The Dresden Files > DF Spoilers
Angelic intervention in Fool Moon
Cozarkian:
--- Quote from: morriswalters on April 10, 2019, 08:16:30 PM ---From the Wikipedia.Just as an aside, the bit about the Mab being unable to lie, is a shortcut. More properly she can't speak a direct lie. Here is an example of a lie of omission from Summer Knight. It's a play on his expectations.
--- End quote ---
GS does not have the structure of a lie by omission. Here is an example of a lie by omission: "If you enter this deal, I, Mab, promise I won't hurt you as punishment for rejecting my request for a favor (but I don't promise I won't hurt you just for spite)." Here is an example of a direct lie: "If you enter this deal, I, Mab, promise I won't hurt you as punishment for rejecting my request for a favor (unless I disagree with your reasons for doing so)."
The GS quote takes the form of the latter: "He is mine to shape as I please (unless he exercises free will)."
Also, again, it doesn't really matter how and why Mab was able to say what she said. What matters is that Uriel would not have said she her words were lies when he knows she can't lie and when he knows that Harry knows she can't lie. Here's the form of the seven words: <Factually questionable assertion that has to be justified by equivocation>, <very important truth>.
Here's the form that Uriel would have used: <Factually accurate assertion>, <very important truth>.
Here are examples of how that could have been done using only seven words:
Wrong, . . .
No, . . .
False, . . .
Incorrect, . . .
Exaggeration, . . .
Hyperbole, . . .
Deception, . . .
Deceiver, . . .
The speaker chose the worst possible word to use in the situation. Cosmic master minds of manipulation don't do that.
morriswalters:
--- Quote from: Ghost Story ---"Because it doesn't have anything to do with balancing the scales of one of the Fallen lying to me," I said. "You haven't done any fortune-cookie whispers into my head have you?"
"No," he said. "Not Yet."
"Well that's what I mean," I said. "The scale still isn't balanced. And I don't think you send people back just for Kicks."
--- End quote ---
And then at Harry's awakening.
--- Quote from: Ghost Story ---And a voice_a very calm, very gentle, very rational voice whispered in my ear, "Lies. Mab cannot change who you are."
--- End quote ---
7 words.
nadia.skylark:
It's possible that Uriel used the word "lies" because he knew that it would have a stronger effect on Harry, and the multiple definition of the word "lie" gave him the leeway to do so.
He could have used the word "lies" because Uriel views it as a lie, since it is an untruth that would work to subvert Harry's exercise of free will, even if it is not a lie by faerie definition. As has been made clear to me in another thread, people frequently see very different things as lies, and I don't see how being different species with completely different codes of conduct would do anything but increase that tendency.
It's also possible that he was trying to warn Harry that Mab was nemfected, but if so, she appears to be resisting well for the moment.
It seems extremely unlikely that Uriel did not have control over the specific words used, given that, as I remember it, in Ghost Story Uriel makes a point of saying that one of the Fallen used seven very specific words to undermine Harry's free will.
morriswalters:
--- Quote from: Ghost Story, the lie ---And it was all your fault Harry.
--- End quote ---
--- Quote from: Ghost Story, the balancing, the undoing of a lie ---"Lies. Mab cannot change who you are."
--- End quote ---
And just so the reader won't miss it, Jim has Harry count to seven after the second quote. Uriel balances the scale by undoing Mab's lie. I think it's why he uses the word. Mab may not be fully aware of the lie, it isn't clear. So my lie of omission may be incorrect, but the text is what it is.
BobbyWac:
Jumping ahead of the conversation about lies, and back to the initial post, I do think it could be Uriel or one of his agents, and I think Harry’s father is one of them. Ghost story makes it clear that the only balance for “the other side” telling him 7 words was that Uriel got to also put 7 words in his head. The entire out of body experience was voluntary. There’s nothing in there that says there haven’t been other cases where something whispered things in his head to be balanced. I’m not sure if it’s been discussed, but to reference my earlier point about Malcolm, the reason I think he’s working for Uriel’s office is that he shows up right after Shiela does and says that it’s because the other side broke the rules.
Navigation
[0] Message Index
[#] Next page
[*] Previous page
Go to full version