McAnally's (The Community Pub) > Author Craft
Originality--How important is it?
Noey:
I think the key, for me, is not to get hung up on originality, but concentrate on saying what I want to say. What is my voice? What's the message that I want to get across? What's the story that I want to tell? Originality comes from you, and only you. So, dig deep. Decide what your main character's goals are, and stay true to those goals. Decide what the tone of your story should be, and stick to that tone. In a sense, I find sometimes that it's best to ignore all the other things that have come before and put my energy into the story itself. Find your voice, and originality will follow.
the neurovore of Zur-En-Aargh:
--- Quote from: arianne on June 11, 2010, 10:59:16 AM --- a male human who falls in love with both a vampire girl and a werewolf girl, and (guess what?) the werewolf girl and the vampire girl are old enemies...that might really be too much of a Twilight rip-off, don't you think? How much "copying" is too much?
--- End quote ---
Depends what you're doing with it.
If, for example, you developed the notion you have above because you had cogent points to make about gender roles in Twilight and what's wrong with them, you might well get something worth saying out of it. (Though critiquing gender ideation in Twilight is like shooting fish in a barrel. With no water in it. Composed entirely out of fish.)
svb1972:
--- Quote from: neurovore on June 11, 2010, 03:58:16 PM ---Depends what you're doing with it.
If, for example, you developed the notion you have above because you had cogent points to make about gender roles in Twilight and what's wrong with them, you might well get something worth saying out of it. (Though critiquing gender ideation in Twilight is like shooting fish in a barrel. With no water in it. Composed entirely out of fish.)
--- End quote ---
With a Bazooka loaded with high explosive shells.
the neurovore of Zur-En-Aargh:
--- Quote from: Noey on June 11, 2010, 03:04:11 PM ---I think the key, for me, is not to get hung up on originality, but concentrate on saying what I want to say. What is my voice? What's the message that I want to get across? What's the story that I want to tell? Originality comes from you, and only you. So, dig deep. Decide what your main character's goals are, and stay true to those goals. Decide what the tone of your story should be, and stick to that tone.
--- End quote ---
Agreed absolutely.
--- Quote --- In a sense, I find sometimes that it's best to ignore all the other things that have come before and put my energy into the story itself. Find your voice, and originality will follow.
--- End quote ---
Well, yes and no. Ignoring everything that's gone before has the failure mode of thinking you are doing something original when you're unknowingly covering ground that's already been done; I'd say, at very least, be familiar with the classics of the genre you are writing in, because if readers or publishers are going to end up thinking of it "as if you liked the Chronicles of Qestfizz you'll love this" it would be no bad idea to be clear in your head how what you are doing is and is not similar to the Chronicles of Qestfizz, which does kind of entail reading the darn things. So that you can then respond to anyone who says "You're just ripping off the Chronicles of Qestfizz" with "of course not, don't be silly, in my book the cyborg shark is on a quest for the Holy Grail because her mother was tragically kidnapped by aliens at an early age, it's completely different... "
(I am making the example up. Thankfully.)
svb1972:
You sure? The book sounds familiar :)
Navigation
[0] Message Index
[#] Next page
[*] Previous page
Go to full version