Show Posts

This section allows you to view all posts made by this member. Note that you can only see posts made in areas you currently have access to.


Messages - RobReece

Pages: 1 ... 15 16 [17] 18
241
Yes.  A wizard's powers can be stolen.

Evidence: In Grave Peril, the Nightmare eats a part of Harry's spirit.  After that, the Nightmare is able to take corporeal form and cast spells -- and Harry's own magic is noticeably weaker.

Permanently?  Less clear.  But Harry was worried that he might never regain his power if he didn't take it back from Kravos by force, which he does.  However, what we learn later about the way a person's soul regenerates over time and with certain life-affirming experiences... it probably wouldn't have been a permanent loss.

Would the White Council do this?

No.  Not a chance. It feels like dark magic.  It probably corrupts the one who steals the power -- especially if they're taking the power from someone corrupted or dark.  Anyone who is dangerous enough that they'd consider this technique... should just be beheaded.

What if the person doing it was in possession of the Blackstaff?

242
DF Spoilers / Re: Senior Council Magic Speciality
« on: June 15, 2017, 04:40:44 PM »
Interesting..
They also both have an eye missing, have a replacement eye that gives them knowledge, both are taller than Harry (which is really rare) and both deal with time manipulation.

WAG: Odin is Gatekeeper

Okay maybe not, but there's definitely a connection there.

They've both had the same job, Odin was the previous Gatekeeper, Rashid's "eye" was probably Odins at one time.

EDIT, ok "A" previous Gatekeeper.

243
DF Spoilers / Re: Are the Mothers immune to iron?
« on: June 14, 2017, 11:40:00 PM »
I like to think that Mother Winter is just so badass/powerful that despite being just as vulnerable to Iron as any other Faerie, she keeps some in her mouth as a statement. "I use my own personal Kryptonite as Dentures, you want some of this?"
:D

244
DF Spoilers / Re: Weapons that can kill Immortals?
« on: June 14, 2017, 04:54:39 PM »
I dunno.  On the one hand we've been told that theoretically circles are unnecessary because anyone sufficiently Powerful can Imagine one strong enough to all but Will it into existence.

On the other hand, there are hard&fast rules to how Power is quantified (barring trans-dimensional exceptions like DR), such as the fact that the material impacts the function of the Circle (Iron affects Fae, Blood can carry the most energy, etc. Also the perfection of the geometry affects efficiency. 

So I have to think that a 4 mile Perfect circle drawn in Pure Energy moving at nearly the Speed of Light would still prove Useful even to the upper-tiers of the NN beings.  I cant say for certain that it would allow them to do things they could not do otherwise, but Im confident anything that might call for it would be easier with Fermilab than without
Can you imagine the being that would take a 4 mile circle of containment?

245
DF Spoilers / Re: Are the Mothers immune to iron?
« on: June 14, 2017, 03:34:00 PM »
In SK she has several sets of teeth, but the metal one "was made out of some kind of silvery metal, shining like a sword", so it wasnt specified as Iron.  The shears are described as "rusty shears", though since it's not "rust-colored" it remains possible that the oxidation was non-specific; silver can be rusty but it's black, or green for copper-based alloys. Many of my old "rusty" tools appear to have black rust, rather than the stereotype red-rust of iron.

But a WOJ makes a strong implication that those shears are the mythic shears of Atropos, used to Cut the strings of Fate and end lives; I tend to question whether such a cosmically significant artifact would be made of common materials.
Not necessarily relevant to the story, but the post....

Red Rust

Hydrated oxide Fe2O3•H2O
 (high oxygen/water exposure)

Rust from Iron (III) oxides forms due to high oxygen and water exposure resulting in red rust.
•Red rust is the result of heavy exposure to air and moisture, combined many times with a contaminate (salt).
•This type of rust is most likely atmospheric because typically there are no signs of rust runs or streaks on the metal parts/equipment where the rust has formed.
•With red rust, there is uniform corrosion, most often from a very corrosive environment.


Yellow Rust

Iron oxide-hydroxide FeO(OH)H2O
 (high moisture)

Rust from Iron (III) oxides that is a very soluble iron oxide results in yellow rust.
•Yellow rust is distinguishable in recessed areas of the metal parts/equipment where the rust “runs and drips” (solvated rust).
•Yellow rust forms as a result of very high moisture content. It frequently found in settings where puddled/standing water has most likely been present.


Brown Rust

Oxide Fe2O3
 (high oxygen/low moisture)

Rust from Iron (III) oxides with high oxygen and low moisture results in brown rust.
•Brown rust is a drier rust than those mentioned above.
•It is most likely atmospheric – having formed as a result of water and oxygen in the atmosphere and presenting as a reddish-brown crust on the metal’s surface.
•Brown rust is sometimes localized rust which appears as non-uniform spots or only in certain areas rather than over the whole surface. It can be the result of a contaminate on the metal’s surface often originating from the manufacturing process.


Black Rust

Iron (II)oxide – Fe3O4
 (limited oxygen)

Rust from Iron (III) oxides with limited oxygen and low moisture results in black rust.
•Black rust can be visually identified as a thin, black film which is the result of oxidation in a low oxygen environment.
•Black rust has an appearance of almost a black stain. Most likely the areas exhibiting the black rust had something covering them, which prevented oxygen from reaching the surface.
•This type of rust is a more stable rust layer that does not propagate as rapidly as other rust forms.

246
DF Spoilers / Re: Maggie's School Friends at SMAGT
« on: June 12, 2017, 05:47:41 PM »
Given the fun he apparently had writing cats into Cinder Spires, I imagine he'd have Maggie teaming up with one in some fashion.
Seeing that Maggie's Dad already has Mister, I don't see another feline joining the cast, but I could be wrong. 

I think it would be interesting to see a relative of Tera West...

247
If I remember correctly, there had been a WOJ or video or something that said there was a possible link between the DV and Alera, even a possible bloodline link between Harry and Tavi.  But that neither have links to the world of the Spires.
The problem with that would be the references to the Furies  of Olympus, that's made.

248
DF Spoilers / Re: What is a Saint? (Series Spoilers)
« on: June 08, 2017, 06:34:47 PM »
This could work, lets chase that. 

When first introduced it was mentioned that "Michael didn't come down into the lab with me because the whole concept of using magic without the Almighty behind it didn't sit well with him, regardless of what we'd been through together".  I always thought this was an indication that Michael was entirely familiar with a farm of magic that /was/ more religious (as distinct from Harry views).  Now, when Michael prays to God it's always characterized as being the very simple, humble and direct sort of Prayer, just asking for help without a lot of ostentatious trappings.  And sometimes when he prays like that spectacular things happen. But other times he shouts Latin battle-cries and such to get the effects.  I submit that when he is using Latin phrases to channel power, he is casting a spell using magic words as mental insulation as per usual; it's likely at least as unconscious a process as the Alpha's transformation has supposedly become, but I think it's still Magic (Not sure if it's Life Energy or Faith Energy, or some blending).  By contrast I propose that those times he's prayed in the more simple way in English for a result we are seeing something qualitatively different, arguably the sort of "divine intervention" miracles that Saints are supposed to be able to request from on-high.    Thoughts?
Now here I would disagree with you, I don't think Michael ever "uses magic" or casts a spell.  There are times when his prayers are more dramatic and flashy and times when he's quiet and humble, but I think it's all based on his Faith that TWG is using him as a tool and the response, whatever shape that response comes in, is coming from on high.

249
DF Spoilers / Re: How Harry would do the Dark Hallow in Changes wag
« on: June 08, 2017, 02:56:19 PM »
I don't have Grave Peril with me at the moment and it's been a while since I've read it, didn't Harry absorb some of the power of the spirits killed by the Reds?  If I remember correctly, it was only temporary, but wouldn't that have been along the lines of a dark hallow?  Improperly done as it was only temporary, but still in that type of power assumption?

250
DF Spoilers / Re: How Harry would do the Dark Hallow in Changes wag
« on: June 06, 2017, 11:58:06 PM »
I don't think it could be done in changes.  Not only not by Harry, but not by anyone.  Per Bob in CD, the mortality of immortals on Halloween is what would have allowed it to work.
The importance of Halloween is that it's when Immortals become semi mortal, also good for when masks(mantles) are donned and/or removed.  The death of an Immortal wasn't required for the DH, but it was convenient to have the Hunt gathering and stirring up the warrior and hunter spirits. 
On any other day, if Harry, or someone, were to perform the DH just consuming spirits and claiming their power could possibly work, but may not raise them to immortality.  During Changes, Harry would probably have been satisfied by just the accumulation of power, sufficient to smite the Reds and retrieve his daughter... 

251
DF Spoilers / Re: Lara-Nemesis-Oblivion War
« on: May 25, 2017, 03:00:28 PM »
tying unrelated phenomenon together in a silly conspiracy that makes no practical sense.
do you have any idea how many theories on this board could be described this way?
including some of mine...

252
DF Spoilers / Re: Lara-Nemesis-Oblivion War
« on: May 24, 2017, 04:14:37 PM »
Jim.  The Archive isn't neutral with the Old Gods, just in other things.  When it comes to killing people who are connected to the Old Ones Ivy is without mercy.  The only crazy i know of is her mother, and that's because she took on the mantle at such a young age.  Her mother was murdered, and she got it too early.
You say her mother was murdered? Do you have a source for that?  As I recall, Ivy's mother was young(upper teens maybe twenty something?) and in love, when her mother was killed in a car crash, Ivy's mom flipped out over becoming the Archive and no longer having "her" life, that as soon as Ivy was born, she committed suicide.

From SmF
(click to show/hide)

Ahh, I just realized that you weren't talking about Ivy,but her mom... ok

253
DF Spoilers / Lara-Nemesis-Oblivion War
« on: May 23, 2017, 04:11:12 PM »
If this has been discussed elsewhere, please accept my apologies...

If Lara were to become nemfected, would that give Nemesis any advantage given her involvement in the Oblivion War?  Would Jim want to use that to bring that conflict into the main book series?

If I remember correctly that he doesn't plan to have Harry involved in the Oblivion War, is this a clue to show that Lara won't be nemfected in order to keep it out?

thoughts?

254
If I remember correctly, there had been a WOJ or video or something that said there was a possible link between the DV and Alera, even a possible bloodline link between Harry and Tavi.  But that neither have links to the world of the Spires.

255
Cinder Spires Spoilers / Re: Olympia
« on: May 16, 2017, 11:22:51 PM »
Either is possible, but my thinking was that their expedition was to retrieve/harvest material that would just be found on the surface, probably near Albion.  I think that if there had been a crash, he wouldn't have had the chance to plan ahead and reserve the rooms and he probably would have taken whatever rooms were available at the base of the spire, not halfway up the side at Landing.

I'm also expecting him to play a part in "The Olympian Affair"

Pages: 1 ... 15 16 [17] 18