Show Posts

This section allows you to view all posts made by this member. Note that you can only see posts made in areas you currently have access to.


Messages - g33k

Pages: 1 2 3 [4] 5 6 ... 172
46
...
Side note: It is obvious that Alfred was aware of the creation of Demonreach which begs the question if he was a genus loci that was present before the prison was formed and he adapted/changed with the formation of the prison or if he was specifically created/formed by Merlin during the creation of the prison to be its Guard. 

I believe Merlin built the Guardian magic atop the (pre-existing) Genus Loci spirit.
I know of no WoJ specifying/clarifying this issue... not really even any hints, alas!
 

47
DF Spoilers / Re: Questions for Mab
« on: May 05, 2025, 09:47:12 PM »
Agreed, unless there is a rule against the Winter Knight getting a salary from his Queen
...  I seem to remember that there was a rule against him being paid, because Mab could have given him money then and didn't.  Unless Harry just doesn't want to be in Mab's debt anymore than he has to be so refuses a salary.
I don't think there's any "rule against" salary, no.
If Harry had included a cash stipend in his negotiation, I don't think Mab would have blinked or balked.

But there is now a rule against Harry being paid:  he didn't bargain for it... and Mab fulfills her bargains with surgical precision, and zero charity.


... Remember before the battle, Molly was buying a house close to her parents to further protect them and she loaned Harry her old place because he was homeless ...
I think Harry is morally/philosophically opposed to leveraging his power too-directly for wealth; it's a really easy line to cross, with a huge morally-grey area.
I suspect this is a too-strict interpretation of the anti-warlock values that Ebenezer instilled.

Molly has no such inhibitions.  She owns a luxurious condo in an ultra-secure enclave, paid for with magical service.

I don't doubt she has used her waywalking & veils & so forth to make her own wealth, independent of the Winter Court.

Like... in her "Ragged Lady" phase, she likely learned a bunch about the criminal underworld of Chicago.  Returning to it as the Winter Lady, she could just walk into a drug-deal under a Veil, put everyone to sleep, and walk out with all the cash; or something similar in other places, where she doesn't bump against Marcone (but I suspect that during the Fomor build-up, his hold over all those street-deals was much weaker:  killing one of those non-Marcone deals might actually put Marcone in Molly's debt!).

Or just use a Way to courier some high-value deliveries with unmatchable-by-mundanes speed & security.

Or Veil into some top-tier business negotiations, and leverage that knowledge in the stock market.

etc etc etc.

48
DF Spoilers / Re: Choices
« on: May 05, 2025, 03:51:50 AM »
    At this point we have put in so many ideas of our own in anticipation that I think there will be a lot of disappointment when it finally comes out.
<shrugs>  Odd theories & alternatives are fine!


"Why,  sometimes I've believed six impossible things before breakfast!" -- the White Queen

49
DF Spoilers / Re: Choices
« on: May 03, 2025, 03:46:49 AM »
Or not, Michael wasn't guided to her aid in the first few books...
No, of course not!  It's the Dresden Files, not the "Carpenter Files;" the Scooby Gang forms around Harry.

But in an Alt!Verse -- where Alt!Harry isn't a suitable nucleus for Scoobies -- Michael looks like he might be a more-active part of the Chicago scene.  "God will provide..." and in lieu of Harry, Michael looks like a damned-good candidate!

... I go back to the original assumption that everyone seems to have, and since I don't keep up with them I don't keep up very well with WOJs, is the other Harry is an evil counter point to our Harry.. If nothing if changed because of that, shrug of shoulders, Harry in the other universe is evil..  However I don't think so ...
The "evil Harry" idea comes from the older WoJ's; new ones are much less readily available/searchable, in that nobody AFAIK has taken the time to transcribe interview/etc videos... or even collect them.

From 2016:
Quote
When are we going to see Mavra again?
Um… 19?  *pondering*  Wait, I’m sorry we’ll definitely see her in Mirror Mirror.  She’s a fast ally of Dresden’s in Mirror Mirror.
-- https://wordof.jim-butcher.com/index.php/word-of-jim-woj-compilation/woj-on-vampires/
 

50
... My own pet theory is that Merlin, with all his time travel shenanigans, sets up the Well to harbor the worst of the worst because he knows it will be needed. Because he knows it will be needed he leaves a message for the future Warden of the Well with instructions and advice. I'm thinking something along the lines of Harry's mother's amulet. This would allow Harry to interact with Merlin and give us a window into who he was without having to do a whole separate book about it.
I think there are Well-secrets behind the firewall that is "Alfred."
We already know it knows stuff Harry doesn't, and doles out information on a very-limited basis.

I suspect there are one or more "levels" of information-disclosure that will be unlocked like a videogame achievement.  Possibly even a videogame-easter-egg that Merlin (who saw it in his time-travels) leaves as a joke.

51
DF Spoilers / Re: Next Series Ideas.
« on: May 03, 2025, 12:11:43 AM »
Fight Night is the supposed title of the book coming out after Mirror Mirror that deals with pro wrestling. In it Hades introduces/hires Harry to investigate trouble happening with gods who are masquerading as pro wrestlers ... 
Yeah, I think Jim might even have mentioned "Fight Night" as the prospective title for his "pro wrestling" book.  Haven't seen the Hades link before, though; can you dig up that cite for me?

The central conceit is AFAIK that a bunch of deity-level adulation-junkies are getting their fix -- their "worship" -- from the "pro wrestling" circuit, the pomp, the glamour.

Given the whole thing with costumes & masks & very-public personna's (that often shift) I expect this is where Harry learns about taking-off and putting-on a Mantle:  lets him "keep" the WK-Mantle without being quite so tightly-bound to all those strictures.

52
... We've seen that Red-Ortega retained some of real Ortega's adoration of Arianna ...

This is an excellent point!
Tho I do notice this accounting of the situation is 2nd-hand, so it may be misunderstood (or even active disinformation by the Rampires).

But I think you've cited a valid point.

... White Vampires are different, the original human soul is still there, grafted on to the parasite...
I think we have to say the parasite is grafted onto the human...   ;)

... That's why, among other things, WVs produce techbane when they use magic, and Red Vampires don't.

Do they?
I don't recall this.

53
DF Spoilers / Re: And another thing...Justine
« on: April 30, 2025, 02:54:12 PM »
Do we know for sure that Justine's illness was manic depression? As we know there are more than one type of mental illness.  If Justine suffered from a form of schizophrenia for example, hallucinations possibly could be the perfect avenue for Nemesis to enter. Can you imagine if Justine was hearing voices for example how easy it would be for Nemesis to become one of those voices? 
I don't think we know the form(s) of Justine's mental illness, no (noting that multiple-diagnoses are very much a thing).  It's not clear to me that Jim does, himself.

I doubt Jim will specifically write it as "hallucinations" though -- that really muddies the whole "free will" issue, which is thematically-important to the Dresdenverse.

54
DF Spoilers / Re: Twelve Months - What our you expecting from it?
« on: April 30, 2025, 02:49:06 PM »
Yes, everyone is so excited about the prospect of seeing an "evil Harry,"  but Jim has been there done that with an "evil Bob." ... 
Dunno that I'm "excited" about it... "interested," for sure.

But it's clear per WoJ that this is a much-darker Harry, more "off-black" than "morally gray," who has "stepped over the line."

Jim says Mirror!Harry is allied with Mavra; and that he summons alt!Harry's to die in his stead, when his own foes have him cornered and are about to kill him.
 

55
DF Spoilers / Re: Does anyone think Harry isn’t the original Merlin?
« on: April 30, 2025, 02:37:37 PM »
Just you wait, it's only a matter of time until Harry defeats communism by making a giant statue of himself and butchers the evil pacifists.
???
I ... guess this is a further riff on "Sword of Truth" (the sundial statue "Life"?)

I'm pretty sure that Jim pretty-rigorously avoids politics (as Harry, he denigrates all politicians equally, just as politicians, without ever calling out specific policies).

And your own remarks in themselves seem to be straying well-into the explicitly-disallowed territory... even if you're "just making a joke" or "forgot the /s" or whatever. 
 

56
DF Spoilers / Re: Twelve Months - What our you expecting from it?
« on: April 28, 2025, 02:47:42 PM »
No hint of that so far, however we haven't heard a word from the other branches of the White Court since "White Night," so it is possible that the Raith family will find itself on the outside looking in ...
That seems unlikely, to me.
Skavis & Malvora both got decapitated in the Raith Deeps -- not only the individuals who were their leaders, but the very-strongest of their Whamp's.  The Raith leadership (and strongest members) are intact.  I don't doubt that the Raiths took steps at  that point to "raid" the resources of their rivals, stripping them also of mundane resources/power.

This may be why Lara is making her power-play right now:  Thomas remarks (in Cold Days) that Lara is "getting scary" in how far she's extending control (where previously the Whamp's had limited themselves to the local Chicago scene, maybe some State elections, but now Lara's moving outside that scope (n.b. she had a USN Destroyer group in position in the Gulf, with military choppers standing by to violate Mexican airspace)).  But for the first time, the White Court resources are largely united, instead of the semi-détente as Skavis & Malvora maneuvered to take the White Throne; such that most of the effort of most of the Whamp's was focused internally).
 
But I'm sure Lara is too canny to just be ignoring Skavis & Malvora.  She knows the strongest of them will be emerging as new leadership, a new generation of challengers.  She knows that if she just ignores this, they will move against her... & she'd be ignorant of it.  So she'll be keeping more than a "weather eye open" to the internal politics, still.

57
...  It is mentioned in Changes that a ton of politicians and business leaders all died/disappeared at the same time the red court died.
I don't remember that...

Nevertheless, it's so.

It's in the chapter immediately following the one where Susan dies; Harry talks about the fallout from the destruction of the entire Red Court; so, not in-the-moment stuff or stuff Harry personally saw/experienced; but Harry telling us about things that he heard of, broadly.

58
... Dead, is D-E-A-D,  nothing remains of the host.
You are wrong:  language remains.  Rampires can speak normally, and don't need years to re-learn "from birth."  Also:  ghosts remain; and ghosts retain the memories that would be so critical for a Rampire to "fake it 'til they make it."

Or maybe part of the Ramp birth-process is to take a magical "brain-scan" of the dying host -- the human's life flashes before the rampire's eyes...

59
DF Spoilers / Re: The Erl King a Vassal of Winter?
« on: April 28, 2025, 01:47:03 PM »
More like an associate of Winter or with Winter, I doubt that Kringle would take a direct order from Mab for example, or that she would give one.. I think they actually agree on a lot of stuff, I also think because of his multiple mantles that he is way too complex to be a subject.

Yes, Odin & Mab agree on lots of stuff (as we saw in Skin Game)... though not on all things.

But the Kringlemantle is one of Winters/Mab's.  Within the scope of Kringle's duties, it is entirely subject to Winterlaw.  Now... Mab does not wish to be seriously at odds with Odin, so she isn't likely to give
any orders that Odin -- or Vadderung -- finds deeply offensive.  By the same token, Odin doesn't want to be seriously at odds with Mab, so Kringle is always looking for ways to be inoffensive.

When push comes to shove (if Mab orders something he's unwilling to do) Odin can simply take off the Kringlemantle and say, "nope."

The thing is:  neither of them want this to happen simply as a result of Aesir/Faerie political squabbling, or points of pride between the two monarchs or their courts.  The Kringlemantle and what it represents and does is important to both of them.  Without ever actually speaking about it, they are lowkey collaborating to avoid needless conflicts; and both of them are pretty damned good at that sort of tactico-strategic thinking, so it works well (and has for hundreds of years).

60
DF Spoilers / Re: Choices
« on: April 28, 2025, 01:18:42 PM »
You are assuming that nothing around Harry changes, that all the people around him remain the same..  That's the mistake I think, because Harry's choice and his change in this other universe doesn't happen in a vacuum.
No, I agree:  things around Harry will begin changing, from the moment of "the Choice."  Harry changes, so what Harry does changes -- how he acts, how he reacts -- and everyone in  his orbit will in turn be changed.

But Michael's northstar isn't Harry; it never was.  He'll be among the less-changed (at least for the first few books); I don't expect any of Harry's changes will affect Michael's faith, or status as a Knight, or his Divine Guidance to help others in need.

And because there is a confluence in Chicago -- all of the same "dark powers" that Harry noted are still coming to bear, there -- I think Michael will more-often be Guided to Murphy's aid, than he originally was in the first few books.

Pages: 1 2 3 [4] 5 6 ... 172