The Dresden Files > DF Spoilers
In This, The End of All Things, I Come Out of Lurking
wardenferry419:
Yeah, that does kinda sum up it. I am with the prosecution. Which means the burden of proof is on me. But, Griffyn, are you the sensible baliff or the judge that forgot his pants?
Griffyn612:
--- Quote from: wardenferry419 on January 03, 2018, 09:03:35 AM ---Yeah, that does kinda sum up it. I am with the prosecution. Which means the burden of proof is on me. But, Griffyn, are you the sensible baliff or the judge that forgot his pants?
--- End quote ---
I'm the Court Reporter making sure everything is recorded for posterity.
Independent George:
Um, we're not 'proving' 'Cowl=Simon' in a court of law. We're fans posing theories based on textual evidence. The case for 'Cowl=Simon' has been made numerous times, and its proponents (including myself) all concede it is purely circumstantial. It's a fan theory, not an indictment.
The OP stated definitively that Simon is NOT Cowl, and... offered no basis for his own conjecture other than to make ad hominum attacks on other fans.
jonas:
--- Quote ---Um, we're not 'proving' 'Cowl=Simon' in a court of law.
--- End quote ---
Well... looks like we are now?
--- Quote ---We're fans posing theories based on textual evidence.
--- End quote ---
I scoff at the idea of limiting myself to the letter of the book lol
--- Quote ---I'm the Court Reporter making sure everything is recorded for posterity.
--- End quote ---
If we're gonna do this then i'm on the Defense's side, cause I want this done right lol.(Sintra's my second)
wardenferry419:
No reason to get so serious. It is merely an idea. And ideas are fluid. I like the idea and find it plausible. But, I am not married to it.
Navigation
[0] Message Index
[#] Next page
[*] Previous page
Go to full version