McAnally's (The Community Pub) > Display Case
DISPROVE THIS
Drachasor:
--- Quote from: Ms. Duck on July 04, 2010, 08:09:29 PM ---Just for the record no one has yet to poke a hole in the original idea. :)
--- End quote ---
Much like no one could poke a whole in the idea that Harry is the Son of God. The critical flaw with both is a lack of any real evidence.
sanchez:
yes but this theory is more plausible when you think about it
Drachasor:
--- Quote from: sanchez on July 04, 2010, 09:22:35 PM ---yes but this theory is more plausible when you think about it
--- End quote ---
No, it really isn't. It's reasoning on the level of "if a little kid is good at basketball and tall, then he's probably going to be Michael Jordan once he travels back in time". Or, to stick with the books, it is like assuming Harry is the original Merlin since they are both wizards, kicked ass, believe in the Laws of Magic, and have had custody of a sword. Overall it is rather silly and is using a coincidence with a similarities or two to make a case for identity...but that just doesn't really hold up and there's counter evidence (such as the fact Molly has no skill with cold magic). You could just as easily say that Elaine is Mab (and Elaine has the advantage of not being covered in piercings).
sanchez:
we have no evidence that molly is not good at cold/ice magics, i believe the only mention of molly doing elemental magic is when harry was teaching her to do fire magic a couple of books back, and if you look at the various theories for molly going back in time and becoming mab/titania, there are very few aspects of them that we could say that could not possibly happen
Landing:
--- Quote from: Drachasor on July 04, 2010, 09:28:00 PM ---No, it really isn't. It's reasoning on the level of "if a little kid is good at basketball and tall, then he's probably going to be Michael Jordan once he travels back in time". Or, to stick with the books, it is like assuming Harry is the original Merlin since they are both wizards, kicked ass, believe in the Laws of Magic, and have had custody of a sword. Overall it is rather silly and is using a coincidence with a similarities or two to make a case for identity...but that just doesn't really hold up and there's counter evidence (such as the fact Molly has no skill with cold magic). You could just as easily say that Elaine is Mab (and Elaine has the advantage of not being covered in piercings).
--- End quote ---
I think your just jealous because you didn't think of it first. :D
Navigation
[0] Message Index
[#] Next page
[*] Previous page
Go to full version