The Dresden Files > DF Spoilers
Is Murphy truly dead
The_Sibelis:
--- Quote from: Arjan on November 16, 2021, 10:31:05 AM ---Jim might do a story from her POV but for all other purposes she is dead. Unless the apocalypse changes everything to such an extend that everything is possible. Jim might go completely crazy in the last books.
--- End quote ---
na, just cause the all father can't do something doesn't mean it can't be done. Death is a spectrum, and I get the feeling Odin took her just to keep her in the right range of it. Odin can revive people because he has soul fire... So exactly what would stop Harry from doing it? Except knowledge directly.
Conspiracy Theorist:
And Bonea would have knowledge of Soul Fire, so all Harry has to do is ask her.
Which he won’t.
Mira:
--- Quote from: Conspiracy Theorist on November 17, 2021, 11:09:40 AM ---And Bonea would have knowledge of Soul Fire, so all Harry has to do is ask her.
Which he won’t.
--- End quote ---
Even if he did use it, since he isn't a god, wouldn't that be an abuse of his gift?
Conspiracy Theorist:
It depends if he is doing so in accordance with the divine plan of the White God. Odin is, in creating the a Einenjhar, Harry cannot do so without abusing it for a personal whim, so he would need some greater purpose, otherwise Murphy dying with Odin at Ragnarok would go to her just reward for her faith and as a former Knight.
Harry would have to take on the Angel of Death, who he has already met in Ghost Story. Foreshadowing?
Mira:
auth,or=Conspiracy Theorist link=topic=54523.msg2351055#msg2351055 date=1637170611]
--- Quote ---It depends if he is doing so in accordance with the divine plan of the White God. Odin is, in creating the a Chekov's gunHarry cannot do so without abusing it for a personal whim, so he would need some greater purpose, otherwise Murphy dying with Odin at Ragnarok would go to her just reward for her faith and as a former Knight.
Harry would have to take on the Angel of Death, who he has already met in Ghost Story. Foreshadowing?
--- End quote ---
The Angel of Death already did his job, Murphy is gone, whether he had anything to do with the
body pick up or not.. Murphy was cold and dead when it happened, not like Harry who wasn't all dead when he fell into the ice water and Mab's arms. If Murphy goes to her just reward after Odin is done with her, it's Heaven, not Harry. The whole debate is muddled, given her history as knight and her faith, I really doubt that she'd choose to go to Valhalla.. That blows out of the water the premise of her faith, as a good Christian she'd want her soul to go to Heaven, not hang out drinking ale in a warrior's paradise so she can fight and kill at a later date for a god she doesn't believe in.
Navigation
[0] Message Index
[#] Next page
[*] Previous page
Go to full version