We ran one last year at our house and had a lot of fun. 

vine.co/v/hlUbp63uJIi

It's come up on some other topics the question of who - aside from Harry - has Jim Butcher tortured the most, so I figured I'd start a list

Karrin Murphy

• poisoned by Victor Sells's scorpions, endured Internal Affairs investigation for rescinding warrant on HarryStorm Front
• arm broken by the Loup Garou, beaten up by FBI hexenwolves Full Moon
• psychic attack by the Nightmare, Grave Peril
• knee injury, Summer Knight
• cut, mind whammy, broken jaw by Lord Raith, Blood Rites
• arm broken, Dead Beat (behind the scenes)
• nearly drowned by Jenny Greenteeth, "Something Borrowed"
• loses command of SI Proven Guilty
• shot by shotgun, face slashed by Deirdre Small Favor
• drugged by Manaed, black eye & bruise from Harry, "Last Call"
• psychic whammy, "Love Hurts"
• loses her job Changes
• defeated by Lily, Maeve & cohort, Cold Days

Susan Rodriguez

• reaction to multiple potions, SF
• turned to vampire, GP
• attacked with snakes by Cassius, injured jumping from car Death Masks
• knocked out by Ik'k'uox, turned to full Red Court vampire, sacrificed, Changes

Mac

• beaten up, "Last Call"
• kidnapped by Red Cap, shot, CD

Toot-toot

• Got swatted by the Skin Walker, SmF
• Wounded and smacked around by Lacuna, CD

Kim Delaney

• killed by Loup Garou, FM

Ron Carmichael

• killed by Loup Garou, FM

Mickey Malone

• hamstrung by Loup Garou, FM
• tortured by barbed wire spell, GP

Michael Carpenter

• battered by Agatha Hagglethorn, broken ribs in fight against Kravos-possessed Lydia, GP
• cut by sword, shot multiple times into kevlar backed armor, DM
• shot multiple times, gravely wounded, SmF
• daughter kidnapped, provoked nearly to murder, "The Warrior"

Charity Carpenter

• nearly sacrificed to Siriothrax
• attacked by Nightmare physically and mentally, inducing premature labor, GP
• arm injured by hammer exploded against warded door, injured by Scarecrow, DB

Mortimer Lindquist

• head laceration, concussion (?), DM
• kidnapped and tortured by Corpsetaker, Ghost Story

Thomas Raith

• bit by vampires, injured catching Harry when thrown by Kravos possessed Lydia, GP
• shot by Lara, nearly sacrificed by Madge, cut and neck broken by Lord Raith, BR
• arm broken by Scarecrow, hit by ice troll, PG
• strangled, electrocuted by Elaine, leg injured by ghouls WN
• injuries from Black Court vampires, "It's My Birthday, Too"
• poisoned by Stygian, "Backup"
• tortured by Skinwalker, Turn Coat
• shot in gut, defeated by Lily, Maeve & cohort, CD

Justine

• abducted by Red Court and fed upon, GP
• drained of lifeforce, BR
• abdomen slashed by Skinwalker, TC
• kidnapped, "Even Hand"
• kidnapped by Red Cap, CD

Elaine Mallory

• presumably enthralled by Justin DuMorne, pre-SF
• attacked by Lloyd Slate, SK
• psychic attack by Skavis, WN

Shiro

• tortured to death by Denarians, DM

Sanya

• arm broken by Ursiel, leg stabbed by Deirdre, injured by Nicodemus, DM

Waldo Butters

• psychiatric treatment after identifying some of the Velvet Room victims as not human, BTS, DM
• grabbed by zombies, tortured and soul gazed by Grevane, nose broken by Cassius, DB
• Shot in vest by Stevie D, Changes
• injured by Aristedes, displaced from body by Corpsetaker, GS

Molly Carpenter

• damage from using black magic, captured by Fetches, PG
• psychic trauma from Skavis death, White Night
• smoke inhalation, "Day Off"
• shot, psychic trauma, Changes
• training injuries from Lea, psychic attack by Corpsetaker, GS
• turned into Winter Lady, CD

Alicia Carpenter

• kidnapped by Father Rourke, "The Warrior"

Daniel Carpenter

• attacked by fetch, PG
• knife wounds from Aristedes, GS

Mouse

• hit by car, PG
• shot in paw, TC
• injured by Ick, Changes
• defeated by Lily, Maeve & cohort, CD

Father Forthill

• nearly beaten to death, GS

Rawlins

• shot in foot, PG

Ivy

• gassed, tortured by Denarians, SF

Kinkaid

• injured by Darkhounds, BR
• injured by Denarians, SF

Anastasia Luccio

• mindswapped by Corpsetaker into wounded body, DB
• mind whammied by Peabody, circa SF
• collarbone broken by Skinwalker, TC

Carlos Ramirez

• knocked out by Cowl (?), DB
• knife wounds from Vittorio Malvora, WN

Maggie Dresden

• kidnapped by Red Court, watch mother sacrificed, Changes

Sarissa

• hit by ogre, turned into Summer Lady, CD

Alphas
not specified

• several wounded in fight with hexenwolves outside Lycanthrope's lair, FM
• several wounded in fight in Chicago Above Chicago, SK

Will

• injured in fight with FBI hexenwolves, drugged, FM
• clawed by Tigress, SK
• intoxicated by White Vampire blood, TC
• knife wound, injuries from Fomor, "Aftermath"

Georgia

• drugged, FM
• beaten, kidnapped and ensorcelled, "Something Borrowed"
• intoxicated by White Vampire blood, TC
• beaten, kidnapped and ensorcelled, "Aftermath"

Andi

• drugged, FM
• infected by psychopagic mites, "Day Off"
• severely wounded by Skinwalker, TC
• beaten, kidnapped and ensorcelled, "Aftermath"
• kidnapped, CD

Kirby

• drugged, FM (? - possibly injured by hexenwolves)
• broken legs, cracked vertebrae, "Something Borrowed"
• infected by psychopagic mites, "Day Off"
• - killed by Skinwalker, TC

Marcy

• drugged, FM
• wounded by Fomor, "Afternmath"

A troll snatching a kid off a playground for a snack is very different then a troll under Mab's orders doing ANYTHING.  Kid snatching is troll NATURE.  Directed violence against a specific opponent of the Winter Queen is an exertion of her will through a tool. 

Also, given what we've learned in CD, should we trust the job description of the Winter Knight we had up till now?

Mab's comments in Changes at least strongly suggest the Hitman option.  "You will destroy what I wish to destroy.  Kill whosoever I wish you to kill."  That doesn't mean that's the end all, be all of his role, though.

I'm betting that Maeve's orders to the knights mostly centered around killing people... Since we know she hasn't been doing her proper job for a while from her "I will never again be your little hunting falcon" jab at Mab I think she'd been perverting the winter Lady and Winter Knight gig for a while know. Be interesting to see more of what the Winter Lady's true role is in helping to hold off Armageddon. Might have to wait a book or two though.

I personally don't think Maeve was corrupted until after Summer Knight, and I took the "hunting falcon" comment as her getting folks killed per Mab's orders.  The scene where Harry uses the Mantle to try to get Maeve also strongly suggests that death dealing is a big part of it.

When Molly removed Harry's memories in Changes, she inadvertently changed him, transferring some measure of her feelings for him.

source: http://www.jimbutcheronline.com/bb/index.php/topic,35005.msg1705045.html#msg1705045

I agree. I know that a dozen arguments will be made to the contrary but Harry is nothing if not responsible and it's irresponsible not to make contact with Maggie. Of course I am a single father of a daughter so I am hardly objective on the subject.

I guess I agreed with the rationale given - he's seen Maggie for all of a couple hours of her life, hours that included him cutting the throat of her mother.  If she does remember him, there's a good chance that all that trauma comes rolling back in.  And if she doesn't... well, she's still recovering from the trauma of the events in Changes, she's got a loving foster family that she looked quite content to be with.

Yes, it does freak him out.  But he's also on a timeline, and there really wasn't that much opportunity to chase her down.  He /could/ have done it, and Thomas and Murphy were pushing him to do it, yes.  But all in all, saving her and the rest of Chicago probably trumps seeing her and risking hurting her. 

In the long run, though, he's gotta get over it.

Can anyone think of a lie that Aurora told?  I really can't - I just remember Harry thinking how she'd used typical Sidhe wordplay and her magic healing touch to distract him.

Granted, the Adversary may not have been willing to let it be known it was in action, but I was just wondering if someone /else/ might have been infected, someone who Aurora trusted and who talked her down the path that lead to her actions.  Elaine is a possibility, but I can't remember if Talos had an on screen death... and I wonder if he might be less trustworthy.

LOL, did no one (else) here actually hear the stories as a kid?   Really?

as a kid, no.  my first Baba Yaga experience was in an X-men comic where she tried to eat Colossus's little sister.  First time I encountered Eitri too... well, no, I tell a lie, I'd read some Norse mythos at that point.