ParanetOnline

The Dresden Files => DF Spoilers => Topic started by: EBRIEN on August 01, 2017, 11:48:36 PM

Title: Marvra and Kemmler (Deadbeat)
Post by: EBRIEN on August 01, 2017, 11:48:36 PM
I feel like I missed something. Did we ever learn why Mavra needed the Book?

Thanks--Brien
Title: Re: Marvra and Kemmler (Deadbeat)
Post by: Griffyn612 on August 01, 2017, 11:53:00 PM
It contained things that could be used against the Black Court.  She didn't want it in anyone else's hands.  Harry tells her at the end that he read it, and knows how it could be used against her kind.
Title: Re: Marvra and Kemmler (Deadbeat)
Post by: DonBugen on August 02, 2017, 12:34:59 AM
I feel, though, that we haven't seen the end of her. Didn't Jim say that she would appear in Mirror Mirror, actually as an ally? I wonder if she was able to use the Word, too. She does have power.
Title: Re: Marvra and Kemmler (Deadbeat)
Post by: raidem on August 02, 2017, 01:14:58 AM
There was a woj on cowl and mavra.

I believe the question asked about both and their longevity going forward. 

From what I recall, the woj suggests mavras end is coming sooner than later.  So I took it that Cowl's storyline will continue longer than Mavras.
Title: Re: Marvra and Kemmler (Deadbeat)
Post by: Griffyn612 on August 02, 2017, 01:39:46 AM
There was a woj on cowl and mavra.

I believe the question asked about both and their longevity going forward. 

From what I recall, the woj suggests mavras end is coming sooner than later.  So I took that coals storyline will continue longer than mavras.
Or, if you're a fan of time travel theories, her story is already over.   ;)
Title: Re: Marvra and Kemmler (Deadbeat)
Post by: Snark Knight on August 02, 2017, 02:29:05 AM
I feel, though, that we haven't seen the end of her. Didn't Jim say that she would appear in Mirror Mirror, actually as an ally? I wonder if she was able to use the Word, too. She does have power.

The WOJ was ambiguous to an extent, but given that his phrasing was 'fast ally' I think prevailing opinion was that she's an ally to evil Mirror Dresden. Prime Harry might collaborate with her temporarily if it was necessary to confront a mutual enemy he considered even worse, but I don't think he could condone her as more than a temporary truce of necessity.
Title: Re: Marvra and Kemmler (Deadbeat)
Post by: kazimmoinuddin on August 02, 2017, 02:53:30 AM
I have this idea that the dar hollow ritual could be adapted to use BCV or even ghouls as a power source. We know it is said Dracula failed when he created the BCV, so this adapted ritual could be a success. To make it as powerful as possible, it would require the sacrifice of the remaining BCV elders. If BCV can be affected by necromancy, I guessed they could be a fuel source, in necromancy violent deaths and older bodies work the best, so the elders are perfect.
Title: Re: Marvra and Kemmler (Deadbeat)
Post by: Rasins on August 02, 2017, 07:26:24 PM
Given that Kemmler was a necromancer, it fits that anything dead would want to limit his knowledge from getting out into the general public (of the supernatural world)
Title: Re: Marvra and Kemmler (Deadbeat)
Post by: kazimmoinuddin on August 03, 2017, 04:58:58 AM
My money is mavra wanting the book for a power play on the BCV, to restore it and her own power on a large scale.
Title: Re: Marvra and Kemmler (Deadbeat)
Post by: forumghost on August 03, 2017, 06:40:57 AM
Given that Kemmler was a necromancer, it fits that anything dead would want to limit his knowledge from getting out into the general public (of the supernatural world)

But if that was all she wanted she could have just left it be and the Council would have probably destroyed the thing.

No, she wanted something that was in those pages for her own use alright. And Harry is gonna be in shit up to his elbows when everyone finds out that the Black Court is back (or something along those lines) just because he wants in Murphy's pants.
Title: Re: Marvra and Kemmler (Deadbeat)
Post by: KurtinStGeorge on August 03, 2017, 07:51:44 AM
The WOJ was ambiguous to an extent, but given that his phrasing was 'fast ally' I think prevailing opinion was that she's an ally to evil Mirror Dresden. Prime Harry might collaborate with her temporarily if it was necessary to confront a mutual enemy he considered even worse, but I don't think he could condone her as more than a temporary truce of necessity.

What Mavra can't tell the difference between the two Harry's?  Prime Harry could work with Mavra, but for a different goal than what Mavra would expect. 
Title: Re: Marvra and Kemmler (Deadbeat)
Post by: jonas on August 03, 2017, 09:37:06 AM
What Mavra can't tell the difference between the two Harry's?  Prime Harry could work with Mavra, but for a different goal than what Mavra would expect.
What if Prime Harry is more insightful than !Harry and uses Necromancy vs Mavra where !Harry cannot.
Title: Re: Marvra and Kemmler (Deadbeat)
Post by: wardenferry419 on August 03, 2017, 11:16:22 AM
Speaking of which Lara, Mavra, and Cowl have been absentee for the last third of the series. Are there any other villians that need to make a re-appearance? Additionally, what has been going on with the Senior Council since Changes? I really want to see their reaction to the new super-charged Harry.
Title: Re: Marvra and Kemmler (Deadbeat)
Post by: Quantus on August 03, 2017, 01:55:04 PM
Speaking of which Lara, Mavra, and Cowl have been absentee for the last third of the series. Are there any other villians that need to make a re-appearance? Additionally, what has been going on with the Senior Council since Changes? I really want to see their reaction to the new super-charged Harry.
Some of them have a recurring pattern, jim has acknowledged vaguely. Like the Denarians every five books, for example. 

I expect most if not all of those to appear in the next one for the Peace Talks (probably not Cowl, at least not as an envoy).
Title: Re: Marvra and Kemmler (Deadbeat)
Post by: Snark Knight on August 03, 2017, 03:43:29 PM
Some of them have a recurring pattern, jim has acknowledged vaguely. Like the Denarians every five books, for example. 
I expect most if not all of those to appear in the next one for the Peace Talks (probably not Cowl, at least not as an envoy).

Skin Game threw me for a bit of a loop with that. I'd kept expecting at least a B-plot with vampires, since one court or another has been significant somehow in every multiple of three up until SG.
Title: Re: Marvra and Kemmler (Deadbeat)
Post by: raidem on August 03, 2017, 03:58:24 PM
Quote
Or, if you're a fan of time travel theories, her story is already over.

You know me too well.
Title: Re: Marvra and Kemmler (Deadbeat)
Post by: Quantus on August 03, 2017, 05:17:45 PM
Skin Game threw me for a bit of a loop with that. I'd kept expecting at least a B-plot with vampires, since one court or another has been significant somehow in every multiple of three up until SG.
Damn, good point.  OK, sooooo....What if Hades is somehow the progenitor of the White Court?  Their official Court Language is from the right general region.  Maybe the spirit half of that particular breed of "half-born" was a greco-roman something? 

Im reaching hard for something, help me out
Title: Re: Marvra and Kemmler (Deadbeat)
Post by: Snark Knight on August 03, 2017, 05:28:20 PM
I'm pretty sure it will just be time to catch up with the vampires in book 16.
Title: Re: Marvra and Kemmler (Deadbeat)
Post by: KurtinStGeorge on August 03, 2017, 07:12:14 PM
Damn, good point.  OK, sooooo....What if Hades is somehow the progenitor of the White Court?  Their official Court Language is from the right general region.  Maybe the spirit half of that particular breed of "half-born" was a greco-roman something? 

Im reaching hard for something, help me out

I don't know what kind of research Jim did before he chose Etruscan as the native language of the White Court, but I know they predate the Romans and according to the wiki article I found on them their civilization may have had some ancient Greek influences.  By ancient Greek I mean Homer and the Trojan War era Greeks, not the later more advanced city states era with people like Pericles, Leonidas, Socrates and Plato. 

There is something I do remember about the Etruscans from a history class I took which could relate to White Court.  The historian and story teller Herodotus; sometimes referred to as the Father of History and at other times as the Father of Lies, was widely traveled and was shocked by the behavior of Etruscan women.  In Athens women were decidedly second class citizens.  If you; assuming you're a man, was invited to diner at someones home, you wouldn't see the women of the house unless they were slaves serving the diner.  A man's wife and daughters were kept cloistered most of the time.  (The same isn't true in Sparta, but they were really weird in other ways.)  If you were a women invited to the same Athenian diner, you were most likely a Hetaira, essentially a highly paid courtesan.  Etruscan women on the other hand seemed to enjoy a measure of equality with their male counterparts.  At a similar diner they would talk politics and the news of the day along with the men; and if Herodotus is correct, their ideas and opinions were no less to be held valid then the men's.  More importantly, Etruscan women had distinct legal rights and could pass down their names and titles to their children.  The Romans and Greeks said Etruscan women were lewd and lascivious because they did scandalous things like going out in public unattended by men, getting under the same blanket their husband was using at a winter banquet, and they rode horses and some had their own chariots, shocking!

So an ancient civilization were women have some degree of equality.  A perfect example for someone who wants to seize power like Lara or; I can't remember her name, the late head of Malvora clan.  It makes the White Court's emergence in that place and era seem plausible.   
Title: Re: Marvra and Kemmler (Deadbeat)
Post by: jonas on August 03, 2017, 10:03:55 PM
Damn, good point.  OK, sooooo....What if Hades is somehow the progenitor of the White Court?  Their official Court Language is from the right general region.  Maybe the spirit half of that particular breed of "half-born" was a greco-roman something? 

Im reaching hard for something, help me out
Are's and Aphrodite had triplets named, terror, lust and despair. ;) one Greco-Roman connection.

I thought every 3 books was a N connection, not Vamp connection? It should work that way.
So 3, Cowl and the poison gifts, 6 Lord Raith, Hwwbh, BCV, ect. 9 BCV, Glau, Whatever came out of AT 12 Two different contingents of RCV fighting with different goals, targeting WC (again) 15... The whore of Babylon Mrs. Lartessa? idk, think it's wrapped up between her, the objects themselves(anti-N/ outsider weapons yea?) and Nic's shattered soul.
I'd still keep looking for any hidden Vampires in SG I guess or better/clearer N connects.
Title: Re: Marvra and Kemmler (Deadbeat)
Post by: Griffyn612 on August 03, 2017, 11:10:16 PM
Are's and Aphrodite had triplets named, terror, lust and despair. ;) one Greco-Roman connection.
Interesting

Quote
9 BCV, Glau, Whatever came out of AT
That was book 8. Book 9 was White Night.
Title: Re: Marvra and Kemmler (Deadbeat)
Post by: kazimmoinuddin on August 03, 2017, 11:27:06 PM
The council expert on the vampire courts was killed, but I. Wonder what happened to his gathered lord. I could see mavra and cowl eager for the parts concerning the BCV, that combined with necromancy would have epic consequences.
Title: Re: Marvra and Kemmler (Deadbeat)
Post by: jonas on August 03, 2017, 11:30:58 PM
Interesting
That was book 8. Book 9 was White Night.
Oh, oops. I wondered why I had to strain on that. WN is easier, We got Raith which covers vamps and N. Cowl, Elaine, ect.
Title: Re: Marvra and Kemmler (Deadbeat)
Post by: Snark Knight on August 04, 2017, 12:57:17 AM
The council expert on the vampire courts was killed, but I. Wonder what happened to his gathered lord. I could see mavra and cowl eager for the parts concerning the BCV, that combined with necromancy would have epic consequences.

I'm pretty sure "Cowl" doesn't need Simon's notebooks...
Title: Re: Marvra and Kemmler (Deadbeat)
Post by: wardenferry419 on August 04, 2017, 12:58:44 AM
Nobody likes to lose a journal.
Title: Re: Marvra and Kemmler (Deadbeat)
Post by: vultur on August 04, 2017, 05:38:17 AM
Are's and Aphrodite had triplets named, terror, lust and despair. ;) one Greco-Roman connection.

That's somewhat of a stretch.  The children of Ares and Aphrodite are usually Harmonia (Harmony), Phobos (Fear), and Deimos (Terror), or just Phobos and Deimos.

Later on Eros and Anteros (gods of love) can be listed as children of Ares and Aphrodite.

But Eros is love and desire, not merely lust (though that's included), and Phobos/Deimos are more like battlefield fears (panic/rout/terror) than despair.
Title: Re: Marvra and Kemmler (Deadbeat)
Post by: jonas on August 04, 2017, 06:44:41 AM
That's somewhat of a stretch.  The children of Ares and Aphrodite are usually Harmonia (Harmony), Phobos (Fear), and Deimos (Terror), or just Phobos and Deimos.

Later on Eros and Anteros (gods of love) can be listed as children of Ares and Aphrodite.

But Eros is love and desire, not merely lust (though that's included), and Phobos/Deimos are more like battlefield fears (panic/rout/terror) than despair.
well,
Quote
In Greek mythology, Eros (/ˈɪərɒs/ or US: /ˈɛrɒs/, /ˈɛroʊs/;[2] Greek: Ἔρως, "Desire")[3] was the Greek god of sexual attraction. His Roman counterpart was Cupid[4] ("desire").

Phobos (Ancient Greek: Φόβος, pronounced [pʰóbos], meaning "fear") is the personification of fear in Greek mythology.
Phobos in Greek literally means fear (Ancient Greek: Φόβος). Spartan soldiers would idolize Phobos, because he symbolized discipline, and consistency of the armed forces.

Deimos[pronunciation?] (Ancient Greek: Δεῖμος, pronounced [dêːmos], meaning "dread"), is the Greek god of terror.
While none of what you say is inherently untrue,(although I give your Eros proclamation a stink eye on it being in the direction of a pure historical opinion at this pointin space/time)but purely looking at it from aspects of power, not from beliefs around those powers the result is the same there. fear, terror, lust in origin. All lines up.
Title: Re: Marvra and Kemmler (Deadbeat)
Post by: Quantus on August 04, 2017, 12:42:48 PM
well,While none of what you say is inherently untrue,(although I give your Eros proclamation a stink eye on it being in the direction of a pure historical opinion at this pointin space/time)but purely looking at it from aspects of power, not from beliefs around those powers the result is the same there. fear, terror, lust in origin. All lines up.
There's also the roman evolution to consider, much like Hades to pluto.

Cupid was re-imagined somewhat, was a bit more specifically "the god of desire, erotic love, attraction and affection." and often associated with Baccus in roman art.  The difference between the Uncontrollable Desire that his arrow's imparted and real Love was the primary theme of the Cupid and Psyche (http://Cupid and Psyche) tale, too.


All this to say I love the idea that the Wampires are a greek mythos offshoot race.  Greek myths were full of that
Title: Re: Marvra and Kemmler (Deadbeat)
Post by: Con on August 04, 2017, 12:57:45 PM
Hmm I've always been of the opinion the Wampire's Hunger is from the Outside. It doesn't fit that they'd be from a Greek offshoot as all the Greek beings or descendants of are part of the Natural Order whether they've turned it Sidhe or a Guardians of Items of Power like Hades.

Plus it fits in with the theme that the Venatores are fighting the Outside and Elder Gods as they have a link to them already, like they're trying to fight their own dual natures.
Title: Re: Marvra and Kemmler (Deadbeat)
Post by: Quantus on August 04, 2017, 01:09:18 PM
Hmm I've always been of the opinion the Wampire's Hunger is from the Outside. It doesn't fit that they'd be from a Greek offshoot as all the Greek beings or descendants of are part of the Natural Order whether they've turned it Sidhe or a Guardians of Items of Power like Hades.

Plus it fits in with the theme that the Venatores are fighting the Outside and Elder Gods as they have a link to them already, like they're trying to fight their own dual natures.
How are the Wampires not "part of the natural order" where Gorgans and cyclopes and, well, a lot of the Fomor still are?


Personally, I think the Blacks might be the Outsider fueled ones, after this WOJ that said: "Black Court Vamps are a different story. They're actually tainted by something hideous and unworldly." They are driven to kill to survive. They don't really have a lot of choice about it. They enjoy being what they are, and doing what they do. They can be sad that they don't have someone who loves them, or upset that the world has passed them by and has changed on them, but at the end of the day, they're basically black-hearts who occasionally pull out a few of the tattered remains of their humanity, fail to fit back into them like they used to, and get maudlin about their glory days when they could watch the sun rise.

Combine that with the fact that Drakul is "something entirely unhuman that got trapped in human form" and Dracula created the Black Court "in an effort to win his father's approval"  Im currently thinking that Drakul is a former Outsider that got trapped/stuck/transformed into a Mortal somehow, and Dracula was trying to tap into Outsider powers somehow (hoping to impress dad) and the accidental result was becoming the first Black Court Vampire.
Title: Re: Marvra and Kemmler (Deadbeat)
Post by: Con on August 04, 2017, 01:24:14 PM
I've always imagined their demon side to be something like a bloodline curse like the Loup Garou curse, not a natural part of the world order, but I guess I could be wrong the emotions they feed on and their antithesis are part of the natural order in a lot of animals. or at least mammals.

I could have been confusing Black Court and White Court in my mind now that you mention it.
Title: Re: Marvra and Kemmler (Deadbeat)
Post by: Quantus on August 04, 2017, 01:51:21 PM
I've always imagined their demon side to be something like a bloodline curse like the Loup Garou curse, not a natural part of the world order, but I guess I could be wrong the emotions they feed on and their antithesis are part of the natural order in a lot of animals. or at least mammals.

I could have been confusing Black Court and White Court in my mind now that you mention it.
What gets me about the White Court and makes me want to say they are more part of Nature than the rest is that they are Born, (can) retain their Soul's, and are "mortal" in the sense of Free Willed beings that could be a Denarian or a Knight or whatever.  Of the 3-7 Vampire Courts out there, that's special so far. 
Title: Re: Marvra and Kemmler (Deadbeat)
Post by: jonas on August 04, 2017, 08:06:08 PM
Quote
All this to say I love the idea that the Wampires are a greek mythos offshoot race.  Greek myths were full of that
Mmm i'm gonna make a complete and total Wag off of that, just to see if i'm right myself :)
In Fight Night
(click to show/hide)
Just because if a connection exists, what better place for it to come up?
Title: Re: Marvra and Kemmler (Deadbeat)
Post by: LordDresden2 on August 05, 2017, 04:26:04 AM


Combine that with the fact that Drakul is "something entirely unhuman that got trapped in human form" and Dracula created the Black Court "in an effort to win his father's approval"

Could you direct me to a WoJ on that?  That's a new one on me.
Title: Re: Marvra and Kemmler (Deadbeat)
Post by: Quantus on August 07, 2017, 12:32:08 PM
Could you direct me to a WoJ on that?  That's a new one on me.
Sure thing, Here you go.. It's the second part, but the Black Court portion of the "Are they Evil" part is also informative

Quote
2015 AMA
Are all red courts and black court vampires evil?
This is a pretty huge question and depends a lot on how you view the world.
Red Court vampires, by definition, to become a vampire, have to murder someone else to become what they are. They have to end another person's life to satisfy a desire that does not /need/ to be satisfied in order for them to continue living. Every single one of them makes a choice to sate that desire rather than allow another human being to live--the Fellowship of St. Giles proves that.

(Of course, there are shades of grey involved--a half-vampire who was kept starving and without water in a basement for three days before they were thrown a mortal has a much more difficult time making a clear-headed choice than a half-vampire who was restrained yet cared for by a group of religiously fanatic monks at a Fellowship stronghold, but there's still a choice being made.)

That could, by some people, be considered a working definition of evil. Sometimes unfortunate, sometimes understandable as to how someone could make that choice, but evil nonetheless.

Black Court Vamps are a different story. They're actually tainted by something hideous and unworldly. They are driven to kill to survive. They don't really have a lot of choice about it. They enjoy being what they are, and doing what they do. They can be sad that they don't have someone who loves them, or upset that the world has passed them by and has changed on them, but at the end of the day, they're basically black-hearts who occasionally pull out a few of the tattered remains of their humanity, fail to fit back into them like they used to, and get maudlin about their glory days when they could watch the sun rise.

And also what is Drakul a scion of?
Drakul wasn't a scion of anything! He was something entirely unhuman that got trapped in human form. Dracula was his half-human child, who naturally had enormous paternal issues, and wound up creating himself as the first Black Court Vampire in an effort to win his father's approval.
It didn't work out so well.
Title: Re: Marvra and Kemmler (Deadbeat)
Post by: kazimmoinuddin on August 07, 2017, 09:57:08 PM
If Drakul really linked to the BCV via Dracula, then I wonder if one can affect the other. I had this theory concerning an altered version of the dark hollow ritual, using the BCV as a fuel source. It could make the ritual work, or some how affect Drakul.
Title: Re: Marvra and Kemmler (Deadbeat)
Post by: Con on August 08, 2017, 11:07:35 AM
If Drakul really linked to the BCV via Dracula, then I wonder if one can affect the other. I had this theory concerning an altered version of the dark hollow ritual, using the BCV as a fuel source. It could make the ritual work, or some how affect Drakul.

Was that you?

damn I thought that was woj. Great theory though man.

I thought the Black Court Elders Dark Hollow was one of the reasons they were a threat to Mab and why she had a hand in stopping them. White Court having got the idea of using printing press to use mortal authorities in part from Mab and the Grimm fairytales.
Title: Re: Marvra and Kemmler (Deadbeat)
Post by: jonas on August 08, 2017, 11:24:37 AM
Was that you?

damn I thought that was woj. Great theory though man.

I thought the Black Court Elders Dark Hollow was one of the reasons they were a threat to Mab and why she had a hand in stopping them. White Court having got the idea of using printing press to use mortal authorities in part from Mab and the Grimm fairytales.
They don't need a hallow though, every time they consume a life they are doing a smaller version of eating spirits. directly from people along with life.... and hopefully not the soul.
Title: Re: Marvra and Kemmler (Deadbeat)
Post by: Con on August 08, 2017, 11:34:18 AM
I think the theory was that during the Black Court Purge, the thirteen Elders of the Black COurt gathered together to perform the Dark Hollow at Tugunska where Ebenezar wiped them out. They were performing the Dark Hollow to survive and ascend from the Purge.
Title: Re: Marvra and Kemmler (Deadbeat)
Post by: Quantus on August 08, 2017, 12:32:23 PM
I think the theory was that during the Black Court Purge, the thirteen Elders of the Black COurt gathered together to perform the Dark Hollow at Tugunska where Ebenezar wiped them out. They were performing the Dark Hollow to survive and ascend from the Purge.
The Darkhallow as we've seen it would need a hell of a lot more Life than an isolated part of Siberia, no? 
Title: Re: Marvra and Kemmler (Deadbeat)
Post by: Con on August 08, 2017, 12:45:05 PM
The Darkhallow as we've seen it would need a hell of a lot more Life than an isolated part of Siberia, no? 

I think the theory was they were going to use the Black Court as the fuel. I dunno I read the theory awhile ago I think when I first joined I'll try to find it.
Title: Re: Marvra and Kemmler (Deadbeat)
Post by: Quantus on August 08, 2017, 12:48:01 PM
I think the theory was they were going to use the Black Court as the fuel. I dunno I read the theory awhile ago I think when I first joined I'll try to find it.
I think that would only get you half-way. Black Court vamps operate on necromantic energy, so they'd be playing the role of the Ghosts for the Darkhallow, but you still need an equivalent amount of Life energy to backfill the space once the Necromantic energy gets sucked in and starts creating the Vacuum.
Title: Re: Marvra and Kemmler (Deadbeat)
Post by: Con on August 08, 2017, 01:03:53 PM
I think that would only get you half-way. Black Court vamps operate on necromantic energy, so they'd be playing the role of the Ghosts for the Darkhallow, but you still need an equivalent amount of Life energy to backfill the space once the Necromantic energy gets sucked in and starts creating the Vacuum.

Well maybe they brought the population with them, I mean how deserted is the area around Chitzen Itza
Title: Re: Marvra and Kemmler (Deadbeat)
Post by: Quantus on August 08, 2017, 01:14:03 PM
Well maybe they brought the population with them, I mean how deserted is the area around Chitzen Itza
It's a dense Jungle, as opposed to a sparcly forested snow desert.  The sort of Life we are talking is on the order of Millions of mortals (and so presumably exponentially more per the Zombie rules), which is not the sort of population you can just import.
Title: Re: Marvra and Kemmler (Deadbeat)
Post by: Con on August 08, 2017, 01:38:36 PM
Hmm I found a post me referencing the theory in part where I mention the theory of Dracula accidentally made the Black Court when he attempted a dark hallow and failed. That it fits with the Black Courts empowerment through the taking of life through necromantic life sucking similar to the dark hallow.

Maybe the Black court thought the build up of life force they'd stolen was enough for the Dark Hallows life supply.
Title: Re: Marvra and Kemmler (Deadbeat)
Post by: Anubissama on August 08, 2017, 01:51:46 PM
Backing up to the main topic, the theory I had about Mavra and her need of Das Wort von Kemmler is as follows.

She knows that Kemmler Necromancy can be turned against Blampires, and she herself is a Wizard level practitioner at this point. Thus he has used Das Wort to set herself up as the main and unifying force of the Black Court, and we will see her making a come back (probably in Peace Talks during the Accords meeting) as the sole ruler of the Court. Who has also been flourishing and growing in strength lately (this is foreshadowed in "It is my birthday too" where a supposed weak and almost extinct vampire clan suddenly appears to breed new Black Court Vampire Masters).
Title: Re: Marvra and Kemmler (Deadbeat)
Post by: Con on August 08, 2017, 07:28:14 PM
I like that theory it also possibly supports my theory that the Dark Hallow and y extension the Word of Kemmler was based on the Black Court and their magic.

Could their be an adaptation of the Dark Hallow where instead of taking life it turns people into lack Court to get numbers risen again?
Title: Re: Marvra and Kemmler (Deadbeat)
Post by: jonas on August 08, 2017, 07:46:09 PM
I like that theory it also possibly supports my theory that the Dark Hallow and y extension the Word of Kemmler was based on the Black Court and their magic.

Could their be an adaptation of the Dark Hallow where instead of taking life it turns people into lack Court to get numbers risen again?
Thinking about how BLV feed, slurping down a whole life. One wonders if every time they feed it's not a miniature DH. They begin draining the life so fast the spirit gets caught up in the 'vortex' too. Instant upgrade.
Title: Re: Marvra and Kemmler (Deadbeat)
Post by: Con on August 08, 2017, 08:00:04 PM
Thinking about how BLV feed, slurping down a whole life. One wonders if every time they feed it's not a miniature DH. They begin draining the life so fast the spirit gets caught up in the 'vortex' too. Instant upgrade.
That's basically the theory yeah, but I don't wanna take too much away from Anubissama's theory of Queen Mavra. How do you think she'd use the Word of Kemmler? How do you think she'd organise her court?
Title: Re: Marvra and Kemmler (Deadbeat)
Post by: Quantus on August 08, 2017, 08:00:20 PM
Thinking about how BLV feed, slurping down a whole life. One wonders if every time they feed it's not a miniature DH. They begin draining the life so fast the spirit gets caught up in the 'vortex' too. Instant upgrade.
fwiw, this has always been my interpretation of the WOJ that alluded to the Erlking using Darkhallow mechanisms: that the Erlking added to his Power one Hunt, one Prey at a Time
Title: Re: Marvra and Kemmler (Deadbeat)
Post by: jonas on August 08, 2017, 08:06:16 PM
fwiw, this has always been my interpretation of the WOJ that alluded to the Erlking using Darkhallow mechanisms: that the Erlking added to his Power one Hunt, one Prey at a Time
Makes sense to me, hasn't it twice now shown up on Halloween? Still in his old hobbies.
Title: Re: Marvra and Kemmler (Deadbeat)
Post by: Quantus on August 08, 2017, 08:07:26 PM
Makes sense to me, hasn't it twice now shown up on Halloween? Still in his old hobbies.
And in CD he indicated that a Halloween Hunt is a yearly tradition. 
Title: Re: Marvra and Kemmler (Deadbeat)
Post by: Con on August 08, 2017, 08:15:53 PM
I wonder how Vadderung/Kringle maintains his power now that he's MORTAL that's right quantus, I said it What?! COme at me Bro!

The worship from his Einherjaar and Valkyrie can't be enough, information is obviously crucial to it given how well informed he is. Their must be something that keeps him on par with Mab enough to tell her to "get in line" or just barely avoid "tedious duels".
Title: Re: Marvra and Kemmler (Deadbeat)
Post by: Quantus on August 08, 2017, 08:38:32 PM
I wonder how Vadderung/Kringle maintains his power now that he's MORTAL that's right quantus, I said it What?! COme at me Bro!

The worship from his Einherjaar and Valkyrie can't be enough, information is obviously crucial to it given how well informed he is. Their must be something that keeps him on par with Mab enough to tell her to "get in line" or just barely avoid "tedious duels".
Blood sacrifice of babies and the cutest puppies, obviously :P
Title: Re: Marvra and Kemmler (Deadbeat)
Post by: jonas on August 08, 2017, 08:41:23 PM
That's basically the theory yeah, but I don't wanna take too much away from Anubissama's theory of Queen Mavra. How do you think she'd use the Word of Kemmler? How do you think she'd organise her court?
Depends...
In need of info, do we KNOW there were 13 BC Elders? I thought it was said to be 30 but I can't find any numbers in any listed woj at all.
Title: Re: Marvra and Kemmler (Deadbeat)
Post by: Con on August 08, 2017, 08:42:19 PM
Blood sacrifice of babies and the cutest puppies, obviously :P

Well Odin was the originator of Being Hanged I wonder if he got all the blood sacrifices from everyone being Hung.
Title: Re: Marvra and Kemmler (Deadbeat)
Post by: jonas on August 08, 2017, 08:48:49 PM
That's basically the theory yeah, but I don't wanna take too much away from Anubissama's theory of Queen Mavra. How do you think she'd use the Word of Kemmler? How do you think she'd organise her court?
Ok now that your post gave me a brain fart and I hunted up the clue I needed.
Quote
And a one-on-thirtyish fight (Mab vs the elders of the BC
I'm feeling waggish. I think the BCE were actually starting to replace old mantles held by the 30 fallen. cause ya know Dracula=son of dragon=winged serpent=fallen angel, ect. They actually both are primarily based on angelic power. So maybe Mavra want's to eat them all up and become a super angel/ fallen/ undead born goddess?
Title: Re: Marvra and Kemmler (Deadbeat)
Post by: Quantus on August 08, 2017, 08:58:19 PM
Depends...
In need of info, do we KNOW there were 13 BC Elders? I thought it was said to be 30 but I can't find any numbers in any listed woj at all.
30-ish Black Court Elders.  Thirteen is the number of Grey Council Members and the max number that can collaborate on a spell via a Circle, but it sometimes gets confused in discussion

Quote
4. if the elders of the black court could have taken mab, then HOW ON EARTH did any mere force of humans manage to go up and stake them? i mean, they should've wiped out anything that was coming after them if they can take on MAB herself...just a thought
Power in the spirit world isn't the same thing as power in the material world.  And a one-on-thirtyish fight (Mab vs the elders of the BC) is WAY different than a one-on-20,000 fight (a BC vampire against a modest mortal city).  Especially when the 20,000 know what your weaknesses are, and how to kill you with them. Smiley  And that's assuming that you don't have a saint, or an independent wizard, or a shaman, a Knight of the Cross or some other champion, or other spiritual allies on your side which was not uncommon.  Hell, for that matter, you might well be aided by vampires from the other Courts.  *Everyone* resented how powerful the Blacks had become.
Title: Re: Marvra and Kemmler (Deadbeat)
Post by: Con on August 08, 2017, 09:02:25 PM
Ah bugger their goes a crucial element of my theory.
Title: Re: Marvra and Kemmler (Deadbeat)
Post by: jonas on August 08, 2017, 10:11:15 PM
Actually, taking all the 30=30 theory out of it, and we have a being who thrives on the same stuff of necromancy and being not trying to eat a crap ton of magic, of life. Born goddess might be more accurate a description than I first thought when you account for the 'you are what you eat' rule/law/maxim(whichever), in which case she might literally become an 'inside' goddess of magic. a resident of this world. Eeek!
Title: Re: Marvra and Kemmler (Deadbeat)
Post by: kazimmoinuddin on August 09, 2017, 04:47:06 AM
To me it sounds like Drakul is a potential inmate for the well, but after it is released from its human shape cage.

Part of me hopes the BCV would be wiped out, but unless something akin to the bloodline curse is used, it would be very tricky. I am at least hoping for the remaining elders and nobles of the court get dealt with. Without the protection of their patrons, the remains of the court would be hunted and removed.
The thing is with such a limited number of elders, I doubt they would ever gather together as it would present too big a target. So it would be a big deal for them to do so.
Title: Re: Marvra and Kemmler (Deadbeat)
Post by: Rasins on August 09, 2017, 02:46:47 PM
To me it sounds like Drakul is a potential inmate for the well, but after it is released from its human shape cage.

Part of me hopes the BCV would be wiped out, but unless something akin to the bloodline curse is used, it would be very tricky. I am at least hoping for the remaining elders and nobles of the court get dealt with. Without the protection of their patrons, the remains of the court would be hunted and removed.
The thing is with such a limited number of elders, I doubt they would ever gather together as it would present too big a target. So it would be a big deal for them to do so.

IF they were actually being hunted.  There's nothing to say that they are still being hunted.  Especially with the Fellowship being decimated in Changes.
Title: Re: Marvra and Kemmler (Deadbeat)
Post by: LordDresden2 on August 10, 2017, 04:07:07 AM
30-ish Black Court Elders.  Thirteen is the number of Grey Council Members and the max number that can collaborate on a spell via a Circle, but it sometimes gets confused in discussion

I'm not sure I trust that 13 limit, either.  Harry claimed it was so way back in Storm Front, yes, but that might have been limited information on his part.  It may well be the usual limit, but JB has at least implied that ways around it exist.

He once said that in theory, the White Council could take on Mab, if they had her Name, and all the Wizards in the Council combined their strength to do it.  That at least implies that it's possible to make spell-combos and spell-circles with more than 13 members...or maybe you can combine such groups of 13 into larger groups of groups, or something.

But per JB's comment it's apparently theoretically possible for the whole Council to hit you at once.  If you don't happen to be Mab or Titania or a Mother or an Archangel, I suspect that would hurt.  A lot.
Title: Re: Marvra and Kemmler (Deadbeat)
Post by: LordDresden2 on August 10, 2017, 04:08:43 AM
Sure thing, Here you go.. It's the second part, but the Black Court portion of the "Are they Evil" part is also informative:

Quote
And also what is Drakul a scion of?
Drakul wasn't a scion of anything! He was something entirely unhuman that got trapped in human form. Dracula was his half-human child, who naturally had enormous paternal issues, and wound up creating himself as the first Black Court Vampire in an effort to win his father's approval.
It didn't work out so well.

Thanks!  I had missed that last.  I remembered reading someone in-story refer to Dracula running away to join the Black Court, but I had not realized that he had founded it.
Title: Re: Marvra and Kemmler (Deadbeat)
Post by: Quantus on August 10, 2017, 12:07:46 PM


Thanks!  I had missed that last.  I remembered reading someone in-story refer to Dracula running away to join the Black Court, but I had not realized that he had founded it.
Same. Finding out he was the Founder changed things dramatically, not the least of which is anchors the Black Court as the youngest by FAR (of the three we've seen, anyway).  Id always discounted theories of Mavra being (or becoming) an Elder based on the assumption that the Elders would be a few thousand years old like the oldest of the Reds or Whites.  But now we know that a)they are all going to be a 1000 years or less (give or take) and b)they gain power via pure bodycount, so in the right circumstances they could really thrive.  And by "right circumstances" I mean anything that might have a Horseman of the Apocalypse Named after it. 
Title: Re: Marvra and Kemmler (Deadbeat)
Post by: LordDresden2 on August 11, 2017, 03:41:37 AM
Same. Finding out he was the Founder changed things dramatically, not the least of which is anchors the Black Court as the youngest by FAR (of the three we've seen, anyway).  Id always discounted theories of Mavra being (or becoming) an Elder based on the assumption that the Elders would be a few thousand years old like the oldest of the Reds or Whites.  But now we know that a)they are all going to be a 1000 years or less (give or take) and b)they gain power via pure bodycount, so in the right circumstances they could really thrive.  And by "right circumstances" I mean anything that might have a Horseman of the Apocalypse Named after it.

All of a sudden, my mind flashes to Kemmler, who according to Bob had a big hand in bringing about the Great War.  Bob told Harry that Kemmler had spent the better part of a century setting it up (which makes sense, because the international tensions that exploded in 1914 had deep roots), but he never did give Harry/us any real motive other than that Kemmler was 'crazy and evil'.  Bob did, however, tell Harry that Kemmler had allies in the vampire courts.

Now crazy and evil can certainly motivate people, but spending decades on end carefully setting up something as big as World War I presumably had some purpose beyond 'just because'.  But if you wanted your Black Court allies to have a chance to level up quickly, that would be a way to go about it.



Title: Re: Marvra and Kemmler (Deadbeat)
Post by: Con on August 11, 2017, 03:44:00 AM
All of a sudden, my mind flashes to Kemmler, who according to Bob had a big hand in bringing about the Great War.  Bob told Harry that Kemmler had spent the better part of a century setting it up (which makes sense, because the international tensions that exploded in 1914 had deep roots), but he never did give Harry/us any real motive other than that Kemmler was 'crazy and evil'.  Bob did, however, tell Harry that Kemmler had allies in the vampire courts.

Now crazy and evil can certainly motivate people, but spending decades on end carefully setting up something as big as World War I presumably had some purpose beyond 'just because'.  But if you wanted your Black Court allies to have a chance to level up quickly, that would be a way to go about it.

Especially if Stoker's Book and the Black Court Purge had been making waves against the Court. Also ties into the idea that Kemmler got his improved Dark Hallow idea from Dracula failed attempt and ascension, and the Black Court's method of feeding on the life force of people.
Title: Re: Marvra and Kemmler (Deadbeat)
Post by: Snark Knight on August 11, 2017, 03:56:56 AM
The thing is with such a limited number of elders, I doubt they would ever gather together as it would present too big a target. So it would be a big deal for them to do so.

Cough TUNGUSKA cough
Title: Re: Marvra and Kemmler (Deadbeat)
Post by: jonas on August 11, 2017, 07:18:41 AM
All of a sudden, my mind flashes to Kemmler, who according to Bob had a big hand in bringing about the Great War.  Bob told Harry that Kemmler had spent the better part of a century setting it up (which makes sense, because the international tensions that exploded in 1914 had deep roots), but he never did give Harry/us any real motive other than that Kemmler was 'crazy and evil'.  Bob did, however, tell Harry that Kemmler had allies in the vampire courts.

Now crazy and evil can certainly motivate people, but spending decades on end carefully setting up something as big as World War I presumably had some purpose beyond 'just because'.  But if you wanted your Black Court allies to have a chance to level up quickly, that would be a way to go about it.
Yes they did, the ground work and death before a dark hallow is part of what makes up how big and bad it's actually going to be, he was setting the groundwork for his own DH that woulda made DB's look like a kitty ride by comparison. iirc, first time they killed him was before he could pull it off.
Title: Re: Marvra and Kemmler (Deadbeat)
Post by: Quantus on August 11, 2017, 12:32:55 PM
I basically he was just setting up a fertile environment for Chaos, Death, and Change.  Which is something that benefited Blamps just as much as kemmler. Probably was a great time for Nic too, I bet he was jealous.  Any or all of them could have been co-conspirators, allies, and/or complicit bystanders in that time.   
Title: Re: Marvra and Kemmler (Deadbeat)
Post by: Griffyn612 on August 11, 2017, 12:59:15 PM
I basically he was just setting up a fertile environment for Chaos, Death, and Change.  Which is something that benefited Blamps just as much as kemmler. Probably was a great time for Nic too, I bet he was jealous.  Any or all of them could have been co-conspirators, allies, and/or complicit bystanders in that time.   
Chaos is a ladder.
Title: Re: Marvra and Kemmler (Deadbeat)
Post by: Quantus on August 11, 2017, 01:01:05 PM
Chaos is a ladder.
Oh my god, my childhood wasnt wasted!


(click to show/hide)
Title: Re: Marvra and Kemmler (Deadbeat)
Post by: Griffyn612 on August 11, 2017, 01:10:45 PM
Oh my god, my childhood wasnt wasted!


(click to show/hide)
Methinks Harry would have been better served playing Guess Who, considering his... nemesis...
(http://i29.tinypic.com/etzfxi.gif)
Title: Re: Marvra and Kemmler (Deadbeat)
Post by: kazimmoinuddin on August 11, 2017, 08:09:48 PM
I. Hope if Harry sees mavra that he carries out his threat and uses necromancy on her, to either turn her into a weapon against other threats or force her into facing the sun/walk into the fire.
Title: Re: Marvra and Kemmler (Deadbeat)
Post by: Griffyn612 on August 11, 2017, 08:28:41 PM
I. Hope if Harry sees mavra that he carries out his threat and uses necromancy on her, to either turn her into a weapon against other threats or force her into facing the sun/walk into the fire.
Or just unmake the magics keeping her animated, causing her to crumble into a pile of dust at a casual wave of his hand.
Title: Re: Marvra and Kemmler (Deadbeat)
Post by: kazimmoinuddin on August 12, 2017, 11:28:43 PM
A BCV is technically a super up necromantic zombie in a way, so what would happen if it was drained of necro energy. A desiccated corpse or would they crumple to dust and lack of energy.
Title: Re: Marvra and Kemmler (Deadbeat)
Post by: EBRIEN on August 13, 2017, 12:26:00 AM
Thanks for all the responses. I really enjoyed reading them!