ParanetOnline

The Dresden Files => DF Spoilers => Topic started by: raidem on September 26, 2017, 04:08:50 PM

Title: Marcone's Age @ SF
Post by: raidem on September 26, 2017, 04:08:50 PM
I wanted to establish a lower limit on Marcone's apparent age via Priscilla's timeline, text, and WOJ's.  I say lower limit because as we have seen with Sarissa, Wizards, etc apparent age can be drastically different than actual age.  Much of this is brought over from the Harry/Marcone Relationship thread as I believe discussion focused on his age is more appropriate in its own thread.

Establishing lower limit on Marcone's age via Priscilla's timeline to include events surrounding Amanda Beckitt.
Quote
Amanda's birth via Priscilla's timeline prior to Storm Front
~13-17 14* BSF: Amanda Beckitt born.  [Age:0]
Quote
[2,4-7* 3 years BSF] What I could see was the Beckitt family. Husband, wife, daughter, a little girl maybe ten or eleven years old. [Age: 10-11]
She is "in her late teens or early twenties" in DM which takes place about 3 years after SF. [Age 18-23] [~16-17]
Quote
Quote
Murphy's jaw tensed, little motions at the corners of her face. Then she said, "Greg and Helen Beckitt. Three years ago, their daughter, Amanda, was killed in a cross fire.
Johnny Marcone's thugs were shooting it out with some of the Jamaican gang that was trying to muscle in on the territory back then. One of them shot the little girl. She lived for three weeks in intensive care and died when they took her off life support."
I didn't say anything. But I thought of Mrs. Beckitt's numb face and dead eyes.
"The Beckitts attempted to lodge a wrongful death suit against Johnny Marcone, but Marcone's lawyers were too good. They got it thrown out before it even went to court. And they never found the man who shot the little girl. Word has it that Marcone offered to pay them blood money. Make reparation. But they turned him down."
Quote
~3-4 BSF: Marco Vargassi decides Marcone has become a threat to his father Tony's organization and tries to stage his death. Amanda Beckitt, daughter of Helen and Greg, is shot.  She is about 10 or 11 at the time, and she is in her late teens to early twenties in DM.  Tony Vargassi bribes the medical examiner to forge Amanda's death certificate to protect his son.  The Vargassis are still in power at the time of "Restoration of Faith."
Quote
~2-3 BSF: Marcone learns of Amanda Beckitt, two years after her "death." per Marcone in DM
Quote
~2 BSF: Marcone topples the Vargassis and founds his own empire.

Now for Marcone
Quote
@BillyYank Marcone was a Marine. [Age>17 when he entered service]
Quote
I looked over my shoulder to see a very, very young-looking Marcone.
He wasn't wearing a business suit. He had on jeans and a black leather jacket. His hair was longish, a little mussed, and he also sported a stubble of beard that gave him the kind of rakish look that would attract attention from the girls who fantasized about indulging with a bad boy. [Age:?] [BSF]
Quote
"Gentleman" Johnny Marcone had been the thug to emerge on top of the pile after the Vargassi family had dissolved into internal strife. The police department saw Marcone as a mixed blessing, after years of merciless struggle and bloody exchanges with the Vargassis.
SF: Marcone's appearance during first Harry/Marcone encounter
Quote
Gentleman Johnny Marcone didn't look like the sort of man who would have my legs broken or my jaw wired shut. His salt-and-pepper hair was cut short, and there were lines from sun and smiling etched into the corners of his eyes. His eyes were the green of well-worn dollar bills. He seemed more like a college football coach: good-looking, tanned, athletic, and enthusiastic. The impression was reinforced by the men he kept with him.
Harry's Age 25@SF per Priscilla timeline.
Quote
25 BSF, October 31:  Harry is born.  Harry's mother, now Margaret Gwendolyn Dresden, dies in childbirth.  She is murdered by a ritual entropy curse, courtesy of Lord Raith. [Harry's Age SF=25]
Based on time of shootout, estimate of Amanda's birth, Harry's birth, and Marcone involvement in a shootout 2-7BSF at age no earlier than 18, I estimate that Marcone is at least 6-10 years older than Harry.

Priscilla's Timeline
http://www.jimbutcheronline.com/bb/index.php/topic,1592.0.html
Title: Re: Marcone's Age @ SF
Post by: raidem on September 26, 2017, 04:57:41 PM
Given this WOJ:"@BillyYank Marcone was a Marine", I really don't see Marcone on active duty as a Marine from the time of Amanda Beckitt's shooting onward. During this time, he is actively fighting to take over a criminal enterprise.  Therefore, he served as a Marine prior to his appearance as quoted below:
Quote
I looked over my shoulder to see a very, very young-looking Marcone.
He wasn't wearing a business suit. He had on jeans and a black leather jacket. His hair was longish, a little mussed, and he also sported a stubble of beard that gave him the kind of rakish look that would attract attention from the girls who fantasized about indulging with a bad boy.
Or, he joined the Marines after the shooting but didn't serve a full term, or much of a term at all. 
So, Marcone's age for me is at least 31-35 during SF, that is the lower limit then. Harry is 25 during SF per Priscilla timeline.

That said, we actually didn't see Marcone appearance in the shootout which "a very, very young-looking Marcone" is based off of; we saw his appearance via a soulgaze between Harry and Helen Beckitt. 
Title: Re: Marcone's Age @ SF
Post by: Mira on September 26, 2017, 06:47:54 PM
Given this WOJ:"@BillyYank Marcone was a Marine", I really don't see Marcone on active duty as a Marine from the time of Amanda Beckitt's shooting onward. During this time, he is actively fighting to take over a criminal enterprise.  Therefore, he served as a Marine prior to his appearance as quoted below:Or, he joined the Marines after the shooting but didn't serve a full term, or much of a term at all. 
So, Marcone's age for me is at least 31-35 during SF, that is the lower limit then. Harry is 25 during SF per Priscilla timeline.

That said, we actually didn't see Marcone appearance in the shootout which "a very, very young-looking Marcone" is based off of; we saw his appearance via a soulgaze between Harry and Helen Beckitt. 

Young looking is also very subjective,   some people have the kind of face that appears very young well into their thirties.. Others begin to look middle aged at thirty..

The man that Harry meets seems to me to be closer to forty if not older verses closer to thirty..

Which story is this from?  Was it a short story I don't recognize the initials for it.
Quote
Quote

    He wasn't wearing a business suit. He had on jeans and a black leather jacket. His hair was longish, a little mussed, and he also sported a stubble of beard that gave him the kind of rakish look that would attract attention from the girls who fantasized about indulging with a bad boy.

Or, he joined the Marines after the shooting but didn't serve a full term, or much of a term at all. 

And where exactly is it placed in the book timeline?
Title: Re: Marcone's Age @ SF
Post by: raidem on September 26, 2017, 07:01:57 PM
I added the first line of the quote as I didn't include it in the previous paste.
Quote
I looked over my shoulder to see a very, very young-looking Marcone.
He wasn't wearing a business suit. He had on jeans and a black leather jacket. His hair was longish, a little mussed, and he also sported a stubble of beard that gave him the kind of rakish look that would attract attention from the girls who fantasized about indulging with a bad boy.
This quote is from White Knight during the soul gaze between Harry and Helen Beckitt when Harry is trying to decide if Helen is involved in the Ordo murders.

It (time of shootout when Amanda gets shot at apparent age 10-11) falls in Priscilla's timeline of 3-4 BSF but that depends on the age of Amanda with her being in DM as "late teens or early twenties." My math has it being between say 3-7 years BSF.  There is further restraints on the timeline of the shooting though where Marcone learns about Amanda surviving 2 years after the shooting, around the time of him taking over Chicago's criminal underworld which according to the timeline occurs 2 years BSF.  So, the shooting seems to be 4 years BSF.

BSF=Before Storm Front.
The
Quote
very, very young-looking Marcone
reference is from Harry's perspective in WK looking back at events some years prior to SF.
Title: Re: Marcone's Age @ SF
Post by: Rhetoric on September 26, 2017, 09:30:21 PM
Quote from: Storm Front
Murphy's jaw tensed, little motions at the corners of her face. Then she said, "Greg and Helen Beckitt. Three years ago, their daughter, Amanda, was killed in a cross fire. Johnny Marcone's thugs were shooting it out with some of the Jamaican gang that was trying to muscle in on the territory back then. One of them shot the little girl. She lived for three weeks in intensive care and died when they took her off life support."

Quote from: White Night
"When did you find out about the girl?"

"Two years later," [Marcone] said. "Everything was set up through a dummy corporation's trust fund."

I don't have anything to add to the conversation. Just wanted to throw in some in-book references.
Title: Re: Marcone's Age @ SF
Post by: wardenferry419 on September 26, 2017, 09:38:48 PM
How about creating a poll to estimate Marcone's age at the beginning of Storm Front?  Maybe using 5 year increments starting with Harry's age of 25.
Title: Re: Marcone's Age @ SF
Post by: raidem on September 26, 2017, 09:40:13 PM
I was thinking about that when I made it just kinda forgot, didn't get around to it.  I'll add one.  I'll start with your suggestion. 

One thing that would throw a huge curveball is if Marcone is some sort of scion where he can be much older than his appearance suggests.
Title: Re: Marcone's Age @ SF
Post by: wardenferry419 on September 26, 2017, 09:55:54 PM
I went with 36-40. So, he would have been too young for Vietnam but not too young for Grenada (1983). Marcone must have seen action somewhere. Desert Storm (1991) is a possible as well.
Title: Re: Marcone's Age @ SF
Post by: jonas on September 26, 2017, 09:59:41 PM
doesn't he still have salt n pepper hair now though? Just wondering cause that would effect my choice.
Title: Re: Marcone's Age @ SF
Post by: wardenferry419 on September 26, 2017, 10:01:39 PM
I thought the latest description used silvery but I could be mistaken.
Title: Re: Marcone's Age @ SF
Post by: raidem on September 26, 2017, 10:25:00 PM
Some years prior to SF [4* years BSF?] [my estimate was 3-7 years BSF]
Quote
I looked over my shoulder to see a very, very young-looking Marcone.
He wasn't wearing a business suit. He had on jeans and a black leather jacket. His hair was longish, a little mussed, and he also sported a stubble of beard that gave him the kind of rakish look that would attract attention from the girls who fantasized about indulging with a bad boy.
His eyes were still green—but they were the green of a summer hunter's blind, bright and intelligent and predatory, but touched with more… something. Humor, maybe. More life.
And he was skinnier. Not a lot skinnier or anything, but it surprised me how much younger it and the other minor changes made him look.

SF: Marcone's appearance during first Harry/Marcone encounter
Quote
Gentleman Johnny Marcone didn't look like the sort of man who would have my legs broken or my jaw wired shut. His salt-and-pepper hair was cut short, and there were lines from sun and smiling etched into the corners of his eyes. His eyes were the green of well-worn dollar bills. He seemed more like a college football coach: good-looking, tanned, athletic, and enthusiastic. The impression was reinforced by the men he kept with him.

SG: [Don't put Skin Game age down in poll, only Storm Front age]
Quote
Seated at her right hand, wearing a charcoal-grey suit, was Gentleman Johnnie Marcone, Baron of Chicago under the Unseelie Accords—and made so, at least in part, by my own signature. There might have been slightly more silver at his temples than the last time I’d seen him, but it only made him look more distinguished. Otherwise, he looked exactly as he always did: calm, alert, impeccably groomed, and as merciful as a lawn mower’s blade.

So yeah, Marcone has salt and pepper hair as of SF that is going more salt than pepper, aka silver.
Title: Re: Marcone's Age @ SF
Post by: Rhetoric on September 26, 2017, 11:13:15 PM
Found all the relevant descriptions that I could. I might be missing others.

Quote from: Storm Front
His salt-and-pepper hair was cut short, and there were lines from sun and smiling etched into the corners of his eyes.

Quote from: Fool Moon
His skin was weatherworn, with an outdoorsman's deep tan. Creases showed at the corners of his eyes and mouth, as though from smiling, but those smiles were rarely sincere.

Quote from: Death Masks
Central casting would have placed him as the genial next-door neighbor. He didn't have the usual boater's tan, it being February and all, but the crow's-feet at the corners of his pale green eyes remained. He looked a lot like the fictional public image he projected-that of a normal, respectable businessman, an American tale of middle class made good.

Quote from: Dead Beat
He was a man a little over average height, somewhere in the late prime of his life, his dark hair flecked with grey.

Quote from: White Night
He was an inch or two above average height, and had looked like an extremely fit forty-year-old ever since I had known him.

Quote from: Changes
He looked like a man in his mature prime, neat and precise from his haircut to his polished leather shoes.

Quote from: Aftermath
His short, conservatively cut hair was dark, except for just enough silver at his temples to announce a man in his physical and mental prime.

Quote from: Skin Game
There might have been slightly more silver at his temples than the last time I’d seen him, but it only made him look more distinguished. Otherwise, he looked exactly as he always did: calm, alert, impeccably groomed, and as merciful as a lawn mower’s blade.

It appears as though somewhere between Dead Beat and Aftermath, Butcher decided to swap the salt-and-pepper look out for greying temples. That, or Marcone started getting fancy with hair dye.

Also, I don't know how much control Butcher exerted over the comics' character designs, but it's worth noting that in the comics Marcone's hair is colored grey overall.
Title: Re: Marcone's Age @ SF
Post by: jonas on September 27, 2017, 12:46:54 AM
Yeah I went with 36-40 too, but 40-45 might be more accurate. However at that age I would expect more mention of passing his prime, so stuck him as slightly younger.
Title: Re: Marcone's Age @ SF
Post by: raidem on September 27, 2017, 12:50:34 AM
Yeah, I have thought the comics have gotten his age wrong based off his hair.  He looks too old in them.

It is interesting though Harry says marcone has looked like a forty year old ever since he has known him in wk.

I still think he might be a scion that chose so his apparent age may be significantly different than his actual age.
Title: Re: Marcone's Age @ SF
Post by: Mira on September 27, 2017, 01:51:47 AM
Quote
Quote from: White Night

    He was an inch or two above average height, and had looked like an extremely fit forty-year-old ever since I had known him.


Quote from: Changes

    He looked like a man in his mature prime, neat and precise from his haircut to his polished leather shoes.


One has to ask, what age is considered "prime?"   That has different meanings depending on the age and sex of the observer, it could mean anywhere from mid to late twenties to fifty...  I looked it up and physically prime is considered around the age of 30-35, but mentally/emotional prime it can be as old as fifty to sixty..   So it is possible that Marcone is in his mid to late thirties when Harry meets him in Storm Front, and is between fifty and sixty years of age as of Skin Game..  He is in good health, no doubt works out, so he may look like a man in his early forties...
Title: Re: Marcone's Age @ SF
Post by: Griffyn612 on September 27, 2017, 01:58:25 AM
My theoretical timeline for Marcone, with ages for him, Helen, and Amanda.

2014 SG - (JM-59)(HB-57)(AB-34)
2003 DM - (JM-48)(HB-46)(AB-23)
2000 SF - (JM-45)(HB-43)(AB-20)
1990 - (JM-35)(HB-33)(AB-10) Amanda is shot. 
1984 - (JM-29) End of third tour; returns to Chicago
1983 - (JM-28) Marine helo-pilot for Grenada Invasion (Operation Urgent Fury)
1980 - (JM-25)(HB-23)(AB-00) End of second tour
1980 - (JM-25) Marine helo-pilot for failed Tehran rescue (Operation Eagle Claw)
1976 - (JM-21) End of first tour
1975 - (JM-20) Marine helo-pilot for Saigon Evac (Operation Frequent Wind)
1975 - (JM-45) Marine helo-pilot for Cambodia Evac (Operation Eagle Pull)
1973 - (JM-18) Joins Marines, Helicopter pilot/crew; stationed in Saigon as post-war support.
1955 - (JM-00)

Notes:
 - During his time in Saigon, Marcone develops a strong dislike of heroin and other drugs that other soldiers use to cope with deployment, seeing friends lose themselves to them. 
 - At the same time, he develops empathy towards orphans and other children facing hardships after the war. 
 - He witnesses corruption within the military, learning how to manipulate officials and officers with prostitution, blackmail, and bribery.
 - After Saigon, he remains in the service, making contacts and running his own little organization where he's stationed.
 - He remains I'm the military after Saigon and Tehran, feeling a sense of failure.  He remains enlisted until the successful Grenada mission gives him a sense of accomplishment.
 - After three tours, he heads to Chicago, where he hopes to use what he learned to make a name for himself.  He lasts about 6 years before he becomes a threat to the families.
Title: Re: Marcone's Age @ SF
Post by: Aminar on September 27, 2017, 02:40:46 AM
I voted 41 to 45, but the range I see as plausible in Storm Front is 40 to 43 or so. He looks middle aged, and like he's been there for a bit. Which implies 40 minimum. He's not a little older than Dresden, he's a lot. 
Title: Re: Marcone's Age @ SF
Post by: wardenferry419 on September 27, 2017, 09:14:07 AM
Damn Griffyn, your level of detail fixation is disturbing, impressive, but disturbing. I can see this as being a very accurate timeline of Marcone. Though, and I could be mistaken, I think Amanda was shot in mid-90s.
Title: Re: Marcone's Age @ SF
Post by: Griffyn612 on September 27, 2017, 11:13:36 AM
Damn Griffyn, your level of detail fixation is disturbing, impressive, but disturbing. I can see this as being a very accurate timeline of Marcone. Though, and I could be mistaken, I think Amanda was shot in mid-90s.
Harry saw her in '03 having aged approximately 7-13 years.  To get Marcone as young as possible, I went with the older end, which would put it in '90.

I think the participation in Tehran is a bit of a stretch, but since they used Marine choppers and pilots, it's hard to resist putting him there.  It'd also feed into a no-man-left-behind attitude.
Title: Re: Marcone's Age @ SF
Post by: wardenferry419 on September 27, 2017, 11:52:41 AM
I did a quick check on the shooting and Murphy says in SF Chapter 15 that Amanda was shot 3 years prior. So, that would put it in a 95 to 97 timeframe.
Title: Re: Marcone's Age @ SF
Post by: wardenferry419 on September 27, 2017, 11:55:03 AM
A few years of guilt, worry, and obsession could make a dark-haired man into salt and pepper.
Title: Re: Marcone's Age @ SF
Post by: Kindler on September 27, 2017, 01:06:23 PM
I did a quick check on the shooting and Murphy says in SF Chapter 15 that Amanda was shot 3 years prior. So, that would put it in a 95 to 97 timeframe.

That would mean that in three years, Marcone went from thug/lieutenant/muscle/hitter/whateverhewas to running organized crime in Chicago. That's... positively meteoric.

Though I'd assume that Harry taking down Bianca in Grave Peril was what gave him a stranglehold.
Title: Re: Marcone's Age @ SF
Post by: jonas on September 27, 2017, 01:15:21 PM
That would mean that in three years, Marcone went from thug/lieutenant/muscle/hitter/whateverhewas to running organized crime in Chicago. That's... positively meteoric.

Though I'd assume that Harry taking down Bianca in Grave Peril was what gave him a stranglehold.
Mmm yes, Harry has done much  to cement a small time 'barony' into a legit lordship.
Title: Re: Marcone's Age @ SF
Post by: Aminar on September 27, 2017, 02:31:56 PM
Mmm yes, Harry has done much  to cement a small time 'barony' into a legit lordship.
Not that much. Marcone seemed pretty established in Storm Front. Definitly not, on top for less than three years established.
Title: Re: Marcone's Age @ SF
Post by: jonas on September 27, 2017, 02:36:21 PM
Not that much. Marcone seemed pretty established in Storm Front. Definitly not, on top for less than three years established.
Yes that much, He was established as Baron Johnny Marcone in SF, Now He's a freestanding lord with rights of his own, who Harry helped secure not just once, but twice because of Mab's request.
Title: Re: Marcone's Age @ SF
Post by: raidem on September 27, 2017, 03:06:09 PM
Great Find Wardenferry419 and rhetoric; It has now been established Shootout occurred 3 years BSF
I did a quick check on the shooting and Murphy says in SF Chapter 15 that Amanda was shot 3 years prior. So, that would put it in a 95 to 97 timeframe.
Quote
Murphy's jaw tensed, little motions at the corners of her face. Then she said, "Greg and Helen Beckitt. Three years ago, their daughter, Amanda, was killed in a cross fire.

Johnny Marcone's thugs were shooting it out with some of the Jamaican gang that was trying to muscle in on the territory back then. One of them shot the little girl. She lived for three weeks in intensive care and died when they took her off life support."
I didn't say anything. But I thought of Mrs. Beckitt's numb face and dead eyes.
"The Beckitts attempted to lodge a wrongful death suit against Johnny Marcone, but Marcone's lawyers were too good. They got it thrown out before it even went to court. And they never found the man who shot the little girl. Word has it that Marcone offered to pay them blood money. Make reparation. But they turned him down."
Title: Re: Marcone's Age @ SF
Post by: Rhetoric on September 27, 2017, 03:21:12 PM
... Yeah, great job.
Title: Re: Marcone's Age @ SF
Post by: raidem on September 27, 2017, 03:36:56 PM
Ok, let's review...
He had this appearance in a soulgaze between Harry and Demeter looking back  years prior to WK,  years prior to SF according to Priscilla's timeline.  (3 years BSF)
Quote
I looked over my shoulder to see a very, very young-looking Marcone.
He wasn't wearing a business suit. He had on jeans and a black leather jacket. His hair was longish, a little mussed, and he also sported a stubble of beard that gave him the kind of rakish look that would attract attention from the girls who fantasized about indulging with a bad boy.
His eyes were still green—but they were the green of a summer hunter's blind, bright and intelligent and predatory, but touched with more… something. Humor, maybe. More life.
And he was skinnier. Not a lot skinnier or anything, but it surprised me how much younger it and the other minor changes made him look. [Age:?] [BSF]
In 3 years time come Storm Front, Marcone looks like this in his interaction with Harry...
Quote
Gentleman Johnny Marcone didn't look like the sort of man who would have my legs broken or my jaw wired shut. His salt-and-pepper hair was cut short, and there were lines from sun and smiling etched into the corners of his eyes. His eyes were the green of well-worn dollar bills. He seemed more like a college football coach: good-looking, tanned, athletic, and enthusiastic. The impression was reinforced by the men he kept with him.

So, Amanda Beckitt's apparent age in soulgaze at time of shooting is 10 to 11.  Her age in Death Masks when Harry follows Marcone to a nursing home is described as late teens, early twenties.  DM occurs ~6 years after her shooting, maybe a little more than that if Jim isn't so hard on keeping to a strict timeline.  I'd have Amanda's birth at around 13 or 14 BSF if Harry's perception of Amanda via soulgaze is correct.  So she would be (16-17) or late teens not early twenties come Harry seeing her in DM.
Title: Re: Marcone's Age @ SF
Post by: Mira on September 27, 2017, 08:42:44 PM
Ok, let's review...
He had this appearance in a soulgaze between Harry and Demeter looking back  years prior to WK,  years prior to SF according to Priscilla's timeline.  (3 years BSF)In 3 years time come Storm Front, Marcone looks like this in his interaction with Harry...
So, Amanda Beckitt's apparent age in soulgaze at time of shooting is 10 to 11.  Her age in Death Masks when Harry follows Marcone to a nursing home is described as late teens, early twenties.  DM occurs ~6 years after her shooting, maybe a little more than that if Jim isn't so hard on keeping to a strict timeline.  I'd have Amanda's birth at around 13 or 14 BSF if Harry's perception of Amanda via soulgaze is correct.  So she would be (16-17) or late teens not early twenties come Harry seeing her in DM.

Yeah, that kind of wear and tear screams late thirties early forties, or a man in his late prime.  Depending on genes and lifestyle many men can look like that well into their early sixties as of Skin Game.
Title: Re: Marcone's Age @ SF
Post by: Griffyn612 on September 27, 2017, 09:12:20 PM
I did a quick check on the shooting and Murphy says in SF Chapter 15 that Amanda was shot 3 years prior. So, that would put it in a 95 to 97 timeframe.
That doesn't make much sense.  Harry saw Marcone in the memory, and commented on how very, very young he looked.  Which would only be 3 years younger than he was in SF.  Which is when he looked like he was in his forties.  Even if he was 40 in SF, and 37 during the shooting, and he had a lot of stress that aged him, he still wouldn't look very, very young to Harry.
Title: Re: Marcone's Age @ SF
Post by: Thatguywhocomesaround on September 27, 2017, 09:15:22 PM
I can't buy him being over 31-35 in SF. Okay, a little - but it in my head it fits more. Of course, this is fiction and Marcone has displayed some slightly superhuman feats. He's extremely athletic.

Able to speed attack supernatural creatures with knife attacks, dodge an attacking flying Nicodemus, throw a knife through a rope, jump across a detaching train. He's done several things physically early in the series which points to him being younger.

Not to say someone upper middle aged and over can't be physically capable, but it catches up to you, does it not? Murphy for example - a big part about last book was her injury and her getting older. Harry and Murphy are about the same age - Marcone has anywhere from five to twenty years on them (we'll assume based on this thread) yet has consistently shown to have superior reflexes, physical prowess, and speed in some regards.

Title: Re: Marcone's Age @ SF
Post by: Griffyn612 on September 27, 2017, 09:32:16 PM
I can't buy him being over 31-35 in SF. Okay, a little - but it in my head it fits more. Of course, this is fiction and Marcone has displayed some slightly superhuman feats. He's extremely athletic.

Able to speed attack supernatural creatures with knife attacks, dodge an attacking flying Nicodemus, throw a knife through a rope, jump across a detaching train. He's done several things physically early in the series which points to him being younger.

Not to say someone upper middle aged and over can't be physically capable, but it catches up to you, does it not? Murphy for example - a big part about last book was her injury and her getting older. Harry and Murphy are about the same age - Marcone has anywhere from five to twenty years on them (we'll assume based on this thread) yet has consistently shown to have superior reflexes, physical prowess, and speed in some regards.
Do you think Hugh Jackman could do those things?  Because he's 48 right now.  The same age as Marcone in DM if he was 45 in SF.  I don't recall Marcone doing anything that a physically fit former Marine couldn't do, even into his fifties. 

Hell, Scott Glenn is a former Marine that could do most of what Marcone does, and he's 76.
(https://media.gq.com/photos/5697dcaaddf2526d190fa448/3:2/w_880/how-I-got-my-body-gq-0216-2.jpg)
Title: Re: Marcone's Age @ SF
Post by: raidem on September 27, 2017, 09:41:05 PM
In white knight, Harry describes him as a "extremely fit 40 year old" but with the caveat that he has looked that way ever since Harry has known him.

If we take the 40 years correctly at time of white knight, that would make him 33 at time of storm front.
Title: Re: Marcone's Age @ SF
Post by: raidem on September 27, 2017, 10:20:20 PM
Thanks rhetoric for providing quotes that somehow I overlooked til another alluded to them.

To be fair, I often use two browsers both edge and chrome on this site.  For some reason, I can't format in edge, so if I bring up the website in edge and want to do any formatting, I change to chrome. This website also takes time to load or update after I post so it gets kinda sluggish.  Anyways I missed them, so this is me recognizing them. :)
Title: Re: Marcone's Age @ SF
Post by: wardenferry419 on September 27, 2017, 11:42:07 PM
Harry, himself, noted that there were small changes in Marcone's appearance from the Beckitt soulgaze that seem to make a significant difference in Marcone's overall appearance. To be taken as a serious threat and criminal leader he had to appear as a serious threat and criminal leader and less like the adult but roguish image that Harry saw in the soulgaze.
Title: Re: Marcone's Age @ SF
Post by: Rhetoric on September 27, 2017, 11:50:36 PM
No problem, it's all good. ;D

Anyway, as for Harry's perception of Marcone's age in Helen's soulgaze...

Quote from: White Night
I looked over my shoulder to see a very, very young-looking Marcone.

He wasn't wearing a business suit. He had on jeans and a black leather jacket. His hair was longish, a little mussed, and he also sported a stubble of beard that gave him the kind of rakish look that would attract attention from the girls who fantasized about indulging with a bad boy.

His eyes were still green—but they were the green of a summer hunter's blind, bright and intelligent and predatory, but touched with more... something. Humor, maybe. More life. And he was skinnier. Not a lot skinnier or anything, but it surprised me how much younger it and the other minor changes made him look.

[...]

Marcone had looked a lot younger when he wore his hair longer, less neat, and dressed more casually. Or maybe he'd just looked younger before he'd seen Helen's daughter die.

It seems like "young" was very subjective in this case, referring more to Marcone's... liveliness, I guess, as opposed to his literal, physical age.
Title: Re: Marcone's Age @ SF
Post by: raidem on September 28, 2017, 01:04:10 PM
Quote
That doesn't make much sense.  Harry saw Marcone in the memory, and commented on how very, very young he looked.  Which would only be 3 years younger than he was in SF.  Which is when he looked like he was in his forties.  Even if he was 40 in SF, and 37 during the shooting, and he had a lot of stress that aged him, he still wouldn't look very, very young to Harry.

Which is why I think something is off.  First, I don't think we can put more weight on the "ever since I had known him" piece of "He...had looked like an extremely fit forty-year-old ever since I had known him" which occurs 7 books in than his earliest description in the books.
 
Storm Front.
One option is that he might be a scion that chose after that shootout where Amanda gets shot.  It was a pivotal event in his life.  He chose to be a professional monster.
Quote
I am a professional monster.
It sounds pretentious. After all, I’m not a flesh-devouring ghoul, hiding behind a human mask until it is time to gorge. I’m no vampire, to drain the blood or soul from my victim, no ogre, no demon, no cursed beast from the spirit world dwelling amid the unsuspecting sheep of humanity. I’m not even possessed of the mystic abilities of a mortal wizard.
But they will never be what I am. One and all, those beings were born to be what they are.
I made a choice.

So prior to the choice, his apparent age was in stasis similar to Sarissa's.  After choosing, he manifested a more mature look.  It has to be as reasonable as going from human to ogre, something completely different.  It would also put him in some way either part sidhe or maybe distant scion of vadderung.  Another option other than changeling/scion is magical spell that morphs his looks.  We have seen that employed quite a few times, his would need to be much more persistent and durable.
Title: Re: Marcone's Age @ SF
Post by: Kindler on September 28, 2017, 01:14:14 PM
No problem, it's all good. ;D

Anyway, as for Harry's perception of Marcone's age in Helen's soulgaze...

It seems like "young" was very subjective in this case, referring more to Marcone's... liveliness, I guess, as opposed to his literal, physical age.

Seeing a little girl get shot in the stomach and blaming yourself ages you.
Title: Re: Marcone's Age @ SF
Post by: Tami Seven on October 02, 2017, 03:35:42 AM
I've always had the feeling that Marcone was approximately 10 years older than Harry, 34-36 age range as of SF.
Title: Re: Marcone's Age @ SF
Post by: raidem on October 02, 2017, 12:20:18 PM
I could try a poll starting at 31, with 3 year age spans.