Show Posts

This section allows you to view all posts made by this member. Note that you can only see posts made in areas you currently have access to.


Messages - sjsharks

Pages: [1] 2 3 ... 8
1
DF Reference Collection / Re: Cold Days Spoilers- Who isn't your Nemesis?
« on: November 30, 2012, 09:07:48 AM »
Yes, which is part of why I don't think that the White King is infected, working with the outsiders sure.

Of course the trippy part comes if we start assuming the outsiders aren't unified but instead have a coinciding goal, and there are multiple diseases.

I mean lets presume for a moment that the Walkers have a He Who Walks Within or In-between, infection and then They That Oppose do as well, then just the mere fact that Vitto exists doesn't preclude the white court from having been infected.

Hell perhaps the vampire courts as a whole are nothing more than ancient disease vectors from Outside who have slowly been worming cracks open in the Outer Gates.

For the Lucifier side: I don't think Lucifier would stand at the unmaking of reality.  He isn't opposed to Life parsay, he is opposed to WG and the way He operates.  I think we will see the Denarians at the least becoming Almost allies.  Or at least 'least concern' by the end of the next book.

I am really not understanding your logic on why the WK isn't infected

And thanks Serack

2
DF Reference Collection / Re: Cold Days Spoilers- Who isn't your Nemesis?
« on: November 29, 2012, 08:48:58 PM »
We kinda have to, though. We're already on a collision course for an answer to this question, just with the Denarians. Why was Nicodemus so surprised by the attack on Arctis Tor? Was he surprised because it meant his other Denarians were "infected" (i.e., Denarians can be evil without being infected, i.e., not all fallen angels are infected, i.e., Lucifer != Nemesis), or just because it meant Lucifer was running a plot he didn't know about? Lucifer would certainly have the metaphysical oomph to mount an attack on Arctis Tor!

I'm sure we will see Lucifer. But he is allowed to cheat and directly act. TWG is not.

3
DF Reference Collection / Re: Cold Days Spoilers- Who isn't your Nemesis?
« on: November 29, 2012, 08:42:36 PM »
The biggest set of questions I have right now revolve around Lucifer.

Lucifer's traditionally referred to as "the Adversary" and has a history of corrupting people by granting them free will, just like Nemesis. He's been consistently off-screen in the books so far, but he definitely exists.

So the big question is, then -- did the Adversary/Nemesis corrupt Lucifer, or is Lucifer "The Adversary"? It's an important question because it also speaks to the power of the White God over Outsiders -- are they truly Outside his Creation? Outside his Plan, or part of it? If "The Adversary" is Lucifer, then the Outsiders are, at least theoretically, part of God's Plan; if Lucifer, and the demonic evils he represents and leads,  are a separate evil from the outsiders, then maybe the Outsiders aren't part of God's Plan, which is terrifying on a whole 'nother level.

In other words, is what happened to Molly part of God's Plan, or a corruption of it?

I don't think that we will ever find out if Nemesis is of TWG's creation or not, because I don't think we will ever truly see TWG or get a real scope for His power.

4
DF Reference Collection / Re: Cold Days Spoilers- Who isn't your Nemesis?
« on: November 29, 2012, 08:39:55 PM »
knnn did a great job of pointing out alternative explenations for my suspicions.  I'm happy with her on the list again :)

As off topic as it may be, do you have any other important new WoJ that I have missed in my absence?

5
DF Reference Collection / Re: Cold Days Spoilers- Who isn't your Nemesis?
« on: November 29, 2012, 08:09:21 PM »
Because targeting his hunger would eventually kill him.

I can't think of what to say to the rest of your stuff, and don't have the time now. But isn't that exactly what Maggie's curse did? Make it so he couldn't feed his Hunger?

6
DF Reference Collection / Re: Cold Days Spoilers- Who isn't your Nemesis?
« on: November 29, 2012, 08:02:41 PM »
We don't, but the fact he works with HWWB isn't a point that he would be infected, and the fact of the matter is he would be free of the curse if it was Nemesis protecting him instead of HWWB, as Nemesis is part of him and HWWB is just a servant of sorts.

I'm just saying assuming he is infected maybe a wrong step.  Though if he is, Lara is as well as he is still alive.

I don't think I'm understanding what your saying at the end there. But why would Nemesis be able to have blocked Maggie's death curse? It targeted his Hunger, not him.

Quote
She has massive amounts of magic power, not will power.  She has the will power of a young child.When did she have contact with an Outsider?

She brought Mordite to the dual with Ortega.
And I thought it was said that the Archive has the life and memories of all the past Archives. Wouldn't that give her immense amounts of willpower?

Quote
I know I am missing like a third of them as this discussion is too much fun and I barely have time to keep up with you.

I had forgotten how much fun I had doing this. I'm glad I decided to come back  :)

Actually we only have Harry's perspective that they do.  There is some ancillary evidence that they don't.  Notably the fact that Harry still breathes despite him being 'outsider bane' and HWWB having had a free shot at a young Harry.


At that point in time, Justin was trying to get Harry to become a killer. HWWB was training Harry to become a scary magical power, and he succeeded. HWWB could have thought that he had Harry on his side at that point, or he may still think he can get Harry.

7
DF Reference Collection / Re: Cold Days Spoilers- Who isn't your Nemesis?
« on: November 29, 2012, 07:50:39 PM »
There could also be several... factions... of Nemesis or similar beings

Actually, strike that. The Outsiders work together. All of them.

8
DF Reference Collection / Re: Cold Days Spoilers- Who isn't your Nemesis?
« on: November 29, 2012, 07:50:06 PM »
Using the previous analysis done of the "Black Council" in the past as a stepping stone, it seems as though most of the beings that the Nemesis had infected and used had the common atribute of ambition.  These people were not puppets though, but were being twisted towards Nemesis' goals.

This kinda brings up the question to me.  Could Maeve not have known who was infected outside her sphere of influence (I.E. since she was not a sock puppet and thus wasn't omnicient on the Nemesis' plans) and thus was excited about a vector to Lara while being ignorant of her status?  Thomas sure did make a big deal about Lara's actions changing lately.  In an Ambitious nature.  Which equates to two huge red flags to me.

There could also be several... factions... of Nemesis or similar beings

9
DF Reference Collection / Re: Cold Days Spoilers- Who isn't your Nemesis?
« on: November 29, 2012, 07:49:22 PM »
I meant I wasn't sold, because Harry had already been a thorn in his side and would have been removed at the mansion fucking the rules of guests.

In fact, I think I can state that the White King isn't infected, because he still put propriety on the standards of his court and behaved in a normal manner.  He utilized the outsiders as tools and weapons, but was still a weakling in the end of it because Harry's Mom's Curse.  If he was infected the curse too Might have been shrugged off.

The WK could have killed Harry, but it would have made him lose all of his power, and would have made him worthless to Nemesis.
Where do we have anything showing infection with Nemesis allowing for resistance of magic? I thought him shrugging magic off was more HWWB's work.

edit:  Egad you people are posting fast

way too freaking fast

Ivy falls into the same category as Mab, Rashid and Demonreach.  If she is infected the game is over and we have lost; therefor she hasn't been infected.

a few things on this.
1. Ivy can possibly fight it with her massive amount of will power.
2. She has been in contact with an Outsider, and had an Outsider with her at one point
3. The end of the world is coming. And Harry's enemies are just getting stronger and stronger
4. Harry would hate to fight Ivy

seriously... 7 new posts while typing...

10
DF Reference Collection / Re: Cold Days Spoilers- Who isn't your Nemesis?
« on: November 29, 2012, 07:36:40 PM »
Yeah, but I think we have to assume that at least one of the Denarians is infected. And if we have to assume that, then we must consider the fact that Ivy might be infected as well.

I am fairly certain that Thorned Namshiel was infected.

It wouldn't surprise me too much if Ivy was infected.

11
DF Reference Collection / Re: Cold Days Spoilers- Who isn't your Nemesis?
« on: November 29, 2012, 07:35:28 PM »
Well, I think Nic is not infected, my reason isnt that great-mainly because how perverse it would for Harry to have to team up with him against the greater threat, nemesis.

Haha, given that Jim has said that he makes his living off of making Harry miserable, we can assume that all of the nicest good people in the series will be infected, while the worst of the evil will not be

12
DF Reference Collection / Re: Cold Days Spoilers- Who isn't your Nemesis?
« on: November 29, 2012, 07:31:55 PM »
Nobody responded to my thoughts on Nic being clean

If you added him to your list, I'd put:

Nicodemus (at least at the point of SmF)

Sorry about that, too many posts to reply to at once.

I agree that Nic was free of Nemesis then.

13
DF Reference Collection / Re: Cold Days Spoilers- Who isn't your Nemesis?
« on: November 29, 2012, 07:26:07 PM »
That's conjecture.

Very good conjecture, but conjecture.  We don't know that's what's protecting him.

Well, he is working directly with HWWB. And when Vitto was working with HWWB he had the exact same magic shrugging off power.

Of course it is always possible that it is something we don't know. But if were gonna say that then you might as well say Mister isn't TWG  ;D

14
DF Reference Collection / Re: Cold Days Spoilers- Who isn't your Nemesis?
« on: November 29, 2012, 07:18:51 PM »
Mab could sense it in her Daughter and both of them are much much much younger than God and His Angels.  God would be able to sense it in His sons and daughters, and Uriel/other Archangels would be able to sense it in his/her siblings.  Hell Harry noticed it in Sith and he knew him for all of a month.  There is no way that God or the Archangels could be corrupted because as I said if they were the war would be over, and because they cannot be infected neither can the lower ranking angels. 

As for vanillas I am absolutely certain that they could.  If not Rashid or Mother Summer would have told him that he could trust them. I also think that Murphy's behavior was very suspect in Cold Days.

Harry noticed it in Sith because he was directly breaking his word and his bonds, and the Sidhe just don't do that.

Even if TWG and Archangles could detect it, they can't act to do anything about it. Other then placing a very smart wizard close enough to find out and help cure the person  ;)

No they have textual evidence from a known infected agent implying (but not out right saying) that they are not infected.
If Nemesis completely replaces your will with its; Maeve hints that Justine or Lara are not infected when one or the other is, because there is a chance that Harry and Co are successful and it doesn't want to lose a more a highly placed foe.

If Nemesis doesn't replace your will with its; Maeve wants to interogate Justine for the exact reason she lays out.He really isn't.  If Rashid is infected, the war is over.  Its why him, DR, and Mab are the only ones I will say with 99.99% certainty are not infected.  The end result of their infection is loss of reality, since reality exists they can't be infected.

Justine and Lara still have some form of proof they are infected, even if it isn't the most trust worthy source.

I will add Rashid to the list

I think its hard to accept Harry is infected due to the fact that he stalls or outright stops the plans of the infected too often.  While I am not sold on the White King being infected, he stopped Aurora and we know she was infected.  We have strong evidence that the first Fivish books were all infected enemies, and Harry killed them all.

When did the White King stop Aurora? Also, he works with the Outsiders directly and has them blocking him from magic

15
DF Reference Collection / Re: Cold Days Spoilers- Who isn't your Nemesis?
« on: November 29, 2012, 07:06:02 PM »
SJS, do you mind if I tinker with some bulleting on your list?  (or I'll edit in a suggestion here in a few min and you can decide to incorporate it into your OP)

be my guest

Pages: [1] 2 3 ... 8