Show Posts

This section allows you to view all posts made by this member. Note that you can only see posts made in areas you currently have access to.


Messages - CrusherJen

Pages: 1 2 3 [4] 5 6
46
DF Spoilers / Re: Zoo day
« on: December 02, 2020, 07:24:57 AM »
This is true... I miss Mouse a lot. But I have a feeling he's got a big part to play in some future story, when we get to discover why he picked Harry.  ;D

47
DF Spoilers / Re: Zoo day
« on: December 02, 2020, 05:59:33 AM »
Indeed, there is downtime. But what is Dresden ignoring so he can look after his daughter? Guarantee that he hasn't been as involved as he could have been. Almost certainly things have slid a bit in some areas. His White Council relationship might have been better had he spent more time working with them.

But that assumes Harry is obsessed with Wizarding duties 24/7, and I find that wholly and completely unrealistic. Harry deserves a personal life, as much as anyone else with an extremely important job. Sure, there may be some tradeoffs in some areas, but I wouldn't dismiss raising a daughter (who is also a potential wizard and if so, will benefit from seeing a good example) as unimportant or meaningless. As the short story "The Warrior" reminds us, the battle of good and evil is fought on many different levels, from huge battles to small, seemingly insignificant interactions between people. So loving and spending time with Maggie can be a contribution, as much as slinging spells or swinging a staff. It's certainly proven a strong motivation for him to fight for the world, and to win. What image did Harry hold on to in order to withstand Ethniu's attack of Will? Holding Maggie and Mouse, his family. Would he have been able to save Chicago without that image to give him strength? Maybe, maybe not, but it does argue that parenting vs. wizardry doesn't have to be a question of either/or.

I keep seeing "well, Harry can't be the perfect parent," and yeah, that's probably true. But why does he have to be a perfect parent? Harry's not a perfect wizard either. He struggles, he makes mistakes, and he does the best he can. That keeps him relatable, and interesting. A perfect anything makes for a very boring story.

I get it, I do. It's a pretty huge change for the series, and it's different, and Harry being a parent just isn't going to appeal to some readers. And that's fine. It's definitely a tricky storyline to weave into the kind of major conflicts Harry's been facing lately, and I expect we're going to see Maggie shoved off-stage a lot over the rest of the series. We'll have to see whether or not it works out over the next few books, I guess.

48
DF Spoilers / Re: Zoo day
« on: December 01, 2020, 03:37:48 AM »
I hear what you're saying... but I don't agree. What we're seeing in the novels and short stories are typically the biggest events in his life-- a highlight (or lowlight) reel. There's plenty of time in between for Harry to deal with more mundane matters, like laundry, paying bills... or managing time with his daughter. We're not seeing him abandon his responsibilities; in Peace Talks we're shown that when he's required to deal with dangerous situations, he sends his daughter to safety so he can go do his job, and Maggie accepts it. Michael Carpenter often had to do the same thing as a Knight of the Cross, yet he still had down-time with his family (if not as much as he would have liked.) If Michael made it work, Harry should be able to as well.

At some point Harry might need to make a choice between Being There for Maggie and saving the world, and that could be interesting. But if the world is ending, it's a fairly slow-moving apocalypse (so far.) So I think we can have both... until the BAT, when all bets are off. A darker turn of the story at that point would be appropriate, but I don't feel we're there yet. But that's just my take on it, YMMV.

49
DF Spoilers / Re: Titania's Duty (BG SPoilers)
« on: November 27, 2020, 07:04:53 PM »
I don't think that is what she meant. In the conversation with Harry, Mab never indicated that she was going to try to do anything with the Eye.
No, I think the dialogue between the Queens have something to do with the fact that both of them worked together for the same objective. That is probably a trigger for something, and perhaps yes, that something has to do with Mab's death.

I think so too, especially since Mab warns Harry to kill Molly if she ascends to Winter Queen. (Sounds like a Checkhov's Gun to me.) Mab is foreseeing something which will likely lead to her death, and is getting her plans in order.

The last time both Queens had spoken before now was at Hastings. We don't know exactly what happened there (or maybe I just don't remember), but it's been implied to be very significant. So the Queens meeting at this battle must be significant too... we just don't know how yet. But I have a feeling we will learn eventually...

50
DF Spoilers / Re: Anyone Else Surprised or Disappointed That Harry
« on: October 14, 2020, 09:30:25 AM »
I'm not sure Ivy tipped off Mab at all. I think it's more likely Mab sensed her Knight was in danger through the bonds of Winter power and acted to save him on her own. I'm not completely ruling out the idea that Ivy contacted Mab, but I don't find it likely. It's an interesting theory though. ;)

51
DF Spoilers / Re: Anyone Else Surprised or Disappointed That Harry
« on: October 14, 2020, 09:20:41 AM »
Clearly JB has memorialized that Ivy [Harry's friend] had made arrangements with Mab [the evil Fae queen that Harry is DESPERATE to get away from] for Kincaid [the assassin Harry contracted to kill Mab's new Winter Knight] to shoot Harry through the heart [a more survivable injury than through the head] so he can fall into the lake where Mab [the evil Fae queen that Harry is DESPERATE to get away from] can save him and then [after 6 months of Harry being literally at death's door] she can take him to the center of her power where he is completely under her control while he recovers from the most compromised physical [and maybe mental] state he probably has ever been in. Guys, I think this part of the conversation has jumped it's shark.

If Ivy had said nothing, done nothing, Harry most likely would have died from a bullet in the head. Sure, surviving and winding up in Mab's clutches isn't the best place for Harry to be, but considering the alternative... Alive and in a bad situation is better than dead and gone. And what else could she really do? The Archive is supposed to be neutral, aware but interfering as little as possible in events outside of the Oblivion War. So my WAG is, Ivy was extremely limited in what she could alter, and changing Kincaid's aim was the absolute limit of what she could do. What happened after wasn't something she could control; she had to have faith in Harry to get through it as well as he could. (I could be wrong, of course, which is why I'm labeling this theory a WAG. YMMV.)

The notion that Ivy tipped Mab off interesting, but I suspect Mab would have been able to find Harry without it, through the tie of Winter power that binds Knight and Queen. So... it's a possibility, but I'm thinking it's less than likely that Ivy had to contact Mab at all. Again, YMMV.

52
DF Spoilers / Re: HUGE BATTLE GROUND SPOILERS - (Un)Answered questions
« on: October 07, 2020, 09:57:23 PM »
Quote
Strictly speaking, Lara can't feed on Harry. It might be possible for her to have sex with Harry and not feed.

I don't think it's likely, considering a mere brush of Harry's skin in Peace Talks was enough to burn Lara.

Unless the protection is broken beforehand, or the marriage vows invalidate it, there's no way for Harry and Lara to be intimate. But who knows what lurks in the mind of Jim?  ;D

53
DF Spoilers / Re: Anyone Else Surprised or Disappointed That Harry
« on: October 06, 2020, 05:19:09 PM »
I'm not sure about Christos, though I'd like to think we'd have heard about it if he'd died. But then, the White Council just kicked Harry out, so it's not surprising we don't get the answer on that one.

I'm pretty sure Andi and Marci were the wolves bodyguarding Butters after the Battle of the Bean, when Harry returns after the final confrontation with Ethniu, so they're okay. And in one of the recent video interviews, Jim confirms that Mister and Bonea were with the Carpenters during the big fight, so they're okay. (I can't remember which one that's from, but I think it was either the Barnes & Noble chat or the Muskogee Library vid.)

54
Quote
Well, post BG there are a few things I see differently from before. KoTC and the Denarians are just one of them. One thing I notice is the fact that Marcone has been holding and using Namsiel's coin for years now and the KoTC has not even reacted. No mission from above, no divine revelation, nothing. Assuming that Marcone has not done any bad things with this power all this time, I doubt anyone would believed it.

The thing is, Thorned Namshiel has been keeping a very low profile. So how would he come to the attention of the Knights? As far as they know, Marcone's a vanilla mortal crimelord, which isn't great, but not anything the Swords were meant to deal with. And they've got twenty-nine other Denarians (give or take) keeping them busy.

If Marcone and Namshiel do something obviously supernaturally evil, then yes, I'd expect the Knights to become aware and act as a counter. But until then (or until Harry lets it slip), I expect they will continue to slide under the Swords' radar.

55
Quote
Mab is making Harry marry Lara. What Lara gets out of it is unclear other than an alliance (and not a long term one). Jim has been foreshadowing Lara and Harry's eventual boinking since Lara was first introduced.

Mab can make Harry marry Lara, but nobody can force them to "boink." Harry has True Love protection from Karrin (as confirmed in Peace Talks) and even with her dead(ish) I don't see that fading in a year's time, especially as Harry knows she's still around as a Valkyrie. I don't have the book nearby, but I seem to recall his protection from Susan lasted a long time after their breakup. So unless something happens in the next year, the marriage would have to be political only. Lara can't touch Harry without burning herself.

56
DF Spoilers / Re: Jury Duty and the Peace Talks
« on: September 22, 2020, 06:39:08 AM »
Um, no, they don't. Thomas survived as a hairdresser, taking small bites of energy as he styled his clients' hair, and they weren't harmed by it. (In fact, they enjoyed it. So it's not too absurd to think that people would volunteer for such an experience, if it was ensured that they wouldn't die in the process.)

And it's been established that White vamps are born with their demon, and their first feeding doesn't have to be lethal. (Although if Irwin Pounder hadn't been the scion of a Bigfoot, he might not have survived his encounter with Connie, so that may be an exception.) If a young White vamp's first sexual experience is based in True Love, there's a chance their demon will die, and they become human, as Inara Raith hopefully did. It's the Reds who must kill to become a fully-fledged vampire, not the Whites.

57
DF Spoilers / Re: We Now Know What/Who Mac Is
« on: September 21, 2020, 05:27:13 PM »
Quote
Or it could be a Malvora getting back at him for Jury Duty.

Oooooh, I hadn't thought of this... but I like it! The White Court is all about manipulation through proxies. If the Malvoras found out Lara was going to use Harry as a tool, the logical counter is to use the cops to take Harry off the board. It fits.

The Fomor is another group I didn't think of, and they're a good option considering their desire to derail the peace talks. But I don't remember them using pressure tactics before. Don't they usually take more violent and direct action? (I think I need to do some rereading.)

58
I'm not saying you're wrong... but sometimes there's a certain amount of flexibility in writer's contracts. Things happen, and books aren't always completed by a deadline. Some authors get contracted for a certain number of books in advance, say, "three novels in two years, with at least one belonging to a particular series." Nobody expected Peace Talks to get split until it happened, so I'm not sure it would have been planned for in the original contract.

(Rob Thurman, an author I adore, only had two books come out in a series I loved, because the publisher didn't pick up the option to print the third. The first two didn't sell enough to merit it, according to the publisher. :-\ I still mourn not knowing what would have happened next... hopefully we'll find out someday.)

59
DF Spoilers / Re: We Now Know What/Who Mac Is
« on: September 21, 2020, 08:17:39 AM »
I don’t think Rudolph is in Marcone pocket. Marcone has no interest in stirring up trouble with Harry at this moment. The reds owned Rudolph so if any of their allies were aware of that they could have taken him over.

Agreed. Why would Marcone need Harry out of the way right now? As an Accorded Baron of Chicago, Harry is obliged to support Marcone at the peace talks... so Marcone benefits from Harry being free to act on his behalf. Marcone's getting everything he wants, the last thing he needs is to give Harry a reason to act against him. If Harry was an obstacle to some future plan, removing him would make sense. But from what we know now, that doesn't seem to be the case.

I don't doubt somebody's putting pressure on Rudolph, but Marcone's the least likely suspect. Allies of the Reds, Mavra (who's resorted to blackmail before, and is mentioned in Peace Talks), Black Council members, or Nicodemus are all possibilities (though if it's Nicodemus, I don't think we'll see a resolution in Battle Ground.)

60
If it was a smaller publisher, with less books to publish, that might have been simpler... but Penguin is huge, with many authors under its imprint, and print schedules planned months in advance. With all their other commitments in place, putting out both books at once probably wouldn't have been possible, especially considering the quantities needed for a best-selling series like this one. Yeah, we think Jim's a big deal (and for good reason!  ;D ) but fast-tracking Battle Ground more than 60 days would have likely meant delaying other, even bigger authors' works, and that's something Penguin probably couldn't do, contractually or physically.

That's my guess, anyway. It might not be completely accurate, since I never worked in publishing, but I did work in bookstores for many, many years, and I remember seeing some lines' publishing schedules worked out months in advance. That might not be the only reason, but I'd figure printer limitations and scheduling was part of it.

Pages: 1 2 3 [4] 5 6