Show Posts

This section allows you to view all posts made by this member. Note that you can only see posts made in areas you currently have access to.


Messages - Snark Knight

Pages: 1 ... 54 55 [56] 57 58 ... 76
826
DF Spoilers / Re: Is Mac God?
« on: April 05, 2018, 06:18:01 PM »
I don't see it. That maenad in the short story really put one over on Mac. It's one thing for him to respect mortal free will, but I don't see Mac letting a supernatural being mess with him like that if he had omniscience and omnipotence going for him.

827
DF Spoilers / Re: Dog Men Release Q&A Suggestions
« on: April 04, 2018, 02:32:11 PM »
That was kind of the thought behind him doing things to pay of debts for others.

I figured what Grey was really getting out of the matter was mainly from Vadderung in exchange for just being available for Harry to 'hire'. It was probably only a dollar because some aspect of the job appealed to him and he just has to keep up his code of being a mercenary so he has to charge something.

Like, Kincaid would probably not care much about money either if someone was shopping around contracts on Nicodemus. Payment would just be a mercenary excuse for doing something he really wants to anyway. (Actually, with Nic left on the run at the end of SG and Marcone having put a price on him, I wonder if Kincaid will be tempted to leave Ivy's service now that she's older and go head-hunting)

828
DF Spoilers / Re: Dog Men Release Q&A Suggestions
« on: April 02, 2018, 02:03:11 AM »
I wonder if maybe he isn't working for Mab, and he's trying to help pay off some of her Debt/Karma by proxy.  We know she's trying to balance her books, so there is that possibility.

The emphasis on rent suggests it's not just any old debt; there's some specific element of paying to be somewhere.

It's probably something to do with being able to retain his strength and shape-shifting off of the traditional skinwalker territories. I'd tend to guess the full-blooded skinwalkers might not take too kindly to him living on their turf.

829
DF Spoilers / Re: Government involvement *spoiler*
« on: March 28, 2018, 11:19:39 PM »
Quick question: Where in the time line does Dog Men land? Harry's exposure to government agents aware of and meddling in the supernatural world has definite series impact.

After Wild Card but before Changes. Probably not super far before Changes.

830
DF Spoilers / Re: What's Up With Marcone?
« on: March 27, 2018, 09:33:00 PM »
The other reason he's not a Starborn is that he's at least a decade older than Harry. The astrological conjunction is only one of the prerequisites for making a Starborn, but it's one that doesn't come around all that frequently. Elaine is eligible because their birth dates are within a few months, but that's about the limit of 'close enough'. Plus I'm not even sure if a non-wizard can be Starborn at all - it very well may be one of the important parts.

831
DF Spoilers / Re: What's Up With Marcone?
« on: March 27, 2018, 12:04:00 AM »
Absolutely not.  When Marcone was talking about killing Harry, it's because Harry was a threat to Marcone, not to Chicago.  Marcone does head up a criminal empire, remember.

I mean, if Harry went dark in a way that offended Marcone's rules (no kids, no excessive public order disruptions) he'd probably order the hit. Maybe that's why MM Marcone is "interesting".

832
DF Spoilers / Re: Baddies - Past, Present, and Future
« on: March 26, 2018, 07:18:11 PM »
Yeah, but Binder's talent is way, way too useful to be considered really minor, in my opinion. I'm talking about the guys who hang out at Mac's, with super minor kinetomancy, things like that.
Though I guess we kinda saw that in Ghost Story, now I think about it; Aristedes was super minor, and we saw what kind of petty villainy that causes.

The smartest thing anyone with villainous inclinations in that weight class could do with their talents is apply them to stealing money from mortals rather than run around picking fights with Wardens. Note, for example, that Aristedes only started pushing his luck because he thought Harry was dead, and he was real cooperative until Butters and Daniel failed his test and outed themselves as fake Wardens. Punching down is just so much safer than challenging someone who can do everything you can and infinitely more besides.


it would be interesting to see someone with probability magic of some kind.  Something similar to Cassandra's tears, but more able to predict outcomes based on probabilities so that it isn't really seeing in the future.

Sounds like you'd enjoy Benedict Jacka's Alex Verus series. A diviner is doing something sort of like Cassandra's tears, but examining a few seconds range of all possible futures or following a single one for longer to simulate the results of actions they're considering. But it's also a skill set that's best suited to being sneaky rather than getting into head-on fights with guys who demolish buildings.

833
DF Spoilers / Re: Dog Men Release Q&A Suggestions
« on: March 25, 2018, 01:47:07 AM »
Great question. It never even crossed my mind to question that scene. Given what Tessa was throwing around later on, I wouldn't think that power is an issue but still...

Tessa probably has use of the Sight, but I'm not sure how effective a tactic it actually would have been in the aquarium. They had no idea what room Ivy was in, and it risks 'information overload' to use it for a room-by-room search. Plus Ivy probably would have changed plans from hide to throw her hardest punch by surprise if she saw anyone trying that.

In terms of questions, I'd like to nominate for consideration:
- Can blampires just go to sleep in a well-hidden coffin for a few decades to wait out a period of danger, and did any of the Elders try to get through the Stokerlypse like that?
- In the DV, historical authors like Shakespeare, Stoker and Lovecraft were "onto something". Are there any others?
- Since the event is for the Dog Men release, I suppose it's topical to ask what was up with those feds? They didn't seem especially bothered by a couple of wizards learning there are clued feds. So there's the (highly reclusive) Librarians and some other agency that's LTW has some familiarity with?
- What's the actual difference between a Fae ruler and a pagan god? The Fae still seem to depend on belief to some extent (hence Mab inspiring the Brothers Grimm and Walt Disney to keep faeries in human cultural mythology). Vadderung / Kringle is straddling the line, and the Erlking also seems to have aspects of some of the pagan hunt gods.
- In Fool Moon, Chauncey the demon told Harry the loup garou curse was "said to" have originally been cast by Saint Patrick. Supernaturally forcing an entire bloodline of people to become involuntary killers seems pretty out of alignment with Heaven's rules on free will. Was Chauncey repeating a false story as hearsay?
- In a previous Q&A about thresholds, Jim said the fetches actually hammered through the Carpenter threshold, making Harry mistaken in assuming they gained an invitation by shapeshifting into a trusted form. Putting together the Scarecrow's seemingly abnormally high resistance to iron with the subsequent information from Cold Days (Cat Sith's explanation of Fae law on thresholds, and that Nemesis releases its hosts from the binding rules of their nature), do we have sufficient basis to confirm the leading three fetches who entered the Carpenter house were N-fected?

834
DF Spoilers / Re: Nick and the Cup (New Theory?)
« on: March 14, 2018, 04:53:58 PM »
Coming from the perspective that Nick want's to "save the world", and he thinks that there is soon going to be a changing of the guard at the Outer Gates, I'm wondering if he didn't want the cup, and the other artifacts to aid him in taking over that charge.

I don't think he wants to just uphold the status quo of defending the gates. I think his long game is lasting destruction of the Outsiders, but he's planning on scorched-earth (probably literally) methods to get there.

835
DF Spoilers / Re: Faerie Queens Full(?) List
« on: March 09, 2018, 02:10:37 AM »
So, would Mother Winter be the closest to the source of Fae power?

The Mother Winter mantle might yet even turn out to be the portion of power the original Hecate chose to keep for herself when dividing the Courts and queen mantles.

836
DF Spoilers / Re: Mortimer Lindquist Powers and Abilities
« on: March 08, 2018, 07:48:52 PM »
2. His control over spirits is extensive. Morty sent ghosts all throughout Chicago to pull off the map trick—you're talking about a compulsion that spans a very, very great distance. Several miles, at the very least, which is difficult with any magic (though you can argue that the rules for ectomancy are a little squishier than other disciplines).

I don't think he was compelling every ghost for miles around to work for him. I think he just asked the ones he was on good terms with. Filling in the map offered them a chance to stick a spoke in the wheels of a threat that was pointed at them too, at minimal personal risk. They wouldn't have needed forcing.

837
Is Jim going to flip flop books between series again?

He said the Olympia Affair (CS #2) is next on his writing queue in one of the previous statements, yes.

As much as we're all hella excited for Mirror Mirror, Jim has said alternating projects helps him not get sick of doing too much of one thing. Besides, more talking cats.

838
DF Spoilers / Re: Yggdrasil
« on: March 06, 2018, 05:50:16 PM »
It's been speculated before. The other theory for Yggdrasil is that it would be at Monoc headquarters.

Heck, if its roots are supernatural, the main tree could be in Scandinavia and its roots reach across the world to below Lake Michigan.

839
DF Spoilers / Re: If Jim handed off the series to someone else...
« on: March 06, 2018, 05:35:57 PM »
Benedict Jacka's Alex Verus series is already heavily similar to the DF. It might be fun to see them write a short story in each other's universe or something.

840
DF Spoilers / Re: TT Harry in Proven Guilty
« on: March 02, 2018, 02:08:51 AM »
That's not tenable, it shows no direct travel to the NN and Harry in the first room after the staircase(in the prison proper) was still in the mortal realm, in fact Mab was still in the mortal realm when she stayed with him as her power stayed with her.(See SK, Aurora and Elaine's convo on trying to kill Harry)
Always considered trapping them inside reality to be the whole point, it prevents them from manifesting elsewhere but leaves their power/balance inside the mortal realm.

The cave ceiling a thousand feet below ground level being full of tree roots that Harry narratively lampshades as being impossible under the conventional rules of nature is a pretty big hint there's something else going on with the cave. The stairwell down below and the barrier to the "minimum security" anteroom both pretty much melted out of previously solid material - that's plenty of opportunity for Alfred opening a gate so skillfully that Harry can't even tell it is a gate (another thing he's lampshaded the real pros being able to do).

I don't really buy that it's in the Nevernever either, though. Your reason that Mab was causing the long winter in Chicago by her presence in the cave taking care of Harry in GS is one solid point. Another is that it doesn't really fit with the surface reflecting onto some super-lethal patch of the NN, and putting supernatural supermax right in the Nevernever doesn't seem all that secure against some ungodly powerful creature of the spirit realm deciding to jailbreak its buddy by brute force either. Mainly, though, what seals it for me is that Harry didn't melt and die shortly after returning to Chicago because of all the cells that had been built on being fed intravenously by the tree roots reverting to ectoplasm.

I'm betting it's some sort of weird pocket dimension that Merlin made. Loosely related to how Bob said Harry could create a demesne within the NN if he wanted to invest sufficient effort, but Merlin's much more advanced technique let him put it in between worlds instead.

Pages: 1 ... 54 55 [56] 57 58 ... 76