Show Posts

This section allows you to view all posts made by this member. Note that you can only see posts made in areas you currently have access to.


Messages - Sharlee

Pages: [1] 2 3
1
DF Reference Collection / Re: Dialogues with Portents and Parents
« on: April 26, 2015, 05:22:12 PM »
How about Harry's dream-conversation with Malcolm by the campfire in Dead Beat?  Malcolm lists a whole bunch of events that await his son, and death is right in the middle of them, in keeping with Changes's position about halfway through the series.

2
DF Reference Collection / Re: Dresden Files: Series Timeline
« on: April 26, 2015, 05:10:38 PM »
We have no information whether Victor had ever demonstrated talent previously. We would probably have to accept this as a “retcon”, as it is later established that unused talents atrophy. Mort Lindquist is one example. He never completely lost it and worked his way back into it. Charity Carpenter is another. We’ve been lead to believe that she could, theoretically, recover her talent but it would be a long, difficult process. Regardless, Victor is a “natural” who “found” his magic – or, as we’ve come to believe, was likely introduced to it… at about age 30-35...and likely coached to some degree. A question is, when did this happen in the story timeline?

We know from the FBI agent in Changes that some people with magical talent can make use of it unconsciously, without actually knowing that talent exists.  Agent Tilly was able to tell if people were lying to him, retaining that knack and even putting it to use professionally, without knowing where his insights came from.  Possibly Sells' talent had a similarly low-key manifestation that he didn't recognize as such, or just didn't opt to tell his wife about, until something convinced him to investigate whether it had a supernatural basis.

3
DF Reference Collection / Re: Dresden Files: Series Timeline
« on: April 26, 2015, 04:56:34 PM »
From War Cry:

3291 BC - The Akkadians are decimated by a colossal shoggoth.  A surviving warrior seeks to warn his nation's prior enemy, but King Hammurabi of Babylon doubts his word and is powerless when the creature attacks his own city.

The date for this event seems to be about 1140 years off, if JB is suggesting the actual Akkadian Empire was finished off by this thing, and 1541 years off if this is supposed to be the real Hammurabi.  If we assume the cultural and personal names are a translation-convention to preserve the Mesopotamian "feel" of the historical flashback, and that the characters involved are from a couple of forgotten cultures of which the shoggoth left no trace for archeologists to unearth, then the captioned date could be accurate in the Dresdenverse. 

Either way, this one's date in the Timeline may have to read "Ancient Mesopotamia (3291 BC?)" until we hear from Jim if it's just a flub from his misreading "3rd millennium BC" in a history book as the 3000s, not the 2000s.


The events of War Cry itself are in late January or early February, four months after Yoshimo's leg was broken in Dead Beat.

4
DF Reference Collection / Re: Dresden Files: Series Timeline
« on: December 17, 2014, 08:45:11 PM »
Turn Coat:  All public records of Demonreach Island were scrubbed some time in the 19th century.

5
DF Reference Collection / Re: Dresden Files: Series Timeline
« on: September 07, 2014, 06:45:49 PM »
Well, fwiw, there is a WOJ about the Stone Table that indicates both courts have access to it when and where they should.  So it appears that while Summer is in power in the Northern Hemisphere, Winter is in Power in the Southern, and Vice Versa.

Or the Southern Hemisphere isn't a factor in determining the Courts' relative power, because most of the planet below the equator is ocean and dominated by the Fomor, who hate both Courts.

6
Incidentally, does anyone know what happened to Harry's shield bracelet or rings in Changes?  He's not wearing them at the end, but I don't recall him ever mentioning them being destroyed or lost.

7
Certainly. Kemmler stuff, take two:
Those two accounts seem fairly different, don't you think? I mean, I wouldn't consider 1961 as being even close to "during" WW2, as has been pointed out.

Kemmler's the one who taught Corpsetaker everything she knew.  Who's to say he didn't stick around as a shade, same as she did?  The Council could've finally whacked his body for keeps during WWII, then come back and cleaned up the Ghost of Kemmler in 1961.

8
Yeah, I'd say that the cemetery one is Mavra. But there's no reason for them to get a count of six when there are seven places.

Maybe Harry'd initially been thinking that there were six places to investigate, as he already knew how one of the seven locations had become marked by necromantic power?  The jump from six unaccounted-for places to six necromancers was where the mistake cropped up, possibly from a worst-case-scenario fallacy: Harry knows he's in deep trouble, and unconsciously inflates that trouble in his mind.

Either that, or the process of revising that scene's text accidentally dropped a line in which Harry deduces that the ink spot for the graveyard is easily accounted for: it's where Grevane must've animated those other zombies he'd brought with him to the Forensics Institute. (It's a pretty safe bet that he wouldn't drag a bunch of undead along on the Way to Chicago, where any passing Warden might notice them or their dark energies, and hauling them into town by car or train is even more conspicuous.)  So, that gives two of the spots on Mort's map to Grevane, leaving five unaccounted for.

9
Close but not quite.  The person doesnt have to consciously Will it, they just have to have Free Will to do it.  So Toot or Bob cannot break the circle (which is why Bob was able to toss harry a potion through a circle in SF).  However if he accidentally knocks something over the circle that is, in Uriel's words, "A Fair Ball."  That is supposedly one of the most common amateur mistakes young summoners make, and why harry always so careful cleans the area around the circle before he attempts summoning.

So now Shagnasty has free will?  He used a circle to break Harry's soulfire-lasso, so unless skinwalkers have free will, it can't be a prerequisite for circle magic.  As for cleaning the area around a circle and laying it out precisely, that's what's necessary to prepare a circle before it's empowered, to make it operate as efficiently as possible so it can be infused with more energy and restrain more powerful beings.

10
I cant help but notice that others have failed to notice that pouring concrete onto the activated ring encased coin should have broken the circle.

Inanimate matter penetrating an empowered circle can only break it if the individual who applies that matter wills it to do so.  We saw that way back in the first book's introduction of magic circles, when Harry empowered the faerie trap, then laid leaves and twigs over it so Toot-toot wouldn't see it.  So long as Harry doesn't will the twigs and leaves, or the wet cement, to disrupt a circle, he can dump stuff on it all day long without a problem.

11
Just wanted to add, Thomas met Justine at Club Zero so that would put that place on a strong emotional connection.

But, again, it wouldn't fit the description of "gentlemen's club".

Hmmm... maybe the club he brought Michael out to just happens to be where Thomas was, when he first learned that his long-lost little brother had moved to Chicago and opened an investigation business there?

12
DF Reference Collection / Re: Dresden Files: Series Timeline
« on: August 13, 2014, 05:29:28 PM »
- In Cold Days, Harry's "physical therapy" began on August 15th, 77 days before October 30th when Mab sent Cat Sith to prepare him for his midnight birthday party.

13
DF Reference Collection / Re: Dresden Files: Series Timeline
« on: August 01, 2014, 06:54:57 PM »
- Checked the timeline, and it looks like Mr. Beckitt (do we know his first name?) must have gotten killed in prison very soon after he was arrested.  Storm Front took place in March of year 0, White Night in May of year 7, and Murphy claimed he'd been dead for "nearly seven years" in WN.

Could explain why Helen only did five years ("nickel in the pen"- Harry in WN), if her husband died in detention before their court trials were complete and her lawyer shifted most of the blame for the drug charges onto him and Sells.  (Helen's year of release may rate a mention.)

- Harry first developed his tracking spell at age 14, because he kept losing his house keys.

- Immediately after Proven Guilty, Mouse causes some property damage at the vet's when a paperwork snafu nearly got him neutered rather than his van-injured shoulder X-rayed.

- Simultaneous with the events of White Night, Ebenezar and the senior Wardens spend a few days battling a powerful rakshasa and its minions in India.

- Kincaid gives Murphy the P90 some time during the year before White Night.

14
DF Reference Collection / Re: Dresden Files: Series Timeline
« on: July 30, 2014, 10:54:58 PM »
- Charity's talent first showed just before her 16th birthday.  (PG)

- Harry's own magic first manifested in the spring (also PG)


15
DF Reference Collection / Re: Suggest Topics Here!
« on: July 23, 2014, 04:36:24 PM »
One thing the Reference Collection could definitely use, if it hasn't already got one I can't find:  a thread summarizing the many, many, many secrets which Harry is either keeping or privy to.  In what books does he learn about them; who else knows and when do they find out; whom is he most worried about concealing the truth from; at what point (if any) did the information cease to be secret or relevant?  With so much secret information to keep hidden, even Harry himself must have trouble keeping track of it at times, so we readers could surely use a summary to consult.

Naturally, a thread about this topic would need to be either spoiler-marked in big, black capital letters, or chock full of hidden text with ambiguous headings (e.g. just "Lara" as a heading for the secret that
(click to show/hide)

Pages: [1] 2 3