The Dresden Files > DF Spoilers
Errors, Inconsistencies, and Oddities
Yuillegan:
I will respond more tomorrow, as I don't have a lot of time now but I just wanted to say this is incredible.
A tad insane, but also amazing. Well done!
I am someone who truly appreciates this, and while errors/inconsistencies don't always ruin my enjoyment of a series I love when someone pays attention this much.
Seriously, congratulations on such a big effort. More discussion to follow :)
Mira:
Great job, inconsistencies to bother me in a series. The one that troubled me is the differences between Summer Knight flash backs and Ghost Story flashbacks as to what really happened when Harry came home early from school to be with Elaine and found what he found, and what happened.
BrainFireBob:
--- Quote from: Mira on April 08, 2020, 02:52:42 PM ---
Great job, inconsistencies to bother me in a series. The one that troubled me is the differences between Summer Knight flash backs and Ghost Story flashbacks as to what really happened when Harry came home early from school to be with Elaine and found what he found, and what happened.
--- End quote ---
I don't think this is an inconsistency. I think someone messed with Harry's memories
Mira:
--- Quote from: BrainFireBob on April 08, 2020, 06:26:15 PM ---I don't think this is an inconsistency. I think someone messed with Harry's memories
--- End quote ---
It can be seen that way, however there is the issue of the "knot" Elaine used to tie Harry up with when he got away from Justin.. She used it again at the end of Summer Knight to fool Aurora so Harry could escape and Elaine confirmed that.. But in Ghost Story, if I remember correctly, Harry wasn't tied up at all, just told to put on the straight jacket, and he rabbited out of there.
Bad Alias:
--- Quote ---Up to this point, he's never mentioned the White Council to Murphy and she doesn't go "White Council? What's that, Harry?" or anything like that
--- End quote ---
I've always figured that she did some looking. Maybe she figured most of it out from Billy who seems to know way too much in Summer Knight. It would explain her attitude change toward Harry.
--- Quote ---You can't do that. There's a waiting period before you can retest.
--- End quote ---
I imagine it's different in every state. For example: "WHAT HAPPENS IF I FAIL MY KS DRIVING EXAM?
If you fail the KS Driving Exam, you will not receive your KS Driver's License. You will be able to retake the test as early as the next business day." What state was Harry in? I've always assumed it was in the midwest. Also, we'd need to figure out what the law was in the 70's.
--- Quote ---Somehow, they're able to recover the sheath later on. Hopefully it fell off the train, otherwise that sucker was gone.
--- End quote ---
Harry's shtick is finding lost items.
--- Quote ---I’m not a truly advanced student, but I’ve practiced every day since I was seventeen.
--- End quote ---
She could have been once a week and taken summers off or whatever before she was 17.
Navigation
[0] Message Index
[#] Next page
[*] Previous page
Go to full version