The Dresden Files > DF Spoilers
Q&A Fantasyfestival 2023 in Esbjerg/Denmark
Mira:
--- Quote ---And even if she changed, I dunno why it wouldn't be something the fans of hers wouldn't want? Why assume the change would be a bad one in the first place? But even if it was, Harry has taken blow after blow, jobs and mantles on himself and he's, let's say "evolved" not necessarily in a positive way, he's extremely flawed at this point, but for most fans, it seems, it has made him more interesting. Murphy fans will know if maybe the same applies to her.
--- End quote ---
In any case, she won't be Murphy anymore.. No matter what your opinion of her turns out to be.
LaraBeck:
--- Quote from: Mira on September 26, 2023, 03:17:44 AM ---In any case, she won't be Murphy anymore.. No matter what your opinion of her turns out to be.
--- End quote ---
In any case, we'll see, the series isn't over yet. And if my opinion of her doesn't matter, obviously neither does yours.
magnuskn:
Moreover, Murphy already has gone through big of personal outlook (and position in life) during the last five books and she still was Murphy at her core.
Mira:
--- Quote ---In any case, we'll see, the series isn't over yet. And if my opinion of her doesn't matter, obviously neither does yours.
--- End quote ---
I, for one never said your opinion doesn't matter, it does, and you are entitled to it.. I just disagree with the idea, and attempt to support why I do so. I am also entitled to my opinion, it also matters, that's how it works..
--- Quote ---Moreover, Murphy already has gone through big of personal outlook (and position in life) during the last five books and she still was Murphy at her core.
--- End quote ---
Is she? Is that even a good thing? Don't know, maybe it would be. She has been murdered in a stupid way by a guy that is arguably insane, but still last we heard an influential member of law enforcement. That might change her just a bit.. Now granted that might be an interesting read, but we won't be reading about the Murphy you think you know. That's just an opinion..
g33k:
--- Quote from: Mira on September 26, 2023, 03:17:44 AM --- In any case, she won't be Murphy anymore.. No matter what your opinion of her turns out to be.
--- End quote ---
Harry got imprinted with the shadow of a Fallen Angel, spent years with her inside his skull.
He died -- dead enough to ghost-around for days -- and came back to life.
He's saddled with the personality-warping influences of a Winter Mantle.
And yet, you say, Harry's still Harry at his core.
But you seem adamant that Murphy cannot still be Murphy...?
I don't see anything to prevent her from still being herself (given the precedents that Jim has written)... except that you don't want her to be.
Navigation
[0] Message Index
[#] Next page
[*] Previous page
Go to full version