The Dresden Files > DF Reference Collection
[CD Sample Chapters - Spoilers] Suggestion Box for the Upcoming Q&As
Elegast:
--- Quote from: KevinSig on December 02, 2012, 10:27:19 PM ---I've got a question, but I'm not sure on the formatting.
Do the Fae have souls? Harry has claimed that they don't, but was he right? Did Harry deny Aurora both a normal life & an afterlife to boot?
If not, what happens to their soul, does it move onto the afterlife when a Changeling chooses, or is it converted into part of the new being.
(Angels don't have free will, & are all soul, so if Harry is making the assumption that the Fae have no souls based on the lack of free will, I just assume its a mistake.)
Wordy, right? If I get a chance, I plan to just really ask the first bit, but I figure I should put out my entire thinking here. It was something I wanted to know, back with Aurora & Meryl, but now has come up to the forefront of my thinking.
--- End quote ---
That's a great question, should be our n°1 priority after CD.
Personally, I'm still trying to get an answer on my "Maeve at Splattercon" theory (see my signature). I'll try at the Bitten Books Q&A.
Aesir:
--- Quote from: KevinSig on December 02, 2012, 10:27:19 PM ---I've got a question, but I'm not sure on the formatting.
Do the Fae have souls? Harry has claimed that they don't, but was he right? Did Harry deny Aurora both a normal life & an afterlife to boot?
If not, what happens to their soul, does it move onto the afterlife when a Changeling chooses, or is it converted into part of the new being.
(Angels don't have free will, & are all soul, so if Harry is making the assumption that the Fae have no souls based on the lack of free will, I just assume its a mistake.)
Wordy, right? If I get a chance, I plan to just really ask the first bit, but I figure I should put out my entire thinking here. It was something I wanted to know, back with Aurora & Meryl, but now has come up to the forefront of my thinking.
--- End quote ---
There are some seeming inconsistencies surrounding this subject. Are sidhe who are not faerie queens immortal? or only the faerie queens? How can Lily be the first "mortal" to become a faerie queen when the same thing occurred with Maeve? and much, much earlier Mab? How can a mortal non-fae become an immortal fae? Does she still have her soul? Or free will? Can such a state be forced on her against her will? What percentage of new fae aredue to fae-fae breeding, and what percentage are due to fae-human breeding? Can fae even breed with each other?
THE_ANGRY_GAMER:
--- Quote from: Aesir on December 02, 2012, 10:39:13 PM ---There are some seeming inconsistencies surrounding this subject. Are sidhe who are not faerie queens immortal? or only the faerie queens? How can Lily be the first "mortal" to become a faerie queen when the same thing occurred with Maeve? and much, much earlier Mab? How can a mortal non-fae become an immortal fae? Does she still have her soul? Or free will? Can such a state be forced on her against her will? What percentage of new fae aredue to fae-fae breeding, and what percentage are due to fae-human breeding? Can fae even breed with each other?
--- End quote ---
Presumably, Lily was the first individual to become Lady without having Chosen or already been a Sidhe.
robertltux:
--- Quote from: Aesir on November 16, 2012, 05:51:59 PM --- Therefore he isn't so good at little evocations that take a lot of pinpoint control, although he is getting better at them as the series progresses. It's big evocations that involve massive destruction and take down entire buildings that he's a natural at. :P
--- End quote ---
Gecko insurance only covers Acts Of Harry and not Acts Of God.
do you think that maybe sometimes Harry should just go ahead and LEVEL a building just so the owner can invoke Total Loss provisions?? (building is 30% toast so go ahead and level it so save the owner a possible Fix Payout)
Arjan:
--- Quote from: THE_ANGRY_GAMER on December 02, 2012, 10:52:36 PM ---Presumably, Lily was the first individual to become Lady without having Chosen or already been a Sidhe.
--- End quote ---
Mab was mortal too
And I think the first queens all were.
My current theory is that when the first queen got children the first changelings were born. Some of these changelings became queen as well. It does not happen often but is was nothing new.
The big problem was that Lilly was uninformed, unprepared and not that bright to start with. Her personality was not too strong either. And Titania did not help her with anything. She was doomed to fail.
Navigation
[0] Message Index
[#] Next page
[*] Previous page
Go to full version