Show Posts

This section allows you to view all posts made by this member. Note that you can only see posts made in areas you currently have access to.


Messages - Aminar

Pages: 1 2 [3] 4 5 ... 27
31
Hitler and Stalin had modern technology, communication and organisation at their side. Unlike Rome however they lost and we do not have to listen to their mythology.

They were innovators and though their crimes were not new they were on a scale unheard of before their time.

Rome was similar. Everything they did was known before the romans came but they killed and enslaved on a scale and efficiency never heard of before. They were innovators too.

But I think I wandered away from my original argument here. They were all horrible people who did far more even than most people in their situation and even in their time would have done. The difference that was important for my argument is that some of them had build a mythology around them.

And that mythology still has power today over peoples mind.

https://mobile.nytimes.com/2016/03/13/opinion/sunday/stalinist-nostalgia-in-vladimir-putins-russia.html
Remember, we see a difference between what a ruler does to others and what they do their own people still. Ceaser and Napoleon didn't commit genocide within their borders on nearly tbe scale Hitler and Stalin did.(Although I think at points Rome did.) That's the difference people see. And it's a tough difference to argue against. In the end I'm not sure the difference matters. But to our culture it does. But you're arguing the wrong thing.

32
After all, He Who Must Not Be Named did great things - Terrible, yes, but great.
Yes. Kemmler was in this story.

33
I thought there was a mention of camoflaging the holy swords in a bucket of mundane ones. Might have been props from his dad's stage magic rather than actual weapons though...
I think it was an Umbrella stand. So with umbrellas, and Canes. And the like.

34
DF Spoilers / Re: Standard Warden Equipment?
« on: July 13, 2017, 02:15:51 AM »
Fair amount by hobby expenditure standards, absolutely.  Fair amount as in equivalent to the Salary of a Full-time Job (even setting aside Hazard Pay), I still think Not Even Close.
Dude. Have you looked at how much Warhammer pewter minis cost. Now remove the mass production stuff that reduces costs. And make each mold unique. A few square miles of chicago would require more than a thousand hand crafted unique very detailed molds. Each one with shipping costs that are not offset by mass production. Little Chicago is in the 6 digit price range. If anything Jim underestimated the cost pre-3d printing.

35
Isn't that mostly due to Stuart Lake's heavily fictionalised "biography" of Earp?

In reality, he was an occasional law enforcer and gambler who was accused of murder after the O.K. Corral shootout and got off because he hired a famous defence attorney. Doesn't really scream "zombie killer" material to me.
I said Legend for a reason. In Dresden legends are truth. Even more recent ones.

36
First I thought that it was Page (as the new recruit) that is doing the summoning but he is just the drummer. Later in the fight, Grevane redirects some zombies to the roof to attack her,  so he was the summoner.

I guess he wanted to be able to throw some evocation around as well if needed? Since in Dead Beat, he summons full powered Zombies and it takes up to much of his energy that he can only attack with mundane weapons besides that.

Okay, still feels unrealistic that a Vanilla Sheriff mowed down a 40+ hoard of zombies, especially when for a good part of it, he was out on the street and the hoard was reportedly approaching from both sides, at some point he should have been surrounded. Feels to nice of an ending simply, no one got hurt, and Luccio has a hot trail to pursue Kemmler (although that one is probably a trap).

This story gives Necromancers a bad rap!
What you're missing is that this is Wyatt Earp. Wyatt Earp.  He's a literal legend. Documentaries are made about him. He's taught about in American schools. Having him be anything other than strictly epic would ruin the cameo and feel off to anyone with enough knowledge of both American History and Alt-history genre savvy. So no, it doesn't give necromancers a bad name. It holds true to the legends of the source material in the same way making Odin terrifyingly powerful does.

37
Let's look at a similar situation.

Harry walks in and uses his little candle lighting spell to light a bunch of candles.

Then, one gets knocked over.

The place burns down and kill some mortals.

Harry is TECHNICALLY guilty of murder, but there would be no council, or cosmic consequences.
I find that ridiculous and unlikely. There comes a point where the magical fire becomes the same as regular fire. At the same time if Little Chicago exploded while Harry was gone and his landlady died I'd see that as a violation due to the increased negligence involved. But it sounds more like the ward issue(both do.)

38
I've never spent a lot of time reading up on the Wild West, so when I beta'd the story, I looked up information on Earp and Dodge City, and landed on the "Dodge City War" as the timing for the short story, since it pretty closely resembles Earp's description of the tensions in the city/saloon.  Hence my estimate of the timing between the two events.
It looks like some of the history is fudged. Jim changed Luke Short's name to Bill Short if that's right. While the story seems to match up with the one I saw.

39
Jim had his Reddit podcast Q&A around the time he wrote Fist Full of Warlocks and said this:

Which is only a year or 3 after the events of Fist Full of Warlocks.  Could be related to your question.
Near as I can tell the story is in 1877. So almost a decade, but not a terribly long time. (As that appears to be when Earp and Bat were working as deputies in Dodge city.)
From wikipedia.
(click to show/hide)

40
DF Spoilers / Re: WK Mantle or Lawbreaker taint?
« on: June 29, 2017, 09:36:07 PM »
Intent might not matter much, but belief might. Guilt might? And I don't think Harry feels nearly as guilty about killing those people as his murder of Susan. Who wasn't mortal and thus doesn't really count for lawbreaking. But might because of how he feels.
Either way, the murderousness is winter. He describes it in tandem with the lust(which wouldn't be from lawbreaking) too often. I feel like that would be an unpleasant and cheap twist beneath Jim's talent. A gotcha moment.

41
DF Spoilers / Re: Lara-Nemesis-Oblivion War
« on: May 25, 2017, 01:34:44 PM »
Possible, if it can do so for someone other than it's (presumably0 bonded wielder). And No, Maeve doomed herself by being a spoiled prat, but since the Staff needs informed consent from it's wielder I have to think it would have needed the same willing participation that Mab did.  In fact, Mab's ability to cure Nemfection might be directly related to the mechanism of the blackstaff.  Assuming of course that both the underlying theories are correct (that the Blackstaff is a Winter Artifact and that Black Magic Taint = Nemfection
The theory is that the supernatural element of Black Magic taint (the bit that the blackstaff protects Eb from, independent of the moral and psychological fallout) is in fact an expression of Nemfection.  There are various threads that pull together to make this theory hold some water, but the core idea is that since Magic is the very fundamental force of Creation and since Mortals are directly empowered like no other to affect the fabric of reality (via Soul and Free Will), so when then choose to twist that Power of Life and Creation is one of several specific Extreme ways, it creates a sort of 'crack' in reality that allows a bit of Nemesis Inside.  Do it often enough and the accumulated Taint/Nemfection would build up and eventually start influencing you more directly.  Since Fae have no Soul, they both do not have the same effect on reality with their magic (just like how they cannot actually Summon Outsiders) but similarly they dont have the same Cosmically protected Choice; so their Nemfections require outside vectors, but also can happen much more swiftly.
That doesn't work... It makes Nemesis an absolute moron. I mean, it's only gotten two barely infected agents into the Council via nemfection. It gets most of its human infectees killed, makes them all addicts, and generally breaks their sanity. And its stupidly overt. So personally, no. Bad stupid theory tying unrelated phenomenon together in a silly conspiracy that makes no practical sense.

42
DF Spoilers / Re: Lara-Nemesis-Oblivion War
« on: May 25, 2017, 12:35:26 AM »
Makes you wonder if the Blackstaff can cure infection, and Eb possessing it doomed Maeve.
It doesn't really add up. Going Warlock is a strictly mortal thing. How would Sith have gone Warlock? Whatever taint Black Magic brings, it's a separate thing.

44
DF Spoilers / Re: Lara-Nemesis-Oblivion War
« on: May 24, 2017, 02:38:05 PM »
Basically, she coordinates the effort to remove books and other sources of information about the Old Gods. Then, when she hasn't heard a certain name come up in any source for 3 or 4 centuries she assumes that everyone else has forgotten about it and 'deletes' it from the archive.

It's a long game.
Do we have a source on this? Because that is decidedly anti-neutral. And given the regular crazy associated with past Archives it seems like that would be ineffective. 

45
DF Spoilers / Re: Lara-Nemesis-Oblivion War
« on: May 24, 2017, 02:20:27 PM »
Ivy's existence is the Oblivion War..  Her purpose is to erase the Old gods from reality.
Care to explain how storing knowledge of them erases knowledge of them? That seems... Off.

Pages: 1 2 [3] 4 5 ... 27