The Dresden Files > DF Spoilers
Harry Dresden's New Apprentice!!?!
Mira:
--- Quote ---Absolutely not all of Lasciel's -- not a literal Fallen Angel -- maybe all of the Shadow's knowlege.
--- End quote ---
Yes, the Shadow did in my opinion, the Shadow was Lasciel in Harry's head. That's why resisting it once that happened was such a big deal.
--- Quote ---But I'm pretty sure Bonea won't suddenly become (for example) Harry's Guide to the Starborn Phenomenon; I do expect she'll have some highly-pertninent Starborn-relevant info, though!
--- End quote ---
In my opinion it doesn't matter whether she becomes Harry's guide about Starborn Phenomenon, he needs the information, that's important, but not as important as what Harry does with that information. However the main thing Bonea has to do is grow up or at least mature a bit. As she is presently, she is a pretty useless character, which begs the question, why all the drama over a half dozen books or more to end up with what? A brilliant, yet totally scatter brained, I further submit potentially dangerous toddler spirit? Is the joke on Harry, or us?
forumghost:
You have to understand, it's implied from what Lash said at the end of White Night that she (and by extension Bonnie) has a great deal of information that is integral to the metaplot and can't be revealed just yet because it would make Harry's life to easy.
So instead she gets to be a genius with all the answers that is simultaneously too dumb to realize she has to hand them out until the last 3 chapters of whatever book they become relevant in.
Just as an example, she 99% knows all about what a starborn is, she can probably tell Harry exactly what Nick's been up to, may well have a bunch of information about what the Black Council has been up to...
Like, she has to be useless, or we don't get a story.
Mira:
--- Quote from: forumghost on December 04, 2025, 09:20:31 AM ---You have to understand, it's implied from what Lash said at the end of White Night that she (and by extension Bonnie) has a great deal of information that is integral to the metaplot and can't be revealed just yet because it would make Harry's life to easy.
So instead she gets to be a genius with all the answers that is simultaneously too dumb to realize she has to hand them out until the last 3 chapters of whatever book they become relevant in.
Just as an example, she 99% knows all about what a starborn is, she can probably tell Harry exactly what Nick's been up to, may well have a bunch of information about what the Black Council has been up to...
Like, she has to be useless, or we don't get a story.
--- End quote ---
That only works for so long, because it then becomes boring, so she has to be taught to think, hence Bonea becomes an apprentice! No, it won't happen over night, but it needs to happen as a check on Marcone/Namshiel. Also making Harry suffer also is getting a bit old, that is becoming all to predictable, and boring.
g33k:
--- Quote from: forumghost on December 04, 2025, 09:20:31 AM ---You have to understand, it's implied from what Lash said at the end of White Night that she (and by extension Bonnie) has a great deal of information that is integral to the metaplot and can't be revealed just yet because it would make Harry's life to easy.
So instead she gets to be a genius with all the answers that is simultaneously too dumb to realize she has to hand them out until the last 3 chapters of whatever book they become relevant in.
...
Like, she has to be useless, or we don't get a story.
--- End quote ---
I think this is exactly correct. Harry has to be kept ignorant, or he cannot be the investigator-protagonist.
--- Quote from: forumghost on December 04, 2025, 09:20:31 AM --- ... Just as an example, she 99% knows all about what a starborn is, she can probably tell Harry exactly what Nick's been up to, may well have a bunch of information about what the Black Council has been up to...
--- End quote ---
I don't think it's at all certain that Bonea knows everything Lash knew... but if she knows just half of what the Shadow knew, that'd be a huge trove of new data for Harry! I kind of think Lash knew she could only send part of herself forward as Bonea, and tried to curate for Harry to have access to the most-useful bits; but OTOH there's also the likelihood that there may have been too much chaos & unpredictability to the event, and Lash couldn't control things completely that way.
I'm pretty certain that Lasciel's Shadow knew vastly less than what Lasciel herself knew! The "Shadow" is an imprint within a mortal mind: I don't think Angelic-scale knowledge fits in there! ;D
But, as for finding out Nic (and Anduriel's) actions/agenda: Bonea can only know what Lash knew, who can only know what Lasciel knew. And we already have seen secrets & infighting between the Denarians... I'm pretty sure there are exactly zero other Denarians who have an accurate understanding of Anduriel's plans.
g33k:
--- Quote from: Mira on November 30, 2025, 01:42:17 PM ---Yes, the Shadow did in my opinion, the Shadow was Lasciel in Harry's head...
--- End quote ---
The Shadow wasn't actual Lasciel, nor Lasciel's presence.
It was a construct; built by Lasciel, but then independent & disconnected from the Fallen angel.
Navigation
[0] Message Index
[#] Next page
[*] Previous page
Go to full version