The Dresden Files > DF Spoilers
Is Murphy truly dead
Mira:
--- Quote ---We have to follow Jim’s story here, not what we think we know about Valhalla.
--- End quote ---
True, but ever stop to think Jim is telling the readers exactly what he means? The rule that even the All Father can't break, "she won't return until she has faded from all living memory..." In other words, neither she nor Hendricks are physically coming back into the story, ever. That isn't to say he might change his mind, he sort of gives himself that option.. But then again, her story ran it's natural course in many ways..
The_Sibelis:
I would rather it not. For one plain and specific reason. Harry's already had one "girl in the bathroom" trope done to him once, with Susan.Murphys death setting up the same sort of character growth for Dresden... Would just be overdone at this point.
Arjan:
--- Quote from: The_Sibelis on November 16, 2021, 08:50:09 AM ---I would rather it not. For one plain and specific reason. Harry's already had one "girl in the bathroom" trope done to him once, with Susan.Murphys death setting up the same sort of character growth for Dresden... Would just be overdone at this point.
--- End quote ---
Jim might do a story from her POV but for all other purposes she is dead. Unless the apocalypse changes everything to such an extend that everything is possible. Jim might go completely crazy in the last books.
Mira:
--- Quote ---Then it is not an afterlife. Then she did not go there. Then the whole story makes no sense at all.
--- End quote ---
Maybe it doesn't because it doesn't follow Murphy's faith, instead she was hijacked after her death, body and all.
--- Quote ---That is not how Gard formulated it.
--- End quote ---
Perhaps not, but the warriors chosen were chosen because they were very good at what they did in life..
--- Quote ---Jim might do a story from her POV but for all other purposes she is dead. Unless the apocalypse changes everything to such an extend that everything is possible. Jim might go completely crazy in the last books.
--- End quote ---
Maybe Harry finds her diary or something of that nature, going through her stuff, a chore that has to be done after one dies.
Arjan:
--- Quote from: Mira on November 16, 2021, 03:27:53 PM ---Maybe it doesn't because it doesn't follow Murphy's faith, instead she was hijacked after her death, body and all.
--- End quote ---
Hades got Deirdre. There are exceptions.
I also remember woj about it. Sometimes you do not end up where you think you should end up and Odin can bargain for you.
--- Quote ---Perhaps not, but the warriors chosen were chosen because they were very good at what they did in life..
--- End quote ---
That too.
--- Quote ---Maybe Harry finds her diary or something of that nature, going through her stuff, a chore that has to be done after one dies.
--- End quote ---
Navigation
[0] Message Index
[#] Next page
[*] Previous page
Go to full version