read what I wrote, I will add: I loved the FX, and the care they put in make-up, clothing and hair dressing. It is obvious there is a lot of work involved.
Title: Re: Peace Talks Trailer.
Post by: Bad Alias on March 25, 2020, 01:34:01 AM
(click to show/hide)
That's a svartalf from Bombshells.
Title: Re: Peace Talks Trailer.
Post by: Dina on March 25, 2020, 01:36:46 AM
The caption identifies her as
(click to show/hide)
Title: Re: Peace Talks Trailer.
Post by: Yuillegan on March 25, 2020, 01:48:58 AM
My apologies Dina, my response came out harsher than I intended. Having seen how people tore apart the last few trailers, not to mention how critical people can be generally about this stuff (especially on the internet) I was a bit defensive. I know some people who worked on those other trailers and the way people reacted to people just trying to provide some entertainment and fan service was very toxic, and we were just so shocked after trying to do something nice for everyone. Just so you and everyone else knows, quite a lot of people involved do read these forums (even if they don't post or even have accounts. It pays to think about how your reaction might affect others. You are always more than welcome to say what you like, but there can be consequences too. Free speech cuts both ways, I'm afraid.  We all run the risk of offending people with any actions we take and whatever things we say. Best thing we can do is try and be respectful and kind, and I compromised my own principles then being harsher than was necessary. I am sorry for that, I hope you have a good day.

Snark Knight - I think the Winter Mantle is more like the Dark Side of the Force. It doesn't so much protect defensively, I suspect it follows the "best defense is a good offense" idea. Kill before you get over powered. Creatures like phages might be biting off more than they can chew trying to eat Winter.

Bad Alias - my bad, so it is. Why Evanna says he is getting justice is strange...who would she care about apart from another Svartalf? Gard maybe (being related in mythological circles)? Although why he would kill Gard is a mystery to me...forget Marcone you have to deal with Vadderung!
Title: Re: Peace Talks Trailer.
Post by: Dina on March 25, 2020, 01:57:00 AM
Ok, my point was that you accused me of being rude when I did not say anything but the way I personally reacted to the trailer, I did not mentioned anything at all about the trailer itself, precisely because I did not want to hurt anyone. I only said what I feel. And of course I did not offend anyone specifically, while you attacked me personally. But it's all right, I understand three things, a) you took it personally because you want to protect the people you know, which is great. b) you were a la defensive because of your previous experience (I personally don't think I said anything about the previous trailer, so I get it is not against me) and c) we are all sensitive right now, with all what is happening. So it's all right. I am sorry our first (as far as I recall) interaction in so many years was that bad. And I did not want to offend anyone.
Title: Re: Peace Talks Trailer.
Post by: Bad Alias on March 25, 2020, 03:09:59 AM
The caption identifies her as
(click to show/hide)
Thanks. I heard Jim and Priscilla say it, but I had no idea how to spell it.

I think maybe Thomas did something regarding the talks that fall under Marcone's aegis. Maybe as host. Thomas almost certainly had reasons, was framed (but that seems duplicative of Turn Coat), mind controlled (see last parenthetical), or something.

One of the things that Jim said is that good stories come from bad decisions. I think that was in the interview linked to over in the "Battle Ground???" thread.
Here's the link to the video:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NpLssK14iL8 (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NpLssK14iL8)
It might've been the live stream. Anyway, I think it's important to keep in mind that flawed characters generally make for better stories.
Title: Re: Peace Talks Trailer.
Post by: g33k on March 25, 2020, 03:33:34 AM
... Snark Knight - I think the Winter Mantle is more like the Dark Side of the Force. It doesn't so much protect defensively, I suspect it follows the "best defense is a good offense" idea. Kill before you get over powered. Creatures like phages might be biting off more than they can chew trying to eat Winter ...

I've previously wondered if White Court mojo might be able to wreak havoc with Winter Knight hungers.  We know that Harry can take a full-on hit of Hungry Lara, and turn that to fuel his own magic, but maybe WK's extra out-of-control "hungers" would weaken Harry's self-control...?

Then I realized...

I now expect that the WK would simply do the sex/violence conversion (that Harry has had to deal with several times).  They're the same, for the WK.  A whamp would never see it coming, never realize when their amorous victim decided to kill them, instead...
Title: Re: Peace Talks Trailer.
Post by: Bad Alias on March 25, 2020, 03:45:27 AM
I agree with g33k. If a White used the sexy vibes on Harry, he might lose all control. Jim did say in one of the videos today that anything that makes one ... more excitable would probably make them more vulnerable to White Court seduction.
Title: Re: Peace Talks Trailer.
Post by: Dina on March 25, 2020, 04:46:58 AM
Yes, and it could also depend of the circumstances, I mean, if, for example, Harry is hurt he will be more prone to loose control.
Title: Re: Peace Talks Trailer.
Post by: Arjan on March 25, 2020, 05:36:16 AM
Arjan - Why must the assassin be Kincaid? There are several assassins in the books so far, why him?

Quote
The assassin, A creature well known to be your frequent ally
That reduces the suspect pool quite a bit.

Also “The Assassin” did sound a bit like a long earned title or a profession, not like someone who just killed someone else. A creature like Kincaid could be called the assassin. It is his profession. And he is at drift now.

Title: Re: Peace Talks Trailer.
Post by: Avernite on March 25, 2020, 06:40:25 AM
Yes, and it could also depend of the circumstances, I mean, if, for example, Harry is hurt he will be more prone to loose control.
Is he ever not hurt?  ;)
Title: Re: Peace Talks Trailer.
Post by: Dina on March 25, 2020, 06:57:01 AM
Good point  :)
Title: Re: Peace Talks Trailer.
Post by: Yuillegan on March 25, 2020, 07:26:54 AM
That reduces the suspect pool quite a bit.

Also “The Assassin” did sound a bit like a long earned title or a profession, not like someone who just killed someone else. A creature like Kincaid could be called the assassin. It is his profession. And he is at drift now.

Maybe that's just how you heard it. Thomas is a much longer term ally than Kincaid, and FAR more frequent. Thomas, at least in the trailer, is implied to be the Assassin. Dresden peers into a cell with a bloodied Thomas inside. Dresden asks, "What will happen to him?" The svatalf Evanna replies, "Justice". He also has been lined up. He has a kid on the way and things are getting riskier, a perfect patsy to destabilize the Peace Talks. Someone who Dresden would fight and die for.

Kincaid would be very on the nose. I doubt he wants to go near Ivy or Dresden, let alone McCoy. Not to mention, even if he is the ACTUAL assassin - he certainly won't be the one everyone thinks it is initially. Which will almost certainly be Thomas.

Also Kincaid is hardly the only professional assassin. McCoy, Thomas, Dresden, one Marcone's many hitter, Mab has thousands apart from Dresden (like the Fetches). Ortega is deceased of course, but there would be one for the Red Court after he died. Hell the Eebs were assassins. Of course the Red Court is dead, but they would have had plenty. And while members of the White Court probably would rarely do their own wetworks, they probably have someone. Drakul lost the Hellhound years ago, he likely has a replacement assassin or two. That's just off the top of my head.
Title: Re: Peace Talks Trailer.
Post by: Arjan on March 25, 2020, 07:34:14 AM
Maybe that's just how you heard it. Thomas is a much longer term ally than Kincaid, and FAR more frequent. Thomas, at least in the trailer, is implied to be the Assassin. Dresden peers into a cell with a bloodied Thomas inside. Dresden asks, "What will happen to him?" The svatalf Evanna replies, "Justice". He also has been lined up. He has a kid on the way and things are getting riskier, a perfect patsy to destabilize the Peace Talks. Someone who Dresden would fight and die for.

Kincaid would be very on the nose. I doubt he wants to go near Ivy or Dresden, let alone McCoy. Not to mention, even if he is the ACTUAL assassin - he certainly won't be the one everyone thinks it is initially. Which will almost certainly be Thomas.

Also Kincaid is hardly the only professional assassin. McCoy, Thomas, Dresden, one Marcone's many hitter, Mab has thousands apart from Dresden (like the Fetches). Ortega is deceased of course, but there would be one for the Red Court after he died. Hell the Eebs were assassins. Of course the Red Court is dead, but they would have had plenty. And while members of the White Court probably would rarely do their own wetworks, they probably have someone. Drakul lost the Hellhound years ago, he likely has a replacement assassin or two. That's just off the top of my head.
Of all these mentioned only Thomas is a frequent ally. He might have a reputation that was completely lost to Harry or the word was used more specifically for one (series of) asassination(s).
Title: Re: Peace Talks Trailer.
Post by: g33k on March 25, 2020, 08:25:45 AM
... I am not sure True Love is a protection against WCVs. More like being in love with someone...I know it is semantics but I think the point is that it doesn't have to be your one and only soulmate ...

Except Jim is explicit that True Love IS protection (specifically against Lust-flavored Whamps); and he's has been repeatedly consistent about it.

Where I think you've missed the point is that "True Love" doesn't actually have to be a "one and only soulmate" sort of thing ...  Lightning can strike twice.
Title: Re: Peace Talks Trailer.
Post by: Yuillegan on March 25, 2020, 08:35:59 AM
Of all these mentioned only Thomas is a frequent ally. He might have a reputation that was completely lost to Harry or the word was used more specifically for one (series of) asassination(s).

How isn't Eb a frequent long term ally? He has known Dresden since he was 15! The rest I was mentioning purely to illustrate that there are lots of assassins out there, both "professional" (can a monster even have a profession?) and otherwise. There isn't really anything except your gut feeling to say that it is Kincaid. It might be him, but it's most likely (at least initially) Thomas.

I am not sure I understand your second point about reputations etc...did you mean that Thomas has a hidden role to Harry, because Back Up confirms that - he is a Venator.

g33k - he specifically refers to Love, not so much True Love. I agree it can be more than one person, that was in fact one of the points I was making. My point is someone can be your True Love, but unless you're actually in love with them (and I guess you have had sex with them and presumably only them) you are unprotected. Unrequited or unknown love is no protection. Again, I know it's minor stuff but it is an important distinction. Otherwise the White Court Raiths would be nowhere near as effective.
Title: Re: Peace Talks Trailer.
Post by: Arjan on March 25, 2020, 09:20:27 AM
How isn't Eb a frequent long term ally? He has known Dresden since he was 15!
He is not hotheaded enough anymore to break the peace that way and despite his mentor ship not really a frequent ally.
Quote
The rest I was mentioning purely to illustrate that there are lots of assassins out there, both "professional" (can a monster even have a profession?) and otherwise. There isn't really anything except your gut feeling to say that it is Kincaid. It might be him, but it's most likely (at least initially) Thomas.
It might be Thomas.
Quote
I am not sure I understand your second point about reputations etc...did you mean that Thomas has a hidden role to Harry, because Back Up confirms that - he is a Venator.
Are we talking about a assassin or the assassin?
Quote
g33k - he specifically refers to Love, not so much True Love. I agree it can be more than one person, that was in fact one of the points I was making. My point is someone can be your True Love, but unless you're actually in love with them (and I guess you have had sex with them and presumably only them) you are unprotected. Unrequited or unknown love is no protection. Again, I know it's minor stuff but it is an important distinction. Otherwise the White Court Raiths would be nowhere near as effective.
They were surprisingly ineffective with the movie director in blood rites. Probably some people have more talent for true love than others. I do not think you can simply add up a few symptoms and predict. You need a vampire to verify.
Title: Re: Peace Talks Trailer.
Post by: SerScot on March 25, 2020, 11:54:01 AM
(click to show/hide)

How can Harry defend Himself against another hit from Kincaid, buy him first?
Title: Re: Peace Talks Trailer.
Post by: SerScot on March 25, 2020, 11:58:34 AM
(click to show/hide)

(click to show/hide)
Title: Re: Peace Talks Trailer.
Post by: Arjan on March 25, 2020, 12:06:52 PM
How can Harry defend Himself against another hit from Kincaid, buy him first?
Who said Harry is the target? Harry is the PI.
Title: Re: Peace Talks Trailer.
Post by: SerScot on March 25, 2020, 12:20:28 PM
Who said Harry is the target? Harry is the PI.

I was thinking longer term
Title: Re: Peace Talks Trailer.
Post by: Arjan on March 25, 2020, 12:50:45 PM
I was thinking longer term
Harry has those diamonds and as a good DM Jim will find a way to get rid of them.
Title: Re: Peace Talks Trailer.
Post by: Gigglestomp on March 25, 2020, 03:03:21 PM
Heres my take, and I think they played with the ordering in the trailer a bit to make people think
(click to show/hide)

Scene 1:
(click to show/hide)
Scene 2:
(click to show/hide)
Scene 3:
(click to show/hide)
Scene 4:
(click to show/hide)
Scene 5:
(click to show/hide)
Scene 6:
(click to show/hide)
Scene 7:
(click to show/hide)
Scene 8:
(click to show/hide)
Scene 9:
(click to show/hide)
Scene 10:
(click to show/hide)
Scene 11:
(click to show/hide)
Scene 12:
(click to show/hide)
Scene 13:
(click to show/hide)
Scene 14:
(click to show/hide)
Scene 15:
(click to show/hide)
Scene 16:
(click to show/hide)
Scene 17:
(click to show/hide)

Spoiler Battlegrounds Description:
(click to show/hide)
Title: Re: Peace Talks Trailer.
Post by: Bad Alias on March 25, 2020, 05:46:55 PM
Are we talking about a assassin or the assassin?They were surprisingly ineffective with the movie director in blood rites.
I think we are talking about the assassin who killed someone at the talks. They were ineffective because they were going for control of Arturo and didn't know who their target was.
Title: Re: Peace Talks Trailer.
Post by: Arjan on March 25, 2020, 07:25:40 PM
I think we are talking about the assassin who killed someone at the talks. They were ineffective because they were going for control of Arturo and didn't know who their target was.
The problem with Genosa is that he fell in love all the time, pretty easily serially. I do not think it has to be your only one true love and soulmate whatever and it comes more easily to some people than to others.
Title: Re: Peace Talks Trailer.
Post by: Just Al on March 25, 2020, 08:49:15 PM
The caption identifies her as
(click to show/hide)

I'm suffering from CRS syndrome (aka Oldtimer's disease) Who is Evanna?
Title: Re: Peace Talks Trailer.
Post by: g33k on March 25, 2020, 09:16:34 PM
I'm suffering from CRS syndrome (aka Oldtimer's disease) Who is Evanna?
A svartalf.
She appeared in one of the shorts, I think...
Title: Re: Peace Talks Trailer.
Post by: didymos on March 25, 2020, 09:23:12 PM
A svartalf.
She appeared in one of the shorts, I think...

In Bombshells, but she wasn't named there.  We got her name from the trailer.
Title: Re: Peace Talks Trailer.
Post by: Dina on March 25, 2020, 09:40:22 PM
Yes, I only wanted to say that was not Gard
Title: Re: Peace Talks Trailer.
Post by: 123Chikadee on March 25, 2020, 09:52:23 PM
Wait, how do we know Evanna is a Svartelf? Did I miss something?

Sorry, I'm not sure how to do the spoiler tags just yet, so I'll try to be vague. Well, we do know that Thomas is a venatori, so maybe trouble caught up with him b/c of that. Harry would then find out in the worst way possible. Another reason why Evanna might be an even bigger antagonist that I suspected. I wonder if she'll become a main cast member to fill out any empty slot...

Hm, I would like Thomas to be a red-herring just b/c he's been under this kind of scrutiny before. Though if they do then he'll need to have genuinely done something 'bad' so that there really would need to be a kind of a legal snafu that has to be corrected.

I think my theory still stands, at least in the general sense, that Thomas has to get a new position of power to get out of the trouble he's in but that paradoxically, leaves him in more danger. Lara also ties into this. I think this might be where she takes a pretty big dent in her power structure, to the point where she could die.  Going to war over Thomas could only be one reason for her power to get diminished.

Maybe Lara vs Marcone? Gosh, Harry would get caught in the middle and have to act to prevent them from causing too much collateral damage. If Hendricks is indeed the one who_____, then that would be reason for Marcone to be so determined/angry and letting Harry know this might be the only courtesy he can manage. This could also be where it's revealed that Thomas and Harry are brothers.

Marcone may be a smaller player than Lara, but he's got a lot to lose if he doesn't succeed/meet his goals here, so he could be more underhanded than usual. Gigglestomp's scene 5 take is pretty spot on in my mind.

With the getting dressed scene, this gives me an idea. B/c it's an establishing scene, I think, it might also be setting another character to be a 'Spanner in the Works' and this time, it isn't Harry. 

I know that having the WK mantle means that Harry is more susceptible to Lara's mojo, but I think this could be a double edged sword, esp since he doesn't suffer intimidate drawbacks to drawing on the mantle in the same way that a Whamp has when they draw on their power. Lara is also used to being able to use Harry as a weapon w/o any ill consequences for her.  She's also counting on Harry sticking to his bargain. But if Thomas is in danger that might not happen. I mean a combo of his natural pragmatism and being pushed hard enough might mean that Harry wouldn't give her any warning. As for trying to control him via offspring, he's already proven that's a bad idea.  I think this time Lara's bitten off more than she can chew.

Gigglestomp's idea about scene 9 is pretty neat. I can see that being true. Maybe scene 8 happens right after that.

W/ regards to scene 11: Oooh, I hadn't thought of that. Now that's gonna be interesting an interesting conflict, I hope that's indeed what's going on.

I like the idea of Undertown being a set for conflict.

I know that Mab's accords are a big deal and by that score, the peace talks themselves, so everyone is trying to protect them, b/c really they do need to do this, but I do wonder if anyone feels the need or can even imagine that said Accords need to be improved upon. Maybe Harry could end up getting new allies under this way of thinking?

Hm, judging from the synopsis for Battle Ground, maybe the masquerade gets broken then. Since what's her face has those goals in mind, she wouldn't exactly be hiding, esp since she wouldn't feel the need to hide.
Title: Re: Peace Talks Trailer.
Post by: Dina on March 25, 2020, 10:18:29 PM
123, write whatever you want to spoiler tag. Then highlight is as if you were planning to copy it and then (when the text is highlighted) click in the "insert spoiler" button, which is just above and right the last emoji in the Post Reply menu. That's all. If you want to check the result, use the "preview" button before posting it.

About BG, I am wondering about the falling of the masquerade too.

Also, I want to know if BG is before or after the Christmas' story.
Title: Re: Peace Talks Trailer.
Post by: Arjan on March 25, 2020, 10:42:54 PM
123, write whatever you want to spoiler tag. Then highlight is as if you were planning to copy it and then (when the text is highlighted) click in the "insert spoiler" button, which is just above and right the last emoji in the Post Reply menu. That's all. If you want to check the result, use the "preview" button before posting it.

About BG, I am wondering about the falling of the masquerade too.

Also, I want to know if BG is before or after the Christmas' story.
Must be before. The two are really one story and it seems like the decision to split them was made this year. Also the scale of the casualties mentioned in and the relative quiet of the christmas story suggests no big battle Harry knows of is in the near future.

Battle Ground is probably a direct result of peace talks.


Title: Re: Peace Talks Trailer.
Post by: Dina on March 26, 2020, 12:18:04 AM
Yes, it is the most probable.
Title: Re: Peace Talks Trailer.
Post by: harry dresden on March 26, 2020, 12:38:29 AM
In relation to the true love thing being an anathema to the Whites being able to feed, maybe Harry and Murph haven't consummated their relationship, but I recall how Michael questions Harry's reaction to Murph being hurt by Nic in Skin Game. Perhaps Harry isn't truly in love with Murph or the Winter Knight mantle is affecting him in ways he can't detect, or it's possible that scene with Lara and Harry is not what it seems.

Anyway for myself I enjoyed the trailer and I concur with Jim the guy playing Marcone nailed it. 
Title: Re: Peace Talks Trailer.
Post by: didymos on March 26, 2020, 12:52:15 AM
Must be before. The two are really one story and it seems like the decision to split them was made this year. Also the scale of the casualties mentioned in and the relative quiet of the christmas story suggests no big battle Harry knows of is in the near future.

Battle Ground is probably a direct result of peace talks.

This is confirmed in the livestream Jim did with Priscilla.  Christmas Eve is being published at the end of Battle Ground:

https://youtu.be/5V9am4XyYz4?t=1499
Title: Re: Peace Talks Trailer.
Post by: 123Chikadee on March 26, 2020, 01:57:58 AM
@Dina: Ah, ok thanks.
IIRC, the comic book, Dogman, has LtW and Harry encounter some government types who are in the know w/ supernatural types. It would go well w/ the hints that someone took the loup-garoux footage all the way back from 'Fool Moon'.  Plus, there is Agent Tilly. I think there might be some government division that will step in who will try to control/help when the masquerade breaks. And surprisingly, to all the supernatural folk, be pretty dang competent.
@harry dresden: I didn't think about that at all, that's an interesting point. But yeah, it could be a red herring via the Lara/Harry. It probably is. And yeah, that was a kickass Marcone. I really do hope they make more trailers with that cast.
 
Title: Re: Peace Talks Trailer.
Post by: Bad Alias on March 26, 2020, 03:20:44 AM
Wait, how do we know Evanna is a Svartelf? Did I miss something?
The livestream.
Title: Re: Peace Talks Trailer.
Post by: Dina on March 26, 2020, 04:04:14 AM
In relation to the true love thing being an anathema to the Whites being able to feed, maybe Harry and Murph haven't consummated their relationship, but I recall how Michael questions Harry's reaction to Murph being hurt by Nic in Skin Game. Perhaps Harry isn't truly in love with Murph or the Winter Knight mantle is affecting him in ways he can't detect, or it's possible that scene with Lara and Harry is not what it seems.

Anyway for myself I enjoyed the trailer and I concur with Jim the guy playing Marcone nailed it.

Yes, I agree. I've remember several discussions here in the forums about all that. My pet theory has always been that the WK mantle is making Harry believe that he loves Murph so he can get laid. I had sore discussions, but I don't remember very well who were involved.
I agree about the guy playing Marcone, he is great (I imagine Marcone older, but it does not matter. His demeanor is (IMHO) perfect)

This is confirmed in the livestream Jim did with Priscilla.  Christmas Eve is being published at the end of Battle Ground:

https://youtu.be/5V9am4XyYz4?t=1499

Ah, thank you, Arjan. I have not seen it (I normally don't watch Q&A videos and that sort of thing because I never understand them very well.

@123Chikadee: you are welcome and thanks! (I have not read any comic book)
Title: Re: Peace Talks Trailer.
Post by: Avernite on March 26, 2020, 06:46:48 AM
Must be before. The two are really one story and it seems like the decision to split them was made this year. Also the scale of the casualties mentioned in and the relative quiet of the christmas story suggests no big battle Harry knows of is in the near future.

Battle Ground is probably a direct result of peace talks.

Of course that then ties back to -
WHY would Thomas-the-assasin shenanigans, which we all assume from the trailer, lead to an attack by a Fomor Titan?

Only thing I can come up with is Thomas murdered a Fomor representative to the talks (say because he/she/it seemed to be trying to harm Justine or Harry), Harry and Lara get away with getting him out (though at cost, as warned in the trailer by Marcone), so the Fomor declare war on Harry and Lara, personally.
Title: Re: Peace Talks Trailer.
Post by: 123Chikadee on March 26, 2020, 12:17:45 PM
@Bad Alias: Ah, ok then. I had watched parts of it but I did fall asleep at some point lol.
@Dina: Yeah, that's why I don't like having something that big and game-changing in the supplementary canon. I haven't read the comic either, I only know what's in it, b/c I looked it up.
@Avernite: Oooh, good point. I like how straightforward that is. 
Title: Re: Peace Talks Trailer.
Post by: toodeep on March 26, 2020, 07:34:03 PM
Harry is never the start of the process, he has always been someone's tool.  Usually Mab's.  We know he is in at least decent favor with Mab at the end of all this because of the Christmas story, so he obviously doesn't screw her or her accords over.

So here are my guesses.
1.  The scene I take to be between Justine and Thomas shows that he knows he was going into serious trouble, maybe knew he was going to die.  The thing that motivates him is protecting their child.  Who made it so that he had to do something that could get him killed, we don't know yet.  My guess is Mab.

2.  I don't think he killed someone of Marcone's, though it is possible.  Marcone seems to be all business, which is what we would expect even if it was personal, but I would hope we would see some actual anger from him if the person killed had been close to him.  He must kill Thomas to maintain his position and the Accords as he is the one running the meeting.

3.  Why the hell are Marcone and Dresden in a room together getting dressed?  I mean, it what universe does that happen?  How undressed were they before the scene we saw? Why?

4.  Harry will get his brother out. This is expected.  Mab can't support him, and will kill him for interfering if he is caught, but if he can pull it off...

Big guess?  At Mab's instigation (why, how, currently unknown) Thomas kills the ambassador for the Fomor.  While this puts him on the chopping block, it puts the Fomor at a disadvantage in the negotiations, which allows alliances against them to form.  This pisses them off, and coupled with Thomas's escape (somehow all is forgiven once he escapes?  Maybe just proven innocent) the Fomor are driven to a murderous rage and they, led by their Titan Queen in conjunction with outsiders attack the proceedings.  Carnage ensues.  This is all part of Mab's plot, because how else would you get a Titan near the one place that can take it out - Demonreach.  Somehow, through convoluted battle Harry must get her to Demonreach, and we get to see the first new inmate get added to the island in a long time.  This destroys the backbone of the Fomor who were in alliance with outsiders... And once again removes an outsider (ally) threat to the world in Mab's preparation for the big battle...
Title: Re: Peace Talks Trailer.
Post by: Bad Alias on March 26, 2020, 07:46:16 PM
On the point of Harry and Murphy's "true love" status, it would make a lot of sense for them to take a long time to get there.  That's going to make it difficult for him to go "all in." Murphy is bad at relationships. Three husbands and Kincaid is her known track record. One of those ex-husbands is now her brother-in-law. Ick. Harry thought he murdered his first girlfriend. Then she disappeared and showed up all of a sudden and manipulated him. She shows up a few years later and doesn't trust him. His next girlfriend, and need I remind everyone how that worked out? Lack of trust resulting in half-turned vampire, a secret child, and ritual sacrifice at Harry's hands? The next girlfriend was mind controlled into it. Then, as Sanya says, he "tapped that ass." Mab.

Then there's everything from the end of Changes to whatever's going on now. There's a good chance one or both of them will be holding back. One day they may get past it. Or they may not.

Somehow, through convoluted battle Harry must get her to Demonreach, and we get to see the first new inmate get added to the island in a long time.
Maybe all he needs is a little blood or some other thaumaturgical link. It's hard to imagine any being worth imprisoning doesn't know that the Demonreach has a new Warden, and it's Harry. Then again, the White Council doesn't really know what Harry's job is.
Title: Re: Peace Talks Trailer.
Post by: AClone on March 26, 2020, 08:47:51 PM
I'm afraid that I'm going to have to make a couple of posts to add a few relevant thoughts...
Heres my take, and I think they played with the ordering in the trailer a bit to make people think
(click to show/hide)
Please pardon me doing some trimming. But I'm not sure of one of Marcone's people actually died or not, we just know that he appears to be the offended party. And that simply could be because he is the official host.

What we do know is that "blood has been spilled", which we saw as a Very Bad Thing when Mab has decided that everyone should play nice--and it's her Accords.

Matter of fact, the "blood spilled" may only be Thomas's--because he clearly got his backside kicked, whatever it was that he tried. Though it does appear (and that may be the key word, because...Jim) that Thomas was attempting to kill someone. If that was Marcone, I think we can guess who handed out the beating.

Scene 4:
(click to show/hide)
Not necessarily people who got the invite, just the ones the trailer had the budget to display.

For the rest, I'll simply refer to Chapter One.
 
Scene 6:
(click to show/hide)
People are drawing some odd conclusions from this scene. It's not as if Harry hasn't gotten dressed for a formal occasion off in a room with someone else before.

Scene 9:
(click to show/hide)
Just to play Devil's Advocate, how do you know that isn't Goodman Grey? Or, remember the Skin Game trailer, where Harry was fooling around with Murphy? We all know how that one turned out.

Scene 11:
(click to show/hide)
What I see is Molly reaching out to touch an invisible barrier (though perhaps commentary said more elsewhere). White Council Security--specifically Carlos, IIRC, has been known to put those up around meeting places before. If Molly is unable to get through, it would be one way for Jim to exclude one of Harry's (now) most powerful allies at a time when he needs all the help he can get. Much the way that Mouse is usually now sidelined with Maggie duties.
Scene 12:
(click to show/hide)
The gravelly voice makes me think Mr. Ferro. (sp?)

Scene 13:
(click to show/hide)
After he snaked his way down a narrow space (ventilation shaft?) to get to Thomas--and his tuxedo pants got caught on something on the way?

Scene 17:
(click to show/hide)
Remember that in the Skin Game trailer, the production was limited by budget to "similar" settings, some of which were pretty distant from the actual setting. I think the point here was just to show Harry squirming down somewhere singing the Spiderman theme.

Spoiler Battlegrounds Description:
(click to show/hide)

I found myself wondering. If the naagloshii were the small fry imprisoned on Demonreach, where a Titan would fit in the pecking order of the powers that are entombed in crystal there.
Title: Re: Peace Talks Trailer.
Post by: KurtinStGeorge on March 26, 2020, 09:17:07 PM
Wait, how do we know Evanna is a Svartelf? Did I miss something?

We found that out in the Q&A video that Priscilla did with Jim.  Priscilla named most of the people and not people sitting and standing around Mab at the opening of the talks which we see in the trailer.  Actually, the photo at Jim's website is better quality.
Title: Re: Peace Talks Trailer.
Post by: Mira on March 26, 2020, 09:31:33 PM


  Yeah, about Thomas, he usually doesn't get his ass kicked.  The last being to do that if I remember correctly was Shaggynasty... 
Title: Re: Peace Talks Trailer.
Post by: Dina on March 26, 2020, 09:54:59 PM
And Harry  :)
Title: Re: Peace Talks Trailer.
Post by: AClone on April 09, 2020, 12:49:14 AM

  Yeah, about Thomas, he usually doesn't get his ass kicked.  The last being to do that if I remember correctly was Shaggynasty...

In one of the Bigfoot stories, Harry is extremely wary of a svartalf posing as a gym coach. So I think we have a likely answer here for the likely culprit.

Given his "hosts", I'm guessing the cage Thomas is in may prevent him from regenerating. Either that, or he's completely out of gas.
Title: Re: Peace Talks Trailer.
Post by: Mira on April 09, 2020, 03:33:01 AM
Quote
I found myself wondering. If the naagloshii were the small fry imprisoned on Demonreach, where a Titan would fit in the pecking order of the powers that are entombed in crystal there.

A Titan wouldn't be in crystal, that is for smaller fry, a Titan would warrant one of the cells deeper down in the tunnel.
Quote
Given his "hosts", I'm guessing the cage Thomas is in may prevent him from regenerating. Either that, or he's completely out of gas.
Thomas cannot just regenerate, he needs to feed to do that.  So unless that happens he will suffer and even die like any vanilla human.
Title: Re: Peace Talks Trailer.
Post by: didymos on April 09, 2020, 03:40:46 AM
Thomas cannot just regenerate, he needs to feed to do that.  So unless that happens he will suffer and even die like any vanilla human.

He can. He just has to have gas in the tank, so to speak.
Title: Re: Peace Talks Trailer.
Post by: Yuillegan on April 09, 2020, 03:52:55 AM
Agreed, Didymos.

And a Titan could be in those crystals. It seems that is the cell for each thing. Some of those were as big as buildings, if I recall.
Title: Re: Peace Talks Trailer.
Post by: Mira on April 09, 2020, 03:44:05 PM
He can. He just has to have gas in the tank, so to speak.

  No, if he is injured bad enough, he has to feed to heal and survive.   That is how the skinwalker got him to kill over and over again, tortured him to the point of death, bring on another young girl.   
Title: Re: Peace Talks Trailer.
Post by: didymos on April 09, 2020, 03:51:59 PM
  No, if he is injured bad enough, he has to feed to heal and survive.   That is how the skinwalker got him to kill over and over again, tortured him to the point of death, bring on another young girl.

Yes, if he is injured bad enough. But they can heal injuries. Lara did it during the naagloshii attack:

Quote
Her forearm had received a compound fracture. I could see bone poking out through the flesh. But over the next few seconds, the flesh seemed to ripple and become more malleable. The bone withdrew, vanishing beneath the skin of her arm—even the hole that the bone had torn in the skin sealed slowly closed, and in ten seconds I couldn’t even tell she’d been hurt.

Butcher, Jim. Turn Coat (The Dresden Files, Book 11) (pp. 239-240). Penguin Publishing Group. Kindle Edition.


Title: Re: Peace Talks Trailer.
Post by: Mira on April 09, 2020, 04:28:45 PM
Quote
Yes, if he is injured bad enough. But they can heal injuries. Lara did it during the naagloshii attack:

 However Lara also keeps more topped off so to speak.  Also have to go back to see whether or not she had already fed upon the more critically wounded.  Now that he is with Justine, especially since she is pregnant, Thomas might be back to nibbling, just enough to keep him going, but not enough to heal if he is really hurt.
Title: Re: Peace Talks Trailer.
Post by: AClone on April 11, 2020, 03:35:34 AM
A Titan wouldn't be in crystal, that is for smaller fry, a Titan would warrant one of the cells deeper down in the tunnel.Thomas cannot just regenerate, he needs to feed to do that.  So unless that happens he will suffer and even die like any vanilla human.
A. The "cells further down the tunnel" are crystal covered--and the size of buildings.

B. Harry had the impression that something was "off" about Thomas. As in, he was Hungry. It seemed implicit to me that if Justine was pregnant and the bab was feeding off of her, Thomas was not feeding. Off of Justine or anyone else. Not even nibbling.

Thus if he got in a fight, he would be able to regenerate until his reserves were empty. In this case, he might have regenerated as much as possible--and the fight kept going, and he got beaten up even more.

Alternately, I suppose that after the fight was over, he had just enough "left in the tank" to heal critical internal injuries and keep himself from dying. Which still left him looking like hamburger.

And unable to feed.
Title: Re: Peace Talks Trailer.
Post by: KurtinStGeorge on April 11, 2020, 09:38:27 PM
However Lara also keeps more topped off so to speak.  Also have to go back to see whether or not she had already fed upon the more critically wounded. Now that he is with Justine, especially since she is pregnant, Thomas might be back to nibbling, just enough to keep him going, but not enough to heal if he is really hurt.

She did, almost immediately after the attack.
Title: Re: Peace Talks Trailer.
Post by: Bad Alias on April 13, 2020, 09:17:00 PM
Jim in 2012:
Quote
The Titans got their asses handed to them by Zeus and company, and were imprisoned, destroyed, or consigned to oblivion. How do you imprison a Titan? Funny you should ask…
Seeing as the imprisonment of Titans is being discussed, I figured I'd just leave this here.
Title: Re: Peace Talks Trailer.
Post by: g33k on April 14, 2020, 11:56:38 PM
Quote
Jim in 2012:
Quote
The Titans got their asses handed to them by Zeus and company, and were imprisoned, destroyed, or consigned to oblivion. How do you imprison a Titan? Funny you should ask…
Seeing as the imprisonment of Titans is being discussed, I figured I'd just leave this here.

"Imprisoned, destroyed, or consigned to oblivion" ...

OK, we've got the Oblivion War for that last one.  And Backup came out in '08, so this '12 wasn't laying that particular Easter Egg (for fans to rediscover), though I suppose that it's "news:"  just the FACT that some Titans were so bad, they were Oblivion-War targets ...

If they were destroyed way-back-when the ol' Greek gods were ramping up, those ones are gone.  Though "death is a grey zone," in the Dresdenverse, so... maybe not as "gone" as one might think?  But he said "destroyed" not "killed," so I suspect they're really gone.

Which leaves Harry the Warden of Demonreach, presumably relevant to that whole "imprisonment" thing.   ;D

And it leaves this "Last Titan..."

Is she returned from the edges of Oblivion?  That would make her one of the more horrific entities...

Was she escaped from imprisonment?  There was an AWFUL lot of in-the-water action at the end of Cold Days, that Harry never saw... maybe breaching the entirety of Demonreach wasn't the primary goal!  If the Fomor were standing by, underwater, with massive amounts of their Entropy Magic, they might have been able to jailbreak one prisoner ...
 
Title: Re: Peace Talks Trailer.
Post by: Bad Alias on April 15, 2020, 02:45:20 AM
Well, I don't think all the Titans were dealt with by the Olympians because several were on the Olympians side. From there, we can assume that his statement is more of a generality. We also have Gard telling us that the Fomor are a collection of defeated entities from various cultures. With all this, it wouldn't be out of place for one of the Titans to have escaped the Olympians and have found a place with the Fomor, or, depending on the time frames, for the Fomor to have found a place with that Titan.

What I found interesting was the last part of the quote. "How do you imprison a Titan? Funny you should ask…" With what we know from Cold Days, this seems to be a clear reference to Demonreach Prison. With the description of Battle Ground, perhaps this was foreshadowing more than just the purpose of the island? We still don't really know how to imprison a Titan or any other extremely powerful being. We just know where.

There's a lot about Demonreach we don't know about. Why, for example, aren't all or most of the monstrosities in Harry's "green book" in the Prison? Does it have a capacity limit? Can beings be summoned out of the Prison?